Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Local picks in Brooklyn Heights

Sandwich shops

Made for those who view a well-constructed sandwich as the only acceptable way to fuel a busy afternoon.

Based on 801 Opinions
+798
User
User
User
Updated
01
Heights Falafel image 1
Heights Falafel image 2
Heights Falafel image 3
View all

Small, hole-in-the-wall falafel spot with cozy interior and outdoor seating near a promenade offering Manhattan views. Atmosphere feels easy-going and unassuming, marked by warm hospitality and quick service. Regulars return for what many consider some of the best falafel and baklava around.

Food comes out quickly and stays fresh even close to closing time. Expect healthy, delicious, and affordable dishes that stand out in the neighborhood.

Falafel sandwiches come very flavorful and generous in size, served quickly and priced very reasonably around five bucks. They taste consistently delicious and satisfy strong cravings.

People are saying

"The food here is amazing, especially the falafel."

"I loved the fresh and authentic food here."

"The food was fresh, tasty, and worth the price."

Good to know

1

The chicken shawarma plate costs $10, while the falafel sandwich is $5.

2

Expect a line down the block during peak hours.

3

Limited seating is available, so plan accordingly.

02
Breads Bakery โ€“ Brooklyn image 1
Breads Bakery โ€“ Brooklyn image 2
Breads Bakery โ€“ Brooklyn image 3
View all

Bakery offers great views of Brooklyn Bridge and Manhattan skyline with plenty of outdoor seating. Atmosphere stays quiet and dependable, making it a good spot to relax after a walk. Food includes rich chocolate babka and savory sandwiches, enjoyed in a beautifully designed, unflashy setting.

Food here is fresh and well made, with options like pizza that suit a spicy Korean palate. Seating allows for a quiet spot to enjoy meals and drinks with good views.

Sandwiches feature fresh poppy and sesame seed rolls and include options like Jerusalem Baguette salmon and egg and vegetable varieties. Friendly staff explain sandwich contents clearly.

People are saying

"I loved their delicious sandwiches on fresh poppy and sesame seed rolls."

"The bakery has great coffee and sandwiches in a nice spot."

"The food here is a little spicy, suiting the Korean palate."

Good to know

1

A slice of chocolate babka costs $5.95.

2

Reservations are not required, but arriving early is recommended as they sell out.

3

The menu includes pastries, sandwiches, salads, and coffee.

03
Lassen & Hennigs image 1
Lassen & Hennigs image 2
Lassen & Hennigs image 3
View all

Spacious bakery with outdoor seating and a calming interior creates a pleasant atmosphere. The vibe feels like family gathering with a joyful neighborhood spirit. Known for gourmet pastries and an impressive sandwich selection, it offers a variety of well-packaged, high-quality baked goods and deli items.

Prepared foods offer a wide variety with freshly made options like pasta, chicken, and breakfast sandwiches. The deli and bakery counters provide great food and desserts that taste consistently delicious.

Sandwiches come on freshly baked bread or soft hero buns with a generous portion size. The pastrami sandwich stands out as a classic choice. The selection covers a wide range of tasty options.

People are saying

"The prepared foods and desserts here are amazing."

"Some sandwiches are tasty, but quality varies a lot."

"The sandwiches here are fantastic, especially on fresh bread."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for custom cakes to ensure freshness.

2

Expect long lines during peak hours, especially on weekends.

3

An additional 3.8% fee applies to credit card transactions.

04
Damascus Bread & Pastry Shop image 1
Damascus Bread & Pastry Shop image 2
Damascus Bread & Pastry Shop image 3
View all

Small shop offers a large selection of Middle Eastern specialties with freshly baked goods and unique pastries. Atmosphere feels charming with amazing smells filling the space. Regulars find it a neighborhood gem known for phenomenal meat pies and **exceptional hummus and spreads.

Lebanese food features lentil soup, hummus, and desserts that taste fresh and wholesome. Prices stay reasonable while the food remains consistently delicious and the service friendly.

Falafel sandwich stands out with great value and solid flavor. It pairs well with zaatar bread and dips for a satisfying meal.

People are saying

"The food is delicious and authentic."

"I love the great Lebanese and Syrian food here."

"I found the food here to be amazing and delicious."

Good to know

1

You need to request halawet Al jibin ahead of time.

2

The pastries are $11 for two savory and two sweet treats.

3

The shop takes credit cards with a convenience fee.

