Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Top picks in New York

Cheesecake and birthday cakes

You believe that a birthday celebration requires both a traditional cake and a proper slice of cheesecake.

Based on 936 Opinions
+933
User
User
User
Updated June 2026
01
Crumbly Cafe & Bakery image 1
Crumbly Cafe & Bakery image 2
Crumbly Cafe & Bakery image 3
View all

Small, cozy bakery with a warm, inviting atmosphere and intoxicating smell of fresh baked goods. Friendly staff create a welcoming vibe, complemented by a pleasant outdoor seating area. The space feels charming and intimate, perfect for relaxing or casual meetups.

Oreo cheesecake stands out as a favorite with a rich, creamy texture. Other options like caramel pecan and key lime cheesecakes offer distinct, homemade flavors. Cheesecakes here are consistently delicious and well-crafted.

Custom birthday cakes come in rainbow layers and themed designs like Minions. Coconut cakes taste just right, not too sweet. Orders complete on time with beautiful, tasty results.

People are saying

"This bakery made my daughter's birthday cake exactly as I requested."

"I thought the birthday cake was gorgeous and delicious."

"I thought the cheesecake here was really delicious."

Good to know

1

Visitors should get to the bakery early on weekends to try new items, as they sell out.

2

Ingredients could be modified due to allergens for special events.

3

Delivery from Crumbly is always on time.

02
Bakelicious By Chef Manny Inc image 1

Bakery offers a cozy, family-owned atmosphere filled with the aroma of freshly baked goods and spotless, detailed decor. The space feels warm and inviting, reflecting pride and dedication in every aspect. It draws a diverse crowd seeking authentic, flavorful pastries and cakes.

Creamy cheesecakes come in flavors like passion fruit blueberry and oreo, blending tangy and sweet notes. Large cheesecakes often disappear quickly at gatherings, showing their popularity.

Custom birthday cakes feature detailed decorations and strong flavor that impress many. Cakes often match specific images or themes, like a Marshmello design or crema de leche flavor.

People are saying

"I found the cake here to be so moist and delicious."

"I found the Biscoff cheesecake to be a must-try."

"This birthday cake was beautiful and delicious!"

Good to know

1

The bakery takes custom orders for cakes.

2

The tres leches cake costs $5.

3

The establishment is very clean.

03
Cakes by Nerwan image 1

Cake shop offers custom designs with fresh, visually stunning desserts including cupcakes, cake pops, and unique items like kunafsicles. Atmosphere feels aesthetically pleasing but lacks warmth. Pricing is notably high, reflecting an elevated, chic experience.

Cheesecakes here stand out for their rich flavor and creamy texture. The cake and cheesecake jars offer a unique way to enjoy this dessert alongside banana pudding.

Birthday cakes come in unique flavors like cannoli and aperol spritz cupcakes with orange and vanilla. Custom designs are made from a single inspiration picture.

People are saying

"I found the cake to be beautiful and delicious."

"The birthday cake here is just delicious."

"I ate one of the best cheesecakes my family has ever had."

Good to know

1

Cakes by Nerwan allows customers to select the design, flavor, filling, and color of the cake.

2

The best way to order cupcakes is through their website.

3

The cake was ready under a 24-hour timeline.

04
Oh.Sweet.Mason [Desserts, Custom Birthday Cake & Specialty Cupcakes] image 1

Cozy and spacious bakery with a welcoming vibe and friendly staff. Custom cakes and cupcakes feature intricate fondant toppers and themed designs like sushi and casino chips. Dessert jars offer unique flavors such as biscoff cookie cheesecake and cinnamon toast crunch cheesecake.

Cheesecakes come in jars with flavors like biscoff cookie and cinnamon toast crunch. Red velvet cheesecake brownies also stand out as a popular choice.

Custom birthday cakes come through even on short notice. Cakes impress with great taste and presentation.

People are saying

"I commissioned a masterpiece cake with a stunning theme."

"I'd get the red velvet cheesecake brownie again."

"The birthday cake here is amazing and delicious."

Good to know

1

Oh.Sweet.Mason provides desserts and sweet treats for events.

2

They offer a variety of cake and cheesecake shooters.

3

Cupcakes are available but may be pricey due to special decorations.

