Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Best of New York

Thrift store jewelry

You prefer the thrill of finding a unique piece of jewelry in a thrift store.

Based on 690 Opinions
+687
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Unearth Vintage image 1
Unearth Vintage image 2
Unearth Vintage image 3
View all
Vintage clothing store

Vintage clothing store offers a brightly lit, well curated space with a gallery feel and comfortable fitting rooms. The atmosphere feels warm and welcoming, with a relaxed vibe and intentional, unique presentation. A vintage gaming setup adds an interactive element, making shopping more engaging.

Jewelry options include unique vintage pieces and gemstone rings with a bespoke feel. Staff assist with selections and polish chosen rings, offering affordable prices and fancy displays.

A constantly changing selection of high-quality vintage items from various decades fills the shelves. Friendly staff help navigate a unique collection that sets a high standard for thrift stores.

People are saying

"The staff at this Vintage spot are so friendly and kind."

"I found this thrift store to be the best curated vintage place."

"I found the jewelry prices unbelievably reasonable."

Good to know

1

Unearth hosts pop-up events regularly, check their schedule for details.

2

The shop is size inclusive, offering a wide range of clothing sizes.

3

Unearth Vintage features unique, one-of-a-kind items not found elsewhere.

02
AuH2O image 1
Second hand store

Small shop offers a curated vintage selection with very affordable prices ranging mostly from $3 to $25. Atmosphere feels kind and welcoming, enhanced by sustainable packaging and thoughtful decorations. The vibe supports accessible thrifting with a feminine focus and inclusive sizing.

A wide range of vintage jewelry offers many styles and affordable options. The collection is nicely curated and draws attention with its variety and attentive service.

Offers a beautiful selection of vintage jewelry and well-curated vintage pieces that often look almost new. Prices run about half of what similar items cost nearby, with many cute finds under $12.

People are saying

"This thrift store has a beautiful selection of jewelry."

"I found so many affordable pieces, with dresses around $10."

"I loved the beautiful selection of vintage jewelry here."

Good to know

1

The prices on vintage pieces are fair, starting as low as $3 for jewelry.

2

Clothing prices range from $10 to $25, making it very affordable.

3

The store has a great selection of stylish items at reasonable prices.

03
Awoke Vintage Brooklyn image 1
Vintage clothing store

Colorful, vibrant space with color-coded sections and a curated selection of vintage and trendy pieces creates a welcoming atmosphere. Crowds gather consistently, drawn by unique accessories like jewelry and cowboy boots alongside standout vintage jeans. Strong presence of women-led ownership adds character to the energetic vibe.

Jewelry section features beautiful, colorful, and vibrant pieces. The store offers a variety of items beyond jewelry, including cowboy boots and vintage Levi's, with several locations providing wide options.

Offers a wide variety of vintage items including jewelry, cowboy boots, and vintage Levi’s. Features color-coded sections and a huge selection of Levi’s jeans with great prices and helpful staff.

People are saying

"I found this vintage shop to be really cute and full of great options."

"I found so many cute vintage items at this thrift store."

"I found amazing jewelry here, it's super cute."

Good to know

1

You can reserve and buy items if you watch their Instagram stories.

2

The store has good quality vintage pieces.

3

You don’t have to dig for items because everything is perfectly curated.

04
Tarin Thomas image 1
Jewelry store

Shop offers an elevated, unique curation of jewelry and vintage items with a stylish, cool vibe. Space feels like an oasis with a wide selection including custom pieces and home goods. Atmosphere attracts those seeking chic, timeless designs and personalized options.

Offers a huge selection of high-quality jewelry including timeless vintage pieces and unique designs. Staff provide helpful service while shopping for bracelets and accessories.

Selection includes vintage home and clothing items along with high-quality jewelry and accessories. Staff offers helpful guidance when choosing pieces like vintage watches.

People are saying

"I found their vintage jewelry selection to be beautiful and unique."

"The jewelry here is beautiful, high-quality, and has unique designs."