05
Diem Eatery image 1
Diem Eatery image 2
Diem Eatery image 3
View all

Cafe offers a cozy, green ambiance with light-filled, airy space and clever decor. Atmosphere feels warm and authentic, inviting quiet conversation and casual meals. Staff provide welcoming service that complements the pleasant, unpretentious vibe.

Food stands out for its consistently fresh and delicious banh mi. The dishes maintain a high quality with excellent flavors and a cozy vibe.

The banh mi sandwich stands out with perfect flavor balance and ingredient distribution. It comes in a huge size and offers a great price for the quality.

People are saying

"The food here is always fresh and delicious."

"The banh mi here is probably the best I've ever had."

"I love how fresh and healthy the food tastes here."

Good to know

1

The cafe has a vegan option, which is important for those who are lactose intolerant.

2

The classic banh mi is priced higher than expected, but it includes two rolls.

3

Expect food safety issues based on recent health concerns.

06
Tutt Heights Cafe image 1
Tutt Heights Cafe image 2
Tutt Heights Cafe image 3
View all

Spacious underground Mediterranean restaurant offers a quiet, relaxed atmosphere with comfortable seating and a language-friendly environment accommodating Spanish, English, and Arabic speakers. Tables are set far apart, creating a clean and inviting space with a cool Brooklyn vibe.

Food here is fresh and well seasoned, focusing on quality and taste without extra frills. Mediterranean dishes come out super delicious and consistently good.

Falafel sandwiches vary widely, with some being flavorful and others lacking taste. Chicken pita and shawarma sandwiches appear consistently enjoyable, while merguez sandwiches sometimes arrive cold and bland.

People are saying

"The food is fresh, delicious, and plentiful."

"The food here is amazing, especially the fresh pita bread."

"I always find the food fresh and amazing here."

Good to know

1

Everything in the restaurant is halal.

2

No pork is served at this place.

3

There is a 20% service charge in addition to taxes.

07
Boutros image 1
Boutros image 2
Boutros image 3
View all

Open kitchen design offers an intimate view of chefs at work, enhancing the modern vibe with high ceilings and purposeful decor. Atmosphere stays quiet and cozy, suitable for date nights or family gatherings. Indoor and outdoor seating includes a full bar and an enclosed streetery, creating a friendly, relaxed setting.

Food here is phenomenal with many delicious flavors. The bread and dip stand out and complement the great Middle Eastern cuisine.

Short rib shawarma sandwich stands out with its hearty portions and rich flavor. Cauliflower shawarma sandwich offers a tasty alternative with a satisfying taste.

People are saying

"The food here is fresh, flavorful, and beautifully served."

"The food is tasty with a fun twist."

"You have to try the short rib shawarma sandwich."

Good to know

1

The restaurant operates on a first come last served basis.

2

Everything is sold as small plates, and sides must be ordered separately.

3

The prices are high compared to the quantity served.

08
Henry's End image 1
Henry's End image 2
Henry's End image 3
View all

American restaurant offers a cozy atmosphere with intimate vibe suited for dates or small groups. Seating is tightly packed indoors, while outdoor seating provides a classy outdoor feeling. Signature cocktails and a unique personality add to the relaxed environment.

Food here is tasty and light, with a focus on inventive dishes that feel unpretentious. Vegetarian options stand out as especially satisfying and well-prepared.

Fried chicken sandwich stands out as a delicious option. The menu also includes a burger, egg torta, and chicken sandwich, offering a solid variety.

People are saying

"The food here is outstanding and expertly prepared."

"I love how the food is always delicious and inventive."

"The place feels cozy but the prices don't always match the food."

Good to know

1

Make sure you book a reservation at least 3-4 days in advance.

2

Single patrons are not allowed; reservations must be for two or more.

3

A service charge is automatically added to your bill.

09
Taboonette (Brooklyn Heights) image 1
Taboonette (Brooklyn Heights) image 2
Taboonette (Brooklyn Heights) image 3
View all

Spacious restaurant with a clean, basic design and a street view that adds to the setting. Atmosphere feels warm and welcoming with good music creating a relaxed vibe. Menu offers fresh, flavorful dishes like grilled chicken and sweet potato falafel that stand out for quality and taste.

Food here is consistently fresh and abundant for the price. The menu features Mediterranean and Israeli dishes with clever preparation and generous portions.

Chicken schnitzel sandwich and Israeli Breakfast Sandwich stand out among the delicious sandwiches. Sandwich construction can be uneven, with ingredients like eggplant sometimes placed awkwardly inside pita.

People are saying

"I found the food here to be amazing and well prepared."

"I was obsessed with the salmon sandwich."

