Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Local picks

Authentic Ice Cream Shops in New York

An ice cream shop that makes its own recipes from scratch, rather than just scooping from a wholesale tub.

Based on 776 Opinions
+773
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Rito Gelato image 1
Rito Gelato image 2
Rito Gelato image 3
View all
Ice cream shop

Cozy gelato shop on the Upper West Side serves authentic Italian gelato with bold flavors. Staff use traditional Roman recipes to craft creamy, fresh treats. Clean layout and clear labels make it a premium ice cream spot loved by locals.

New ice cream shop offers a fresh spot for frozen treats. Located on the upper west side, it brings a local option for ice cream lovers.

Gelato here has a very authentic Italian taste with bold flavors. The texture and flavor profile match traditional gelato closely.

People are saying

"The gelato here is amazing, rich, and perfectly creamy."

"I found the authentic gelato to be incredibly smooth and creamy."

"I found the Lotus cookie gelato at this ice cream shop to be amazing."

Good to know

1

Rito Gelato just opened, offering a fresh selection of gelato.

2

The owner makes gelato and sorbet on-site using traditional recipes.

3

Rito Gelato offers about 11 flavors of gelato and many creative sorbet options.

02
Mr P's Homemade Ice Cream image 1

Ice cream shop showcases Caribbean-inspired flavors in a colorful, spacious setting with indoor seating and sampling options. Bright and welcoming atmosphere reflects a family-run passion for homemade treats. The vibe blends cultural heritage with a modern twist on classic ice cream.

Creative Caribbean flavors define the ice cream here, crafted by a small family-run team. Nostalgic original creations celebrate Caribbean culture in every scoop.

Fresh ice cream offers an authentic Caribbean flavor with a natural texture that avoids a heavy cream feel. The taste stays true to traditional recipes without artificial heaviness.

People are saying

"The staff here is so friendly, they really take care of you."

"The unique Caribbean flavors here are outrageous, especially the ginger."

"The authentic Caribbean flavors were amazing and delicious."

Good to know

1

Mr. P's celebrates Labor Day weekend with special flavors like lemon ginger and mango.

2

The establishment offers a $3 portion size for ice cream.

3

You can choose 3 flavors on arrival for a tasting experience.

03
Figo il Gelato Italiano image 1

Small ice cream shop offers rich, creamy gelato with authentic Italian flavors like classic pistachio. Heated outdoor seating creates a cozy, warm vibe reminiscent of Venice and Rome. Friendly staff provide generous tastings, making it perfect for enjoying an affogato or coffee.

Gelato offers a distinctive, flavorful taste that stands out from typical ice cream. Cozy seating invites enjoying an affogato or coffee alongside the creamy treats.

Gelato here is rich, creamy, and packed with authentic Italian flavors. Pistachio stands out with a true nutty taste that feels like classic Italian gelato.

People are saying

"I thought the gelato made with Greek yogurt was the best I had."

"The gelato here is rich, creamy, and tastes authentically Italian."

"I thought this was the best ice cream shop in Astoria."

Good to know

1

Figo's is open until midnight for late-night gelato cravings.

2

Each month features seasonal specials to try.

3

The gelato is served in the same size cup for all servings.

04
Gelatoville Gelateria Coffee & bakery image 1

Spacious ice cream shop near Times Square offers authentic Italian gelato with rich, creamy flavors like real pistachio. Cozy seating and free tasting samples create a welcoming vibe. Perfect spot for a sweet treat with vegan options.

Located near Broadway and Times Square, this spot offers convenient access for grabbing ice cream. The shop stands out as a nice place to enjoy a sweet treat.

Flavors come rich and creamy with an authentic Italian touch. Pistachio stands out as a true gem tasting like real pistachios. Gelato is homemade with vibrant, authentic flavors throughout.

People are saying

"The ice cream scooper's energy made the whole experience so much fun."

"I found the gelato to be rich, creamy, and authentic."

"The ice cream shop's flavors are rich, creamy, and so authentic."

Good to know

1

The gelato shop is doing a soft launch today and tomorrow.

2

You can try the flavors before ordering.

3

They are super generous with sampling flavors.

