Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
CPW Historic District's best

Pizza pie

A slice of pie that holds its own structure, avoiding the soggy mess that usually comes with a quick lunch.

Based on 628 Opinions
+625
User
User
User
Updated April 2026
01
Parla image 1
Parla image 2
Parla image 3
View all

Modern space combines airy design with intimate seating including private booths and communal tables. Atmosphere feels fun and lively without crowding, supported by well-crafted cocktails and standout pizzas. Layout efficiently uses space to create a cozy yet vibrant dining experience.

Crunchy crusts define the pizzas here, with styles ranging from hot honey to mushroom-packed options. The pepperoni meatballs add a unique twist to the pepperoni pizza.

Crust on both pie styles is perfection. Hot Hunny square pie stands out as phenomenal. NY Classic round and shroom pie offer solid flavors. Plans include trying upside down and burrata pies next.

People are saying

"The pizza here is so fluffy and addicting."

"The pizza is light, airy, and full of flavor."

"The Hot Hunny square pie blew me away."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for brunch to avoid long wait times.

2

The wait time to be seated can be around 35 minutes during busy hours.

3

The restaurant is wheelchair accessible, featuring a lift and spacious seating.

02
Marinara Pizza Upper West image 1
Marinara Pizza Upper West image 2
Marinara Pizza Upper West image 3
View all

Clean, tastefully decorated pizza restaurant with air conditioning and outdoor seating offers a relaxing atmosphere and good vibes. Busy during lunch hours, it serves large, excellent New York-style pizza slices with a variety of toppings. Seating is ample but can fill up quickly during peak times.

Thin-crust style pizza comes out quickly with fresh ingredients and a delicious margherita option. Vodka pizza stands out as a notable specialty with consistently excellent quality.

Grandma square pies fit neatly in the fridge without unpacking. Both the pizza and spinach pies taste very good with an option to try an assortment of bar pies.

People are saying

"The pizza's sauce and crust were excellent."

"The thin crust pizzas here are always great."

"Some pizzas taste great, but others miss the mark."

Good to know

1

The establishment closes at 9 PM, limiting late-night food options.

2

Lunch hour is very busy, making seating hard to find.

3

You should bring cash to this pizza joint.

03
Freddie & Pepper's image 1
Freddie & Pepper's image 2
Freddie & Pepper's image 3
View all

Underground pizza spot with tiny, cozy interior and minimal seating including two small tables and outdoor options. Atmosphere feels old school and nostalgic, with walls decorated by foreign banknotes and decades-old decor. Vibe is warm and welcoming, offering a genuine neighborhood experience.

Thin and crunchy crust defines the pizza here, paired with toppings like chicken ranch, meat lovers, and vegetarian that stand out. Every pizza delivers solid flavor and consistent quality.

Pies come with a well-browned crust and a thin base. Whole wheat pies are available, but extra sauce is served on the side rather than on the pie itself. Preparation is quick.

People are saying

"I loved the thin, crispy, and flavorful pizza."

"I always enjoy their classic New York-style pizza."

"It's my favorite spot for the best local pizza."

Good to know

1

If you have a peanut or nut allergy, avoid this place.

2

Customers should be ready to wait due to the busy times.

3

There is very little seating available.

04
Motorino Pizza image 1
Motorino Pizza image 2
Motorino Pizza image 3
View all

Small space with brick oven creates authentic, wood-fired pizza experience. Atmosphere feels cozy and relaxed, with dim lighting and art enhancing warmth. Outdoor seating with heaters adds comfort for cooler evenings.

Small individual pizzas follow the Neapolitan style and cook in a brick oven to perfection. Generous toppings and a delightful stracciatella pizza stand out among a wonderful selection.

People are saying

"I love the authentic, cozy vibe and great pizza."

"The pizza was tasty but sometimes pricey and small."

"This pizza has the best crust and balanced flavors."

Good to know

1

The average price of pizza is $20 to $23.

2

The lunch deal is $17 for a pizza and a simple mixed green salad.

3

Delivery is quick and the pizza is fresh.

