Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Top picks in Lenox Hill

Pie shops

A slice of pie that holds its shape and flavor without being an overly sweet, mass-produced mess.

Based on 493 Opinions
+490
User
User
User
Updated
01
YORK AVE PIZZA image 1
YORK AVE PIZZA image 2
YORK AVE PIZZA image 3
View all

Small dining area with exposed brick walls offers a quiet, friendly vibe. Outdoor seating adds a relaxed touch. Pizzas shine with crispy grandma crusts and unique toppings like mushrooms and black olives, making each bite a flavorful experience.

People are saying

"This place is my go-to for great pizza."

"The pizza and other dishes always hit the spot."

"Billyโ€™s passion makes the pizza experience special."

Good to know

1

Expect a wait time of 20-30 minutes during busy lunch hours.

2

The restaurant offers a lunch special of 2 slices and a drink for $10.

3

Parking is limited; consider using public transport or rideshare.

02
Two Boots Pizza Upper East Side image 1
Two Boots Pizza Upper East Side image 2
Two Boots Pizza Upper East Side image 3
View all

New Orleans-inspired spot offers creative pies like Meat The Mets and spicy Klaatu. Vibrant, eclectic decor creates a lively atmosphere with colorful art. Small seating makes it an intimate oasis in the city, plus vegan and gluten-free options add variety.

Creative pies stand out with options like the Meat The Mets Pie and the spicy Home Pie, the Klaatu. Slices come fresh and offer a unique and tasty twist on classic pizza.

People are saying

"I love their tasty, fresh, and vegan-friendly pizza."

"The place has a fun vibe and great pizza."

Good to know

1

The last order time changes daily, with recent times being 8:15 PM and 8:30 PM.

2

The establishment closes early at 9 PM.

3

Take out is the only option from this point on.

03
La Pizza Italia ๐Ÿ‡ฎ๐Ÿ‡น image 1
La Pizza Italia ๐Ÿ‡ฎ๐Ÿ‡น image 2
La Pizza Italia ๐Ÿ‡ฎ๐Ÿ‡น image 3
View all

Bright, clean space with gorgeous decorations creates a cozy vibe. Loud music keeps it lively, fitting for casual dining. Specialty pies shine with great variety and well-made crusts, showing quality ingredients and solid prep.

People are saying

"The pizza here is fresh, tasty, and satisfying."

"The place feels cozy and the atmosphere is inviting."

Good to know

1

The pizzeria offers a buy one get one free deal on the pasta special.

2

The restaurant is affordable.

3

The new pizza shop has good prices.

04
Jones Wood Foundry image 1
Jones Wood Foundry image 2
Jones Wood Foundry image 3
View all

Pub-style spot boasts a lively bar and cozy indoor patio with a temperature-controlled garden. Pies shine with meat-forward fillings like lamb and curried pork. Authentic British vibe pairs well with a rich cask ale selection for a true taste experience.

Hearty pies feature meat-forward fillings like ground lamb and braised curried pork with sweet potato. Shepherd's pie comes with a golden mashed potato crust and root vegetables, offering simple, authentic flavors.

People are saying

"The shepherd's pie is hearty and delicious."

"The chicken and leek pie's crust was outstanding."

"I always save room for the banoffee pie."

Good to know

1

Make sure to have reservations before visiting.

2

Roast chicken is only available at dinner on the weekend, which is not clarified on the website.

3

The restaurant only serves beer and wine due to its proximity to a school.

05
JG Melon image 1
JG Melon image 2
JG Melon image 3
View all

Small bar and grill buzzes with a lively crowd and cold beer. Outdoor seating is dog friendly, perfect for relaxed vibes. Key lime pie is a standout dessert, with apple and pecan pies offering rich flavors.

Key lime pie stands out as exceptional and delicious, often served with care. Apple pie with nuts and pecan pie also offer strong, memorable flavors.

People are saying

"The key lime pie here is a must-try."

"I love their key lime and apple pies."

"The burgers and pies make a great combo."

Good to know

1

The restaurant only accepts cash payments; bring cash or hit the ATM before arriving.

2

Expect a 45 minute to 1 hour wait on Tuesday evenings around 8pm.

3

Come early or during off-peak hours for the best tables with little to no wait.

06
Finnegan's Wake image 1
Finnegan's Wake image 2
Finnegan's Wake image 3
View all

Traditional Irish decor sets an authentic atmosphere while friendly staff serve perfectly poured Guinness. Apple pie ร  la mode offers a delicious flavor, though shepherd's pie quality varies. Multiple monitors show games, making it a local gathering spot.

Apple pie ร  la mode stands out with its delicious flavor. Shepherd's pie varies, sometimes fresh with great taste, other times bland with frozen peas and plain mashed potatoes.

People are saying

"I love how laid back and welcoming this pub feels."

"Some found the shepherd's pie tasty, others thought it bland and basic."

"The steak and kidney pie didn't feel like a real pie."

Good to know

1

Happy hour runs from 4-6pm on weekdays with discounted drinks.

2

The cost is $26 for a meal of 4 short ribs or 4 slices of corned beef.

3

The prices are reasonable for the area, making it a good value.

07
Pizza Napoli image 1
Pizza Napoli image 2
Pizza Napoli image 3
View all

Small pizza spot offers affordable prices and a cozy dining experience with limited seating. Known for wide pie variety, including the popular grandma slice and fresh 18-inch Rainbow pie. Clean, well-decorated space adds to the peaceful vibe.

People are saying

"The pizza is always fresh, crispy, and delicious."

"The place is clean and the prices are fair for great food."

Good to know

1

An 18โ€ Rainbow pie costs $24.

2

Pizza Napoli is open late.

3

The restaurant uses quality ingredients.

08
Frico on 2nd image 1
Frico on 2nd image 2
Frico on 2nd image 3
View all

Tiny space with award-adorned walls offers Detroit-style pizza with crispy cheese edges and airy crusts. Whole pies like the honey cup show uneven cooking, mixing soggy and crunchy parts. Prices are higher but match the innovative toppings and quality.

People are saying

"The Detroit-style pizza here is insanely good and unique."

"I love that they have tasty gluten-free pizzas baked separately."

Good to know

1

Weekly special slices are available, adding variety to the menu.

2

Slices cost $6.50 plus tax and tip, which is on the higher side.

3

Whole pies generally cost in the mid-$20s and up.

09
Uncle Vinny's Pizza image 1
Uncle Vinny's Pizza image 2
Uncle Vinny's Pizza image 3
View all

Small space with only two tables creates an intimate setting. Loud Albanian music and friendly greetings build a lively, community feel. Pizza shines with crispy thin crust and grandma pie's unique crust, making it a standout for pie lovers.

People are saying

"The pizza tasted great but felt pricey."

"The pizza was fresh and really delicious."

"I definitely recommend trying their pizza."

Good to know

1

A regular slice of pizza costs $3.75 here.

2

They occasionally hand out free slices later at night for customers to try new flavors.

3

The restaurant is open late on weekends, usually until 4am.

Discover more

Lenox Hill, New York

Area guide