Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Top picks in Bayside

Italian food spots

Italian food that feels like a home-cooked dinner, not a mass-produced imitation of a classic recipe.

Based on 567 Opinions
+564
User
User
User
Updated April 2026
01
Joe's Sicilian Bakery Inc. image 1
Joe's Sicilian Bakery Inc. image 2
Joe's Sicilian Bakery Inc. image 3
View all

Small old school bakery fills the air with an inviting aroma of freshly baked Italian bread, pastries, and cookies. Cash-only policy and a single register create lines, especially during holidays. Known for fresh bread, outstanding pastries, and classic Italian treats made in-house.

Quality bread and desserts like cookies and cannolis stand out. The baked foods are consistently tasty and satisfying.

Cannolis stand out with a unique shell possibly spiced with cinnamon or nutmeg and a well-balanced cream filling. The bakery also offers traditional Italian butter cookies, prosciutto bread, and filled breads with sausage, peppers, and olives.

People are saying

"I love their fresh, tasty cannolis and pastries"

"You have to try their Italian Food; the cannolis are the best."

"The baked food here is quality and tasty."

Good to know

1

The bakery only accepts cash; there's an ATM on-site.

2

Expect long lines on weekends and holidays due to its popularity.

3

Customers should call in their order ahead of time for quicker pickup.

02
Baraki image 1
Baraki image 2
Baraki image 3
View all

Eclectic restaurant combines modern elegant decor with a live DJ playing loud, vibrant music that energizes the space. The atmosphere is cozy yet lively, attracting those who enjoy strong beats alongside dining. A notable feature includes an awesome backyard area enhancing the overall experience.

Food features authentic Greek cuisine served hot and fresh, with standout dishes like beef sliders and grilled cheese. Cocktails and overall flavors come across as delicious and fabulous.

Whipped feta and hot honey spread stand out alongside the grilled cheese focaccia with vodka sauce. Gnocchi shines here, especially the gnocchi vodka and pesto versions.

People are saying

"The food here is amazing, especially the gyro bao buns."

"The food and drinks were delicious and satisfying."

"I loved the great food and cozy vibe here."

Good to know

1

Reservations are necessary due to limited seating at the restaurant.

2

The restaurant allows only 1 hour to eat and leave.

3

There is a live DJ on Thursday, Friday, and Saturday nights.

03
Valdari Ristorante image 1
Valdari Ristorante image 2
Valdari Ristorante image 3
View all

Italian restaurant offers open kitchen with wood-fired pizza oven and live music that creates a lively, sometimes loud atmosphere. The space feels romantic and classy with nice decor and good lighting, suited for groups or dates.

Food here stands out for its great taste and consistent quality. Groups find the dishes delicious and satisfying every time.

Fresh pasta stands out with big portions and dishes like fettuccine alfredo with shrimp and tagliatelle bolognese. Mozzarella, meatballs, and bread served with EVOO complement plates like clam linguine, Margherita pizza, and chicken parmesan.

People are saying

"The food here is amazing and full of flavor."

"The wood-fired pizzas and homemade pastas here are delicious."

"The food was amazing and perfectly seasoned."

Good to know

1

The restaurant offers a $100 four-course meal with tax and tip included.

2

Happy hour specials are available with delicious and reasonably priced offerings.

3

Brunch features DJ music on weekends and bottomless options.

04
L'Italiano Trattoria image 1
L'Italiano Trattoria image 2
L'Italiano Trattoria image 3
View all

Small, quaint Italian restaurant with a cozy family atmosphere and intimate, friendly vibe. The space feels like dining at home, often quiet enough for conversation. Known for well-priced, homemade dishes and consistent quality in a neighborhood setting.

Italian cuisine stands out for its authentic flavors and excellent quality. Dishes come at reasonable prices and the overall food experience is consistently impressive.

Authentic Italian cuisine shines with fantastic homemade pasta and dishes like Pollo alla fria featuring chicken, spinach, and prosciutto in wine sauce. Plates like Pasta Primavera show attention to detail with fresh, balanced flavors served thoughtfully.

People are saying

"I loved the authentic Italian food; it tasted like family tradition."

"The food here tastes like homemade Italian cooking."

"The food is always fresh and delicious every time."

Good to know

1

Reservations are a must, especially on game days.

2

The restaurant offers tableside card payment for convenience.

3

The restaurant serves veal and lamb, but no pork chops.

05
Trattoria 35 image 1
Trattoria 35 image 2
Trattoria 35 image 3
View all

Italian restaurant offers a warm and inviting decor with a friendly atmosphere suited for intimate occasions. Valet parking adds convenience despite limited parking options. Dining spaces are clean and well spaced, enhancing comfort during meals.

Traditional Italian food shines with authentic flavors and consistently excellent quality.

