Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Diamond District's best

Jewelry stores

Made for those who demand precision and craftsmanship when investing in high-end jewelry.

Based on 850 Opinions
+847
User
User
User
Updated April 2026
01
Segal Jewelry image 1
Segal Jewelry image 2
Segal Jewelry image 3
View all

Fine jewelry offers unmatched craftsmanship and exceptional diamond quality with unique designs. Engagement rings show flawless execution and the team gives excellent support throughout purchase. Atmosphere reflects true artistry and care.

Engagement and wedding rings come with flawless execution and unparalleled craftsmanship. The team provides excellent customer support throughout the entire purchasing process.

People are saying

"The jewelry from this Jewelry Store exceeded all my expectations."

"The jewelry quality and craftsmanship blew me away."

"I highly recommend this place for special jewelry."

Good to know

1

Segal Jewelry offers a perfect combination of quality, design, and customer care.

2

The selection of engagement rings at this place is exceptional.

3

Every piece at Segal Jewelry is meticulously made.

02
Malidani Jewelry image 1
Malidani Jewelry image 2
Malidani Jewelry image 3
View all

Jewelry store offers high-quality pieces like engagement rings and necklaces with personalized service in a laid-back atmosphere. Staff provide trustworthy expertise and a smooth buying experience. Shop feels warm and efficient, unlike typical busy stores.

High-quality jewelry includes engagement rings, wedding rings, earrings, necklaces, and bracelets. The team offers knowledgeable and trustworthy service with a smooth buying experience and a rich history.

People are saying

"The staff at this Jewelry Store are so patient and helpful finding the perfect pieces."

"I love their beautiful custom jewelry and prices."

"I highly recommend this place for all jewelry needs."

Good to know

1

Malidani Jewelry offers a stamped 'Seven Day Money Back Guarantee' if jewelry does not appraise for purchase price or more.

2

The store has a stunning selection of diamonds and engagement rings.

3

Expect knowledgeable and trustworthy service from the staff.

03
The Natural Sapphire Company image 1
The Natural Sapphire Company image 2
The Natural Sapphire Company image 3
View all

Showroom blends quaint design with calm vibes. Custom sapphire rings and earrings shine with luxury quality. Detailed gemstone info and free resizing make shopping easy.

Offers custom sapphire jewelry including engagement rings, wedding bands, and earrings. Pieces are unique and crafted with luxury quality.

People are saying

"I had outstanding customer service at this jewelry store."

"I always recommend their stunning sapphire jewelry."

"Their custom jewelry is beautiful and well priced."

Good to know

1

The Natural Sapphire Company offers certified and appraised sapphires for purchase.

2

All jewelry comes with a cleaning kit and gemstone certifications.

3

Rush delivery options are available for faster shipping.

04
Diana M. Jewels image 1
Diana M. Jewels image 2
Diana M. Jewels image 3
View all

Jewelry store shines with exceptional metals and brilliant diamonds in a relaxed, family-like setting. Personalized, concierge-style service ensures a perfect fit for special occasions. Quality and value meet in every stunning design.

Jewelry shows unparalleled quality and workmanship with pieces that offer great value. Staff provide personalized service and help find items with the right size and brilliance for special occasions.

People are saying

"This jewelry store's service feels like family, not just customers."

"The design process was smooth and easy."

"I love the quality and how well they communicate."

Good to know

1

Diana M. Jewels offers a wide selection of engagement rings, earrings, and bracelets.

2

Custom jewelry can be produced quickly, often within a few days.

3

Shipping is available at no cost, with overnight delivery options.

05
Forever Diamonds NY image 1
Forever Diamonds NY image 2
Forever Diamonds NY image 3
View all

Showroom blends intimate atmosphere with high-quality jewelry craftsmanship. Family-owned warmth meets luxurious shopping for engagement rings and wedding bands. Experience feels personal and elegant, unlike typical jewelry stores.

Offers high-quality jewelry with beautiful craftsmanship. Specializes in engagement rings and wedding bands with a luxurious shopping experience.

People are saying

"This jewelry store made my dream ring and exceeded my expectations."

"The jewelry here is beautiful and top quality."

"Roman makes buying jewelry feel easy and personal."

Good to know

1

Make sure to schedule your appointment with Rosie for personalized service.

2

Roman offers fully customizable rings, making each piece unique.

3

Expect a memorable shopping experience at Forever Diamonds.

