Pie spots in New York

Bright, spacious pastry shop with Greek-inspired decor and a massive selection of pastries including sweet and savory options. Atmosphere feels cozy and welcoming, with indoor and outdoor seating in clean, shaded areas. Popular for authentic Greek baked goods and a variety of treats like cheese pies and galaktoboureko.

An actual parking lot sits outside with customer spots available. Parking feels super convenient though sometimes a bit tight.

Savory pies feature homemade phyllo dough, especially the spinach feta pie and cheese pies. The bakery offers a good assortment of pies and cookies, including apple pie for holidays.

Large American restaurant offers spacious layout with multiple TVs showing different games and a separate party room for private events. Atmosphere is warm and friendly, though loud music in the party room can overwhelm conversation. Dog-friendly policy and on-site parking add to the convenience.

Parking includes a tiny lot on site with free spaces. Having their own lot makes parking surprisingly easy.

Shepherd's Pie stands out with its perfect balance and rich flavor. The dish comes in a quiet atmosphere that complements the meal well.

Caribbean restaurant offers a casual dining space with cleanliness and generous seating. Soca music and an arcade create a lively, chill vibe. The aroma of authentic dishes draws a diverse crowd, highlighting budget-friendly, flavorful cuisine.

Plenty of parking spots sit close by. Finding a space is usually quick and easy.

Aloo pie and doubles stand out for their strong flavors and quality. The macaroni pie offers a creamy, cheesy texture baked to a golden finish.

Supermarket offers extensive Mediterranean selection with varieties of feta cheese and an exquisite olive bar. Atmosphere feels authentic with homemade Greek specialties like spanakopita and fresh tzatziki. Small parking area exists, sometimes requiring luck or valet assistance.

Parking offers easy and convenient access despite being small. An attendant provides helpful service, making the experience smooth.

Small counter offers hot cheese and meat pies alongside Spanakopita, a Greek spinach pie with feta cheese.

Classic steakhouse with old-fashioned decor and a brightly lit dining room creates a straightforward atmosphere. Energy feels comforting yet brisk, with staff moving efficiently around the room. Known for exceptional steak quality, it draws diners focused on the food rather than ambiance.

A parking lot exists a block away, offering super convenient access. Finding the lot can be a bit tricky, but it helps since street parking is scarce.

Chunky apple pieces and a crunchy exterior define the apple pie, flavored with cinnamon and raisins. The pecan pie comes with homemade whipped cream that pairs well with an Old Fashioned.

Classic diner space with retro booths and vintage car seat designs creates a nostalgic, cozy vibe. Bright signage and aluminum siding add to the throwback atmosphere reminiscent of 1950s diners. Spacious layout supports comfortable dining with wheelchair-friendly accessibility.

A large, adjacent parking lot offers ample space and easy access. Free parking adds to the convenience and helps keep visits relaxed.

Blueberry pie tastes excellent and fresh. Cherry pie has a hard crust with a strange shine and a filling that is not too sweet. Pies likely come from an outside bakery.

Modern steakhouse blends sports bar vibes with eclectic decor featuring gas fireplaces and a disco ball. Loud music creates a lively, club-like atmosphere where conversation requires raising voices. Specialty cocktails and high-quality steaks stand out amid a trendy, energetic setting.

Valet parking offers easy access right off the Belt Parkway. Convenient valet service handles parking efficiently.

Ember potato pie stands out as a must-have alongside steak and appears consistently as a very good side. It pairs well with dishes like Brussels sprouts and creamed spinach, adding a hearty touch.

Traditional Brooklyn diner space offers comfortable booths and flat screens playing sports throughout. Atmosphere feels warm and inviting, with background music featuring old favorites and unique selections. Large parking lot supports easy access, and kid-friendly touches include coloring supplies.

A private parking lot offers plenty of space, making it easy to find a spot without searching. Parking is straightforward and convenient for dining in.

Homemade spinach pie stands out for being tasty and not greasy. The Lemon Meringue and coconut cream pies offer satisfying dessert options.

Wood-paneled walls and vintage decor create a timeless vibe reminiscent of mid-20th century Brooklyn. The atmosphere feels old school and authentic, with waiters in classic white jackets and ties adding to the experience. The space is small and cozy, offering a quiet, nostalgic setting.

A small parking lot sits right next to the building on a corner street. Parking is limited and tight, but it is free to use.

Apple and blueberry pies come homemade and fresh with a balanced sweetness. Serving pies a la mode pairs well with the rich, complementary ice cream.