Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Bay Ridge's best

Calamari spots

Calamari that is tender enough to chew, not the rubbery rings that usually show up on the plate.

Based on 592 Opinions
+589
User
User
User
Updated
01
Terina image 1
Terina image 2
Terina image 3
View all

Speakeasy-style lounge features live jazz band and after-dinner cocktails in an elegant setting. Fried calamari offers a delightful crunch with a spicy kick. Warm, sophisticated atmosphere blends classic Italian charm for a cozy, refined dining experience.

Fried calamari offers a delightful crunch with a spicy kick. It comes served as a spicy appetizer.

People are saying

"I love the warm vibe and great food here."

"Every dish I tried was fresh and delicious."

"The calamari here is so friendly and welcoming."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for dinner, especially during the grand opening week.

2

The restaurant features a speakeasy located downstairs for a unique experience.

3

Valet parking is available for guests upon arrival.

02
Bay Ridge Fish Market image 1
Bay Ridge Fish Market image 2
Bay Ridge Fish Market image 3
View all

Seafood market offers fresh fish selection and a shaded garden patio for cozy dining. Fried calamari is crispy and flavorful, served with tomato sauce and lemon. Warm, family vibe makes it a homey seafood experience despite the cramped space.

Freshly fried calamari arrives with tomato sauce and lemon wedges. It stays flavorful and crisp across orders, often paired with seafood like shrimp and clams.

People are saying

"The seafood here is fresh and delicious."

"The calamari and shrimp sandwich was good."

"The fried calamari and shrimp taste fresh and delicious."

Good to know

1

The Bay Ridge Fishbar is BYOB, allowing guests to bring their own drinks.

2

Customers can choose the fish, which is freshly displayed and can be cooked on the spot.

3

The pricing at Bay Ridge Fishbar is incredibly fair for the quality.

03
Peppinoโ€™s Pizza & Restaurant image 1
Peppinoโ€™s Pizza & Restaurant image 2
Peppinoโ€™s Pizza & Restaurant image 3
View all

Woodfired brick oven creates a warm, inviting atmosphere perfect for enjoying soft, tender calamari oreganata. Regulars love the authentic, thin and crispy pizza and exceptional Italian dishes that feel like dining with family.

Soft and tender texture defines the calamari here, especially the calamari oreganata which stands out. Both dine-in and take-out options deliver consistently fantastic flavor.

People are saying

"The food is amazing and the place feels like family."

"The calamari here is fantastic and tender."

"The prices feel way too high now."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended as the restaurant is always crowded.

2

The restaurant is closed on Mondays and Tuesdays.

3

The hours of operation are from 4 PM onwards.

04
Port Sa'id Seafood Restaurant image 1
Port Sa'id Seafood Restaurant image 2
Port Sa'id Seafood Restaurant image 3
View all

Market-style seafood spot shines with interactive dining and a relaxed vibe. Greek-style calamari offers a sharp char balanced by lemon and garlic, while fried options come in a light batter. Bright LEDs and friendly staff complete the authentic experience.

Char on the Greek-style calamari offers a sharp contrast to the lemon and garlic flavors. Fried calamari comes in a light, flavorful batter and also appears stuffed, adding variety to the options.

People are saying

"I love how fresh and tasty the seafood is."

"This spot serves seafood that feels real and worth trying."

"The calamari here is lightly battered, crispy, and not greasy."

Good to know

1

The restaurant offers a wide variety of seafood, including branzino, striped bass, and lobster.

2

Prices are fair for the quality and variety of seafood offered.

3

The total bill for a meal is typically less than $70.

05
Uncutt Bar & Restaurant image 1
Uncutt Bar & Restaurant image 2
Uncutt Bar & Restaurant image 3
View all

Greek-themed spot offers a cozy vibe with chic decor and dim lighting. Fried calamari is crispy outside, tender inside, perfect for seafood lovers. Families and couples enjoy the upscale yet relaxed atmosphere for casual or special dinners.

Fried calamari comes out crispy on the outside and tender inside. It stays super soft to eat, showing careful cooking.

People are saying

"The food was fresh, flavorful, and perfectly cooked."

"It's a cool, friendly place to enjoy drinks and food."

"The calamari here is so crispy and tender."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for weekend dining to avoid long wait times.

2

Happy hour features discounted drinks and appetizers from 4-6pm on weekdays.

3

The restaurant offers a variety of meat dishes, perfect for sharing.

06
Piccante image 1
Piccante image 2
Piccante image 3
View all

Tiny Italian spot offers a cozy atmosphere with just eight tables and a full-size bar. Grilled calamari shines with perfect charred flavor, while fried calamari pairs well with house-made bread. Warmth and charm fill the space, making it a friendly, intimate dining choice.

Grilled calamari stands out with perfect cooking and a charred flavor that many find impressive. Fried calamari also appears as a common starter, paired often with house-made bread.

People are saying

"I thought the grilled calamari here were the best."

"I like starting with their fried or grilled calamari."

"I would eat the grilled calamari every day."

Good to know

1

Space is tight, so making a reservation is recommended.

2

The restaurant is celebrating its 6th anniversary.

3

Expect a wait even for an early dinner.

