Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Best of Bensonhurst

Italian food spots

Made for those who hold Italian cooking to a high standard and seek out authentic flavors in their own neighborhood.

Based on 751 Opinions
+748
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
La Palina image 1
La Palina image 2
La Palina image 3
View all
Neapolitan restaurant

Old-school Italian spot shines with perfectly cooked pasta and best sauce recipes by Peter, Anthony, and Charlie. Dim lighting and traditional decor create a laid-back atmosphere for an older crowd. Full bar offers sangria and house Chianti, plus valet parking adds ease.

Old-school Italian dishes feature best sauce recipes prepared by Peter, Anthony, and Charlie. Many delicious options deliver consistently incredible flavor and outstanding service.

Every dish features perfectly cooked pasta and just right marinara sauce. Options like veal parmigiano, chicken parmesan, and mussels marinara stand out for their quality.

People are saying

"I found the old school Italian food here to be excellent."

"I found the food here to be amazing."

"The Italian food here is really good and home style."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended as the restaurant gets packed quickly.

2

Cash payments can help you save money on your bill.

3

Parking can be difficult; consider valet service if available.

02
Girolamo's Pizza image 1
Pizza restaurant

Neighborhood pizzeria offers a cozy atmosphere with classic Italian decor and chill music. Food shines with thoughtful preparation, featuring standout items like spicy vodka pizza and homemade mozzarella sticks. Owner-run spot ensures quality and a clean, inviting space.

Food shows attention to detail and thoughtful preparation. The spicy vodka pizza balances spice well for non-spicy eaters, making the menu stand out.

Homemade mozzarella sticks and a variety of slices like vodka and zucchini stand out. The Trifecta pie blends marinara, vodka, and pesto sauces for a flavorful mix.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza was delicious, light, and crispy."

"The owner's passion for his Italian food products really shines through."

"The food's crispy crust and fresh sauce are amazing."

Good to know

1

The restaurant closes at 7:30 PM, which may be inconvenient for late diners.

2

Credit cards and mobile payments are accepted; cash is also welcome.

3

Parking is limited; consider arriving early to find a spot.

03
Queen Ann Ravioli and Macaroni image 1
Italian grocery store

Pasta shop layout with homemade pasta and frozen ravioli stands out, featuring a 1901 pasta machine. Atmosphere feels authentic with a focus on high-quality Italian products. Customers come for fresh mozzarella, sauces, and a variety of pasta, enjoying good prices and a traditional vibe.

Quality stands out with real food that invites comparison taste tests. The flavors evoke memories of Brooklyn's food scene.

Fresh pasta and ravioli stand out with homemade mozzarella and sauces like marinara, meat, and vodka. The shop uses a 1901 pasta machine and offers frozen gnocchi and prosciutto bread alongside its pasta.

People are saying

"I thought the ravioli here was the best I'd ever tasted."

"The food, especially the cheese ravioli, is rich, creamy, and the best I've tasted."

"The Italian food here, especially the ravioli, is the best I've ever tasted."

Good to know

1

The restaurant serves authentic Italian cuisine.

2

The prices at this place are great.

3

The place has an amazing history.

04
La Villa image 1
Pizza restaurant

Small, intimate spot with a wood-burning oven offers a cozy, lively vibe. Enjoy spicy arrabbiata calamari and creamy rice balls with great service. Outdoor seating adds charm to this family-style Italian experience.

Amazing food and great service create a memorable dining experience. The dishes consistently impress with their delicious flavors and quality.

Rice balls filled with creamy risotto and bolognese stand out alongside spicy arrabbiata calamari and fresh prosciutto e rochetto. Pastas, including chicken parm and eggplant parm, pair well with frozen bellinis and classic tiramisu.

People are saying

"The food here is fresh and flavorful."

"The service for dinner spots was super welcoming and attentive."

"I thought the Italian food, especially the pasta, was amazing."

Good to know

1

The restaurant can host large parties, accommodating over 20 people.