05
Gelateria Gentile image 1
Ice cream shop

Small space with bright, clean decor and adorable display cases creates a cozy, welcoming atmosphere. Sampling two flavors with test spoons is allowed, highlighting attention to detail in gelato and pastry offerings. Outdoor patio and quiet setting add to the relaxed vibe.

Operates late into the night with a focus on ice cream. Offers a solid selection for late-night cravings.

Authentic Italian gelato shines here with flavors from Bari, Puglia. Small gelateria offers well-made, traditional gelato that stays true to its roots.

People are saying

"The gelato here is creamy, rich, and full of flavor."

"The pastries here are fantastic and divine."

"I found the ice cream here to be delicious and high-quality."

Good to know

1

The establishment claims to close at 12:30 AM.

2

You can sample two flavors before making a choice.

3

There is a limit of 2 samples for tasting.

06
Gelatoville Gelataria & Coffee image 1

Stylish interior and ample seating create a cozy vibe. Exceptional gelato rivals Verona's best with authentic Italian flavors like Rafaello and Kinder Bueno. Vibrant music adds to the upbeat, welcoming atmosphere.

Offers exceptional gelato that rivals shops in Verona, Italy. Serves as a true institution for ice cream lovers with consistently awesome flavors.

Gelato here offers authentic Italian flavors that are smooth and rich. Varieties like Rafaello, Kinder Bueno, and Ferrero taste genuine and refreshing.

People are saying

"I thought the gelato here was the best Iโ€™ve ever had."

"The gelato here is rich, creamy, and bursting with authentic flavor."

"I found this ice cream shop to be one of the best I've ever visited."

Good to know

1

The price for a small with two flavors is $7.

2

The price for a medium gelato is $8.

3

There is limited seating in the store.

07
Venchi Chocolate and Gelato Columbus Av image 1

Walls lined with fine Italian chocolates create a cozy, photogenic space with indoor and outdoor seating. Guests enjoy a fancy ice cream experience with samples before buying. Gelato offers rich, authentic flavors and a creamy texture for a genuine Italian taste.

Offers a fancy ice cream experience with a chance to sample flavors before buying. Known for chocolate and gelato that stands out in town.

Gelato features rich, authentic flavors and a perfect creamy texture. The experience offers a genuine taste of Italian gelato with authentic flavor profiles.

People are saying

"The staff here are so nice and helpful with gelato recommendations."

"The gelato here is so rich and authentic."

"The ice cream here is delicious and creamy."

Good to know

1

The establishment is closed for a private event from 5-7 PM.

2

Make sure to register for their loyalty club for a free chocolate bar and discounts.

3

A small cup of gelato with no extras costs $9.

08
Venchi Chocolate Bleecker St image 1

Chocolate boutique boasts glamorous design with gold accents and waterfalls, creating a cozy vibe. Ice cream blends Venezuelan and Colombian flavors with authentic Italian gelato like pistachio's deep nutty flavor. Friendly staff and free samples make it welcoming.

Offers a mix of Venezuelan and Colombian flavors in its ice cream. The shop feels nice and lovely with a clearly good reputation among ice cream spots.

Authentic chocolate and gelato shine here, especially the pistachio gelato with its deep, nutty flavor. The ice cream feels genuinely Italian and the chocolate brands offer a contemporary yet true-to-origin taste.

People are saying

"I found the gelato to be the best I ever had."

"The gelato here is so rich and nutty, it tastes truly authentic."

"This is my favorite ice cream shop; I love the flavors and atmosphere."

Good to know

1

Customers need to pay first and get a ticket to receive gelato at this store.

2

The establishment stays open till midnight when others close at 9 or 10 PM.

3

The gelato shop offers vegan options for customers.

09
Venchi Chocolate & Gelato 7th Avenue image 1

Space combines chocolate shop and gelato bar with a beautifully designed interior featuring colorful ice cream cone decor. Atmosphere feels welcoming and cozy, evoking a European cafรฉ vibe with friendly staff and calm energy. Homemade waffle cones and a spacious seating area add to the inviting experience.

Chocolate uses Venezuelan cocoa for a rich flavor. The shop features a high-end design that stands out on 7th Avenue.

Gelato features authentic flavors and a creamy texture that highlights quality ingredients. Chocolates offer a rich, smooth taste with genuine Italian character.