05
Les Gateaux de Marie image 1

Small bakery with Parisian patisserie style and handmade elegant decorations creates a warm, cozy atmosphere with a welcoming neighborhood vibe. The space feels clean and charming, inviting guests to enjoy beautifully crafted cakes and desserts.

New York style cheesecake stands out with its rich, creamy texture and scratch-made quality. Personalized edible flowers add a unique touch, and many find it very tasty and exceptionally good.

Custom birthday cakes come with detailed themes like Pokémon and exceed expectations. Cakes get delivered to the venue, making celebrations easier.

People are saying

"The cake was absolutely delicious and beautifully done."

"This birthday cake is gorgeous and tasted great."

"This cheesecake is the best I've ever had."

Good to know

1

Croissants are sold at a 50% discount after 5pm.

2

There is no indoor dining available.

3

The bakery offers custom cakes for special occasions.

06
Conti's Pastry Shoppe image 1

Bakery offers wide variety of Italian pastries displayed in orderly glass counters within a beautiful, vintage atmosphere with modern twist. The space feels clean and inviting, with outdoor seating and a full coffee bar adding to the experience.

Cheesecakes come in varied flavors like Pumpkin Carrot, Apple Strudel, and Strawberry Topped. The New York cheesecake and Blondie cheesecake stand out for their taste and freshness.

Birthday cakes come in custom designs and are ordered repeatedly for family celebrations. Cakes like Boston Cream and other pastries appear regularly for birthdays and special occasions.

People are saying

"They executed the custom cake design exactly to my vision."

"This birthday cake is beautiful and absolutely delicious."

"The red velvet cheesecake is the best I've ever tasted."

Good to know

1

You should preorder your custom cake in advance around the holidays due to high demand.

2

The bakery has a 2-day notice for placing cake orders.

3

Expect long lines on holidays like Christmas Eve due to high customer volume.

07
Mia's Brooklyn Bakery image 1

Cozy bakery with rustic wooden accents and beautiful decor creates a warm, inviting atmosphere. Comfortable seating indoors and outdoors supports relaxed visits, though loud music sometimes fills the space. Cakes and desserts stand out as memorable and excellent offerings.

Strawberry cheesecake stands out as a memorable and frequently thought-about dessert. Varieties like three-fruit, pecan, and blueberry cheesecakes offer tasty options, with some slices topped in salted caramel for a special treat.

Custom birthday cakes come with detailed designs like dinosaur themes and match exact requests. Cakes are beautiful and delicious, often ordered last-minute and loved by kids and adults alike.

People are saying

"The custom cake came out exactly how I imagined it."

"I thought the cheesecake here was great."

"I ordered a birthday cake that was stunning and delicious."

Good to know

1

Reservations are required for custom cake orders, especially for weekends.

2

The bakery offers a variety of gluten-free and vegan options.

3

Cakes are prepared in advance and may not be freshly baked.

08
Huascar & Co. Bakeshop image 1

Tiny bakery with a beautifully decorated interior and outdoor cafe area offers a comforting atmosphere filled with the delicious smell of fresh baking. Customers enjoy unique gluten-free treats and exquisite cupcakes with bold flavors in a cozy, tucked-away setting.

Passion fruit cheesecake stands out with its bright, tangy flavor. Cheesecakes come in jars featuring a Graham cracker base and balanced sweetness, including the visually appealing Empire State Cheesecake.

Custom birthday cakes and themed cupcakes come with detailed designs like mermaids. The bakery handles special orders with care and creativity.

People are saying

"These cupcakes are beautiful, delicious, and fresh."

"The bakery cakes here are beautiful and delicious."

"The Birthday Cake was a stunning centerpiece and tasted delicious."

Good to know

1

The bakery provides dependable delivery of delicious products.

2

The bakery offers desserts to go, including passion fruit cheesecake and tres leches cake.

3

The alfajores come individually packaged, making them great for gifts.

09
Cookies and Cream Pastry Shop image 1

Small pastry shop offers a cozy atmosphere with cute outdoor seating and a warm vibe. Pastries are high quality and reasonably priced, with standout items like rich muffins and custom cakes. The space feels inviting for casual visits with friends or family.

Cheesecakes come in several tasty varieties like caramel flan, red velvet, and pumpkin. The caramel flan cheesecake melts in your mouth and feels very satisfying.