2

Reservations are recommended for large groups to ensure availability.

3

The NYC special pizza is available for takeout.

05
Pastosa Ravioli - Bensonhurst (Flagship) image 1

Italian grocery store shines with fresh pasta and authentic ravioli. Friendly vibe and homemade Italian dishes make shopping a joy. Quality meats like sweet soprasata add to the rich Italian food selection.

Freshness stands out with fresh pasta and homemade Italian dishes. A wide variety of high quality Italian foods fills the store, especially notable are the ravioli and prepared meals.

Fresh pasta stands out with a great selection including cheese raviolis and pesto ravioli salad on Fridays. Meats like sweet soprasata and fresh sausage complement the homemade Italian offerings well.

People are saying

"I found the handmade pasta and sauces packed with authentic flavor."

"The fresh, handmade Italian food here tastes like it's straight from the vine."

"The homemade pasta and sauces here are outstanding."

Good to know

1

The store offers a wide variety of fresh pasta and Italian specialties.

2

Prices are reasonable, with items like meatball parm bruschetta costing $3.

3

A pound of lasagna costs $8.99 and weighs about 1.7 pounds.

06
Il Colosseo Ristorante | Brooklyn image 1

Small space with live Italian music creates a cozy, authentic atmosphere that feels like home. Frequented by those seeking traditional Italian dining, it offers a family-style vibe despite occasional loudness. The focus stays on food quality over decor, giving it a genuine, unpretentious character.

Food here is delicious and fresh with a focus on homemade Italian dishes. Service is consistently excellent, complementing the overall dining experience.

Homemade Italian dishes like authentic carbonara and marinara stand out here. The tiramisu serves as a notable dessert highlight.

People are saying

"The Italian food here is authentic, flavorful, and beautifully presented."

"I found the seafood here to be so fresh and delicious."

"I thought the food was amazing and delicious."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended, especially for larger groups.

2

A 4% charge applies to credit card payments.

3

Valet parking is available for guests.

07
Frank & Sal Italian Market Brooklyn image 1

Italian grocery store with a small layout and a meat counter offers a friendly atmosphere and cozy, inviting vibe. It features fresh mozzarella, authentic Italian foods, and a butcher counter with pristine meats. The market stands out for imported pasta and next day cheese delivery.

Offers a wide range of authentic Italian foods and cheeses with a strong focus on freshness. Includes real pasta, cold cuts, coffee, and bread alongside high-quality meats, fruits, and vegetables.

Fresh mozzarella and parmigiano reggiano stand out for their quality. The garlic focaccia is fragrant and rich, while the Italian imported pasta, including whole wheat options, offers more flavor than typical American pasta.

People are saying

"This Italian food is the real deal, especially the fresh mozzarella."

"The deli's fresh mozzarella is creamy, soft, and reminds me of Italy."

"I thought the prepared food was fresh and delicious."

Good to know

1

The store offers next day delivery for cheese orders.

2

They accept SNAP payments, making it accessible for more customers.

3

The butcher counter provides fresh meats, including high-quality steaks and sausages.

08
Grotta Azzurra image 1
Pizza restaurant

Classic old school pizzeria offers a cozy atmosphere and authentic vibe with crispy crusts and traditional flavors. Pasta dishes like spaghetti and meatballs and rich lasagna shine alongside the chicken parmigiana hero on big Italian bread. Food crafted by Andre and family is consistently delicious.

Awesome food stands out with consistently delicious dishes crafted by Andre and his family. This pizzeria serves fantastic cuisine that never disappoints.

Pasta dishes taste freshly made and include a generous portion of spaghetti and meatballs. The lasagna stands out as a rich, satisfying option alongside the chicken parmigiana hero on big Italian bread.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was excellent."

"This pizza is delicious, fresh, and has an excellent crust."

"I found the Italian food here to be great, especially the pizza with its nice crust."

Good to know

1

If you're in a hurry, consider pre-ordering to skip the wait.

2

They don't do delivery and require online orders.

