Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Local picks

Italian food for dinner in Carnegie Hill

Sometimes the evening calls for nothing more than a slow Italian meal and a glass of wine.

Based on 715 Opinions
+712
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Costa image 1
Costa image 2
Costa image 3
View all
Mediterranean restaurant

Mediterranean restaurant offers an elegant setting with velvet seating, chandeliers, and pale colors creating a cozy and hip atmosphere. Live jazz music plays softly, supporting conversation without overpowering the space. Guests enjoy a mix of fresh, flavorful dishes alongside expertly crafted cocktails in a warm, inviting environment.

Rigatoni and eggplant and linguine with clams stand out with rich flavors and balanced seasoning. The menu includes truffle pasta, risotto with mushrooms, and classic desserts like tiramisu.

Dinner offers a unique experience with attentive service from Julio and Marvin. After meals, Mina, the charming bartender, suggests cocktails, and dinners often end with Cappuccinos.

People are saying

"The food here is incredible and delicious."

"The staff here made my dinner a unique and helpful experience."

"The Italian food and service here made my day."

Good to know

1

Live jazz is played on Thursdays.

2

Reservations are recommended for dinner service.

3

Expect a wait time of 30-45 minutes during peak hours.

02
Lex Restaurant image 1
Italian restaurant

Italian restaurant offers an intimate, cozy atmosphere with candlelit tables and fresh roses creating a romantic setting. Outdoor seating includes heated tables with foot warmers, enhancing comfort. The space feels warm and inviting, suited for quiet dinners and special occasions.

Pasta dishes like penne vodka with chicken and pappardelle with veal ragu stand out for their freshness and flavor. The risotto and veal piccata are tender and well prepared, with the seafood risotto and bolognese pasta noted for their excellent taste.

Offers an easy Italian dinner with a welcoming touch, including a free after-dinner drink. The atmosphere suits special occasions like anniversaries.

People are saying

"I thought the food here was amazing."

"The dinner here is amazing, I can't wait to return."

"The lasagne here is the best Italian food I've had."

Good to know

1

You might need to make a reservation for dinner to secure your spot.

2

Prices are a bit high but worth it.

3

There are many specials each night which adds to the fun.

03
Paola's image 1
Italian restaurant

Small Italian restaurant with 1950s Americana decor and Frank Sinatra music creates a warm, cozy atmosphere. Inside is noisy, while outside seating offers a quieter, peaceful experience. Dark wood paneling and small tables add to the romantic, intimate vibe.

Handmade pasta shines here with dishes like Ligurian pasta featuring potatoes, green beans, pesto cream sauce, and pine nuts. Off-menu requests like fettuccine Alfredo and vegetable pasta with tomato sauce get made, alongside menu items like rigatoni with porcini and sausage and fettuccine bolognese.

Dinner features homemade pappardelle served in a setting with 1950s decor and Frank Sinatra music creating a classic evening vibe.

People are saying

"The food here is simple, original Roman cuisine you can't find elsewhere."

"I was craving authentic Roman style Italian food."

"The food at these dinner spots is fantastic and wonderful."

Good to know

1

The restaurant is open on Thanksgiving Sunday for lunch.

2

They do not have brunch; it's just a dinner menu for brunch.

3

Ordering takeout from Paola's is always a great option.

04
Sfoglia image 1
Italian restaurant

Rustic wooden tables and farmhouse aesthetic create a cozy, intimate atmosphere reminiscent of an old Italian trattoria. The vibe stays warm and quiet, attracting an elegant, young crowd suited for romantic dinners or quiet gatherings.

Pappardelle bolognese stands out with its incredible depth and richness of flavor. The menu blends traditional Italian cuisine with creative artistry, offering homemade pasta options that satisfy both meat lovers and others.

Dinners here offer a romantic atmosphere with attentive service and delicious food. The setting suits special occasions and pre-event meals well.

People are saying

"The pasta dishes at these Dinner Spots are delicate, rich, and flavorful."

"You must try the bread pudding; it's a must."

"The Italian food's bolognese sauce is rich and flavorful."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended at the restaurant.

2

The restaurant allows customization of the menu for events.

3

The restaurant is wheelchair accessible.

05
Siena Cafe • Italian • Brunch • Dinner • Lunch image 1

Large space with lively atmosphere and a live DJ energizes the room. Outdoor seating offers an inviting spot to relax, complemented by a full bar serving standout cocktails. Decor blends classy and cute elements, creating a warm and friendly vibe.

Pasta dishes stand out with pesto gnocchi praised for its flavor and spaghetti cooked al dente. Desserts like Tartufo and Tiramisu offer a sweet finish, while crostinis with burrata, salmon, and wild mushroom add variety.

Dinner features gnocchi with short rib, chicken Milanese, and drunken chicken parm. The outside seating area feels relaxing and cozy. Weekday dinners stay mostly quiet, good for easy conversations.

People are saying

"The brunch deal here is really good."

"The Italian food, especially the rigatoni alla vodka, was delicious."

