Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Local picks in New York

Banana pudding and ice cream

A banana pudding and an ice cream are both non-negotiable parts of your dessert rotation.

Based on 764 Opinions
+761
User
User
User
Updated June 2026
01
Avrilililly's Creamery LLC image 1
Avrilililly's Creamery LLC image 2
Avrilililly's Creamery LLC image 3
View all

Ice cream shop showcases vibrant colors and a poetic Harlem theme with original murals and wall poetry. Comfortable indoor and outdoor seating supports a family- and vegan-friendly atmosphere with good music and WiFi. The space balances a sophisticated yet playful vibe that invites work and socializing.

Banana pudding here has a light, fluffy texture and is not too sweet. It carries a perfect balance of flavor that stands out among desserts.

Gelato and sorbet here are subtle and sophisticated with standout flavors like guava yuzu and mango. Sampling every flavor is possible, and the ice cream consistently impresses with its quality.

People are saying

"The owner's warm greetings make the ice cream experience special."

"I found the gelato here to be the best I had outside of Italy."

"I thought the banana pudding was creamy and flavorful."

Good to know

1

They offer a 10% discount for students, teachers, and first responders.

2

To get the college student discount, you need to print your ID card.

3

Gelatos from the day before are discounted.

02
Noona's Ice Cream image 1
Ice cream shop

Small shop offers Asian-inspired ice cream with unique flavors like toasted rice and strawberry yuzu. Space feels compact and stuffy, with limited seating for a few people. Ice cream is thick, creamy, and less sweet than traditional options.

Banana pudding appears as a mochi flavor paired with Nila water cookies and caramel drizzle. It delivers a wildly delicious taste that stands out among other flavors like passion fruit and rice cake.

Asian-inspired flavors like strawberry yuzu, ube, and pandan stand out with thick, creamy texture made from quality ingredients. Creative toppings such as turmeric honeycomb and black sesame jam add unique twists to the ice cream experience.

People are saying

"The ice cream flavors here are so unique and delicious."

"The mochi topping is really good and pairs well with any flavor."

"You have to try the banana pudding, it's so good."

Good to know

1

The average price for a pint is $13-15.

2

Customers are allowed to try many flavors before choosing.

3

You must order 3 pints or more for delivery.

03
Willow Vegan Bistro image 1
Vegan restaurant

Mid-century modern decor with sound absorbing panels creates a cozy, inviting atmosphere despite tight table spacing. The space features huge windows that add natural light, balancing the compact layout. Music and lighting contribute to a warm, comfortable vibe where conversation is easy.

Rich, creamy texture defines the banana pudding here, making it a standout dessert. It pairs well with other dishes like the oyster mushroom calamari and Chefโ€™s Cookie Skillet for a satisfying finish.

Housemade ice cream stands out with its rich texture and generous toppings like syrup and nuts. The Chef's Cookie Skillet pairs ice cream with roasted peanuts for a decadent dessert experience.

People are saying

"The vegetarian comfort food here is so flavorful and satisfying."

"I thought I knew good Banana Pudding until I tried theirs."

"You have to try their housemade ice cream; it's excellent."

Good to know

1

Happy hour offers half-priced drinks and finger food from 5 to 6:30 pm.

2

Sandwiches are discounted on Thursdays.

3

Reservations are recommended for weekends or busy hours.

04
Trudy's Ice Cream image 1
Ice cream shop

Small ice cream shop offers homemade waffle cones and a variety of unique flavors like pistachio and coconut. Bright, colorful space includes outdoor seating and welcomes dogs with special pup cups. Neighborhood spot combines a fun, clean atmosphere with a friendly vibe.

Banana pudding stands out with its delicious flavor and is often paired with pistachio or walnut & maple for variety.

Homemade ice cream here is freshly made and delicious with a variety of great flavors. Portions are generous and prices are affordable, plus the spot is dog-friendly.

People are saying

"I found the homemade ice cream here to be delicious."

"The orange creamsicle soft serve is amazing and keeps me coming back."

"I found the banana pudding flavor to be delicious."

Good to know

1

The owner and his wife make the ice cream fresh every day.

2

Waffle cones are made fresh at the shop.

3

The Maple Walnut flavor is only $5.

05
Heap's Ice Cream image 1
Ice cream shop

Cozy ice cream shop with an old school vibe and bright natural light fills with families enjoying treats. Creative flavors like mango sticky rice and stroopwafel stand out alongside fresh waffle cones. Ample outdoor seating complements a friendly, welcoming atmosphere.

