Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Loved by locals

Expensive spots in Jamaica, New York

Made for those who view dining as a high-stakes investment and refuse to settle for anything less than an expensive, curated experience.

Based on 702 Opinions
+699
User
User
User
Updated
01
Connie Cocktail Lounge image 1
Connie Cocktail Lounge image 2
Connie Cocktail Lounge image 3
View all

Cocktail lounge inside a vintage Lockheed Constellation aircraft offers a kitschy vintage airplane vibe and a lively, social energy. Drinks are expensive and often miss the mark on taste, making the experience more about the unique setting than the beverages.

People are saying

"I love the cool vintage airplane vibe inside."

"The drinks were pricey and served in plastic cups."

Good to know

1

Parking at Connie Cocktail Lounge is expensive.

2

Cocktail prices range from $16-20, with beers costing $8-9.

3

The menu is accessible via a QR code.

02
Aloha Krab Cajun Seafood & Bar image 1
Aloha Krab Cajun Seafood & Bar image 2
Aloha Krab Cajun Seafood & Bar image 3
View all

Small space with charming decor and a live DJ sets a lively club vibe. Loud music makes chatting tough but sparks dancing and fun. Prices are high, making it an expensive spot for appetizers and drinks.

People are saying

"I love the flavorful food and lively atmosphere here."

"The wings are either too salty or just okay for me."

Good to know

1

Happy hour on Fridays features a live DJ and runs from 4-7pm.

2

The restaurant has last seating an hour before closing.

3

Crab legs cost an extra $5 during the lunch special.

03
La Vie image 1
La Vie image 2
La Vie image 3
View all

Small restaurant offers a quiet atmosphere away from airport noise with comfortable seating. Food shines with well-regarded pasta and pizza paired with good wine selections. Prices are high, with wine around $18.50, but the quality justifies the cost.

People are saying

"The food was mostly good with some misses."

"The bartender made the place feel friendly and welcoming."

Good to know

1

The restaurant automatically includes and charges an 18% tip for a party of 2.

2

You have to order on your own phone or key in your card info on their tablet.

3

You should allot a few extra minutes or get your check early to leave on time.

04
Bobby Van's image 1
Bobby Van's image 2
Bobby Van's image 3
View all

Steakhouse offers a large, luxurious space with classy wood trimming and a semi-secluded, relaxed setting that contrasts with the busy airport outside. The atmosphere stays quiet and inviting, enhanced by great background music and attentive service. Bar areas include power outlets for convenience, supporting both dining and working needs.

05
HALAL DINER image 1
HALAL DINER image 2
HALAL DINER image 3
View all

Spacious dining area with booth seating offers a cozy, peaceful spot for quiet meals. Food is made fresh after ordering, ensuring quality. Prices are high, making it feel expensive and somewhat overrated for value.

People are saying

"I love how fresh and authentic the food tastes."

"The food is tasty, fresh, and fills me up."

"Their biryani and kebabs are my favorites."

Good to know

1

Parking is available on nearby streets without difficulty.

2

Prices are surprisingly affordable considering the location in New York City.

3

The portion sizes are great, so order accordingly.

06
Burgery image 1
Burgery image 2
Burgery image 3
View all

Small space offers a homey vibe with ongoing renovations and warm energy. Certified halal menu shines with freshly baked bread and juicy smash burgers. Prices are steep, with small portions costing $42 for two burgers and fries.

People are saying

"The burgers and fries are always perfectly seasoned."

"Their halal smash burgers are the best I've had."

"The meat is always tender and tastes high quality."

Good to know

1

The restaurant is 100% HALAL CERTIFIED, making it a great option for Muslims.

2

You should be willing to pay at least $6.50 for a burger.

3

The food is ready impressively within 6 minutes.

07
Ideal Food Basket image 1
Ideal Food Basket image 2
Ideal Food Basket image 3
View all

Roomy supermarket offers wide product variety and fresh produce in a clean, busy space. Prices are very expensive due to location. Multiple self-checkouts and large deli and bakery sections enhance the shopping experience.

