Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Best of Hell's Kitchen

Pie shops

You want a slice of pie that is made with purpose. You aren't looking for a mass-produced dessert.

Based on 530 Opinions
+527
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Poseidon Greek Bakery image 1
Poseidon Greek Bakery image 2
Poseidon Greek Bakery image 3
View all

Tiny bakery shines with handmade phyllo dough and classic Greek pastries. Meat and spinach pies offer rich flavors perfect for breakfast. Blue and white decor with family photos adds a bright, authentic atmosphere.

Meat pie and spinach pie stand out with rich flavors. The beef pie serves as a tasty breakfast option, alongside hand pies like Meninaโ€™s Mash and finikia.

People are saying

"I found this little family-owned Greek bakery to be a hidden gem."

"These flaky, buttery pastries are simply perfect."

"I loved the flaky phyllo and juicy filling of the meat pie."

Good to know

1

The bakery has been in business for 100 years and offers homemade phyllo dough.

2

Pastries are priced at $6 each, including spanakopita.

3

The bakery offers both savory and sweet pastries.

02
by & by image 1
Restaurant

Eclectic space offers a cozy atmosphere with a classy, sea-like vibe. Rabbit Pie shines with its crispy pastry crust and rich, slow-braised ragu. Inventive cocktails and a welcoming bar draw locals and visitors alike for a balanced, flavorful experience.

Rabbit Pie comes as a stew with a pastry crust served separately to keep it crispy and light. Slow braised ragu and rabbit pot pie pair well with wine for a rich experience.

People are saying

"The food here is fantastic and flavorful."

"The cocktails here are creative and perfectly balanced."

"Vinnie's recommendations made the rabbit pot pie exceptional."

Good to know

1

Happy hour at the bar runs from 4-7pm on weekdays.

2

The cafe at by & by just opened, offering coffee and light bites.

3

Reservations are not required but recommended during peak hours.

03
Little Pie Company image 1

Open kitchen fills air with buttery pastry aroma while bakers craft innovative pies like Apple Sour Cream Walnut. Cozy space with outdoor shaded seating offers a homey vibe. Apple pie is a top choice praised for perfect sweetness.

Pies here stand out for their innovative flavors like Apple Sour Cream Walnut and consistently deliver perfectly balanced sweetness. The apple pie ranks as a top choice, often described as the best ever tasted.

People are saying

"I tasted the best key lime pie I have ever had."

"I found the cheesecake to be incredibly creamy and delicious."

"The pecan pie here has an amazing abundance of pecans."

Good to know

1

Little Pie Co offers 50% off select pies at 7 PM daily.

2

Pre-order pies for holidays like Thanksgiving to ensure availability.

3

Expect high prices; pies can cost around $64 each.

04
West Side Steakhouse image 1

Cozy space with warm lighting fits both celebrations and business dinners. Pecan pie shines as a dessert highlight, often paired with Haagen Dazs ice cream. Historic city photos add charm, while lively music keeps the vibe upbeat despite some noise.

Warm pecan pie stands out as a dessert highlight, often paired with Haagen Dazs ice cream. Apple pie also appears as a classic choice alongside main dishes.

People are saying

"You can get a great steak here at a reasonable cost."

"The service at this Steakhouse is always great and attentive."

"I loved the warm apple pie with ice cream."

Good to know

1

Booking in advance is useful due to the busy nature of the restaurant.

2

The last lunch order is at 3:30 PM.

3

The bill cannot be split.

05
The Landmark Tavern image 1
Irish restaurant

Historic Irish pub features original mahogany interiors and a pressed metal ceiling for a classic feel. Shepherd's pie offers a rich, hearty filling that pairs perfectly with draught beers. Live Celtic music creates a vibrant energy that fills the lively back room.

Shepherd's pie stands out with its rich, hearty filling and well-balanced flavors. It pairs well with draught beers and is often mentioned alongside fish and chips and bangers and mash.

People are saying

"The pub's food was so good, especially the crispy fish and chips."

"It feels like stepping back in time at this historic gem."

"I found the shepherd's pie to be delicious."

Good to know

1

Live music is available on Monday nights from 8 to 11 PM.

2

The restaurant has been around for 153 years.

3

A mandatory 20% tip is included in the bill.

06
Joe Allen image 1
American restaurant

Quaint spot with Broadway flop posters sets a cozy, classy vibe perfect for theater fans. Banana cream pie offers a rich flavor that delights dessert lovers. Dress-up-friendly yet casual, it blends comfort with a classic bar counter atmosphere.

The banana cream pie stands out with its rich flavor and creamy texture. The lemon cheesecake also offers a tangy, smooth dessert option.

People are saying

"The food here is phenomenal, especially the steak."

"The dinner spots here have terrific menus and melt-in-your-mouth chicken."

"You have to try the banana cream pie; it's amazing."

Good to know

1

Always make a reservation to ensure a table.

2

Everyone who came without a reservation was turned away.

3

The restaurant is very attentive to allergies.

07
Hibernia Bar image 1
Irish pub

Small Irish pub buzzes with live sports on multiple TVs and walls decked in signed jerseys. Shepherd's pie shines with rich flavor, perfect alongside hearty burgers. Energetic vibe draws crowds for games, music, and social fun.

Shepherd's pie stands out with its rich flavor and consistent high praise. It pairs well with other hearty dishes like burgers and appetizers.

People are saying

"It's a great place for live sports with a lively atmosphere."

"The food here is delicious, especially the perfectly cooked burger."

"I thought the shepherd's pie was better than perfect."

Good to know

1

Arrive early on game day to secure a table or bar spot.

2

The kitchen is open until 2 AM for late-night snacks.

3

Expect a lively atmosphere during Steelers games on Sundays.

08
Down Under Coffee image 1

Coffee shop in an underground market offers wide vegan and gluten-free options with a warm, fragrant atmosphere. Vegan pie tastes like a sausage empanada, perfect for a quick bite before the train. Location is tricky, attracting those seeking specialty dietary treats.

Vegan pie tastes like a sausage empanada and works well for a quick bite before the train. Ham & cheese pie offers a classic savory option alongside other sandwiches.

People are saying

"They have so many tasty vegetarian options, both sweet and savory."

"The staff here is so friendly and fast with your order."

"I tried the vegan pie; it was convenient for a quick bite."

Good to know

1

The shop has many vegan and gluten-free treats available.

2

There are no chairs for seating, so plan to take your food to go.

3

The shop is located in the Underground Market by the subway.

Discover more

Hell's Kitchen, New York

Area guide
Loading Map...