Banana pudding comes as a creative ice cream flavor here, standing out among options like mango sticky rice and stroopwafel. It delivers a smooth, sweet taste that many find excellent and enjoyable.

Ice cream features unique flavors like Thai tea and banana pudding. Creative options include ice cream sushi. The shop offers non-dairy choices and thoughtful accessibility.

People are saying

"I thought the ice cream here was delicious and artisanal."

"The dairy-free sorbets here are delicious and creative."

"I found the banana pudding flavor to be out of this world."

Good to know

1

One scoop of ice cream costs $6.50.

2

There are non-dairy options available.

3

Heap's offers unique flavors and fresh ingredients.

06
C as in Charlie image 1
Korean restaurant

Tables sit close together in a warm, eclectic space filled with loud energy and interactive experiences like dessert painting. The vibe blends Korean jeong with Southern hospitality, creating a fun atmosphere suited for small groups. An open kitchen adds warmth, while music keeps the mood lively.

Banana pudding comes as a dessert that guests can draw on and enter a contest. It arrives alongside complimentary sweet tea and pairs well with dishes like mushroom bibimbap and oxtail pasta.

A unique ice cream sandwich shaped like a bagel stands out here. It features cream cheese gelato and homemade jelly inside a bagel-shaped wafer.

People are saying

"The toast roll and banana pudding dessert were my favorite dishes."

"You have to try the deli bagel ice cream dessert; it's unique and delicious."

"The banana pudding here was good."

Good to know

1

Reservations are highly recommended due to the crowd.

2

The restaurant offers a 22:30 dinner slot on Saturdays.

3

The place gets fun at the end of the night Thursday to Saturday nights.

07
Sweets for the Sweeties image 1

Dessert shop with cute decor and an energetic vibe that feels like a party. Music plays a big role in setting a happy, positive atmosphere. Known for delicious cupcakes and ice cream, it draws a lively crowd looking for a sweet treat.

Banana pudding stands out for its delicious flavor and quality. Price tends to be on the higher side compared to similar desserts.

Toasted coconut and strawberry cheesecake stand out as unique ice cream flavors. Options like sea salt caramel and cookie and cream add variety, all at affordable prices.

People are saying

"I loved their delicious cupcakes; they were amazing."

"I had the best ice cream Iโ€™ve had in a while here."

"I really loved their Banana Pudding."

Good to know

1

The shop offers a create-your-own milkshake project for kids' parties.

2

Birthday parties are fun and well-organized at this location.

3

The ice cream servings are large and affordable.

08
Uncle Louie G image 1
Ice cream shop

Ice cream shop offers standing tables only and a clean, cool interior with friendly atmosphere. It features an unbeatable variety of flavors including Italian ice and acai bowls. The outside seating area lacks cleanliness, contrasting with the inviting inside space.

Banana pudding pie stands out as very tasty and delicious. The banana pudding offers a signature Magnolia taste and is often described as extremely delicious and amazing.

Phenomenal ice cream comes in many forms here, from loaded sundaes like the strawberry shortcake with cheesecake ice cream to unique treats like Big Louie G. Portions are generous, often filling cups so much they don't close, and flavor options range from classic chocolate to inventive combinations with funnel cake and fried Oreos.

People are saying

"I found the acai bowls here to be out of this world."

"I found the ice cream to be great and delicious."

"I found the banana pudding to be extremely delicious."

Good to know

1

They stopped taking orders at 9:20 PM except for ice cream and Italian ice.

2

The restaurant closes at 10:00 PM.

3

They have the option for gluten-free granola.

09
Dreams of Sugar image 1

Pink decor and cute aesthetics define the small bakery, creating a friendly and girly atmosphere. Indoor seating includes a ceiling swing for photos, adding to the playful vibe. Dense, fresh cupcakes and soft cinnamon rolls attract those seeking quality desserts with a design-focused touch.

Whipped texture balances well with the right amount of bananas and cookies. The banana pudding is not overly sweet and often considered better than Magnolia's by some.

Ice cream appears mostly as part of dessert combos, often paired with cupcakes or dessert cups. The shop offers vanilla ice cream combined with cake and cookies, creating a sweet, layered treat.

People are saying

"These cupcakes are light, fluffy, moist, and delicious."

"I thought the banana pudding was whipped and excellent."

"I was hooked on these amazing cupcakes with a homemade taste."

Good to know

1

An extra fee is charged for credit card payments instead of cash or debit.

2

Customers should be informed about the credit card fee beforehand.

10
NY Bakery and Desserts Times Square image 1

Clean space with luxurious decor and a chocolate waterfall wall creates a striking setting. Loud music fills the air, making conversation challenging. Outdoor seating offers views of street shows and passersby, adding to the lively atmosphere.