3

The prices are great.

09
Villa Fiorita image 1
Italian restaurant

Rustic interior with snow-white tablecloths creates a homey, family atmosphere that feels like a reunion. The vibe is laid back and cozy, with authentic Italian music playing softly in the background. Tables fill steadily, reflecting a welcoming spot where people enjoy leisurely meals together.

Food offers a homemade taste with generous portions and a focus on fine Italian cuisine. Meals come with friendly service and a relaxed atmosphere for leisurely dining.

Linguine pescatore stands out with fresh clams and baked garlic, offering a scrumptious seafood pasta experience. The saltimbocca features tender meat over spinach, topped with prosciutto and a crisp egg, capturing homemade Italian flavors.

People are saying

"The Italian food here, especially the seafood, is so fresh and delicious."

"The dinner spots here have excellent food and generous portions."

"I found the food here to be delicious and great."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended due to high demand and limited seating.

2

Expect longer wait times during peak dining hours.

3

Arrive early to secure a table, especially on weekends.

10
Teri's Pizzeria image 1
Pizza delivery

Pizza delivery spot offers cozy, welcoming atmosphere with a warm aroma of fresh dough and herbs. The space stays clean and comfortable, attracting locals and passersby alike. Known for fast service and high-quality, flavorful pizza with a crispy crust and tasty sauce.

Food comes out very fast and tastes amazing with great prices for the quality. Staff and service support the overall positive food experience.

Chicken Alfredo stands out with rich flavor and perfectly cooked pasta. The mozzarella melts perfectly on pizzas like the hot honey and chicken parmigiana with linguine. Gnocchi di porcini and spinach roll add variety to the Italian cuisine offerings.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was the best I ever tasted."

"The food here tastes so fresh and delicious."

"The pizza here is out of this world, with a thin, flavorful crust."

Good to know

1

The pizzeria closes at 10 pm, and the latest they send out delivery is at 9:30 pm.

2

I paid $3.50 for a plain slice, which is cheaper than most places.

3

Their lunch specials offer great value for a filling meal.

11
Panino Rustico of Bensonhurst image 1

Cozy Italian restaurant with an old school Brooklyn vibe and authentic atmosphere invites lingering. Small space includes outdoor terrace seating and a warm, homey interior. Friendly, comfortable setting feels like a welcoming neighborhood spot.

Food here is consistently excellent and delicious with no complaints. Every order arrives without issues, maintaining a fantastic quality every time.

Bruschetta stands out with perfectly crispy sourdough topped with combinations like mozzarella, tomato, basil pesto, asparagus, parmigiano reggiano, and truffle oil. Paninis such as the Chicken Parmigiana and Chicken with pesto sauce feature mozzarella cheese and fresh ingredients. Cannolis are filled fresh upon order, adding to the authentic Italian offerings.

People are saying

"Their paninis are super tasty and generously stacked."

"I had a delicious cappuccino, one of the best I've had."

"I thought the food here was really good."

Good to know

1

Delivery usually takes 20-40 minutes.

2

Parking can be a little tough sometimes.

3

The restaurant is not open on Sundays.

12
Fratelliโ€™s Pizzeria image 1

Small space with five tables and a TV creates an intimate setting. Atmosphere carries a family vibe with a quiet, unassuming design. Known for crispy, flavorful pizza featuring a unique sesame crust and upside down square pies that stand out in quality and taste.

Italian cuisine features well-prepared dishes with very good flavors. Several tables allow for dining in, but watch for billing issues after ordering.

Spaghetti comes with garlic and oil on thin pasta. Mozzarella sticks have very greasy breading made from oily dough and lack flavor, with just the cheese inside.

People are saying

"You have to try the pizza; it's spot on."

"I found the food here to be very good and well-prepared."

"The Italian food here is delicious and well-prepared."

Good to know

1

The price of the pizzas is only $3.50.

2

There is a Monday special for an 18โ€ pie.

3

You should double check over the phone what you're ordering as many items differ from the website.