Custom birthday cakes come with detailed designs that match requests and taste great. Cupcakes and cookies also complement the cake for celebrations.

People are saying

"Their pastries are fresh, delicious, and have great flavor profiles."

"I loved how beautiful the birthday cake was, I didn't want to eat it."

"I loved their pumpkin cheesecake."

Good to know

1

Reservations for custom cakes require at least two weeks' notice.

2

Pricing for cakes, cupcakes, and cookies is very reasonable.

3

Customer service can vary; visiting early may improve your experience.

10
Tasty Pastry Shoppe image 1

Bright, clean bakery offers wide gluten-free and sugar-free selection alongside traditional treats. Space feels tight and busy, especially on weekends, but lines move quickly. Known for exceptional cheesecake and cakes, it caters well to diverse dietary needs.

Cheesecakes come in a big variety with flavors like mango, chocolate mousse, strawberry, and passion fruit. They are creamy and phenomenal, with passion fruit standing out for its strong flavor.

Delicious birthday cakes come with beautiful designs that suit all ages. Cakes for first and third birthdays show consistent quality and care.

People are saying

"I thought their cakes and pastries were better than I could imagine."

"This cheesecake is phenomenal, so creamy and delicious."

"I thought the birthday cake was delicious and moist."

Good to know

1

The shop gets really busy on weekends, but the line moves fast.

2

They offer a wide variety of gluten-free, sugar-free, and vegan options.

3

Small slices of pastries cost about $3 each.

11
New York Bakery Café image 1

Bakery offers lively ambiance with stylish, cozy seating and beautiful cake displays. Music plays softly in the background, creating a warm, inviting atmosphere. The space supports both casual visits and working sessions comfortably.

Red velvet, caramel, and Oreo cheesecakes stand out for their rich flavors and texture. Varieties like carrot cake, creme brulee, and mixed fruit cheesecake offer a range from firm to creamy, with sweetness well balanced.

Birthday cakes come in funfetti half sheets and strawberry tres leches varieties. Jeta provides great customer service and helps with custom orders.

People are saying

"The bakery staff are so friendly and attentive."

"I found the cheesecake here to be the best I ever had."

"They were so kind and helpful with my birthday cake order."

Good to know

1

Cakes are available for birthdays and special events.

2

You need to order custom cakes at least a day in advance for special occasions.

3

They are open nearly until midnight.

12
Happy Zoe Vegan Bakery image 1

Small space with vintage ambiance and cozy seating creates a calm, homey vibe. Decor includes anti-leather signs and a style reminiscent of a southern thrift store. Energy stays relaxed, making it suitable for quiet conversation and casual visits.

Vegan cheesecake stands out with its rich flavor and creamy texture. Variations like pistachio matcha cheesecake add unique twists, making it a memorable choice among other vibrant desserts.

Vegan birthday cakes come in beautiful, custom designs that suit allergy needs. The cakes are consistently delicious and visually appealing, with options like cheesecake also available.

People are saying

"This cake is so delicious, I can't stop eating it."

"These moist, delicious dairy-free cakes are perfect for birthdays."

"This birthday cake is the best I've ever had."

Good to know

1

The correct hours of operation are Tuesday to Sunday from 12 PM to 5 PM.

2

Everything is animal cruelty free and 100% vegan.

3

This bakery has many options for people with allergies to dairy, wheat, egg, and soy.

13
Fat Cardinal Provisions image 1

Bakery offers homemade donuts and a variety of freshly baked pastries with reasonable prices. Atmosphere feels inclusive and welcoming with a small counter and a red table outside for coffee enjoyment. Known for quality goods made on location and a homely neighborhood vibe.

Berry cheesecake stands out with a rich, tasty flavor. Cheesecake options come at a reasonable price and pair well with other desserts like blueberry muffins and key lime pie.

Birthday cakes come with custom themes like a cars design that gets duplicated with precision. Ordering happens repeatedly, showing consistent satisfaction with their themed cake quality.

People are saying

"I found the custom cakes here to be beautiful works of art."

"They perfectly captured the details for my birthday cake idea."

"I enjoyed the cheesecake; it was wonderful and yummy."

Good to know

1

The bakery offers affordable prices for all items.

2

Quality goods are made on location for freshness.

3

The shop is a small takeout spot for quick visits.