Rich flavor and creamy texture define the banana pudding here. It consistently tastes delicious and stands out among desserts.

Gelato stands out with flavors like passion fruit and lemon and American cherry. The ice cream pairs well with desserts like chocolate cake and tiramisu, offering excellent taste and service.

People are saying

"The desserts here are fresh and absolutely amazing."

"The gelato here is amazing and delicious."

"I found the banana pudding to be truly delicious."

Good to know

1

There are no seats available inside the bakery, only outside seating.

2

The price of the apple turnover is $8 plus tip.

3

The bakery is located right in the middle of Times Square.

11
NY Bakery and Desserts Midtown image 1

Bright, cozy bakery with beautiful decor and a flowing chocolate fountain creates a friendly atmosphere. Seating includes a small back area and outdoor options, offering a comfortable place to enjoy a wide array of desserts. The vibe is inviting and the space feels clean and well-appointed.

Layered pudding mixture creates a rich texture in the banana pudding. It stands out with a smooth, creamy consistency and pairs well with other desserts like vanilla cupcakes.

Gelato stands out with mango and cookies and cream flavors that taste fresh and rich. Sorbets and ice creams carry real fruit flavors, like the amarena cherry gelato which is very flavorful and satisfying.

People are saying

"I found the desserts here to be amazing."

"The gelato here is delicious and refreshing."

"I thought the banana pudding was the best I had ever tasted."

Good to know

1

The establishment is open 24 hours for late-night cravings.

2

Cheesecakes and desserts are available late at night.

3

No vegan options are available for those with dietary restrictions.

12
Thai Diner image 1
Thai restaurant

American diner setting blends with Thai-style decor featuring plants and art, creating a vibrant atmosphere. Outdoor seating offers a cozy, multi-season space that welcomes dogs and service animals. Crowd tends to be cool and lively, with dim lighting and a mix of indoor and outdoor areas.

Sweet and creamy, the banana pudding offers a familiar yet fresh finish. It stands out as an outstanding dessert that consistently impresses.

Coconut ice cream stands out as a key dessert, often paired with banana rum pudding or served in a sundae. These options highlight the dessert menu with rich, tropical flavors.

People are saying

"The diner food here is flavorful, comforting, and perfectly executed."

"I thought the banana pudding was outstanding."

"The coconut ice cream sundae was the best I had."

Good to know

1

Expect a wait of 1.5 hours during peak hours, especially on weekends.

2

Reservations are recommended for breakfast to avoid long wait times.

3

The restaurant serves brunch items daily before 5pm.

13
Martha's Country Bakery image 1

Spacious bakery with plenty of seating and an appealing design creates a welcoming environment. Evenings feature a live DJ spinning an eclectic mix of music, making the atmosphere lively and energetic. Outdoor seating adds to the relaxed vibe during quieter hours.

Creamy texture and use of real bananas stand out in the banana pudding. It ranks as one of the best-tasting versions, often considered the star dessert here.

Warm desserts often come paired with ice cream like salted caramel or vanilla, enhancing the flavors. The selection includes strawberry and espresso ice cream, plus gelato and ice cream cakes that balance richness and sweetness well.

People are saying

"The pastries here are amazing and generously filled for the price."

"I thought the banana pudding was very creamy and delicious."

"The espresso ice cream is delicious and nicely balanced."

Good to know

1

On Mondays, gourmet cupcakes are on special for only $1.95 each.

2

The shop has a daily promotion with different specials each day.

3

They have a deal of the day where a different pastry or cake slice is half off.

14
Mia's Brooklyn Bakery image 1

Bakery offers cozy indoor seating and a quiet backyard garden with beautiful lighting for a relaxed atmosphere. Space feels crowded and noisy inside, with tables placed closely together. Outdoor area provides a calm spot to enjoy desserts and drinks away from the bustle.

Rich and creamy with a whipped texture, the banana pudding has a cheesecake feel. It stays moist and flavorful, making it a very good and delicious choice for banana pudding fans.

Gelato features prominently alongside gourmet ice cream options. The setup includes a coffee bar that complements the ice cream and gelato offerings.

People are saying

"I found the cake here to be amazing and delicious."

"They have gourmet ice cream and gelato with tons of flavors."

"I found the banana pudding to be truly amazing."

Good to know

1

Mia's is open until midnight on weekends and 10 PM on weeknights.

2

Expect a 15-minute wait for to-go desserts during peak hours.

3

Parking near the bakery is challenging, with limited metered spaces.

Discover more

New York, New York

Area guide
Loading Map...