Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Local picks

Pizza spots in Carroll Gardens

A slice of pizza is the only thing that will hit the spot right now.

Based on 616 Opinions
+613
User
User
User
Updated April 2026
01
Aromi image 1
Aromi image 2
Aromi image 3
View all
Italian restaurant

Wood-burning oven crafts Neapolitan pizza with authentic dough that impresses locals and visitors alike. Cozy space with heated patio and dim lighting invites relaxed chats. Specialty cocktails and a private back room add unique charm to this Italian restaurant.

Neapolitan style shines through with authentic dough that stands out. The pizza ranks among the best in the city, impressing even those familiar with traditional Italian pies.

People are saying

"I found the Italian food here to be delicious and authentic."

"I thought the pizza here was amazing, with light, fluffy dough."

"I thought the pizza here was amazing and generously topped."

Good to know

1

Wines are 50% off on Monday evenings.

2

Reservations for 3 at about 7 pm on a Sunday are recommended.

3

Get the lunch special on Friday.

02
Savelli image 1
Italian restaurant

Large space with a wood-fire oven creates a cozy vibe with soft lighting and live guitar music. Pizzas shine with unique toppings like prosciutto and artichokes on a crispy crust. Fresh garden produce and well-crafted cocktails complete the inviting menu.

Pizzas feature a perfect blend of cheese and sauce with toppings like prosciutto, mushrooms, artichokes, and olives on a crispy crust. Options include a quattro stagioni and a sweet pizza with honey, arugula, and spicy soppressata salami.

People are saying

"The Italian food, especially the gnocchi and pizza, was amazing."

"The dinner spots here have delicious, shareable plates with good quantity."

"I thought the pizza here was excellent and perfect."

Good to know

1

Cocktails are $7 during happy hour.

2

Reservations are recommended because it is a busy place.

3

There is a 4% 'convenience' fee on the bill for paying by credit card.

03
Smith Street Pizza image 1
Pizza restaurant

Quaint pizza spot shines with perfect bread and standout slices like margherita with burrata. Outdoor seating offers a chilled backyard vibe that's clean and cute. Paying before eating keeps things simple and uncrowded for a relaxed meal.

Perfect bread sets the pizza apart, with slices like the margherita with burrata and the white slice standing out. Hot sauce adds a unique kick, and the pizza offers great flavor at a reasonable price.

People are saying

"This pizza has a perfect crunchy bottom and delicious toppings."

"I found the food here to be amazing and delicious."

"I needed an authentic slice, and it was delicious."

Good to know

1

Prices for pizza slices range from $3 to $6.

2

A large pizza costs $24.

3

You may need to get 2 slices as the slices are slightly smaller.

04
The Grape Leaf image 1
Halal restaurant

Authentic Middle Eastern architecture creates a comfy, quiet space with open windows and soft Arabic music. Large vegan options shine alongside amazing falafel and shawarma. The laghmagen pizza blends Armenian, Turkish, and Lebanese styles, with the chicken pizza as a solid choice.

The laghmagen offers a tasty take on Armenian, Turkish, and Lebanese pizza styles. The chicken pizza fills you up and stands out as a solid choice.

People are saying

"I loved the Mediterranean falafel sandwich; it made my heart happy."

"I found the shawarma to be amazing and perfectly seasoned."

"I tried the Armenian Pizza, and it was spot on tasty."

Good to know

1

The establishment closes at 10 PM, not 10:30 PM as advertised.

2

The chicken shawarma pita costs $20.

3

Parking is hard to find, but there is paid street parking available.

05
Nate’s Detroit Pizza image 1
Pizza restaurant

Detroit-style pizza shines with crusty white pizza and beef pepperoni. Vinyl records and art on walls create a chill vibe. Loud music from a record player adds energy to the cozy, tight seating.

Detroit-style pizza stands out with its crusty, tasty white pizza and beef pepperoni options. The flavor blends a New York twist with classic Detroit style, creating a special and delicious experience.

People are saying

"I thought Nate's Detroit Pizza was the best pizza in the area."

"The Italian food's tomato sauce is delicious and adds so much quality."

"You have to try the shrimp scampi slice; it's unlike anything I've ever tried."

Good to know

1

The slices cost $6-7 each.

2

A medium supreme pie costs $36.

3

It took about 30 minutes to make the pizza.

06
Bobbi’s Italian beef image 1

Retro Chicago decor and vintage wood paneling create a warm, casual vibe filled with 80s memorabilia and classic arcade games. Tavern pizza features homemade sausage made the traditional way, offering an authentic taste. Family-friendly atmosphere with great music enhances the nostalgic feel.

Tavern pizza here features homemade sausage prepared the traditional way, not sliced. The style closely matches classic Chicago tavern pizza, offering a genuine taste of that region.

People are saying

"I found the Italian Beef sandwich to be the best I ever had."

"I loved the classic Chicago hot dogs and Polish sausage."

"This tavern pizza is the closest you'll get to Chicago."

Good to know

1

Weiner Wednesday offers $2 off hot dogs, making it a popular choice.

