Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Local picks in Lincoln Square

Cake spots

A slice of cake that feels like a genuine treat instead of a mass-produced sugar rush.

Based on 567 Opinions
+564
User
User
User
Updated April 2026
01
Patisserie Chanson image 1
Patisserie Chanson image 2
Patisserie Chanson image 3
View all

Small bakery offers a calming atmosphere with quiet seating and good music. Cakes like Bunny Cheesecake and Napoleon cake impress with hotel-level quality and beautiful presentation. Pastries are beautifully made and delicious, perfect for slow enjoyment.

Cakes here have a hotel-level quality with beautiful presentation. Varieties like Bunny Cheesecake, Sesame Muse Cake, and olive oil chocolate cake stand out, along with a Napoleon cake that is crispy with less sweet cream. Some cakes and eclairs feature a golden crunchy ball topping.

People are saying

"I found the pastries here to be beautiful and delicious."

"I loved their Napoleon cake and pistachio madeleine; the French food is amazing."

"The cakes here are delicious and beautifully made."

Good to know

1

Sandwiches are 50% off after 3 PM.

2

They run daily promotions, including a Tuesday promotion for coffee and bakery items.

3

Expect upcharges for every item, including milk of any sort, even in a latte.

02
Muffins Cafe image 1

Small cafe offers a cozy interior and outside seating with jazz music setting a relaxed mood. Lemon Cake shines with its bright, fresh flavor, while staff create a welcoming vibe that invites quiet moments and friendly chats.

Lemon Cake stands out with its bright, fresh flavor. Orange and chocolate cakes also appear regularly, offering delicious options alongside seasonal pumpkin cakes.

People are saying

"The pastries and lattes at this cafe are delicious."

"The staff here really make it feel like home, remembering names and all remembered my name."

"I loved the lemon cake, especially the icing."

Good to know

1

Denying service dogs access is illegal under the ADA and New York law.

2

Businesses must allow service animals in all areas accessible to customers.

3

The price for a cup of iced coffee with oat milk is $7.

03
Old John's Luncheonette image 1

Old school diner offers a quintessential New York experience with outdoor booths featuring built-in air conditioning and heating. Big servings of chocolate cake and house-made ice cream delight dessert lovers. Amazing cocktails add to the cozy yet lively vibe.

Big servings of chocolate cake stand out as a popular dessert choice. Carrot cake and banana pudding also appear frequently, with ice cream and cake made inhouse.

People are saying

"This diner's food tastes amazing, especially the pancakes."

"Evelyn was super nice and took good care of us at breakfast."

"The chocolate cake here is massive and perfect for dessert."

Good to know

1

Make reservations to avoid a wait time.

2

Customers should be prepared to wait on weekends or make a reservation.

3

The kitchen closes at 10 PM.

04
Rampoldi New York image 1

Elegant restaurant shines with Monagesque decor and red lighting creating a lively vibe. Lemon meringue cake bursts with bright citrus flavors and perfectly torched meringue. Guests savor exquisite cocktails in a chic, welcoming space.

Bright citrus flavors and perfectly torched meringue highlight the lemon meringue cake. Rich chocolate cake pairs well with ice cream, and tiramisu also stands out.

People are saying

"The food here is delicious and thoughtfully prepared."

"It's a classy place with an elegant and inviting atmosphere."

"The chocolate cake with ice cream was delicious."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for the pre-theater menu.

2

The dinner service starts at 6 PM for an 8 PM concert.

3

Dress code is formal attire; casual wear is not acceptable.

05
El Fish Marisqueria image 1
Mexican restaurant

Minimalist decor with abundant plants and elegant modern design creates a cozy, warm atmosphere with perfect lighting. Tables are spaced for comfortable conversation, supporting a sensual vibe that enhances the dining experience. The space balances upscale energy with a relaxed, inviting feel.

People are saying

"The grilled oysters and artichoke cod were my favorite seafood dishes."

"The dinner spots here have outstanding dishes, especially the tostada."

"The grilled octopus was so soft and flavorful."

Good to know

1

Make a reservation if you can since the restaurant is usually full.

2

Brunch is available at this restaurant.

3

Happy hour at the bar is definitely a vibe.

