Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Loved by locals

Pizza and Italian food in Mid Island

A slice that tastes like a neighborhood tradition rather than a generic fast-food order.

Based on 665 Opinions
+662
User
User
User
Updated June 2026
01
Ungaro Coal Fired Pizza Cafe image 1
Ungaro Coal Fired Pizza Cafe image 2
Ungaro Coal Fired Pizza Cafe image 3
View all

Small rustic spot offers coal fired pizza with fresh, delicious taste and a cozy, family vibe. Italian dishes like risotto balls and fried raviolis shine alongside a notable white sangria. Warm hospitality and simple decor create an authentic, welcoming experience.

Risotto balls stand out as a highlight. Fried raviolis come highly recommended. Crustini with burrata, fig, and honey adds a unique touch. Pasta dishes and tiramisu also impress.

Coal fired pizza stands out with its fresh and delicious taste. The pizza combines warm hospitality and a welcoming atmosphere that complements the food.

People are saying

"I thought the square pizza was the best."

"The food here is fresh and delicious."

"The Italian food here, especially the pasta and pizza, is delicious."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for dinner, especially after 5 PM.

2

Ungaro offers heart-shaped pizza on Valentine's Day.

3

The restaurant serves dine-in, pick up, and delivery options.

02
A & S Pizza image 1
Pizza restaurant

Spacious spot serves rustic crust pizza with perfectly chopped toppings and offers classic Italian dishes like creamy ravioli and chicken Alfredo. Quiet, grungy vibe attracts locals and ferry riders seeking a peaceful meal. Friendly, unpretentious setting makes it a great choice for relaxed dining.

Menu includes BBQ chicken pizza, spinach with chicken Alfredo, and ravioli covered in creamy cheese. Pizzas range from white with crispy chicken to classic cheese, alongside pastas and sandwiches.

Pizza here has a rustic crust that is thicker than regular but lighter and crunchier than Sicilian style. Toppings like onions and sausage come chopped nicely and cooked to perfection, with options to split a pie into two different toppings.

People are saying

"The pizza here is classic, tasty, and satisfying."

"I enjoyed the generous pasta here."

"The Italian food, especially the pizza, is fantastic."

Good to know

1

Parking in this neighborhood is very difficult.

2

The pizzeria is more takeout oriented, but dining in is still an option.

3

The cost for 4 large slices and 2 drinks is $18.

03
Osteria Santina image 1
Italian restaurant

Large space buzzes with lively atmosphere and music. Italian dishes like penne vodka shine alongside fresh, Sicilian-style pizzas from the outdoor oven. Valet parking makes visits easy for families and parties.

Penne vodka and veal santina stand out as flavorful dishes. Eggplant parm and steak also get strong praise. The food pairs well with exceptional service that enhances the dining experience.

Personal-sized pizzas come out fresh and delicious. The pizza station offers a variety of options that stay consistently on point with Sicilian flavors.

People are saying

"The Italian food here is phenomenal, especially the lobster ravioli."

"The homemade pasta here is a 10 for a date spot."

"I thought the pizza here was excellent."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for weekends to avoid long wait times.

2

Valet parking is available, but the lot is small and can be crowded.

3

Expect a 30-45 minute wait for a table during peak hours.

04
Verde's Pizza & Pasta House image 1

Small pizza spot with perfect crust and generous toppings offers a nostalgic vibe and family warmth. Chicken parmesan with fresh mozzarella shines alongside rich vodka penne sauce. Friendly hospitality and lively sports chats make it feel like home.

Chicken parmesan with fresh mozzarella stands out, paired with spaghetti and sauce that impresses. The meat lovers pie and vodka penne sauce deliver rich, satisfying flavors, while the crust stays crisp with perfectly melted cheese.

Slices come with incredible flavor and a perfect crust. The pizza often arrives with generous toppings and a fresh, satisfying taste.

People are saying

"I found the pizza here to be great and delicious."

"The delivery drivers here are such good, friendly people."

"I thought their Italian food, especially the pizza, was great."

Good to know

1

The restaurant has limited seating, so arrive early to secure a table.

2

Reservations are not accepted; seating is first-come, first-served.

3

Credit cards and mobile payments are accepted; cash is also welcome.

05
Kills Boro Brewing Company image 1

High ceilings and exposed brick create a dark, masculine atmosphere that feels youthful and comfortable. Homemade pastas like mafaldine and fresh seafood dishes shine alongside a Hot Pepperoni Square pie. Endless craft beers perfectly complement the Italian flavors.

Homemade pastas like mafaldine, rigatoni, and linguini stand out with fresh, creative flavors. Dishes such as linguini with pesto and clams, calamari, and branzino show a focus on fresh seafood and flavorful Italian classics.

Hot Pepperoni Square pie stands out with a strong Italian vibe. The pizza pairs naturally with craft beer and artisanal cocktails for a solid combo.

People are saying

"The beer here is crisp, clean, and served perfectly."

"The pizza at this brewery is outstanding, especially the square pies."

"I thought the pizza was amazing and delicious."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended by 6 PM as tables fill up quickly.

2

Street parking is available, but can be challenging during peak hours.