Good to know

1

Meal prices range from $13 to $16 depending on the order.

2

Portions are generous, often enough for two meals.

3

Online prices may differ from what you pay in-store.

10
Vineapple image 1
Vineapple image 2
Vineapple image 3
View all

Outdoor seating includes a cozy backyard garden and courtyard that open when weather permits. Atmosphere feels homey and local with live music on Friday nights adding to the vibe. Cocktails stand out for their creative presentation and unique flavors.

Fresh ingredients shape the menu with dishes like avocado toast with prosciutto and egg scramble with mushrooms and spinach. Italian cuisine stands out, served with consistent quality and great presentation.

Prosciutto sandwich stands out as moist and juicy with rich flavor. Breakfast sandwich earns a perfect 10, served on a bagel and highly satisfying.

People are saying

"I found the food here to be delicious and hit the spot."

"I love the delicious and consistently great food."

"The food was good but sometimes just okay."

Good to know

1

Making a reservation is highly recommended.

2

Brunch orders start at 9am.

3

After 3PM, all the pastries at Vineapple cafe are 50% off.

11
Clark's image 1
Clark's image 2
Clark's image 3
View all

Diner with European style and cozy atmosphere offers outdoor seating where people watch the world go by. Inside feels a bit cramped but manages to seat everyone comfortably. The vibe is pleasant and relaxed, fitting a neighborhood spot with friendly energy.

Food stands out for its amazing quality and delicious flavors. Prices stay reasonable compared to local standards.

Crabcake and pastrami sandwiches stand out for their rich flavors. The hot Reuben features housemade sliced meat, and the roast beef sandwich is prepared perfectly.

People are saying

"The food is always delicious and satisfying."

"I thought the food here was delicious and excellent."

"Some food tastes amazing, but others are just okay."

Good to know

1

Brunch is very popular on weekends, expect long wait times.

2

Lunch hour is busy, plan to arrive early.

3

Dinner service starts at 10 PM.

12
Henry Street Ale House image 1
Henry Street Ale House image 2
Henry Street Ale House image 3
View all

Small bar with vintage touches and many TVs showing sports creates a lively, friendly vibe. Outdoor seating and a community area add a relaxed, social element. The atmosphere stays chill and down to earth, attracting those who enjoy good beer and casual gatherings.

Food offers a home-like feeling with consistent, reliable quality. Choices include great beer and food at reasonable prices.

The fried chicken sandwich stands out with its thin, very crispy coating and consistent preparation over the years. It tends to be a bit dry but remains a solid choice among the good pub fare options.

People are saying

"The food here is several steps above average bar fare."

"The food was hit or miss but sometimes great."

"I enjoyed the good food and drinks here."

Good to know

1

The restaurant claimed to be open until 1 AM but closed at 11 PM.

2

Customers should be careful if they are heading there at 11 PM.

3

The total cost can end up being $30 per person after adding extras and a 20% tip.

13
Grand Canyon Restaurant image 1
Grand Canyon Restaurant image 2
Grand Canyon Restaurant image 3
View all

Neighborhood diner with classic diner style and Mexican-inspired dishes offers a calm, family-friendly atmosphere with quiet jazz music and spaced seating. Outdoor seating adds to the relaxed vibe, making it suitable for casual meals and conversations without raising voices.

Food comes out freshly grilled with big portions and a cosy atmosphere. Service is fast and kind, matching the consistently excellent quality of the dishes.

Chicken salad sandwich stands out as flavorful. Some sandwiches like the grilled chicken and breakfast options taste good, but others such as the Mexican and club turkey sandwiches lack flavor or are served incorrectly without apology.

People are saying

"I love the tasty food and big menu choices."

"I thought the food was really good and fresh."

"The food is good, big, and worth it."

Good to know

1

The restaurant charges an 18% service charge fee on all bills.

2

Breakfast is served all day, making it a flexible dining option.

3

The diner can accommodate large parties, perfect for gatherings.

14
Le French Tart image 1
Le French Tart image 2
Le French Tart image 3
View all

Narrow bakery with a rustic atmosphere and cramped layout that limits movement. Offers authentic French pastries including highly regarded croissants and unique items like Tarte Tropizienne. Space feels cozy but tight, with a quiet, unhurried vibe.

French foods include croissants and pastries with a variety of options. Food quality is good and tasty, though some items feel overpriced.

Lamb merguez baguette and croissant bacon egg and cheese stand out with optional cheese add-ons. Sandwiches come fresh and tasty but can sometimes fall apart.

People are saying

"I found the sandwiches to be a true bargain for their quality."