06
Harry's Table by Cipriani image 1
Italian restaurant

Large space blends cafรฉ, market, bar, and restaurant with Italian-style pasta shop and family-friendly vibe. Vanilla Meringue cake is light and fluffy, perfect for dessert lovers. Outdoor play area and mini park add lively yet peaceful charm for kids and pets.

Vanilla Meringue cake stands out for being light and fluffy with a delicious taste. Chocolate options include a mousse cake that is rich and beautifully presented.

People are saying

"I loved the authentic Italian food, especially the pasta."

"The Caesar salad here is huge and delicious."

"I loved their Vanilla Meringue cake; it was light and fluffy."

Good to know

1

Expect to pay around $20 for a single dish without sides.

2

The restaurant is not kid-friendly and lacks accessibility options.

3

Harry's Table is located next to Waterline Park, a nice spot for a walk.

07
maman image 1
Coffee shop

Space blends French countryside charm with a stylish New York vibe, featuring floral decor and indoor plants. Cakes offer a moist, dense texture with crunchy, sour icing that balances sweetness. Outdoor terrace provides sunlit comfort, perfect for warm days.

Cakes here have a moist, dense texture that feels light at the same time. Icing often adds a crunchy, sour contrast that pairs well with the cake's sweetness.

People are saying

"The coffee here is amazing, especially the honey lavender latte."

"This cafe's pastries are buttery, flaky, and taste like actual butter layers."

"The cake here is moist and flavorful."

Good to know

1

Maman is a laptop-free environment, so leave your laptop at home.

2

Expect over an hour wait for a salad during busy times.

3

The kitchen closes at 4pm, so no savory items are available after that.

08
Breads Bakery - Upper West Side image 1

Modern bakery offers fresh bread aroma and cozy outdoor seating with heaters and plugs. Gluten-free coconut chocolate chip cake stands out with a special taste, while lemon cake is dry and crumbly. Friendly service adds to the coffee shop vibe.

Loaf cakes come in banana, lemon, and coconut chocolate chip flavors. The gluten-free coconut chocolate chip cake has a special taste and is delicious. The lemon cake tends to be dry and crumbly with a weak lemon flavor.

People are saying

"The bakery's almond croissants are buttery, flaky, and so delicious."

"The babka here is an extraordinary experience."

"I found the cakes here to be the best I had ever tasted."

Good to know

1

The bakery doesn't have seating options inside and has few tables outside.

2

If you go at the last hour, the cheesecakes are $5.

3

The price for two cups of tea is $10 plus tax.

09
Tatiana by Kwame Onwuachi image 1
Caribbean restaurant

Stunning venue with tall glass windows and intimate lighting creates a romantic yet lively vibe. Guests enjoy an R&B playlist that energizes the space and encourages dancing. The Golden Rum Cake offers rich flavor and moist texture, making desserts a highlight.

Golden Rum Cake stands out with rich flavor and moist texture. The Bodega Special also offers a unique twist on classic cake desserts.

People are saying

"The Fine Dining here is bold, thoughtful, and reverent, with dishes telling unique stories."

"The oxtail was tender and fell off the bone."

"The rum cake was exceptionally delicious."

Good to know

1

Reservations are in high demand, so try to schedule months in advance.

2

If you do not make a reservation, expect a wait time.

3

If you arrive at 5 PM, expect a three-hour waitlist.

10
Rosa Mexicano image 1
Mexican restaurant

Mexican restaurant shines with table-side guacamole and signature margaritas in a vibrant setting. Tres leches cake offers a rich, moist texture with a creamy chocolate twist. Spacious, dog-friendly outdoor seating provides city views and a calm atmosphere later in the day.

The tres leches cake stands out with its rich, moist texture. The chocolate tres leches version adds a creamy, sweet twist that many enjoy.

People are saying

"I loved the tableside-prepared guacamole, made fresh right in front of me."

"The drinks here are amazing, especially the mango guava margarita."

"The tres leches cake here is delicious and amazing."

Good to know

1

Happy hour runs from 4-7 pm, Monday through Friday, with creative drink options.

2

Taco Tuesday offers great deals on tacos.

3

Wine Wednesday features $5 glasses of sangria.

Discover more

Lincoln Square, New York

Area guide
Loading Map...