06
Liori Diamonds - Engagement Rings & Jewelry image 1
Liori Diamonds - Engagement Rings & Jewelry image 2
Liori Diamonds - Engagement Rings & Jewelry image 3
View all

Showroom blends modern elegance with a calm, welcoming vibe. Jewelry features high-quality diamonds and lifetime warranties. Certified experts ensure true value and offer custom designs for proposals and upgrades.

Every piece comes with lifetime warranty and detailed paperwork. Certified experts appraise rings with true to value accuracy. Options include proposal rings and upgrades.

People are saying

"Avi and Diana's service at this jewelry store is incredibly prompt and helpful."

"I always trust their jewelry quality and selection."

"The jewelry quality and buying experience are excellent."

Good to know

1

Liori Diamonds is not open on weekends.

2

Appointments are recommended for a smoother experience.

3

They offer a lifetime warranty on all purchases.

07
Keyzar Jewelry image 1
Keyzar Jewelry image 2
Keyzar Jewelry image 3
View all

Online jeweler offers high-quality rings with amazing craftsmanship and easy 360-degree views. Customers enjoy flexible payment plans and fast, discreet shipping. Custom orders may take several weeks but ensure detailed personalization.

Quality jewelry stands out with amazing craftsmanship and great customer service. Flexible payment installment options make purchases more affordable.

People are saying

"The rings at this jewelry store are stunning and look amazing."

"I loved how smooth and satisfying my jewelry purchase was."

"The jewelry’s quality and craftsmanship impressed me."

Good to know

1

Expect to add another 500-1000$ in duties and taxes when ordering to Canada.

2

The expected return date for the rings is around the 11th of February.

3

The wait time for the ring was initially stated as 4-5 weeks.

08
Gotham City Jewelers image 1
Gotham City Jewelers image 2
Gotham City Jewelers image 3
View all

Jewelry store shines with custom designs and exceptional craftsmanship. Staff offer patient, creative service and pricing stays reasonable. Trading in old gold adds value, making shopping smooth and satisfying.

Inventory includes beautiful jewelry with impressive attention to detail. Pieces offer top quality and fair prices, especially when trading in old gold.

People are saying

"This jewelry store custom-made my perfect anniversary ring."

"I highly recommend this jeweler for great finds."

"They delivered my custom ring right on time."

Good to know

1

They offer unique and beautiful jewelry pieces.

2

All jewelry is crafted with exceptional quality and attention to detail.

3

Pricing is reasonable compared to larger jewelry stores.

09
Vale Jewelry image 1
Vale Jewelry image 2
Vale Jewelry image 3
View all

Jewelry studio offers ethically sourced pieces with stunning craftsmanship. Women-owned by sisters, it blends custom designs with a welcoming atmosphere. Ava and team provide exceptional service for engagements and special occasions.

Exceptional customer service stands out, especially from Ava and the team. Rings for engagements, weddings, and anniversaries show stunning craftsmanship and bring lasting joy.

People are saying

"I loved working with the team at this Jewelry Store to create a custom ring."

"I love how they made my custom ring perfect."

"I love their beautiful jewelry and always recommend them."

Good to know

1

Appointments are recommended for personalized consultations, especially on weekends.

2

Vale Jewelry offers custom ring services tailored to individual preferences.

3

The store provides a unique shopping experience where customers can explore freely.

10
I.D. Jewelry image 1
I.D. Jewelry image 2
I.D. Jewelry image 3
View all

Certified Gemologist creates a transparent atmosphere with pressure-free service. Offers diamond studs and custom engagement rings with exceptional quality. Pricing is best in district with quick turnaround and a family-oriented vibe.

Offers a wide range of engagement rings and custom pieces like anniversary rings. Known for diamond studs and tennis bracelets, with consistent quality and professional service over decades.

People are saying

"The staff at this jewelry store are so attentive and friendly."

"Their jewelry looks like art and fits perfectly."

"I've trusted Yekutiel for my jewelry needs for years."

Good to know

1

I.D. Jewelry resizes rings for free within two days.

2

ID Jewelry ships products overnight for quick delivery.

3

The craftsmanship of their jewelry is highly regarded by appraisers.

11
G Diamond USA image 1
G Diamond USA image 2
G Diamond USA image 3
View all

Family-owned jeweler shines with flawless craftsmanship and honest service. Staff provide personalized attention that makes buying rings easy and comfortable. Warm, trustworthy atmosphere ensures fair pricing and clear communication.

Highly knowledgeable staff offer access to the best stones and honest service. Personalized attention makes buying engagement and wedding rings straightforward and comfortable.