13
Papa Mikes Brick Oven Pizza image 1

Brick oven pizza restaurant offers trendy, clean decor with indoor and outdoor seating plus a separate coffee and beverage section. Atmosphere feels welcoming and casual, attracting a mix of locals who appreciate classic and vegan pizza options. The place balances a neighborhood staple vibe with a modern touch.

Chicken rollatini stands out as a highlight. Food tastes good and comes at a cheap price.

Brick oven pizza stands out with a thin, crispy crust and fresh mozzarella. Chicken marsala with pasta and the Marinara slice also show solid preparation and flavor.

People are saying

"The food here is delicious and great."

"I believed this pizza was the best in my area."

"The brick oven pizza here is so tasty."

Good to know

1

The actual price charged was $55 instead of the online checkout price showing less than $40.

2

The large pizza costs $16.00 as of May 2023.

3

Not a lot of places in the area have vegan pizza.

14
Lioni Italian Heroes image 1

Old-school Italian sandwich shop offers fresh mozzarella and razor thin prosciutto on crispy bread. Enjoy quick, perfectly portioned sandwiches with bold flavors in a retro, rustic vibe. Cozy space with a full olive bar and classic Italian music adds to the charm.

Italian sandwiches stand out with perfect portions and quick preparation. Food offers great value and consistent quality.

Fresh mozzarella stands out with its creamy texture and quality. Italian sandwiches feature razor thin prosciutto, crispy bread, and bold flavors like roasted peppers and marinara.

People are saying

"I tasted the best sandwich I have ever had."

"The food here is great, especially the heroes."

"You have to try their huge Italian heroes; the portions are generous."

Good to know

1

The restaurant only accepts cash.

2

Expect long lines around 1pm due to cashier bottlenecks.

3

A sandwich costs $15 and is large enough for two meals.

15
Papa Pasquale Ravioli & Salumeria image 1

Fresh pasta dominates the selection with massive variety and flavor-packed ravioli standing out. Sandwiches come in huge hoagie rolls or smaller deli rolls, often stuffed with meat. Prices stay affordable while portions remain generous.

Authentic Italian flavors shine through every dish here. The food quality stays consistently unmatched, making it a solid choice for anyone craving real Italian food.

Fresh pasta stands out with a massive selection and homemade ravioli packed with flavor. Classic Italian specialties like rice balls and prosciutto balls add to the authentic experience.

People are saying

"These ravioli are packed with flavor and taste like grandma's."

"The food here is authentic and fresh, tasting like Italy."

"The Italian food here, especially the ravioli, is packed with flavor."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended on weekends due to high demand.

2

Expect a wait time of 20-30 minutes during peak dinner hours.

3

Parking is limited; consider using public transport or rideshare services.

16
Buonissima Pizza Pasta image 1
Pizza restaurant

Pizza restaurant offers a warm, friendly atmosphere with loud music and a happy vibe. It attracts a neighborhood crowd seeking affordable prices and high-quality pizza. The place stands out for its consistent product versus price balance.

Food here is consistently excellent and delicious with affordable prices. Every visit offers a satisfying meal with great flavors.

Penne vodka with chicken stands out with rich flavor and extra sauce. The chicken cutlet on spaghetti pairs well with the sauce. Mozzarella sticks come limp and greasy, wrapped in foil that makes them soggy.

People are saying

"I thought this was the best pizza I've ever had."

"The Italian food's vodka sauce is so delicious and creamy."

"I found the food to be excellent and affordable."

Good to know

1

The $20 order can feed 4 people.

2

The 18-inch pizza costs $11.99.

3

A $20 order can get you a large pie, a order of French fries, and a 2L soda.

17
Rimini Pastry Shoppe image 1

Tiny, old-school Italian bakery with beautiful presentations and a warm, inviting atmosphere. Pastries and cakes are fresh and delicious, featuring standout items like cannoli and cheesecake. Space feels cramped on busy days, adding to a bustling, cozy vibe.