"The food is tasty with good variety."

"I thought the food was very good and tasty."

Good to know

1

The bakery closes at 7:30 PM.

2

You can add brie to the lamb merguez baguette sandwich for $1 extra.

3

The chocolate bread costs $3.75.

15
Kaigo Coffee Room image 1
Kaigo Coffee Room image 2
Kaigo Coffee Room image 3
View all

Coffee shop offers stunning waterfront views and an open, spacious layout designed for quick service and takeout. Atmosphere feels relaxed and inviting with friendly conversations adding warmth to the calm environment. It attracts a steady flow of people, especially on busy weekends near the piers.

Coffee and food draw people in, though the pastries and food options lack appeal. The dining area sits open before the bar but can be closed off, limiting seating.

Panini sandwiches and a grilled cheese stand out for their taste and simplicity. Sandwiches come with options suitable for quick, on-the-go meals and pair well with a cold brew shake.

People are saying

"I love the coffee and chill vibe here."

"I found the sandwiches to be tasty and full of ingredients."

"I enjoyed the delicious coffee and food here."

Good to know

1

Customers cannot sit down as the dining area is closed 40 minutes before closing time.

2

They charge almost $7 for the Oatmilk Matcha Latte.

3

The establishment can get busy on weekends due to the area's popularity.

16
Sippy Cafe image 1
Sippy Cafe image 2
Sippy Cafe image 3
View all

Small, clean space with few seats and a modern marble bar by large windows creates a bright atmosphere. The vibe suits quiet activities like reading or chatting at small tables. Air conditioning and in-house baked goods add comfort to the casual setting.

Food features a Green Egg & Cheese sandwich and a variety of teas. Meals come in takeout containers even when eaten inside, with a menu that looks good and tastes good.

Egg sandwiches stand out with brioche bread and rich flavors like truffle and kani tamago. Drinks pair well, especially lychee ice tea, complementing the quality sandwiches.

People are saying

"The egg sandwiches here are some of the best I've had."

"The truffle egg sandwich is delicious and perfectly cooked."

"The food here looked great."

Good to know

1

The cafe has no restroom available for customers.

2

Food is served in takeout containers even if you're eating there.

3

The coffee shop is a small place with limited seats and tables.

17
Luke's Lobster Brooklyn Bridge Park image 1
Luke's Lobster Brooklyn Bridge Park image 2
Luke's Lobster Brooklyn Bridge Park image 3
View all

Seafood shack offers picturesque waterfront views beneath a famous bridge, creating a serene atmosphere with a quiet vibe outside peak times. Lines form during busy periods, reflecting its popularity despite a fast food setup. Lobster rolls stand out for their freshness and flavor, often praised as top quality.

Food tastes fresh and delicious with consistently great flavor. The setting by the river adds a nice vibe to enjoying the meal.

Sandwiches come generously filled and flavorful, especially the lobster sandwich which is full and tasty. Portions are small and prices are on the higher side.

People are saying

"I loved the lobster sandwich; it was super delicious."

"I found the food here to be amazing."

Good to know

1

Expect long wait times during peak hours, especially on weekends.

2

Prices for lobster rolls start at $39, with some reaching $50.

3

There is no indoor seating available; all dining is outdoors.

18
Poppy's image 1
Poppy's image 2
Poppy's image 3
View all

Small cafe with a cozy atmosphere and outdoor patio by the sidewalk. Offers a market with fresh fruit and a variety of grab-and-go food items. Known for high-quality pastries and sandwiches, attracting a steady weekend crowd.

Food features high quality pastries and a variety of delicious options. A small market adds to the fantastic food selection alongside good coffee.

Egg sandwiches stand out with their incredible taste and freshness. Other options include a chicken cutlet sandwich and an artichoke and mozzarella sandwich, all served in a clean shop with friendly staff.

People are saying

"I found the food here to be incredible."

"The food and coffee here taste amazing and fresh"

"Some prepared foods taste fresh but feel overpriced"

Good to know

1

There is no restroom available at this place.

2

Seating is limited with a handful inside and an outside sidewalk shed.

3

The price of bone broth is $10 per cup.

19
Urban Deli image 1
Urban Deli image 2
Urban Deli image 3
View all

Grocery store offers 24/7 food service with a wide variety of Latin products and affordable prices on essentials like beer. Atmosphere feels welcoming and diverse, attracting a broad mix of customers. Food options include standout items like Trinidadian doubles and flavorful samosas.

Hot food stands out with very good quality and a variety of options including many Latin products. Quick grab meals offer reliable good taste and solid choices.

