Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Top picks in Central Harlem

Cakes

Made for those who measure the success of an outing by the quality of the cake served.

Based on 518 Opinions
+515
User
User
User
Updated April 2026
01
Pastitalia image 1
Pastitalia image 2
Pastitalia image 3
View all

Pasta shop offers visible kitchen, backyard garden dining, and Italian-style bar in a cozy, well-decorated space. Atmosphere feels like a slice of Italy with a warm, homey vibe and quiet outdoor patio. Seating options include sun, shade, and air conditioning, creating a relaxed setting for enjoying fresh pasta and pastries.

Desserts come fresh daily with an array of vegan and gluten-free options that are homemade. Pairing them with nice coffee completes the meal perfectly.

Homemade cakes come in beautiful, tempting slices that add a sweet note to the experience. The cakes are gorgeous and pair well with coffee or latte.

People are saying

"The cakes here are gorgeous and homemade."

"I love finishing meals with dessert and coffee."

"The vegan and gluten-free desserts taste amazing."

Good to know

1

The restaurant is self-serve, requiring customers to buy food at the counter.

2

The price for 2 vegetarian pastas is $50.

3

The restaurant closes at 6:30 PM, so plan to arrive before then.

02
Lee Lee's Baked Goods image 1
Lee Lee's Baked Goods image 2
Lee Lee's Baked Goods image 3
View all

Old-fashioned bakery with a cozy, warm atmosphere and a bright red and white theme. Small space with no indoor seating, offering a couple of tables outside. Known for legendary rugelach with balanced sweetness and flaky tenderness.

Pastries serve as satisfying desserts after a long day. Cakes, cookies, and a flan-looking dessert sit in the fridge alongside cheesecake options.

Carrot cake stands out with a unique flavor that many find amazing. Pound cake is dense and nostalgic, often paired with chocolate icing for a delightful treat.

People are saying

"You have to try the rugelach; it's legendary."

"The carrot cake was amazing and unlike any other."

"You have to try their rugelach; it's amazing."

Good to know

1

The price of rugelach is $3 for 2 bites.

2

The bakery has minimal seating available.

3

You cannot just buy a coffee and sit outside; a purchase is necessary to sit.

03
Archer & Goat image 1
Archer & Goat image 2
Archer & Goat image 3
View all

American restaurant offers intimate vibe with front and back patios and a cozy, trendy atmosphere. Music plays loudly with a mix of '90s retro tunes, creating a laid-back energy. Seating includes tight but comfortable indoor options and ample outdoor space, attracting an eclectic crowd.

Warm date cake stands out as a go-to dessert with an interesting twist. The key lime pie also offers a notable sweet option.

Warm date cake stands out as a decadent dessert with bourbon caramel notes. Other sweets include a key lime pie and a lime tart, all worth trying.

People are saying

"You have to try the warm date cake; it's decadent."

"You've got to try the key lime pie for dessert."

"The dessert felt oddly presented and slow to arrive."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended to secure a table.

2

There is a one-hour maximum time for service.

3

Unlimited mimosas are available during brunch hours.

04
Enoteca Harlem image 1
Enoteca Harlem image 2
Enoteca Harlem image 3
View all

Spanish restaurant offers cozy, intimate atmosphere with a beautiful back patio that stays quiet and welcoming. Tables sit close together, creating a lively, social vibe, while authentic Spanish and Chilean wines and creative tapas dishes highlight the menu. A gorgeous bar adds to the well-designed space, making it suitable for dates, gatherings, or casual nights out.

Torta mil hojas with manjar stands out as a favorite dessert. They offer a variety of desserts and accommodate dietary needs with special dairy-free options.

Dulce de leche and passion fruit cake stands out with its rich flavors. Chocolate cake comes with vanilla instead of passion fruit mousse, a choice they acknowledge but do not change.

People are saying

"The desserts, like tres leches and flan, were delicious."

"The tres leches and torta mil hojas cakes were amazing."

"The desserts taste just like my grandma's cooking."

Good to know

1

The restaurant offers gluten-free and dairy-free options on the menu.

2

Sunday brunch features a variety of dishes and is popular among visitors.

3

Reservations are recommended for weekend brunch to avoid long wait times.

05
Azara Kitchen LLC image 1
Azara Kitchen LLC image 2
Azara Kitchen LLC image 3
View all

Space combines modern style with full African design, creating an atmosphere that is both elegant and cozy. Lighting and decor foster a warm, inviting vibe with touches like fresh flowers and dim candles enhancing the mood. Cleanliness stands out throughout, contributing to a polished and comfortable dining experience.

Desserts include Tiramisu and Red Velvet Cake. Tiramisu tastes decent, while Red Velvet Cake draws more interest for next time.

Tiramisu stands out with its rich, creamy layers. Red Velvet Cake offers a classic, moist texture and vibrant color.

People are saying

"The food was delicious and perfectly seasoned."

"The desserts here, like Tiramisu and Red Velvet, were excellent."

"The desserts, including the carrot cake, were so good."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended on weekends due to high demand.

2

Expect longer wait times during peak dinner hours.

3

Live music nights occur every Friday, starting at 8pm.

06
L.A Sweets image 1
L.A Sweets image 2
L.A Sweets image 3
View all

Bakery features black actors and actresses murals and a strong inviting aroma that fills the street. Atmosphere is lovely and culturally rich with respectful staff and southern-style red velvet cakes highly praised for their moist texture and subtle flavors.