"I found the vintage jewelry selection to be amazing and unique."

Good to know

1

Tarin Thomas hosts pop-up events for small businesses on weekends.

2

The store is the only place in Manhattan to find ArtAche Hotel candles.

3

Tarin offers a wide variety of items, from candles to vintage clothes.

05
28 Scott Vintage image 1
Vintage clothing store

Vintage clothing store offers a beautifully curated collection with handcrafted goods and sterling silver jewelry. Warm, inviting atmosphere features incense from Bali and music that creates a relaxed vibe. Space feels spacious and welcoming, reflecting careful attention to detail.

A lovely selection of sterling silver earrings, rings, bracelets, anklets, and chains fills the shelves. The store offers handcrafted artisan jewelry alongside vintage pieces, all curated with care.

A beautiful curation of vintage treasures from around the world fills the shelves. Prices stay extremely reasonable while the selection and merchandising remain consistently delightful.

People are saying

"I found beautiful, curated vintage pieces from all over the world."

"This thrift store has a beautiful, curated selection of global vintage pieces."

"I found a nice selection of jewelry and vintage goods here."

Good to know

1

The vintage store is super close to the L train and other bars and lunch places.

2

The prices for the suits are exceptional, with a gorgeous Italian wool suit costing $45.

3

The prices at the vintage store are amazing, especially for the high quality of the items.

06
Upper EastSide Thrift shop image 1

Shop offers vintage and designer pieces packed into a tight, boutique-style space. Atmosphere feels quiet and uninviting without background music, contrasting with nearby busy spots. Prices remain surprisingly low for high-quality, unique items.

Wide selection of vintage jewelry and custom pieces stands out. Prices stay low while offering branded items alongside unique finds.

Shelves hold a wide range of vintage clothing, antiques, and unique handmade pieces. Prices stay low, with most shirts and pants under $5, alongside a solid mix of CDs, books, and vintage jewelry.

People are saying

"I found this thrift store to be the best I'd ever been to."

"I found the prices for women's clothing to be unbelievably cheap."

"I found an amazing selection of vintage jewelry here."

Good to know

1

Thrift prices are $5 or less for most shirts and pants.

2

The thrift store offers a wide selection of jewelry, clothes, shoes, and home goods.

3

The selection includes vintage, unique, handmade, and designer pieces.

07
Brooklyn Vintage Company image 1
Vintage clothing store

Vintage clothing store offers an extensive, well-curated selection of unique items including clothes, furniture, and vinyl. Spacious layout creates a pleasant, warm atmosphere with occasional live music enhancing the vibe. Prices range from reasonable bargains to high-end treasures, attracting a diverse crowd.

Silver jewelry stands out with a well curated selection. Staff offers good knowledge to help find pieces among a wide array of objects.

Offers a wide range of vintage items including clothes, records, and furniture all in one spot. The selection is tastefully curated with many unique, high quality treasures at reasonable prices.

People are saying

"This thrift store is a must-visit, I would live here if I could."

"I found so many beautiful, one-of-a-kind vintage treasures here."

"I found so many well-curated items, including jewelry, at great prices."

Good to know

1

The store has a large selection of vintage home items and clothing.

2

Prices at the vintage store are generally fair and reasonable.

3

Expect to find beautiful vintage shoes, handbags, and vinyl records.

08
Mr Goods Buy & Sell image 1
Consignment shop

Consignment shop with a well-organized layout and eye-catching displays creates a quiet, serene atmosphere blending luxury and hypebeast culture. The environment feels welcoming and comfortable, attracting those interested in exclusive designer goods and fair, immediate transactions.

Offers a wide range of unique luxury jewelry including engagement rings and diamond pieces. Provides trustworthy service for buying, selling, and trading with honest pricing and good deals.

Stock includes vintage Louis Vuitton bags, jackets, and sneakers at discount prices. Selling items is quick and easy with helpful staff.

People are saying

"The staff here is knowledgeable about luxurious items and attentive to your needs."

"I found amazing designer bags and sneakers at this thrift store."