14
Buttercup BakeShop image 1
Cupcake shop

Small cupcake shop with classic, old school design and pink, cute interior creates a warm, inviting atmosphere. Soft jazz music plays while two small tables offer seating for quick treats. Known for outstanding cupcakes and unique flavors like banana cream pie and red velvet cheesecake.

Red velvet cheesecake stands out as a favorite, alongside the marble cheesecake and New York cheesecakes. Cheesecake brownies and raspberry almond cheesecake also appear as popular choices.

Custom birthday cakes come with personalized messages and match exact requests. Flavors like red velvet and cookies n cream stand out as sweet and delicious options.

People are saying

"The cupcakes here are amazing and delicious."

"The Birthday Cake service was so patient and helpful."

"I found the red velvet cheesecake to be very good and creamy."

Good to know

1

The bakery offers gluten-free options, ensuring a variety for dietary needs.

2

Prices for baked goods are clearly posted outside the shop.

3

There is usually no long wait at this cupcake shop.

15
Cestra's Bakery image 1

Cozy bakery with an inviting smell of freshly baked goods and a wide selection of high quality pastries and Italian bread. Staff wear gloves while handling food, maintaining a clean environment. Free dog treats add a unique touch to the welcoming atmosphere.

Creamy cheesecakes come in several flavors like pistachio, strawberry, and raspberry. Chocolate cake also pairs well with the cheesecake options.

Carrot cake stands out as a top choice here. Birthday cakes come with a variety of delicious flavors alongside cookies, pies, and cheesecakes.

People are saying

"The custom cakes from this bakery are always made exactly like the picture."

"I thought the birthday cake was absolutely delicious."

"I found the strawberry cheesecake to be amazing."

Good to know

1

After 7pm, the restaurant gives away their Italian bread.

2

The bakery opens at 8 am on Christmas day, not 6 am as stated online.

3

Always prepay for your wanted items in advance to ensure availability.

16
Artuso Pastry Shop image 1

Spacious bakery with old-school charm and a family atmosphere offers a wide selection of colorful, fresh pastries and cakes. The place feels cozy and clean, inviting guests to enjoy the simple, delicious surroundings while exploring traditional treats.

Small cheesecakes come in mini sizes with flavors like raspberry and guava. The selection includes fruity options and rich varieties like tiramisu and dulce de leche cheesecakes.

Vanilla sponge birthday cakes come with chocolate and vanilla ice cream. Cakes are available for last minute orders and consistently delicious.

People are saying

"I found the cakes here to be so fresh and delicious."

"I loved their cheesecake; it was one of my favorites."

"I loved the birthday cake; it tasted wonderful."

Good to know

1

You need to get a ticket as you enter.

2

The numbered ticket system should always be used.

3

Some items sell out towards the end of the day.

17
Butterly Bakeshop image 1

Narrow space with cozy modern decor and a chained yellow bike outside sets a charming scene. Warm atmosphere fills the air with the aroma of freshly baked goods. Known for moist cupcakes and rich banana pudding, it offers limited indoor seating and caters mainly to non-vegan, non-allergic customers.

Apple cheesecake bars combine crumble, pie, checked layers, and a crumbly crust in equal parts. The cheesecake itself adds very little flavor to the overall dessert.

Birthday cakes come out fresh, delicious, and attractive even with short notice. They rank among the yummiest in the city and have been a reliable choice for multiple years.

People are saying

"They recreated my custom cake design perfectly."

"I tried the apple pie cheesecake and it was so filling."

"They recreated my custom Birthday Cake design perfectly."

Good to know

1

The bakery is closed on Mondays.

2

The bakery offers great vegan and gluten-free options.

3

There is not much indoor seating available as the space is very narrow.

18
AnnTremet Cake image 1

Small bakery with just a few tables inside and one outside offers a cozy atmosphere and stylish presentation of intricately designed cakes. The space feels minimalist with white walls and limited decor, creating a simple backdrop for the artful desserts.

Cheesecakes come in unique flavors like Black Sesame, Sakura, and Pandan Coconut. The Bunny Cheesecake stands out for its cute design and enjoyable taste.

Strawberry birthday cake stands out for its flavor and quality. Cakes consistently come out delicious and well-executed, impressing everyone at parties.

People are saying

"Annabelle was so helpful and patient with my cake questions."