People are saying

"The food is fresh and there's lots to choose from."

"The prices here feel higher than other stores."

"I find this place more expensive than other supermarkets."

Good to know

1

There is no parking available at the store.

2

The prices are very expensive compared to supermarkets in the area.

3

The store has a great selection of ready-made salads and cold food options available at the deli.

08
SHEIKHS N BURGERS image 1
SHEIKHS N BURGERS image 2
SHEIKHS N BURGERS image 3
View all

Modern design and intimate seating create a lively, welcoming vibe with good air conditioning. Prices are high, ranging from $30 to $50, reflecting the 100% certified zabiha halal quality. Unique cover playlist music adds to the distinct atmosphere.

People are saying

"I love that they serve tasty halal food."

"The food is fresh and tastes great."

"The burgers and fries are really tasty."

Good to know

1

They stop serving food at 11:30 PM, not 12 AM as advertised.

2

They are currently holding a 15% off for students sale.

3

The restaurant offers Halal fast food options.

09
J&C Fish Market Inc. image 1
J&C Fish Market Inc. image 2
J&C Fish Market Inc. image 3
View all

Seafood market offers fresh fish and an on-site kitchen with hand-breaded seafood. Atmosphere feels like beach side with a wide selection. Prices are high, reflecting quality and quantity.

People are saying

"The seafood quality and prices vary a lot here."

"The seafood is fresh and seasoned just right."

Good to know

1

There is a large selection of fresh fish available.

2

Prices for catfish are around $10.99 per pound.

3

Expect to pay around $78 for a large seafood order.

10
MyUnique Jamaica - Downtown (DJQ) image 1
MyUnique Jamaica - Downtown (DJQ) image 2
MyUnique Jamaica - Downtown (DJQ) image 3
View all

Large thrift store has a chill vibe but a musky smell. Prices are consistently high, with some items very expensive despite daily sales. Shoppers include many resellers hunting for unique vintage pieces and well-known brands.

People are saying

"I find great unique stuff at fair prices."

"The store just doesn't feel the same anymore."

"Some staff were rude, but others helped me."

Good to know

1

UNIQUE offers clothing for all tastes and ages, including coats, jackets, and shoes.

2

The store has a huge selection of products, including home items like curtains and bed linen.

3

UNIQUE charges prices based on the colors of the labels of the clothes.

11
5ive Steak image 1
5ive Steak image 2
5ive Steak image 3
View all

Modern steak house offers a calming atmosphere with comfortable seating away from airport crowds. Prices are high but include complimentary water to offset drink costs. Screens show muted sports games, adding to a relaxed vibe.

People are saying

"The food was great and the service was spot on."

"The chicken BLT tasted good but felt pricey."

Good to know

1

The prices at the terminal restaurant are maximum airport prices.

2

The terminal offers sit-down dining options including pulled pork sliders and chicken BLT.

3

The restaurant fills up slowly with the lunch crowd.

12
Stop & Shop image 1
Stop & Shop image 2
Stop & Shop image 3
View all

Spacious layout and newly renovated aisles make shopping easy. Prices are high, especially for Boars Head deli items. Fresh produce and quality meats stand out, with some rare finds not available nearby.

People are saying

"I like that the store is clean, well stocked, and offers good deals."

"The deli and other items feel really expensive."

"I find this place pretty expensive overall."

Good to know

1

Checkout processes are fast and efficient, including self checkout for express shoppers.

2

Customers often wait close to an hour to check out their items on weekends.

3

Parking can be challenging, especially during peak hours.

13
Tizarah & Co image 1
Tizarah & Co image 2
Tizarah & Co image 3
View all

Flower shop offers fresh bouquets with unique decorations in a welcoming space. Prices are on the expensive side but remain reasonable with delivery and tips. Local customers enjoy affordable quality and timely service.

People are saying

"I felt supported and confident throughout planning."

"They made my wedding decor feel truly special."

Good to know

1

Consultations are available by appointment only, so book ahead.

2

A deposit is required to secure your event date.

3

Final payment is due two weeks before the event.

Discover more

Jamaica, New York

Area guide