People are saying

"The gelato here is delicious, especially the pistachio."

"The authentic gelato here is rich, smooth, and tastes like Italy."

"The ice cream here is fantastic, especially the chocolate."

Good to know

1

The price for a small gelato cup with one flavor is $10.

2

Venchi stays open late, closing at 11:30 PM.

3

The establishment is open until 1 am.

10
Venchi image 1
Ice cream shop

Space shaped like a tapering triangle features chocolate pouring walls and a chocolate fountain at the back. Atmosphere feels like a warm, welcoming Wonka fantasy with free chocolate samples and soothing music. Seating areas include an intimate corner with a waterfall and outdoor spots for relaxed enjoyment.

Offers a large selection of ice cream and chocolate. Combines variety with a pleasant atmosphere.

Quality chocolates stand out with rich, authentic flavors. Pistachio gelato contains no color additives and tastes genuine.

People are saying

"The gelato here is so creamy and delicious."

"I loved the rich, authentic flavor of their gelato."

"Douglas made the ice cream shop experience personal and enjoyable."

Good to know

1

There is no parking in this area.

2

The prices are crazy expensive.

3

Customers must decide on the size and pay before trying the flavors.

11
Anita La Mamma del Gelato image 1

Colorful gelato displays fill a beautifully decorated space with indoor and outdoor seating. The atmosphere blends sophisticated design with a fun, lively vibe, supported by loud music and energetic energy. Outdoor tables offer a pleasant spot for people watching and enjoying fresh air.

Lines form even in cold weather, showing strong demand. Ice cream offers excellent flavor and exquisite taste that stands out among nearby shops.

Bold, balanced flavors capture the essence of true Italian gelato. Each scoop offers a rich, creamy texture with authentic tastes that mirror those found in Italy and Sicily.

People are saying

"This gelato is the best ice cream I ever had."

"The ice cream shop has so many delicious flavors."

"The gelato here tastes so rich and authentic, like Italy."

Good to know

1

Expect a long line at night because it is a very popular place.

2

Anita's is open until midnight.

3

The gelato is very expensive at $9 after tax.

12
Venchi Chocolate and Gelato NOMAD image 1

Cozy shop offers free gelato sampling and a chocolate waterfall that adds charm. Creamy gelato boasts authentic Italian flavors with rich, true tastes. Warm, clean space invites ice cream lovers to enjoy excellent quality in a relaxed setting.

Beautiful design creates a welcoming atmosphere. The ice cream features excellent quality and stands out among shops in major cities. Rich flavors make it a notable spot for ice cream lovers.

Creamy texture and authentic Italian flavors define the gelato here. Chocolates and gelatos consistently deliver a true taste of Italy with spectacular authenticity.

People are saying

"The staff here is so friendly, they helped me pick the best gelato."

"The gelato here is rich, creamy, and bursting with authentic flavor."

"The ice cream flavors here are so delicious."

Good to know

1

A scoop with choco sauce in Venchi's tiniest cup costs $8.66 plus tip.

2

The price for 2 cones with 2 flavors is surprisingly high at $20.

3

Customers must pay before trying or selecting a flavor, which is an unusual system.

13
il laboratorio del gelato image 1

Space resembles a laboratory with visible equipment and fluorescent lighting, creating a spooky lab vibe. Atmosphere feels unconventional for an ice cream shop, with some loud children adding to the energy. Seating includes window spots but metal benches feel less inviting.

Lab gelato stands out with rich, delicious flavors that often surpass other ice cream shops. The venue has an unusual warehouse look rather than a typical ice cream parlor style.

Pistachio gelato has a very nutty and authentic flavor. Dark chocolate gelato tends to be sweeter than typical authentic versions here.

People are saying

"The gelato here has so many unique and natural flavors."

"The authentic flavors, like mango and black sesame, were superb."

"This ice cream shop has so many awesome and unique flavors."

Good to know

1

Three scoops of ice cream cost around $6.

2

The price for 4 big scoops in a waffle at Il laboratorio del gelato is $8.

3

There are no samples or sampling available at Il Laboratorio del Gelato.

14
Julietta Gelato Cafรจ image 1

Small gelato shop offers plenty of unique flavors with a lively atmosphere created by house music. Seating includes outdoor options and small indoor tables with stools. Sampling is allowed, and a dairy-free creamy gelato section is available.