People are saying

"This jewelry store's owners are honest, patient, and incredibly knowledgeable."

"I felt comfortable getting exactly what I wanted."

"I always trust this place for quality jewelry."

Good to know

1

They offer competitive pricing on diamonds and jewelry.

2

Expect personalized service from knowledgeable staff.

3

They provide fair appraisals and repair services.

12
Lauren B Jewelry image 1
Lauren B Jewelry image 2
Lauren B Jewelry image 3
View all

Bright, modern showroom offers a peaceful atmosphere with custom jewelry creation featuring virtual meetings. High-quality craftsmanship shines in engagement rings and wedding bands. Experience is calm and friendly, ensuring personalized attention without pressure.

Custom jewelry creation involves close coordination, including virtual meetings to view real rings in real time. The service features high-quality craftsmanship and personalized attention, especially for engagement rings and wedding bands.

People are saying

"I worked with Catherine to create beautiful rings at this jewelry store."

"I love how the jewelry quality exceeded my expectations."

"I love how their jewelry feels special and unique."

Good to know

1

You can work with Kimberly virtually even if you don’t live in NYC.

2

They offer a warranty that they stand behind.

3

The process of designing wedding bands is stress-free and enjoyable.

13
Deena Jewelers image 1
Deena Jewelers image 2
Deena Jewelers image 3
View all

Family-run jeweler shines with custom pieces and solitaire stud diamond earrings. Honest, supportive service helps find jewelry within budget. Prices are incredibly competitive, making quality pieces affordable.

Offers quality jewelry including solitaire stud diamond earrings, earrings and bracelets, and beautiful rings. Jewelry pieces show clear attention to detail and craftsmanship.

People are saying

"Sandy and Chuck at this Jewelry Store are so helpful and patient."

"Their jewelry looks great and fits my budget."

"I always come back for their stunning jewelry."

Good to know

1

Deena Jewelers offers engagement rings, custom pieces, and fashionable jewelry.

2

The store is budget-friendly and does not impose a ring on you.

3

There is no pressure or upselling at Deena Jewelers.

14
Daniel of Fifth Avenue image 1
Daniel of Fifth Avenue image 2
Daniel of Fifth Avenue image 3
View all

Daniel crafts custom engagement rings with expert care in a family-run shop. Customers enjoy a pressure-free space with clear pricing and expert advice on stones. Shop offers timeless pieces and rare watches all under one roof.

Daniel handles engagement rings and bespoke jewelry with expertise. He offers custom jewelry services and is trusted for selecting stones and fine pieces.

People are saying

"Daniel makes the jewelry process feel special, personal, and stress-free."

"I highly recommend Daniel for beautiful jewelry."

"Daniel made my custom jewelry fast and affordable."

Good to know

1

Daniel offers custom jewelry that is more affordable than traditional stores.

2

Expect a quick turnaround for custom rings and jewelry.

3

Daniel provides a one-on-one consultation to discuss your jewelry needs.

15
Jewelry by Garo image 1
Jewelry by Garo image 2
Jewelry by Garo image 3
View all

Handcrafted jewelry shines with unique designs and customization options. Fast delivery comes with authenticity certificates and elegant packaging. Personalized service ensures satisfaction through attentive follow-up.

Unique jewelry pieces stand out with customization options and a varied selection not found elsewhere. The store offers personalized service including follow-up communication to ensure satisfaction.

People are saying

"The Jewelry Store's customer service is amazing and super helpful."

"I love their unique, high quality jewelry."

"Their jewelry is affordable and easy to customize."

Good to know

1

The ring was ready in 3 days.

2

Mr. Celik resized my ring in only 2 days and it was promptly shipped back.

3

There is a variety of jewelry selection that you won't find anywhere else.

16
Rachel’s Lab Grown Diamonds image 1
Rachel’s Lab Grown Diamonds image 2
Rachel’s Lab Grown Diamonds image 3
View all

Shop offers lab grown diamonds with unbeatable prices and exquisite craftsmanship. Staff explain diamond quality clearly, making buying easy. Custom engagement rings and wedding bands stand out for quality and value.

Custom pieces use lab grown diamonds and finest materials with impressive craftsmanship. Mike offers engagement rings and wedding bands with quality and price that stand out.

People are saying

"I loved the quality and quick custom jewelry options."

"Mike at this Jewelry Store was honest, helpful, and gave a great price."

"The jewelry feels special and shines perfectly."

Good to know

1

The shop specializes in lab grown diamonds, including necklaces, bracelets, and loose stones.