"This birthday cake tastes amazing and isn't too sweet."

"The cheesecake bunny was too cute not to buy and I didn't regret it."

Good to know

1

Reservations are highly advised due to limited seating.

2

The Halloween Afternoon Tea costs $52 per person and features eerie treats.

3

Christmas tea time slots fill up quickly, so book early.

19
Mark's Bake Shoppe image 1

Intimate bakery space creates a warm and cozy atmosphere with a welcoming vibe from staff. Large selection of baked goods includes custom cakes and soft donuts that attract small groups and celebrations.

Rainbow cookie cheesecake stands out as a favorite, often sparking conversation. Large cheesecakes come in various flavors, including a pumpkin cheesecake made for special occasions.

Birthday cakes come in varied quality, with some orders matching Instagram inspiration and others falling short. The shop offers birthday cake muffins and has been a regular source for cakes over multiple years.

People are saying

"I thought their carrot cake was the best I've ever had."

"The rainbow cookie cheesecake was a big hit."

"I've ordered birthday cakes here every year and they never disappoint."

Good to know

1

You can order online and pick up your order for a specific time.

2

The bakery delivers if you order through their website.

3

Vegan cakes are available for kids with allergies.

20
Jean Danet Pastry Shop and Caffe' image 1

Pastry shop offers a wide variety of baked goods with a quiet, clean atmosphere. Fresh cream puffs and exceptional cheesecake stand out among the options. Prices are moderate and the staff is friendly.

Strawberry cheesecake stands out with its excellent flavor and creamy texture. Cheesecakes here consistently show exceptional quality and freshness.

Birthday cakes feature cream-heavy layers with minimal sponge. Custom inscriptions like "Happy Birthday Baby Cakes" are available. Cakes suit various ages, from children to adults.

People are saying

"The cake here is delicious and turned out beautifully."

"This Birthday Cake is delicious, filled with strawberries and cream."

"I thought their cheesecake was exceptional."

Good to know

1

You can buy a last minute cake here for a forgotten birthday.

2

This bakery charges a fee if you use a credit or debit card to pay.

3

The bakery is moderately priced but not cheap.

21
Maison De Gateaux image 1

Bakery offers an elegant decoration with tables on the sidewalk creating a cute and quiet space. Atmosphere stays inviting and peaceful, suitable for quiet moments or friendly get-togethers. Cakes and pastries are fresh and moist, with a wide variety that draws those who appreciate quality desserts.

Many cheesecakes look tempting with a variety of flavors. The Dubai cheesecake stands out as incredible, while birthday cakes and cheesecake slices are consistently delicious.

Custom birthday cakes come with quick responses and helpful service. Tiramisu cakes and cheesecake slices stand out as delicious options.

People are saying

"The cakes here are so moist and delicious."

"The coffee here is great, and the staff is so warm and welcoming."

"The cheesecake slices here looked amazing and were delicious."

Good to know

1

Maison De Gateaux offers a wide variety of fresh and exceptional desserts.

2

The prices at Maison De Gateaux are very affordable.

3

The cake can be customized in just 3 days.

22
Sugarboy Bakery image 1

Bright, pink, and inviting space offers a warm and friendly atmosphere. Cakes and pastries focus on freshness and visual presentation, with a standout tres leche cake praised for its softness and flavor. The bakery balances affordable prices with a professional and welcoming vibe.

Cheesecake features a perfect texture and is not too sweet. Fresh fruit toppings add a bright, natural flavor that complements the cake well.

Birthday cakes come in various styles here, including tres leche. Some cakes are fresh and meet expectations, while others can be dry and stale. Prices can be high but reflect the cake's presentation.

People are saying

"The cakes here are beautiful and full of flavor."

"I thought the cheesecake was amazing."

"I was speechless with the work Kayleen did on our birthday cake."

Good to know

1

The bakery offers a variety of pastries and specialty cakes for events.

2

Prices for cakes and pastries are generally affordable.

3

Pre-made cakes are available for immediate purchase in the display case.

23
ZZ Day Spa image 1
Day spa

Space offers a lush jungle vibe with water features for a peaceful, romantic escape. Guests enjoy tailored massages paired with mini cheesecakes and champagne. Birthday celebrations shine with a personalized cake and festive gifts.