Huge and delicious deli sandwiches come with lunch specials including baked wings and Trinidadian delicacies. Staff sometimes need reminders to wear gloves, and bread or rolls can be stale.

People are saying

"The food is fresh and tastes great."

"The food here, especially the doubles, is delicious and a perfect street bite."

"I thought the deli sandwiches were huge and delicious."

Good to know

1

The restaurant serves food 24/7.

2

They have lunch specials featuring specialty baked wings and various international foods.

3

The bodega is a great place for quick grab food in the area.

20
L'Appartement 4F image 1
L'Appartement 4F image 2
L'Appartement 4F image 3
View all

Upstairs seating offers a spacious, charming cafe vibe reminiscent of a 1970s Parisian petit cafรฉ with a blend of modern and vintage decor. The atmosphere is lively and sometimes loud, often filled with freelancers working over coffee. Outdoor tables add a pleasant dining option in natural light.

Food bursts with flavor and delivers simple, delicious perfection. A French bakery setting offers a consistent 10 out of 10 quality with a welcoming space upstairs for enjoying meals.

Sandwiches feature quality ingredients with a perfect marriage of flavors like butter and ham or brie and pear. Bread quality varies but can be delicious, especially in the jambon beurre sandwich.

People are saying

"The pastries here are flaky and buttery, truly remarkable."

"The food was delicious and full of flavor."

"I loved the food and the vibe here."

Good to know

1

Going on weekdays around 12:30 is recommended to avoid lines and have a good selection.

2

Arrive at 7:30-7:45am before they open at 8am to beat the crazy line.

3

Expect a line down the block when itโ€™s the weekend and the weather is nice.

21
Popeyes Louisiana Kitchen image 1
Popeyes Louisiana Kitchen image 2
Popeyes Louisiana Kitchen image 3
View all

Bright, newly renovated space offers a clean, welcoming atmosphere with a warm, cozy vibe. Lines often form at the register, reflecting steady activity and popularity. Food features crispy, flavorful chicken and fresh, juicy sandwiches that stand out among similar places.

Food comes out fresh and hot with consistently good quality. The dishes are delicious and often exceed expectations.

Chicken sandwich features a perfect brioche bun and juicy, fresh chicken. One incident involved a hair on the sandwich, which was addressed by reheating it in oil.

People are saying

"The food here is served quickly and with great hospitality."

"The food is always fresh and tastes great."

"I think the food here is the best around."

Good to know

1

The establishment opens at 11 AM.

2

The establishment closes at 9 PM instead of the stated 10 PM.

3

There is no mild chicken available at 12 noon during lunch time.

22
O'Keefe's Bar & Grill image 1
O'Keefe's Bar & Grill image 2
O'Keefe's Bar & Grill image 3
View all

Sports bar with lots of screens and a large bar creates a lively setting. Atmosphere ranges from festive to laid back, often filled with friendly crowds. Music and multiple TVs keep energy high, making it a solid spot for watching games.

Large plates of comfort food come with great flavor. The menu offers a variety of bar food that satisfies different tastes.

Steak sandwiches stand out with solid flavor and good quality. The Chicken Parmesan Sandwich offers a tasty option, but the buffalo chicken sandwich may lack real chicken and feels less satisfying.

People are saying

"The food here is surprisingly good bar food."

"The food was mostly good and hit the spot."

"I loved the great pub food and lively vibe."

Good to know

1

They have a comedy show every Wednesday.

2

Happy hour drinks are only $1 off.

3

The venue has different types of beer and lots of giant screens with all kinds of sports channels.

23
Hanco's image 1
Hanco's image 2
Hanco's image 3
View all

Cozy mom-and-pop pho shop with a super chill vibe and friendly atmosphere. Small, somewhat cluttered space with clean surroundings. Known for vegetarian options and classic Vietnamese dishes like pho and banh mi.

Food features amazing flavor and tasty dishes with scallions that stand out on top of rice. Service is fast and efficient, and prices remain affordable despite increases.

Classic sandwiches feature a small meat portion with radish dominating the flavor. Prices hover around 7 dollars, but protein quantity can vary.

People are saying

"I found the food here to be delicious and flavorful."

"Some find the food tasty despite price concerns."

"It's a small spot with less authentic Vietnamese food."

Good to know

1

The beef pho costs $14.70.

2

Customers have to go get their food themselves from the window.

3

The restaurant charges $5 extra for extra meat on the classic sandwich.

Discover more

Brooklyn Heights, New York

Area guide