Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Best of Lincoln Square

Pizza spots

Made for those who treat a slice of pizza as a serious culinary pursuit rather than a quick snack.

Based on 592 Opinions
+589
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Two Boots Pizza Upper West Side image 1
Two Boots Pizza Upper West Side image 2
Two Boots Pizza Upper West Side image 3
View all

Funky pizza joint offers creative toppings with both dairy and vegan cheese. Colorful decor and a retro vibe create a friendly atmosphere. Small, cozy space includes outdoor seating for a relaxed experience.

Slices show creative toppings and push the envelope of what pizza can be. Both dairy and vegan cheese options deliver great flavor with fresh basil and tomatoes.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza was super delicious and tasty."

"Their inventive Italian food, especially the pizzas, has a great spicy kick."

"I found the place to be small and cozy."

Good to know

1

The restaurant is open until midnight on Friday and Saturday.

2

Each slice is around $5, making it budget friendly.

3

A large pizza can feed up to 4 people.

02
Emmy Squared Pizza: Midtown West image 1

Dark minimalist interior creates a laid-back atmosphere with bar seats and large TVs showing sports. Detroit-style pizza offers crispy edges and balanced sauce-to-cheese, with popular options like MVP and Big Al on gluten-free crust. Seating supports both casual gatherings and relaxed dining.

Detroit-style pizza features crispy edges and a balanced sauce-to-cheese ratio. Options include the MVP and Big Al on gluten-free crust, both highly praised for flavor and texture.

People are saying

"I thought the Detroit style pizza was top notch."

"The outdoor seating is really charming and great."

"The Date Spots here are so fun thanks to Kelly's wicked sense of humor."

Good to know

1

Expect a 20-25 minute wait for pizza during peak hours.

2

Reservations are not required, and seating is usually available.

3

The restaurant does not sell pizza by the slice.

03
La Traviata Pizzeria image 1
Pizza restaurant

Small pizzeria offers classic New York-style pizza with fresh, flavorful slices like Margherita and Pepperoni. Cozy indoor and covered outdoor seating create a warm, welcoming atmosphere. Perfect for those who enjoy old school charm and quality pizza.

Slices stand out for their delicious and fresh taste with excellent consistency. Options like Margherita and Pepperoni pizzas deliver great flavor and quality.

People are saying

"I found La Traviata Pizzeria served the best pizza in New York."

"You can sit outside, but the outdoor seating is limited."

"The Italian food's calzones are outstanding, filled with fresh cheese."

Good to know

1

A plain slice and canned soda cost under $5, which is pretty good for lunch.

2

The restaurant is a perfect spot to go before a movie.

3

Delivery from this restaurant is always fast.

04
Atlantic Grill image 1
Seafood restaurant

Elegant space with warm lighting and beautiful booths offers a cozy vibe. Shrimp pizza shines with a crisp crust and fresh toppings, while pepperoni is tasty but can be soggy. Creative cocktails and impeccable service complete the memorable meal.

Shrimp pizza offers a crisp, delicious crust with fresh toppings. Pepperoni pizza tastes very good but some pizzas have a soggy middle.

People are saying

"The food here is delicious and presented so nicely."

"The service at these dinner spots is so friendly and attentive."

"The pizza here has a crisp, delicious crust."

Good to know

1

The total cost for three people for four dishes and no alcohol was $200.

2

The restaurant is suitable for a pre-theater dinner.

3

Arrangements are made for convenience to the 8pm show at The Met.

05
Pizza Collective image 1
Pizza restaurant

Small, cozy spot with a pink design and live DJ outside sets a cool vibe. Roman-style square pizza has a unique focaccia-like crust with fresh vegan and veggie toppings. Outdoor seating and modern decor make it a comfortable hangout for all pizza lovers.

Square pizza offers a Roman style with a crust like a cross between focaccia and regular pizza. Vegan and veggie options feature fresh toppings and stand out as some of the best available.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was just great."

"I loved the delicious vegan pizza options here."

"I loved the unique pizza selections with creative topping combinations."

Good to know

1

Happy hour deal is $12 from Monday to Friday.

2

The carbonara pasta is available from 12 p.m. to 4 p.m.

3

Buying any 2 slices allows you to get 1 cheese slice for $1.

06
Francesco's Pizza image 1
Pizza restaurant

Roomy pizza spot shines with huge New York slices and a cozy atmosphere filled with signed celebrity photos. Affordable prices and quick service keep the crowd happy. Dim lighting and sports on TV create a friendly vibe perfect for casual dining.