2

The sandwich shop is closed on Mondays, so plan accordingly.

3

Prices for sandwiches range from $15 to $23, depending on the selection.

07
F&F Pizzeria image 1
Pizza restaurant

Outdoor seating shines with a garden-style backyard framed by grape vines, creating a relaxed vibe. Pizza boasts a super crispy thin dough with standout Sicilian slices and fresh clam toppings. Energy stays friendly and local, especially in the chill outdoor area.

Pizza features a super crispy thin dough with no flop and a little crispy-ness. The clam and partenna pizzas highlight quality ingredients and lovely flavors, while the Sicilian pizza stands out as the most recommended option.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was the best I ever had."

"The outdoor seating here is perfect for enjoying their delicious, crispy crust pizza."

"The clam pizza seafood here is amazing with lots of clams and lemon."

Good to know

1

Be prepared to wait if you visit during prime time.

2

A slice of pizza costs between 4 to 5 dollars.

3

The restaurant closes at 9 PM.

08
Giardini Pizza image 1
Pizza restaurant

Classic Brooklyn-style pizza features a crispy crust and buffalo chicken slices that stand out. Homey vibe with a covered outdoor patio hosts live blues music. Old school New York feel creates a family-like atmosphere among customers.

Brooklyn-style pizza shines here with a favorite pizza sauce and piles of toppings on each slice. The buffalo chicken and cheese slices stand out among many slice options available.

People are saying

"I found the pizza here to be authentic Brooklyn-style."

"I found the most authentic pizza here, made with fresh, homemade ingredients."

"The outdoor seating is nice and super shaded."

Good to know

1

The location is right across from the Carroll Gardens F/G station, making it an easy detour when transiting.

2

A slice of pizza costs only $3.

3

They accept Apple Pay with a small surcharge.

09
F&F Restaurant and Bar image 1
Pizza restaurant

Upscale yet relaxed spot offers wild mushroom pizza and leek pizza that pair perfectly with a 50/50 martini or chilled red wine. White tablecloths and diffused lighting create a casual yet elegant atmosphere ideal for events and date nights. Indoor and outdoor seating provide a laid back to lively vibe.

Leek pizza and wild mushroom pizza stand out for their flavor. The pizza pairs well with a 50/50 martini or chilled red wine.

People are saying

"I found the pizza to be very fresh and flavorful."

"The Italian food here, especially the pasta, is perfect for dinner or lunch."

"You have to meet CoCo at the Bar; her personality is swoon-worthy."

Good to know

1

The cheese plate costs $25 and includes only 3 small wedges of cheese.

2

Bread is not included with the cheese plate and costs an additional $6.

3

The portions are shareable and on the smaller side.

10
Mazzola Bakery image 1

Neighborhood bakery shines with artisanal breads and a cash-only policy that keeps things simple. Pizza slices offer a quick snack, showing off their solid baking skills. Fresh pastries add to the historic charm of the place.

Pizza slices come with a variety of pastries. The pizza serves as a quick snack and reflects solid baking skills from their bread expertise.

People are saying

"I thought the lard bread here was the best I ever had."

"I loved their iced hazelnut coffee."

"You have to try the lard bread, it's amazing."

Good to know

1

The establishment only accepts cash.

2

The roll costs $1.50.

3

The iced latte costs $9.

11
Lucali image 1
Pizza restaurant

Brick oven pizzeria offers phenomenal taste with fresh, coal-fired pizzas. Candlelit ambiance and cozy atmosphere create a warm, rustic vibe. Guests enjoy watching dough rolled, adding to the immersive experience in this intimate spot.

Fresh and delicious pizza stands out with a phenomenal taste that many consider unmatched in the city. The pies consistently deliver an excellent and memorable experience.

People are saying

"The Italian food here has a spectacular atmosphere and warm hospitality."

"This calzone's cheeses and crust were so good, I might think about it in therapy."

"I thought the pizza here was the best I ever had."

Good to know

1

You need to arrive well before 4 PM and wait in line.

2

It is recommended to get in line at 1:00/2:00 PM to ensure your name gets on the list.

3

The restaurant does not take reservations and is cash only.

12
Sociale image 1
Italian restaurant

Cozy Italian spot shines with crispy pizza crusts and fresh toppings like prosciutto and arugula. Romantic vibe thrives under low lighting and lush live plants. Covered patio blends indoor and outdoor dining for a stylish, inviting experience.

Pizzas feature super crispy yet light crusts with fresh ingredients. The fried pizza options are crispy and pillowy, topped with salty prosciutto and peppery arugula, including a standout honey and nduja sausage combination.

People are saying

"The Italian food, especially the carbonara and fried pizzas, is rich and well executed."

"I found the cocktails here to be wonderful and beautifully presented."

"The fried pizza here is crispy, pillowy, and so good."

Good to know

1

Lunch is served daily, making it a great spot for midday meals.

2

Dinner is popular, so expect a busier atmosphere in the evenings.

3

The average price for a meal is around $18, but some dishes may cost more.

Discover more

Carroll Gardens, New York

Area guide
Loading Map...