"The pasta dishes here are delicious and freshly made."

Good to know

1

The bottomless brunch costs $32 and includes a meal.

2

Reservations are required for brunch.

3

Finding parking is difficult in the area.

06
Catch n' Chop image 1
Steak house

Steak house combines sleek modern-luxury design with an elegant yet relaxed atmosphere. Live jazz music and a beautiful bar and patio area create a romantic vibe that suits special occasions. Cocktails stand out as unique and well-crafted, complementing the overall experience.

Creative dishes include lobster pasta with a slight spice and seared scallops over wild mushroom risotto topped with shaved truffles. The beet risotto pairs well with halibut, and the pretzel breadsticks stand out as a highlight.

Dinner features live jazz on some nights and a menu that invites repeat visits. Drinks like the raspberry sidecar start the meal, setting a special tone for the evening.

People are saying

"I thought the steak was perfectly cooked and amazing."

"The food at these dinner spots was amazing and wonderful."

"The Italian Food here is amazing, thanks to the kind and attentive service."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for dinner, especially on weekends.

2

Expect a wait time of 30-45 minutes during peak dinner hours.

3

The average price per person is around $125, excluding drinks.

07
Pascalou image 1
French restaurant

Small, cozy space with intimate ambience and quiet despite crowding creates a relaxed vibe. Street seating adds charm, evoking a Parisian bistro feel. The atmosphere suits casual dining with a friendly, local character.

Seafood risotto stands out with its rich flavor. Lobster ravioli and scallops come with a creamy, flavorful sauce. Polenta features a crisp top paired with tomato pesto and prawns.

Great atmosphere sets the tone for dinner here. Regular visits show it works well for friendly gatherings and couples alike.

People are saying

"The chocolate soufflé is heavenly, served with whipped cream."

"The French onion soup and lamb chops were outstanding."

"The Italian food, especially the ravioli, is delicious and perfectly seasoned."

Good to know

1

It is better to have a reservation to avoid long wait times.

2

The Grand Marnier Souffle takes 30 minutes to make, plan accordingly.

3

The appetizer costs around $20, so budget for your meal.

08
Paola's Osteria image 1
Italian restaurant

Italian restaurant offers a cozy, quaint interior with cheesy art that creates a casual yet sophisticated vibe. The atmosphere is often loud and chaotic, filled with local families and children running around. Outdoor dining provides a lovely alternative to the noisy indoor space.

Pasta dishes like pappardelle with wild boar stand out with authentic Italian flavors. The menu includes off-menu pasta options for kids, and desserts like tiramisu pair well with real Italian espresso.

Laid back atmosphere sets the tone for dinner here. The spot works well for a relaxed mid-week meal with simple, comfortable vibes.

People are saying

"The Italian food, especially the pasta and pizza, was delicious."

"The food here is delicious, fresh, and well prepared."

"The food at these dinner spots is delicious and well prepared."

Good to know

1

Customers should make a reservation before visiting the restaurant.

2

There is an additional 20% gratuity for two people.

3

The menu prices will be increased by +4% from the prices posted.

09
La Vita image 1
Pizza restaurant

Spacious pizza restaurant with plenty of seating and outdoor dining keeps a laid back and lively atmosphere. Music leans toward 80s disco, creating a unique vibe. Staff enthusiasm adds to the welcoming energy.

Lasagna tastes homemade and is very delicious. Tiramisu stands out as a top dessert. Linguine comes with a generous amount of clams. Vodka sauce penne offers rich flavor and good portion size.

Spaghetti meals and pizza stand out as solid dinner choices. Bread sticks and a dinner salad with green olives, cucumbers, and Italian dressing complement the meal well.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was amazing and delicious."

"I think their Italian food is the best pizza and pasta."

"You have to try the pizza at these dinner spots; it looked amazing."

Good to know

1

This restaurant is one of the only places open late.

2

A slice of spinach pizza and a drink to eat in costs $8.

3

The cheese slice is only $2.75 plus tax, making it $3 total.

10
Bocado image 1
American restaurant

Indoor space feels tight and loud, with club music playing during meals. Outdoor seating offers a cozy, homey vibe with clean, attractive decor. Bar area features pretty lighting and an interesting wine selection, creating a spot more suited for casual drinks than quiet dining.

Big bowls of penne vodka come topped with lots of Parmesan cheese. The gnocchi is well made, and dishes like shrimp carbonara and chicken Alfredo taste fresh and delicious.

Staff provide attentive service and recognize returning diners. Dinner includes thoughtful touches like complimentary desserts. The spot handles busy times well, welcoming guests without reservations.

People are saying

"The Brunch staff here is so friendly and attentive."

"The Italian Food here has such attentive and kind servers."

"The food at these dinner spots was so delicious and flavorful."

Good to know

1

The Prix Fixe Lunch ends at 5pm.

2

Brunch includes a free mimosa or bellini.

3

Bocado Cafe offers a free first drink, either coffee or mimosa.

Discover more

Carnegie Hill, New York

Area guide
Loading Map...