Offers very good gelato in a cute and pretty setting. Stands out as a spot worth returning to for ice cream.

Gelato here tastes very authentic with a creamy, fresh texture and balanced sweetness. Flavors burst with genuine Italian style, making it stand out as truly refreshing.

People are saying

"I thought the gelato was creamy, fresh, and bursting with authentic flavor."

"I found the gelato to be really authentic and awesome."

"It's a cute and pretty ice cream shop."

Good to know

1

The price for the smallest serving is $6 plus tax and tip.

2

A small size has two scoops.

3

You can get 2 flavors in 1 small cup.

15
Amorino Gelato - New York Times Square image 1

Gelato served in rose-shaped presentation stands out visually. Loud club music fills the space, creating a high-energy atmosphere. Self-serve ordering kiosks speed up lines, while outdoor seating expands capacity year-round.

Offers solid ice cream options with a good overall experience. Some other parlors nearby provide more variety or flavors.

Gelato features authentic Italian flavors with a fresh quality that matches classic Italian gelato. Rich aromas and tastes bring a genuine Italian experience.

People are saying

"You have to try their specialty hot chocolate with gelato inside."

"I loved the authentic Italian gelato flavors."

"The ice cream shop has excellent, friendly service."

Good to know

1

Customers must go to a kiosk to place their order and pay before standing in line.

2

In the event of a large crowd, expect a long wait.

3

Customers are not allowed to taste flavors before purchasing due to long lines.

16
Gelateria Gentile - West Village image 1

Small gelato shop offers authentic Italian gelato with a limited variety of flavors. Outdoor seating is cute but scarce, filling up quickly. Atmosphere feels Italian and cozy, suited for quick, satisfying visits.

A tiny ice cream shop with a cute, small space draws people from farther away than other nearby spots.

Gelato here tastes truly authentic with rich, creamy textures. It captures the classic flavors that feel like genuine Italian gelato.

People are saying

"The ice cream here is amazing and delicious."

"It's nice to grab a cup of gelato and sit in the outdoor space."

"The gelato here is so rich, creamy, and authentic."

Good to know

1

The gelato costs $8 for a small scoop, which is considered pricey.

2

The shop opens at 12:30 PM, not at 12:00 PM as advertised.

3

There is no indoor seating available for customers.

17
Malai image 1
Ice cream shop

Small space with cozy seating and appealing decor creates a cute ambiance. Friendly staff contribute to a welcoming atmosphere despite limited room. Unique flavors and creative presentation define the experience.

Unique flavors and egg allergy-friendly options define this ice cream shop. It offers a delicious experience that stands out among others.

Indian ice creams here offer delicious, authentic flavors but the kulfi leans more toward Indian-inspired rather than traditional. Kolkata Chai Co. brings a warm cultural vibe with flavorful chai and friendly staff.

People are saying

"I loved the unique and delicious ice cream flavors here."

"The ice cream shop has delicious and creative flavors."

"The Indian ice cream flavors here are so authentic and delicious."

Good to know

1

Two one scoop ice creams cost a total of $18.

2

There is a $2 surcharge for the cone.

3

There is a $1 surcharge for sprinkles.

18
Chelsea Market image 1

Large covered market inside a restored industrial factory blends historic architecture with modern culinary culture. Vibrant atmosphere fills the space with diverse shops and food stalls, attracting many visitors. Outdoor heated booths offer comfortable spots to eat despite the busy, sometimes warm environment.

An ice cream parlor inside an air-conditioned indoor market offers various flavors. Staff behavior includes racist treatment, which affects service quality.

An authentic asado grill runs here, rare outside Mexico. The market offers a diverse array of global cuisines including fresh seafood, hand-rolled sushi, and authentic tacos.

People are saying

"This market has endless food options and great shopping."

"It's a vibrant, energetic place with authentic food from all over."

"I found numerous ice cream shops inside this indoor market."

Good to know

1

Happy hour offers half price on oysters and beers/wine.

2

Chelsea Market hosts various events, including cooking classes and pop-up shops.

3

Expect a 20-minute queue outside every restaurant during peak hours.

Discover more

New York, New York

Area guide
Loading Map...