Mini cheesecakes come with massages, paired with champagne and mimosas. Each guest receives a cheesecake as a sweet finish to the experience.

They bring out a birthday cake with your name on it and sing Happy Birthday. The presentation is beautiful, and they include a birthday sash and tiara along with gifts and smiles.

People are saying

"The spa massages here are some of the best I've had."

"They surprised me with cheesecake and champagne at the end."

"They surprised me with a delicious birthday cake and mimosas."

Good to know

1

Booking an appointment is highly recommended to secure your preferred time.

2

The couples romance package includes complimentary drinks and desserts.

3

The birthday package features a photo booth, champagne, and cake.

24
Iva’s Sweet Parlour image 1

Pastry shop offers cozy seating and elegant, stylish decor with a friendly vibe. Desserts feature beautiful presentation and include standout items like tres leches and brownies. The atmosphere feels welcoming and quaint with a high-end ambiance.

Red velvet cheesecake stands out with its consistent quality and spectacular taste. Other options include apple cheesecake caramel crumb and strawberry cheesecake, all offering rich, satisfying flavors.

Chocolate and dulce de leche birthday cakes come out delicious and well designed. Pickup is straightforward and convenient.

People are saying

"The tres leches cake here is so moist and flavorful."

"The birthday cake here is great."

"I thought this cheesecake was the best I had in my life."

Good to know

1

Be wary of ordering on UberEats or Seamless as items may be forgotten.

2

The shop is open late for those looking for a sweet treat.

3

There is limited seating in the shop, so plan accordingly.

25
Mi Bakery & Cafe image 1

Small space fits only a few people, creating a cozy atmosphere with amazing decorations. Cakes and pastries show creative design and high quality, making it a popular spot for custom cakes and sweet treats.

Cheesecakes come alongside muffins and other cakes like Tres Leches and Dulce de Leche. One cheesecake had red velvet flavor but showed signs of spoilage with mold and a rancid smell.

Birthday cakes come with creative designs that match specific themes like Harry Potter or Little Einstein. Cakes are beautifully crafted and meet exact design requests.

People are saying

"The cakes here are beautiful and delicious."

"They made my vision come true for my birthday cake, sometimes even better."

"Their cheesecakes are amazing and on point."

Good to know

1

The bakery accepts EBT as a form of payment.

2

Prices are super affordable, making it a budget-friendly option.

3

It's easy to call and place an order or walk in.

26
L.A Sweets image 1

Bakery features black actors and actresses murals and a strong inviting aroma that fills the street. Atmosphere is lovely and culturally rich with respectful staff and southern-style red velvet cakes highly praised for their moist texture and subtle flavors.

Cheesecake here offers a wonderful creaminess that is not too heavy. The strawberry topping adds a fresh touch, though some find it overly sweet with unmelted butter pieces.

Red velvet cakes stand out, including a vegan option. Same-day orders are possible, but sometimes the flavor may not match the order exactly.

People are saying

"The cake here is so moist and delicious."

"I couldn't put my fork down, the peach cobbler was amazing."

"I got the red velvet birthday cake and it was perfect."

Good to know

1

The bakery offers vegan options suitable for those with dairy allergies.

2

This bakery is the only place that offers egg, milk, and nut allergy-free cupcakes.

3

It is recommended to go early to LA Sweets to avoid sold-out items.

27
Martha's Country Bakery image 1

Country bakery offers cozy, old-school warmth with both indoor and outdoor seating, including a heated back area and privacy walls between tables. Atmosphere feels welcoming and lively, sometimes cramped but charming. Space features sunlit glass windows and a patio that adds to the inviting vibe.

Cheesecakes come in many varieties here, including vegan, Oreo, and red velvet options. Rich and creamy textures stand out, with flavors like strawberry and Nutella also available.

Birthday Cake tastes great and includes decorations like message plates and berries. Cakes can be ordered by phone or delivery, but delivery sometimes causes decorations to fall off.

People are saying

"I ate the best cakes here, they were incredibly delicious."

"I thought the cheesecake was rich, creamy, and excellent."

"The Birthday Cake here is delicious and a big hit."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended ahead of time, especially for holidays.

2

Customers have to order the strawberry banana cake prior to visiting.

3

You should go early to find parking.

Discover more

New York, New York

Area guide
Loading Map...