"I sold my gold jewelry here and got cash quickly."

Good to know

1

All items at Mr. Goods are authentic and high quality.

2

You can receive cash on the same day for your sold items.

3

Transactions are priced and negotiated quickly.

09
Life Boutique Thrift image 1

Two floors and a basement hold curated vintage clothing, unique home decor, and affordable prices. The atmosphere blends boutique charm upstairs with classic thrift vibes downstairs, creating a cozy and welcoming space. Neat organization and a diverse selection invite long browsing sessions.

Jewelry options come in a variety of styles and the section is always stacked with pieces. The store offers unique and vintage jewelry alongside other hidden gems.

Offers a great selection of vintage and affordable items with a focus on quality vintage clothing. Includes a diverse range of unique home decor alongside clothing.

People are saying

"I found so many great vintage items and unique finds here."

"I found so many lovely vintage dresses at this thrift store."

"It's a hidden gem with a stacked jewelry section."

Good to know

1

The thrift store has seasonal events and sales.

2

There is a $5 basement full of clothes.

3

The store has multiple $5 racks in the downstairs area.

10
Vintage Thrift Shop image 1

Small space filled with curated vintage furniture, authentic decor, and rare deep funk music creates a cozy, friendly vibe. Bright and well organized, it offers a high-quality selection of clothes, housewares, and collectibles. Prices tend to be higher but reflect the lasting value and careful curation.

Offers a large selection of vintage and secondhand jewelry alongside furniture and household goods. Jewelry pieces come with reasonably-priced tags and sit among other unique accessories and decor items.

A well organized thrift store with a curated selection of vintage clothes and art. Staff are informative and personable, making it easy to find special pieces in great condition.

People are saying

"I found so many interesting vintage clothing and unique items here."

"I found the selection to be beautifully curated with great prices."

"This thrift store is a gold mine for unique vintage items."

Good to know

1

Every item in the store is unique.

2

The merchandise is carefully curated and in good condition.

3

The store has a good assortment of clothing, home wares, art, and books.

11
The RealReal image 1
Consignment shop

Consignment shop offers a beautifully curated selection of high-end designer items in impeccable condition within a clean, organized space. Atmosphere feels comfortable and relaxed, with knowledgeable staff providing a personal touch. The process runs smoothly with no pressure, making it a place for luxury with heart and expertise.

Jewelry experts provide detailed advice and recommendations. Staff like Peter and Samantha show strong knowledge and assist with purchases and services like ring sizing.

A well-curated selection of vintage and new pieces offers more affordable prices. Discounts apply for minor flaws, and items like a vintage Chanel bag are available and used daily.

People are saying

"The consignment process with Tochi was so easy and friendly."

"The staff here is so knowledgeable about luxurious pieces."

"The staff at this Thrift Store were super polite and helpful."

Good to know

1

There are no returns on bags, putting sellers and buyers at risk of scams.

2

Make an appointment for personalized assistance with luxury items.

3

Expect to pay a commission based on the estimated net selling price for items.

12
Bliss Vintage & Handmade (by Violet's Volition) image 1

Small, colorful shop filled with handmade and vintage items creates a warm, energetic atmosphere. Eclectic displays change regularly, offering unique gifts and accessories sourced with care and fairness. The vibe is whimsical and community-focused, welcoming all ages and tastes.

Rings and earrings stand out among the jewelry options. The selection pairs well with other unique items like vintage clothing and women-made products.

Bright and colorful, this thrift store offers a carefully curated mix of vintage clothing, accessories, and small trinkets. The selection includes vintage-inspired pieces, greeting cards, and unique items like badges and paolo santo sticks.

People are saying

"I found this vintage shop packed with unique gifts and fun accessories."

"I found the jewelry and other handmade or vintage items to be kitschy and adorable."

"I found the thrift store's curated selection of unique vintage items magical."

Good to know

1

The shop offers a well-curated selection of handmade and vintage items.

2

Many products are locally made and ethically sourced.