2

Expect personalized service from knowledgeable staff who can help you find what you need.

3

The shop may appear small, but a wide variety of products are available upon request.

17
Simon Ardem Diamond Jewelry image 1
Simon Ardem Diamond Jewelry image 2
Simon Ardem Diamond Jewelry image 3
View all

Jeweler offers exceptional craftsmanship and affordable luxury with a welcoming atmosphere. Owner provides a personal touch and expert custom work, including combining rings. Quality stones and fair pricing stand out among jewelers.

Dealing directly with the owner offers a more personal touch than typical salespeople. Custom work includes combining multiple rings into one, showing expert craftsmanship and personalized service.

People are saying

"This jewelry store crafts brilliant, custom pieces that exceed expectations."

"I love how the custom diamond jewelry turned out."

"I love how their jewelry feels special and unique."

Good to know

1

Expect custom jewelry orders to take up to four weeks for completion.

2

Appointments are recommended for personalized consultations and custom designs.

3

Quality of jewelry is consistently high, surpassing many competitors.

18
old world diamonds image 1
old world diamonds image 2
old world diamonds image 3
View all

Offers an extensive range of vintage diamonds with quick custom ring production finishing in about a week. Pricing is notably competitive, often much lower than other jewelers. Earrings ordered online arrive in less than 24 hours, ensuring fast, reliable service.

Custom rings finish in about a week after design and wax approval, much faster than typical 12-18 week waits. Earrings ordered online arrive in less than 24 hours, showing a quick and reliable service.

People are saying

"I got my engagement ring here and they were so knowledgeable."

"I love how sparkly jewelry makes me feel and lasts."

"Custom rings get done way faster here than usual."

Good to know

1

Adam offers the best quality antique diamonds with the fairest prices.

2

The turnaround time for custom rings is about a week after design approval.

3

There are no shipping fees, and certificates are included at no extra cost.

19
Iannelli Diamonds image 1
Iannelli Diamonds image 2
Iannelli Diamonds image 3
View all

Shop offers unmatched quality jewelry with custom pieces and excellent service. Prices stay surprisingly affordable with no hidden fees. Family-run vibe keeps atmosphere unpretentious and honest, making it easy to trust and return.

Jewelry here shows unmatched quality with options for custom pieces and a focus on excellent service. Multiple purchases include wedding bands and other jewelry, encouraging repeat visits.

People are saying

"This jewelry store treats you like family and remembers your milestones."

"Their prices and service really stand out."

"I loved my ring but had some problems later."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for dinner, especially on weekends.

2

Expect a wait time of 20-30 minutes during peak hours.

3

Parking is available on-site, but fills up quickly during events.

20
Roman Malakov Diamonds image 1
Roman Malakov Diamonds image 2
Roman Malakov Diamonds image 3
View all

Jewelry store offers custom designs with unique pieces like antique jade button earrings. Staff treat customers like family, creating a warm atmosphere. High-quality craftsmanship shines in every diamond earring and special item.

Custom jewelry includes unique pieces like earrings made from antique jade buttons. Staff treat customers like family while providing high-quality diamond earrings and other special items.

People are saying

"This jewelry store helped me create my dream ring with amazing craftsmanship."

Good to know

1

The ring comes with necessary certification and a cleaning cloth.

2

Expect the ring to be ready in about a month.

21
Zoland Jewelers image 1
Zoland Jewelers image 2
Zoland Jewelers image 3
View all

Fred's workshop shines with handcrafted rings that show deep care for diamond quality. Staff keep the vibe relaxed and honest, making buying easy and fun. Every piece reflects expert guidance and lasting quality.

Fred crafts amazing rings with clear integrity and attention to every diamond and jewelry detail. All rings come out beautifully, making him the go-to for any jewelry purchases.

People are saying

"Fred at this Jewelry Store helped make my jewelry dreams come true."

"I loved how they helped me design a perfect diamond ring."

"Fred makes beautiful custom jewelry that feels personal."

Good to know

1

Zoland offers custom engagement and wedding rings tailored to your preferences.

2

Expect high-quality materials and exquisite craftsmanship at Zoland.

3

Zoland's prices on diamond earrings are competitive and worth checking out.

22
B2C Jewels image 1
B2C Jewels image 2

Online jeweler offers wide selection of high-quality diamonds with heart-shaped prongs in custom pieces. Purchases are easy via WhatsApp with secure packaging and reliable delivery, though some geographic limits apply.