07
somethingreek image 1
somethingreek image 2
somethingreek image 3
View all

Outdoor patio and backyard offer a cozy atmosphere with natural birdsong adding to the peace. Fried calamari is fresh and crispy but best eaten quickly to avoid sogginess. Small interior space contrasts with a private terrace perfect for dining.

Fried calamari comes out fresh and crispy with a delicious marinara sauce. It needs to be eaten quickly to avoid getting soggy, and sometimes it can be tough to chew.

People are saying

"The food is fresh, authentic, and always tasty."

"The place feels cozy and welcoming with a nice outdoor area."

"The fried calamari was fresh and crispy."

Good to know

1

The restaurant offers daily specials that change regularly.

2

Lunch specials include pita sandwiches, except for the shrimp one.

3

Expect longer wait times if you don't order ahead for pick up.

08
Leo's Casa Calamari image 1
Leo's Casa Calamari image 2
Leo's Casa Calamari image 3
View all

Pizza spot shines with Golden Fried Calamari and authentic Italian dishes. Indoor and outdoor seating create a community-focused atmosphere with big screens showing sports. Casual dining blends with quick takeout, making it great for seafood and pizza lovers alike.

Golden Fried Calamari stands out as a tasty option. The place offers calamari alongside pizza but has limited seating.

People are saying

"The portions are big and the food tastes great."

"The delivery took forever and was really frustrating."

Good to know

1

The restaurant is primarily a takeout.

2

The order is ready within 10 minutes on average.

3

There is a wide variety of food available on the menu.

09
Gino's image 1
Gino's image 2
Gino's image 3
View all

Italian restaurant buzzes with a boisterous crowd and old New York decor. Fried calamari offers a perfect crunch and rich flavor. Valet parking adds convenience to the lively, intimate setting.

Crispy and flavorful textures define the fried calamari here. The preparation stands out for its perfect crunch and taste.

People are saying

"Some love the fried calamari, but others find it chewy or small."

"The calamari here is perfectly crispy and flavorful."

"I like pairing calamari with other tasty appetizers."

Good to know

1

Making reservations is recommended due to the crowd.

2

Wednesdays are 20% off on all menu items.

3

Reservations are recommended at Gino's because it gets packed on Friday-Sunday.

10
Puertas image 1
Puertas image 2
Puertas image 3
View all

Vibrant murals and authentic salsa vibe fill the space with energy. Live music pumps Latin rhythms like reggaeton and merengue. Fried calamari arrives fresh and crunchy, making a crisp starter for salsa lovers.

Fried calamari comes out fresh and crunchy. Calamari fritto serves as a crisp, satisfying starter.

People are saying

"The food is packed with flavor and authenticity."

"The cocktails were tasty and worth the price."

"The calamari fritto was so fresh and crunchy."

Good to know

1

Happy hour drinks are available, but specific times are not mentioned.

2

A live band plays on weekends, enhancing the dining experience.

3

Salsa night events are hosted regularly, providing a lively atmosphere.

11
Zio Toto image 1
Zio Toto image 2
Zio Toto image 3
View all

Small, intimate space offers a warm atmosphere with authentic Italian dishes made from fresh ingredients. Fried calamari is mostly perfect with a crispy texture and served with marinara sauce. Stunning views create a romantic setting ideal for dinners or casual meals.

Fried calamari comes with marinara sauce and is cooked mostly perfectly. Some find the texture a bit hard.

People are saying

"The Italian food mostly tasted authentic and delicious."

"The place feels cozy and perfect for a date with great food."

"The fried calamari here is perfect!"

Good to know

1

Expect higher prices than those listed on the menu; verify before ordering.

2

The restaurant gets very busy, especially by 8 pm when all tables are full.

3

Pack a snack if you're hungry, as portion sizes are small.

12
Mussels & More image 1
Mussels & More image 2
Mussels & More image 3
View all

Seafood restaurant shines with crispy fried calamari and a cozy atmosphere perfect for families and couples. Outdoor seating and a great bar add charm, while occasional live bands keep the vibe lively yet relaxed. Guests enjoy lingering in this homey setting.

Fried calamari comes as a crispy appetizer alongside other dishes like pizza and pasta. It pairs well with a variety of meals including seafood paella and Cajun chicken pasta.

People are saying

"I loved how tasty the food was."

"I really enjoyed the cozy vibe and food."

"The calamari here is delicious and the atmosphere is lovely."

Good to know

1

Reservations are not required to dine at the restaurant.

2

The pricing at the restaurant is great and reasonable for the quality.

3

There are no happy hours available.

13
Come On Thai image 1
Come On Thai image 2
Come On Thai image 3
View all

Small, cozy spot shines with authentic Thai flavors like Pad Thai and basil fried rice. Golden calamari side lacks flavor and crispness, not a highlight. Cute, pretty decor and soft music create a warm, inviting atmosphere perfect for relaxed dining.

People are saying

"I loved the bold flavors and perfect spice levels."

"The place felt cozy but portions were small."

Good to know

1

The restaurant closes at 10 PM, but the kitchen closes at 9:30 PM.

2

They offer discounts for paying cash for orders over 45 dollars.

3

Vegan options are available upon request.

Discover more

Bay Ridge, New York

Area guide