Huge, New York-style slices come with a crisp bottom crust. Pizza offers affordable prices and quick, efficient service. The pizza is consistently delicious and satisfying.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was top tier."

"The food here is fresh and delicious."

"I returned for the pasta; it was awesome."

Good to know

1

The pizza place has a $10 minimum for card payments.

2

They do not take contactless credit cards, including Google/Apple Pay.

3

The pizza place only accepts cash.

07
Harry's Table by Cipriani image 1
Italian restaurant

Large space blends cafรฉ, market, bar, and restaurant with Italian-style pasta shop and family-friendly vibe. Wood-fired pizzas shine with rich flavors and crisp crust, especially the Tartufo Nero pizza. Outdoor play area and mini park add to the lively yet peaceful atmosphere.

Wood-fired pizzas stand out with rich flavors and a crisp crust. The Tartufo Nero pizza offers a unique, earthy taste that pairs well with other Italian dishes like pastas and paninis.

People are saying

"I loved the authentic Italian food, especially the pasta."

"The Caesar salad here is huge and delicious."

"I found the wood-fired pizza here to be delicious."

Good to know

1

Expect to pay around $20 for a single dish without sides.

2

The restaurant is not kid-friendly and lacks accessibility options.

3

Harry's Table is located next to Waterline Park, a nice spot for a walk.

08
Cafe Fiorello image 1
Italian restaurant

Italian spot shines with thin crust pizzas from Milan and Florence, boasting perfect crust and rich sauce. Cozy heated outdoor seating adds charm despite tight space. Bar serves expertly crafted cocktails and fresh baked cookies, all amid a loud, lively atmosphere that sparks conversation.

Thin crust pizzas inspired by Milan and Florence stand out with perfect crust and quality ingredients. The sauce complements the crust well, making the pizza a solid choice.

People are saying

"I loved the amazing Italian food, especially the pasta."

"The antipasto bar here is well-stocked with delicious temptations."

"I thought the thin crust pizza was the best I had."

Good to know

1

Reservations are essential due to the restaurant's popularity.

2

They allow dogs in the outdoor seating area when it's not crowded.

3

Brunch and an all-day Italian menu are available on weekends.

09
Peperino West Side image 1
Pizza restaurant

Small pizza shop offers tasty and inexpensive pizza with classic toppings like pepperoni and mushroom. Family-friendly vibe shines through large community table and outdoor seating by the park. Lively energy comes from sports games on display, making it welcoming and fun.

Tasty and inexpensive pizza stands out here, with options like cheese, pepperoni, and mushroom that appeal to all ages. The place offers a real New York pizza experience that beats many other late-night spots.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was great and inexpensive."

"I thought the food here was great and delicious."

"You can enjoy outdoor seating next to a small park area."

Good to know

1

The restaurant is dog friendly.

2

The restaurant delivers through a third party.

3

The store has indoor and outdoor seating.

10
Little Italy Pizza image 1
Pizza restaurant

Cramped space with small tables creates a casual vibe. Young crowd enjoys New York style pizza, especially the margherita. Prices stay unbeatable, making it a lively spot for late-night bites.

Slices come plain and classic with a New York style that is consistently delicious and satisfying. The margherita pizza stands out as a must-have option with unbeatable prices.

People are saying

"I found their pepperoni pizza to be really good."

"The food here is served by genuinely good humans who treat everyone with warmth."

"It's a comfortable outdoor space with a few tables."

Good to know

1

The pizza spot is open 24 hours for late-night cravings.

2

You can get 2 large slices and a fountain drink for $6.95.

3

Expect delivery times within 20 minutes in the area.

11
Rosetta Bakery image 1

Bright space with modern decor and both indoor and outdoor seating creates a lively vibe. Freshly made pizzas boast perfect red sauce and house-made breads. Comfortable seats offer midtown views while loud pop music fills the air.

Freshly made pizzas feature perfect red sauce and the right amount of cheese. Breads and pizzas are made in house, offering a large selection alongside pastries and desserts.

People are saying

"The pastries here are beautiful and tasty."

"I loved the fresh and delicious prosciutto sandwich."

"The pizza here is so fresh and delicious."

Good to know

1

Grab pastries to-go and enjoy them at a nearby park.

2

Prices are high, with a cup of tiramisu costing $10.

3

Expect to pay $9 for a sandwich that is only half filled.

Discover more

Lincoln Square, New York

Area guide
Loading Map...