Sweets and desserts include a variety of options with notable vegan choices. The selection changes frequently, offering different treats each visit.

Cakes here are moist and colorful, matching detailed descriptions perfectly. Vegan options taste amazing, and the owner assembles cakes quickly with personalized messages.

People are saying

"The cakes are moist and taste amazing."

"The cake here is so moist and delicious."

"The desserts taste just right and moist."

Good to know

1

The bakery offers vegan options suitable for those with dairy allergies.

2

This bakery is the only place that offers egg, milk, and nut allergy-free cupcakes.

3

It is recommended to go early to LA Sweets to avoid sold-out items.

07
Charles Pan-Fried Chicken image 1
Charles Pan-Fried Chicken image 2
Charles Pan-Fried Chicken image 3
View all

Small space with open kitchen and limited seating offers a family-like atmosphere energized by live music and interactive moments. Outdoor patio adds comfort for sunny days. Energy feels lively and welcoming despite compact setup.

Desserts include cheesecake that stands out even for those who usually avoid it. The owner often offers samples on the house, and the sides and desserts are consistently delicious.

Cakes here feature red velvet with a solid texture and a watermelon cake that includes summery fruits. Chefs prepare the cakes with care, making them well made and tasty.

People are saying

"The desserts are delicious and often come free."

"I ordered cheesecake and it tasted like home."

"I love the red velvet and fresh fruit cakes."

Good to know

1

Chicken and waffles are only available on Sundays.

2

They serve catfish on Tuesday.

3

You canโ€™t dine in; the eatery is for take out only.

08
Vinaterรญa image 1
Vinaterรญa image 2
Vinaterรญa image 3
View all

Outdoor seating includes heated pods that create an intimate atmosphere with tables placed very close together. The interior is sunny and bright with classy decor, balancing a lively bar scene and a romantic vibe despite occasional noise and busy periods.

Desserts feature an olive oil cake that is not too sweet and has a perfect texture. They consistently deliver delicious options alongside other dishes.

Olive oil cake stands out with its perfect texture and balanced sweetness. It offers a delicious dessert option that is not overly sweet.

People are saying

"I love the cozy vibe and tasty food here."

"The olive oil cake for dessert was not too sweet."

"You have to try the olive oil cake; it's not too sweet."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended, especially on weekends when it gets busy.

2

Happy hour offers $1.50 oysters and great specials on wine and select dishes.

3

Be prepared for a wait, particularly for outdoor seating during peak hours.

09
The Original Cake Man Raven image 1
The Original Cake Man Raven image 2
The Original Cake Man Raven image 3
View all

Cake shop known for best red velvet cake with soft, buttery texture and great frosting. Atmosphere is appointment-only entry with limited cake varieties available on site. Service operates mainly through advance payment and cash-only purchases.

Desserts stand out as the highlight here with consistently satisfying flavors. This spot serves as a reliable go-to for good desserts that deliver every time.

The cakes stand out for their moist and sweet texture without being overly sweet. The Red Velvet cake is especially notable for its buttery and creamy frosting and consistent quality.

People are saying

"The cake is moist, sweet, and delicious."

"The red velvet cake is the best I've had."

"The red velvet cake's frosting is to die for."

Good to know

1

You need to make a reservation to order cake from Cake man Raven.

2

Cake man Raven seems to be cash only for on-the-spot purchases.

3

Customers are required to text a screenshot of their order when picking up the cake.

10
Red Rooster Harlem image 1
Red Rooster Harlem image 2
Red Rooster Harlem image 3
View all

Restaurant offers live jazz performances with a colorful African American decor that creates a soulful atmosphere. The space includes a covered terrace and a bar area, though the bar can feel cramped. The vibe is engaging and lively, especially during music events.

Crab cakes stand out with a heavenly flavor and solid texture. Corn bread resembles cake in appearance, and they offer a complimentary cake with a candle for celebrations.

People are saying

"The crab cakes and appetizers were really tasty."

"The mango sorbet dessert was divine and felt healthy."

"I loved the desserts and special birthday treats."

Good to know

1

Make a reservation well in advance, especially for Sunday brunch.

2

Gospel brunch is held every Sunday and features live music.

3

Happy hour runs from noon to 10 p.m. with discounted appetizers and cocktails.

11
Amy Ruth's image 1
Amy Ruth's image 2
Amy Ruth's image 3
View all

Soul food restaurant offers a family atmosphere with phenomenal murals and live R&B music at a low volume. Seating feels comfortable despite a small, somewhat cramped layout. The vibe suits celebrations and large groups, creating a welcoming, lively energy.

Carrot cake and banana cream pudding stand out among the desserts. The rum cake is soaked in rum, adding a rich flavor, and the Peach cobbler invites seconds.

Soft, pineapple coconut cake stands out alongside banana cream pudding and exceptional carrot cake. Desserts focus on rich, classic flavors with a moist texture.

People are saying

"I love the pineapple coconut and carrot cakes."

"The desserts here are large portions, enough for two people."

"The cakes here are so moist and delicious."

Good to know

1

Expect long wait times on Sundays due to gospel mass attendance.

2

Wednesday is Grape Kool Aid day, a special event at the restaurant.

3

Get there early if you want to dine in, especially on weekends.

Discover more

Central Harlem, New York

Area guide
Loading Map...