05
Famous Original Ray's Pizza image 1
Famous Original Ray's Pizza image 2
Famous Original Ray's Pizza image 3
View all

Spacious seating area with 1980s decor creates an authentic NYC vibe and old-school diner atmosphere. Lighting is pleasant and the space feels welcoming and family-friendly. The place suits casual dining and late-night bites with a friendly, no-frills energy.

Slices have a nice crispy crust with dough that is chewy and low in oil. Sicilian pizza stands out as amazing and the overall style is authentic New York with options for vegans and indoor seating.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza was delicious and had a perfect crust."

"The pizza tastes fresh and delicious with a nice thin crust."

"I enjoy the wide variety of tasty pizzas here."

Good to know

1

2 slices of pizza cost almost 10 dollars.

2

Be sure to check your total before paying.

3

The restaurant has a bathroom available for customers to use.

06
Made In New York Pizza image 1
Made In New York Pizza image 2
Made In New York Pizza image 3
View all

Pizza restaurant offers both indoor and outdoor seating with a clean and spacious environment. Atmosphere feels warm and cramped inside, while outdoor seating is tight but pleasant. Crowd tends to be busy and lively, especially late at night.

Slices feature a New York-style crust with standout toppings like spinach mushroom. The pizza offers a great taste that many find exceptional in the city.

People are saying

"This place is my favorite for real New York pizza."

"The pizza tastes great with many options."

"I enjoyed the authentic New Yorkโ€“style pizza here."

Good to know

1

The restaurant has a forced gratuity policy.

2

You get a bit of a discount if you pay cash.

3

Show up at 11:45am for freshly baked cheese pizza.

07
Peacefood - Upper West Side image 1
Peacefood - Upper West Side image 2
Peacefood - Upper West Side image 3
View all

Open layout with close tables creates a loud, bustling atmosphere marked by constant kitchen noise. Hipster vibe recalls Northern California, blending relaxed, cozy elements with energetic service. Outdoor seating adds a pleasant option amid the lively indoor scene.

Raw key lime pie stands out as a favorite, often described as the best ever. Other options include raw chocolate mousse pie and sweet potato pie, offering a variety of rich, plant-based flavors.

People are saying

"The raw key lime pie is the best."

"I thought the key lime pie was the best I ever had."

"I loved the potato pizza the most."

Good to know

1

Expect at least an hour and a half wait if ordering online.

2

The bakery only sells slices of cake and does not sell whole cakes.

3

The restaurant has a policy that prohibits customers from eating outside food.

08
Patsy's Pizzeria image 1
Patsy's Pizzeria image 2
Patsy's Pizzeria image 3
View all

Exposed brick walls and vintage photos create a classic decor with a spacious layout that includes outdoor seating. The atmosphere feels relaxed and pleasant, suitable for casual meals. Pizza stands out with its thin crust and high-quality toppings, complemented by options like Peroni beer and Montepulciano wine.

Chewy and super thin crust stands out on the pizza. The pizza is consistently on point with a flavor that many consider a favorite in the city.

People are saying

"The pizza tastes great with perfect crust and toppings."

"I thought this was the best pizza I had in my life."

"The pizza feels authentic and stands out from others."

Good to know

1

Reservations are not required and you can walk in to be seated immediately.

2

Expect a wait time of over 30 minutes during peak hours.

3

The restaurant does not sell pizza by the slice.

09
UNO Pizzeria & Grill image 1
UNO Pizzeria & Grill image 2
UNO Pizzeria & Grill image 3
View all

Spacious interior offers a quaint event space with a lovely view near a museum. Atmosphere feels dark and gloomy with a need for remodeling. Background music plays softly, and kids can enjoy a pizza-making activity.

Deep pan pizza stands out with its Chicago style and quality ingredients. Thin crust and Farmer's Market options offer variety, all delivering very delicious pies.

People are saying

"The deep dish pizza tastes good but feels small."

"I loved the Chicago-style deep dish pizza here."

"I think their pizza is always delicious and well made."

Good to know

1

The restaurant has a happy hour from 3 to 6pm with discounted drinks.

2

On December 6th, pizzas are only $6, attracting many locals.

3

The restaurant does not accept contactless payment, cash, or physical card.

Discover more

Central Park West Historic District, New York

Area guide
Loading Map...