3

Bliss Vintage & Handmade is dog-friendly, making it a great stop for pet owners.

13
Yesterday's News Antiques and Collectibles image 1

Shop resembles a museum-like space filled with curated vintage furniture and American-themed collectibles. Bright and clean atmosphere invites browsing through a wide variety of hand-picked items from different eras. Prices remain reasonable, reflecting quality and neighborhood standards.

A generous selection of vintage jewelry sits alongside antique furniture and glassware. The store offers a variety of hand-picked items across different categories.

A wide variety of vintage furniture, glassware, and collectibles fills the store. Unique finds include colorful glass plates, vintage artwork, and collectible trading cards at fair prices.

People are saying

"I found so many amazing vintage treasures, from furniture to collectibles."

"I found an amazing selection of vintage furniture and homewares here."

"I found so many amazing vintage treasures and collectibles here."

Good to know

1

Yesterday’s News gets new inventory around 3-4 times a week, so there is always something new to see.

2

The store closes at 6 PM.

3

You can find anything from clothing to furniture for an incredible price.

14
Brooklyn Woke Vintage image 1

Shop offers a retro vibe with incense-scented air and a Pikachu chandelier. Shelves hold a random assortment of vintage toys, magazines, records, and affordable trinkets. Space feels well-organized and invites browsing for nostalgic gifts and collectibles.

Lots of jewelry and unique trinkets fill the shelves. The selection includes figurines, pins, and knickknacks alongside the jewelry.

Small shop filled with vintage items like old walkmans, cassettes, and vinyl records. Offers novelty knickknacks including a Pikachu chandelier, vintage polaroid cameras, and second-hand baseball gear.

People are saying

"I found so many cool vintage toys and jewelry here."

"This vintage shop has a huge selection of cute clothes and jewelry."

"This thrift store has a huge selection of cool vintage items."

Good to know

1

The shop sells vintage items like old walkmans, cassettes, and clothing.

2

The store offers vinyl records, old toys, baseball gear, stamps, and magazines.

3

Prices of items in the shop are generally affordable.

15
Artists & Fleas Market Williamsburg image 1

Indoor flea market offers wide aisles and separate fitting rooms creating a spacious, organized layout. Energy stays warm and lively with a mix of handmade crafts and vintage items from local artists. Benches spaced comfortably support a relaxed browsing experience amid diverse stalls.

A wide selection of vintage jewelry and handmade pieces fills the space. Everyday rings and costume jewelry appear alongside retro styles and local artisan creations.

Space hosts many vendors offering a wide selection of vintage clothing, handmade jewelry, and local postcards. Finds include old shirts, records, soap, and unique accessories.

People are saying

"I found so many unique handmade crafts and vintage items at this market."

"I found cute everyday rings and unique jewelry pieces here."

"I found so many cool vintage clothes and artisan pieces here."

Good to know

1

Most items are priced between $60 and $150, making it a bit pricey.

2

The market features a variety of independent vendors selling vintage and handmade items.

3

Expect to find unique items like jewelry, clothing, vinyl records, and art.

16
Bushwick Market image 1
Flea market

Open air market with eclectic vintage items and street art creates a super chill and inviting atmosphere. Variety includes clothes, jewelry, plants, and antiques, appealing to those with special tastes. Vendors offer a mix of quality and pricing, with some willingness to haggle.

Vintage and costume jewelry fills the shelves with a wide variety of styles. Friendly sellers offer room to negotiate prices on unique pieces.

Shelves hold vintage hats and headpieces alongside old records and postcards. Kitchenware, audio gear, and vintage china and silverware fill the space with a mix of clothes, jewelry, and home decor.

People are saying

"This market has so many unique and beautiful vintage items."

"I found unique jewelry and other cool items here."

"I found so many beautiful vintage items at this Thrift Store."

Good to know

1

Clothes are priced at $2 each.

2

Old fashioned Christmas ornaments cost $1 and $2 each.

3

Expect to haggle a bit on prices.

Discover more

New York, New York

Area guide
Loading Map...