Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Guide to Bay Ridge

Burgers and sandwiches

A burger that demands two hands and a napkin, rather than the sad, pre-packaged sandwich experience.

Based on 653 Opinions
+650
User
User
User
Updated April 2026
01
Bay Ridge Fish Market image 1
Bay Ridge Fish Market image 2
Bay Ridge Fish Market image 3
View all

Seafood market with fresh fish selection and small, cozy seating including a shaded garden patio. Atmosphere feels warm and inviting, with a friendly, family-oriented vibe. Space is clean but cramped, offering a genuine, homey seafood experience.

Salmon burger stands out with its rich flavor and is often a repeat choice. The burger deluxe offers a large, old-school vibe. Crabby patty burger ranks among the most satisfying.

Soft shell crab and shrimp po boy sandwiches stand out with fresh, crispy seafood. The cold lobster sandwich pairs well with French fries, and the shrimp Banh mi features gigantic, perfectly fried shrimp.

People are saying

"The shrimp po' boy sandwich is amazing and delicious."

"The soft shell crab and shrimp sandwiches are amazing."

"I found the seafood dishes here to be the best I ever ate."

Good to know

1

The Bay Ridge Fishbar is BYOB, allowing guests to bring their own drinks.

2

Customers can choose the fish, which is freshly displayed and can be cooked on the spot.

3

The pricing at Bay Ridge Fishbar is incredibly fair for the quality.

02
Chictea image 1
Chictea image 2
Chictea image 3
View all

Modern space with soft lighting and cozy, stylish decor creates a calm, chill atmosphere. Seating is ample and the environment welcomes friendly dogs, making it a relaxed spot to enjoy bubble tea and snacks. Prices are affordable with a focus on Asian street food-style offerings.

Burgers here come in big sizes and taste fresh. The chicken burger and combos with onion rings stand out for flavor and freshness.

Huge fried chicken sandwiches feature extra thick, juicy chicken breast with a crispy, crunchy outside and tender inside. Special sauce, tomatoes, and lettuce add flavor, and prices offer good value for the neighborhood.

People are saying

"Their fresh fruit teas and snacks are delicious."

"The chicken sandwich is huge, juicy, and perfectly crunchy."

"I had the tastiest, biggest burger ever."

Good to know

1

All drinks are buy one get one free during the grand opening from July 20-23.

2

Hot foods will be buy one get one 50% off for a limited time after the grand opening.

3

They only have 1 person and 1 machine to prepare the drinks.

03
Slap Burger Brooklyn image 1
Slap Burger Brooklyn image 2
Slap Burger Brooklyn image 3
View all

Spacious seating and clean atmosphere create a comfortable fast food setting with a visible, organized kitchen. The place serves halal smashed burgers and chicken with great prices and a menu known for fresh, flavorful options. Grease and kitchen smoke add a distinct aroma to the environment.

Burgers here are smash style, fresh, and smashed to perfection with a special Slap Sauce that adds depth. Prices are reasonable, with specials including a burger patty, fries, and a drink for under ten dollars.

Hot chicken sandwiches stand out with amazing coleslaw adding layers of flavor and texture. The chicken is HALAL and competes with well-known chains for taste.

People are saying

"The burgers and chicken taste amazing and seasoned just right."

"I thought the burgers here were great."

"Some burgers taste fresh and juicy, but others feel bland or dry."

Good to know

1

The restaurant offers an $8.99 special that includes a burger, fries, and a drink.

2

All food served is halal, including the chicken sandwich.

3

Expect minimal wait times during peak hours.

04
Pier 69 Market image 1
Pier 69 Market image 2
Pier 69 Market image 3
View all

Spacious cafe with clean, well-decorated interior and nice view near the pier. Atmosphere is calm and family-friendly with good music enhancing the vibe. Tables fill quickly, often with groups, creating a lively yet cozy setting.

Smash burgers stand out with a strong aroma that reminds many of classic burger spots. Prices run high, close to Manhattan levels, with burgers sometimes coming out hard in texture.

Chicken pesto and chicken parmesan sandwiches stand out with rich flavors. Breakfast sandwiches offer a delectable variety that pairs well with drinks.

People are saying

"I thought the burgers here were better than Five Guys."

"The breakfast sandwiches are tasty and come in many kinds."

"The chicken parmesan sandwich was the best of the best."

Good to know

1

The restaurant is currently closed due to a recent fire.

2

You should budget an extra hour for wait times compared to other restaurants.

3

The cafe offers a good selection of snacks and drinks for a quick bite.

05
Olives & Pita image 1
Olives & Pita image 2
Olives & Pita image 3
View all

Small Greek restaurant with cozy backyard seating and simple decor creates a friendly, relaxed vibe where people seem familiar with each other. Music features auto-tune pop with techno beats, adding an unusual touch to the atmosphere. Known for flavorful gyros and authentic dishes, it offers a casual dining experience with a family feel.

Louieโ€™s Smash burger stands out with a strong reputation. Burgers come with fries that complement well, and the overall quality surprises with its consistent flavor.

Gyro and pita sandwiches stand out with options like lamb gyro, chicken souvlaki, and falafel pita. Vegan gyro and Greek fries often accompany these flavorful sandwiches.

People are saying

"I had the best burger and fries in years."