Fresh cakes and pastries stand out with great selection and tasty flavors. Food overall is consistently good and enjoyable.

Cannolis stand out with perfect taste and beautiful presentation, though some can be a bit soggy. A variety of fresh Italian pastries like sfogiatellle, napoleons, tiramisu, and prosciutto bread complement the selection.

People are saying

"The cakes here taste amazing and look gorgeous."

"Their Italian pastries, especially the cannolis, are so fresh."

"The food here is fantastic, especially the cakes."

Good to know

1

The bakery offers a wide variety of fresh pastries, breads, and cakes.

2

Prices are reasonable compared to other bakeries in the area.

3

All products are made fresh daily, ensuring quality and taste.

18
Villabate Alba image 1
Dessert shop

Old school Italian bakery atmosphere with heavenly aroma and beautiful, bright setup creates a calm, inviting vibe. Fresh Sicilian pastries like cannoli and sfogliatelle stand out as specialties. Coffee bar and ice cream add to the authentic Italian corner feel.

Authentic Sicilian desserts and fresh, high-quality food break the usual Italian American mold here. Despite slow service, the delicious flavors stand out and draw a crowd.

Cannoli filled fresh with perfect crunch stand out here, with ricotta that ranks among the best in the city. Pastries like light and crispy sfogliatelle and desserts such as tiramisu and chocolate cheesecake add to the strong Italian food selection.

People are saying

"I thought the pastries here were excellent, even hard to get better in Italy."

"The Italian pastries, especially the cannoli, are incredible."

"I thought the food, especially the pastries and cookies, was amazing."

Good to know

1

You pay at the end of the line after telling them what you want.

2

The pastries cost almost $5 each.

3

Customers cannot take pictures or videos inside the establishment.

19
Tommaso image 1
Italian restaurant

Warm, cozy setting echoes an old-school Italian trattoria with live opera music enhancing the atmosphere. The space feels airy and bright with cloth napkins and tablecloths adding a touch of formality. Regulars enjoy authentic Italian dishes including rare menu items like scungili and escargot.

Authentic Italian American cuisine shines with fresh ingredients cooked to perfection. Food consistently delivers excellent quality and exceptional service complements the experience.

Pasta dishes like rigatoni with red sauce and spaghetti bolognese stand out for their authentic flavors. The Arrabbiata sauce is notably spicy and full of flavor, complementing dishes like cheese ravioli and penne vodka well.

People are saying

"The food here is authentic Italian, with unforgettable meatballs and perfect pasta."

"I heard live music on Saturday night; it was a fantastic backdrop."

"The Italian food here honors Tommaso's authentic recipes and spirit."

Good to know

1

There is live music on Saturday.

2

The lunch special is $34.00 and includes an appetizer, main dish, dessert, and coffee.

3

Tommaso's menu offers a wide range of traditional Italian specialties.

20
New HK Tea & Sushi image 1
Hong Kong style fast food restaurant

Hong Kong style fast food restaurant offers a spacious interior with simple decor and vibrant atmosphere. The place fills with a loud, crowded energy typical of traditional Hong Kong cafes. Popular among locals, it serves a variety of dishes including sushi, noodles, and rice combos.

Food offers Cantonese style with lots of flavor and cheesy baked dishes that are filling. Portions come quickly and are affordable, with consistently delicious taste even during busy times.

Baked rice and spaghetti dishes stand out here, especially the pork chop cheese baked spaghetti and curry cheese baked pasta. Macaroni soup often accompanies these meals, creating a consistent combo.

People are saying

"The Japanese food here, especially the sushi, is good for the price."

"The food here is delicious and the portions are generous."

"You have to try the cheese baked spaghetti; it's amazing Italian food."

Good to know

1

You need to pay cash to avoid extra fees on your bill.

2

The prices are very low at this restaurant.

3

The portion sizes at the restaurant are gigantic.

Discover more

Bensonhurst, New York

Area guide
Loading Map...