Fettuccine alfredo stands out with rich, creamy flavor. Crab ravioli topped with scallops and marscapone cream offers a unique twist. Fried ravioli and salmon pasta add variety, while Francese and Marsala come with spaghetti in an olive oil sauce.

People are saying

"The food here is delicious and cooked perfectly."

"The food was mostly fresh and delicious."

"The food is always delicious and satisfying."

Good to know

1

Reservations are required, but expect a 10-15 minute wait upon arrival.

2

Parking can be difficult; consider using street parking around the block.

3

Valet service is available for convenience.

06
Papazzio Restaurant & Caterer image 1
Papazzio Restaurant & Caterer image 2
Papazzio Restaurant & Caterer image 3
View all

Intimate space with cozy decor and old school mom and pop style creates a warm and welcoming atmosphere. Live entertainment adds a soothing vibe on some nights. The setting suits friends, date nights, and families seeking a relaxed, low-key environment.

Exceptional Italian food stands out here, with dishes like Penna Alla Vodka praised for their flavor. Every dish uses high-quality ingredients, and the food consistently impresses with its delicious taste.

Pasta dishes like Ravioli and Alfredo stand out with perfect cooking and solid seasoning. Appetizers include Burrata and fried mozzarella, while entrees feature Veal picatta, Saltimbocca, and spaghetti with meatballs.

People are saying

"The food here is delicious and so gluten-free friendly."

"I love the cozy vibe and great Italian food here."

"The food is fresh, tasty, and always hits the spot."

Good to know

1

The restaurant offers a $12 pasta menu on Wednesdays and Sundays after 4pm.

2

Papazzio is a great choice for hosting events with no hassle.

3

The restaurant provides many gluten-free options for customers with celiac disease.

07
VIVO! Restaurant & Catering image 1
VIVO! Restaurant & Catering image 2
VIVO! Restaurant & Catering image 3
View all

Old mansion converted into an event space offers elegant decor and cozy, romantic atmosphere with both indoor and outdoor dining areas. Soft lighting and spacious rooms create a sober, delightful vibe suited for weddings and gatherings. Plenty of parking and a gazebo enhance convenience and charm.

Food here stands out for its excellent quality and delicious flavors. Buffet-style brunch and catering options receive many compliments for both taste and presentation.

Mussels marinara stands out with rich, fresh flavors. Burrata offers a creamy texture, while tiramisu delivers a classic, smooth finish. Chicken parmesan comes with natural flavors paired with spaghetti and sauce.

People are saying

"I loved the great food and perfect atmosphere here."

"The food here was really tasty and wonderful."

"The food at events was delicious and well received."

Good to know

1

Reservations are highly recommended, especially for special events.

2

Parking is easy with ample space available.

3

The buffet ends at 2:30 PM, so arrive early.

08
Lucia Pizza Bayside image 1
Lucia Pizza Bayside image 2
Lucia Pizza Bayside image 3
View all

Spacious seating area with high ceilings and a clean marble interior creates a warm and inviting atmosphere. The place stays quiet and calm, offering both indoor and outdoor seating. It stands out with authentic New York-style pizza and an old school vibe with counter and stools.

Food here is consistently delicious and well-prepared. Watching the kitchen shows the care put into every dish, and the overall quality stays very good.

Penne a la vodka and chicken Parmesan come in large portions and taste fresh and well cooked. Some pasta dishes like penne bolognese and pasta e fagioli fall short, with underwhelming flavors and texture issues.

People are saying

"I found the food here to be amazing and delicious."

"The chicken parm and pasta dishes taste fresh and satisfying."

"The Italian food, especially the pasta, is delicious every single time."

Good to know

1

Reservations are not required but can help during busy hours.

2

Expect a 20-30 minute wait during peak dinner times.

3

Credit cards and cash are accepted for payment.

09
Jimmy's Trattoria image 1
Jimmy's Trattoria image 2
Jimmy's Trattoria image 3
View all

Classic old-style Italian restaurant with nicely spaced tables and a balanced atmosphere that blends family warmth with romantic quietness. The space feels clean and well-lit, inviting conversation without feeling crowded. It suits both special occasions and casual gatherings with familiar faces.

Italian dishes come with an authentic taste and fresh ingredients. Meals are beautifully prepared and consistently delicious.

Linguine with Clam Sauce stands out as a signature dish alongside veal and eggplant parmigiano and chicken cacciatore with pasta. Large portions come with delicious bread, seasoned olive oil, and classic Italian appetizers like tomato/mozzarella and tortellini carbonara.

People are saying

"The food is delicious and the portions are huge."

"The food tastes great and the prices feel fair."

"Some pasta dishes are great, but others feel watery or overcooked."

Good to know

1

The restaurant requires at least pants, shoes, and a dress shirt.

2

You have to deal with street parking.

3

If you go after 5 PM, you can pay the meter for 2 hours.

Discover more

Bayside, New York

Area guide
Loading Map...