"I love their chicken souvlaki and gyro sandwiches."

"The falafel and vegan pita sandwiches are great."

Good to know

1

The chicken gyro platter costs $13 with fries, baked potato, or rice.

2

The vegan gyro platter and falafel platter cost over $60, totaling $75 with tip.

3

The restaurant is accommodating to those with peanut allergies.

06
Sheel & Mashi bay ridge image 1
Sheel & Mashi bay ridge image 2
Sheel & Mashi bay ridge image 3
View all

Small, narrow space with cozy atmosphere and family-friendly vibe. Seating includes high bar tables and some outdoor chairs inside flowerpot-lined areas. Menu focuses on quality over quantity with standout shawarma and sandwiches.

Burgers come juicy and full of flavor, cooked to perfection with good halal meat. Smash burgers stand out as fantastic and the price matches the quality well.

Each sandwich comes fresh to order and stays hot. The chicken sandwich stands out. Sandwiches are small but filling and priced around six dollars.

People are saying

"I thought the sandwiches here were the best I had."

"The smash burgers are juicy, flavorful, and affordable."

"The sandwiches are small but tasty and worth it."

Good to know

1

Contactless payment options are available for a safer transaction experience.

2

Prices are generally affordable, with each dish costing around $6.99.

3

The portion sizes are smaller than average, so consider ordering extra.

07
Halal taco and gyro image 1
Halal taco and gyro image 2
Halal taco and gyro image 3
View all

Small space with Mexican-inspired decor and large wooden benches creates a cozy, lively atmosphere that feels welcoming and friendly. Cleanliness stands out despite the hole-in-the-wall style. The vibe is enhanced by entertainment and a sense of family.

Burgers come out juicy and flavorful, cooked to perfection. They offer a healthy option alongside other items like gyro and wings.

Spicy chicken sandwich stands out with strong flavor and good heat. Cheeseburgers are solid and well-made. The cheese steak sandwich blends taco elements, which may not suit traditional tastes.

People are saying

"The food is fresh, tasty, and full of flavor."

"I tried the best burgers, cooked to perfection and so juicy."

"I tried the spicy chicken sandwich and it was fantastic."

Good to know

1

The food is HALAL and freshly cooked.

2

They offer delivery through Uber Eats.

3

The portion sizes are large for a good price.

08
Skinflints image 1
Skinflints image 2
Skinflints image 3
View all

Traditional American restaurant with long bar and large electric trains circling the room creates a lively, cozy atmosphere. Busy during sports games, it offers outdoor seating and festive decorations year-round. The space features wood and stained glass, reflecting its past as an ice cream parlour.

Juicy burgers cooked to order stand out here, especially the cheddar cheese burger and the blue cheese burger. The burgers pair well with other comfort foods like ribs and mashed potatoes.

Reuben sandwich and Philly cheesesteak stand out with rich flavors. The burger and steak sandwich also delivers a solid, tasty experience.

People are saying

"I found the burgers here to be simple and delicious."

"The burgers here are juicy and top quality."

"The Christmas decorations here are beautiful and charming."

Good to know

1

Happy hour runs from 4-7 PM on weekdays with discounted drinks.

2

Brunch specials under $20 (including a drink) are available on Sundays.

3

Expect long wait times during peak hours, especially on weekends.

09
Bean Post Pub image 1
Bean Post Pub image 2
Bean Post Pub image 3
View all

Cozy pub with light rock music and games on TV creates a chill atmosphere for watching sports or unwinding. Friendly crowd from the local community gathers here, enjoying homemade wings and burgers alongside a Touchtunes jukebox that livens the mood.

Burgers come with a respectable amount of bacon and generous mushrooms. They hold up well for takeout and pair nicely with fries and onion rings.

Great sandwiches come with burgers and fried pickles. They also offer wraps and salads alongside the sandwiches.

People are saying

"The burgers and sides were seriously tasty"

"I found the burgers here to be amazing and cooked to perfection."

"I loved the wings and burgers here"

Good to know

1

The kitchen closes at 10:56 PM.

2

The cost of the traditional specialty wings bundle is about $19.

3

Everyone is welcome at the pub, reflecting the local community's culture.

10
Halal Munchies image 1
Halal Munchies image 2
Halal Munchies image 3
View all

Spacious halal restaurant with clean, welcoming atmosphere and plenty of seating. Decor adds a vibey, comfortable feel that invites diners to relax. The environment consistently offers friendly, wholesome vibes.

Heart attack burger stands out on the menu but tastes like a corner store burger. Platters and burgers rank among the favorite items, while buffalo wings also get mentioned as really delicious.

Gyro sandwiches stand out with rich, savory flavors. Grilled chicken sandwiches come well marinated and mildly spiced, offering a tasty but not overpowering kick.

People are saying

"The grilled and spicy chicken sandwiches taste amazing."

"I found the grilled chicken sandwich delicious and flavorful."

"I love the juicy sandwiches and hearty sides here."

Good to know

1

The restaurant allows people to sit and eat but does not provide a bathroom.

2

Their chicken/rice over chicken is only $10, almost $11 after taxes.

3

Asking for extra sauce will incur a high charge.

Discover more

Bay Ridge, New York

Area guide
Loading Map...