Custom pieces feature heart-shaped prongs and perfectly matched stones. Purchases happen easily through WhatsApp, with clear online info and direct office pickup.

People are saying

"Adam at this Jewelry Store was so patient helping me choose my diamond."

Good to know

1

Check for seasonal sales and promotions before visiting.

2

Parking is available nearby, but it can fill up quickly.

3

Credit cards and mobile payments are accepted; cash may be preferred for small purchases.

23
ItsHot Diamond Jewelry & Watches image 1
ItsHot Diamond Jewelry & Watches image 2
ItsHot Diamond Jewelry & Watches image 3
View all

Jewelry store shines with natural diamond earrings and 14K gold settings. Staff deliver great service in a chill, professional space. Unique items like Rolex watches add luxury and style to the affordable, high-quality selection.

Offers natural diamond earrings with 14K gold settings and a strong focus on hip-hop jewelry styles. Staff provide great service and the jewelry quality stands out for its craftsmanship and price.

People are saying

"The jewelry here is beautiful, high quality, and sturdy."

Good to know

1

The store offers a wide selection of diamond earrings and engagement rings.

2

Shipping is fast and reliable for online orders.

3

Custom jewelry can be designed based on individual needs.

24
Fantasy Diamonds LLC image 1
Fantasy Diamonds LLC image 2
Fantasy Diamonds LLC image 3
View all

Store offers fast turnaround on rings with friendly staff ensuring a welcoming vibe. Space is well-organized and lively, perfect for those seeking quality jewelry at good prices.

Quick turnaround time for rings and consistent updates on progress stand out. Friendly staff make the experience welcoming while offering quality jewelry and trustworthy service.

People are saying

"This jewelry store's staff is so friendly and professional."

"Their jewelry is beautiful and fits any budget."

"They fix jewelry fast and really know their stuff."

Good to know

1

They offer lifetime resizing for rings purchased from them.

2

Repairs are done at a nearby location and take about an hour.

3

Both of my fiancΓ©s diamond rings came GIA certified.

25
The Natural Gemstone Company image 1
The Natural Gemstone Company image 2
The Natural Gemstone Company image 3
View all

Penthouse showroom offers a jaw-dropping view and a calm, refined atmosphere. Custom jewelry shines with beautiful gemstones and clear updates during creation. Fast shipping and a vast selection make browsing smooth and enjoyable.

Offers a custom-made jewelry experience focused on designing colored stone jewelry from start to finish. Keeps customers updated during creation and uses beautiful gemstones in their pieces.

People are saying

"Lauren made designing my custom jewelry piece so easy and professional."

"I love designing my own jewelry here."

"I love the jewelry I bought and want more."

Good to know

1

Custom jewelry orders can take up to four weeks for completion.

2

Shipping is typically completed within 3-5 business days after order confirmation.

3

Appointments for in-person consultations are recommended to ensure personalized service.

26
OMI Jewelry image 1
OMI Jewelry image 2
OMI Jewelry image 3
View all

Offices feature beautiful design and a pet-friendly environment that keeps things relaxed. Jewelry here boasts exceptional quality with outstanding customer service ensuring smooth, no-pressure transactions and fast, reliable shipping.

Exceptional quality jewelry and watches come with outstanding customer service. Transactions are smooth and efficient, with staff going above and beyond to ensure satisfaction even after delays.

People are saying

"The staff at this Jewelry Store are friendly and helpful."

"I love the quality and variety of their jewelry."

"I trust them for buying luxury watches and jewelry."

Good to know

1

OMI Jewelry ships items within 4 days, faster than the average 7-10 business days.

2

All watches sold are authentic and come with appraisal papers.

3

Customer service is reported to be efficient and helpful.

27
ECI Jewelers image 1
ECI Jewelers image 2
ECI Jewelers image 3
View all

Family-owned store shines with high-quality craftsmanship and custom pieces. Staff offer exceptional service and handle items with care. Transparent pricing and financing options make buying easy and trustworthy.

High-quality jewelry and custom pieces stand out here. Staff provide exceptional service and handle watches and jewelry with care.

People are saying

"This jewelry store's staff is knowledgeable and made the process easy."

"I love their jewelry and custom pieces."

"I've trusted their timeless jewelry for years."

Good to know

1

ECI Jewelers offers a two-year warranty on all purchases.

2

Shipping is fast and secure, often arriving within 24 hours.

3

They provide financing or layaway options for customers.

Discover more

Diamond District, New York

Area guide
Loading Map...