3

The dinner menu starts at 5 PM; earlier arrivals can only order pizza.

06
Di Farina Pizzeria image 1
Pizza restaurant

Super clean space with a vibrant mural sets a modern vibe. Thin, crunchy crust defines the pizza, including gluten-free options that stay fresh and hot. Italian dishes shine with buffalo mozzarella pie and chicken Parmesan, all served in large portions perfect for takeout or quick dine-in.

Square slices come with three sauces: marinara, vodka, and pesto. The grandma pizza and chicken stromboli with marinara stand out, along with a buffalo mozzarella pie and chicken Parmesan noted for its quality.

Thin, crunchy crust defines the pizza here, with both slices and Sicilian styles tasting equally good. Gluten-free options come fresh and hot, causing no reactions, and prices stay reasonable.

People are saying

"This pizza is by far the best I've had."

"I found the Chicken Parmigiana to have amazing flavor and great portions."

"The Italian food here has a delicious, thin crust pizza."

Good to know

1

Order a whole pie for the freshest slices.

2

The restaurant only makes chicken rolls fresh and it takes about 12 minutes to prepare them.

3

Di Farina gives big portions; a single pizza will not feed more than two people.

07
Crispy Pizza image 1
Pizza restaurant

Small space with limited seating and no air conditioning creates a warm, cozy atmosphere with an old school pizzeria vibe. The interior is modern and clean, offering a welcoming environment despite the heat. The place draws people looking for crispy, well-regarded pizza in a casual setting.

Dinner plates like Lasagna, Spaghetti Bolognese, and Chicken Francese stand out. Pizza features a succulent blend of mozzarella and tomato sauce, while pastas like penne vodka and spaghetti with meatballs have balanced sauces without sourness.

Consistently great pizza with a thick crust and a variety of toppings, including a notably delicious chicken option. Friendly staff support a solid pizza experience beyond just the pies.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was the best I had ever tasted."

"I found the delivery food to be the best on the island."

"The Italian food here, especially the pizza and pasta, is delicious."

Good to know

1

Crispy Pizza is open every day at 10:00 am and on Sunday at 11:00 am, closing at 10:00 pm.

2

There is on-street parking available.

3

The restaurant does not accept Apple Pay or tap and go.

08
Basil Cucina & Catering image 1
Italian restaurant

Italian restaurant offers fresh pizza, rich chicken noodle soup, and customizable dishes made on request. Atmosphere varies with some inconsistencies in food quality and delivery service. Known for high prices and a catering menu with unique policies.

Lasagne stands out as delicious. Wings and mozzarella rice balls also get attention. Pasta dishes like the Louisiana Cajun chicken pasta come as a thick pasta soup, which some find disappointing.

Pizza features a thin crust with a well-seasoned sauce. It tastes fresh and is consistently described as very good.

People are saying

"I found the food here to be packed with flavor and delicious."

"I thought the pizza here was very good."

"The Italian food here is terrific and delivered just right."

Good to know

1

Delivery can take over two hours for large orders.

2

Expect a $10 delivery fee on all orders.

3

Portions are large, especially for salads and lunch specials.

09
Mama Rosaria's Pizza & Restaurant image 1

Pizza restaurant offers huge menu with many entrees and goodies and serves cheesy pizza with large slices. Atmosphere suits comfortable meetings and supports delivery, take-out, and dine-in options. Pricing stays affordable and the overall experience feels fantastic.

Pasta dishes come with a variety of options and generally decent quality. The Grandma pie features a thin rectangular crust topped with fresh basil, mozzarella, and pizza sauce.

Pizza comes with gooey cheese and large slices served fresh and piping hot. Options include both square and regular slices, with a notable Caesar salad pizza available.

People are saying

"I found the pizza here to be amazing and delicious."

"The food here is always good and freshly made."

"The Italian food, especially the pizza, was amazing."

Good to know

1

Delivery, take-out, or dine-in options are available.

2

The restaurant has a wide variety of choices including pasta and pizza.

3

Ordering food to go is an option.

10
DiLeo's Pizzeria image 1
Pizza restaurant

Pizza restaurant offers house-made zeppoli and serves dishes on real dishware with beautiful plating. Atmosphere feels friendly and family-oriented despite some cleanliness issues. Multiple big screens show Spanish TV, adding to a casual, lively vibe.

Nutella zeppoles and cannolis stand out among desserts. The menu includes classic dishes like chicken parm, penne vodka, sausage and peppers, eggplant rollatini, and calamari, alongside pizza and pasta options.

Pizza features an authentic New York style with a variety of toppings. The vodka sauce and BBQ chicken pizzas stand out for their balanced flavors and careful preparation.

People are saying

"I found the pizza here to be really fresh and delicious."

"The Chicken Parmigiana here is delicious."

"I found their Italian food, from pizza to pasta, to be delicious."

Good to know

1

The lunch special is $7.50 and includes a huge range of dishes with a drink, even on weekends.

2

Delivery takes at least 60 minutes, so plan accordingly.

3

A free can of soda is included with the lunches.

Discover more

Mid Island, New York

Area guide
Loading Map...