Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Top picks in Midtown East

Lobster cheesecake spots

A slice of dense cheesecake is the only way to properly finish a meal centered around lobster.

Based on 727 Opinions
+724
User
User
User
Updated June 2026
01
P.J. Clarke's Third Avenue image 1
P.J. Clarke's Third Avenue image 2
P.J. Clarke's Third Avenue image 3
View all
American restaurant

Historic pub with 19th-century interiors and a 150-year-old bar creates an authentic old New York vibe. Atmosphere shifts from quiet dining to lively, crowded bar with classic jukebox tunes and live music. Walls display photos of legendary bartenders, adding to the timeless local charm.

Lobster rolls come huge and rich, often paired with burgers or fish and chips. The lobster cob stands out as fantastic, and adding lobster to baked macaroni and cheese works very well.

Classic New York style cheesecake offers a light, creamy texture with large slices suitable for sharing. The PJs Cheesecake stands out for its great size and price.

People are saying

"I thought the burgers here were fantastic and great."

"The lobster roll here is amazing and a generous portion."

"You have to try their cheesecake; the slices are huge!"

Good to know

1

Reservations are advisable, especially for dinner service.

2

Expect a 20-40 minute wait during peak hours.

3

The bar area operates on a first-come, first-served basis.

02
Morton's The Steakhouse image 1

Upscale restaurant with art deco style and an intimate, romantic atmosphere featuring mellow jazz music and live performances. Spacious bar area offers a wide selection of cocktails and wines. Decor blends modern and vintage elements, creating a stylish and luxurious setting.

Rich lobster bisque stands out as a highlight. The lobster mac and cheese combines creamy texture with a Cajun twist. Lobster tail pairs well with tender steaks like filet mignon.

Cheesecake comes with lemon sauce or lemon curd and often features strawberries on top. Individual-sized portions appear for special occasions. It tastes decadent and pairs well as a dessert.

People are saying

"The Steakhouse staff's hospitality and attention made my dining experience outstanding."

"I highly recommend the awesome cheesecake; it was decadent."

"I've never had a lobster bisque this good."

Good to know

1

The restaurant offers a three-course meal for $60 per person during restaurant week.

2

Restaurant week features a prix fixe menu with various options.

3

Happy hour runs from 4-7pm on weekdays with discounted drinks.

03
Benny John's Bar and Grill image 1

Live guitar and jazz music create a relaxed, European cafe vibe with comfortable seating both indoors and on a pleasant outdoor patio. The atmosphere suits both solo diners and groups, offering an upscale yet cozy setting with excellent energy throughout.

Lobster bisque stands out as rich and flavorful. In-house made lobster ravioli and lobster risotto offer solid options featuring lobster.

Cheesecake stands out as a favorite dessert here, often described as excellent and among the best ever tasted. It pairs well with cocktails and is served with notable hospitality.

People are saying

"I've never had a steak cooked so perfectly to my preference."

"The lobster risotto was absolutely delicious."

"I enjoyed the cheesecake; it was to die for."

Good to know

1

The restaurant has an all-day happy hour with a variety of appetizers.

2

Happy hour drink specials are available all night at the bar.

3

Reservations are recommended due to high demand during peak times.

04
Sparks Steak House image 1

Classic steakhouse with old school decor and a rich history creates an elegant dining space filled with a friendly, jovial atmosphere. The place hosts a lively crowd enjoying traditional steaks and an exceptional wine list. Private rooms and personalized touches add to its distinctive charm.

Lobsters come in huge sizes, sometimes over 5 pounds, with an amazing taste. The menu offers a large selection including lobster paired with shrimp, crab meat, and oysters.

Cheesecake stands out with its delicious flavor and often comes as a complimentary birthday treat. It pairs well with other desserts like chocolate mousse and yogurt cake.

People are saying

"This steakhouse has an amazing old-school NYC vibe."

"You have to try the desserts; they're an experience."

"The cheesecake was delicious, especially with fresh fruits."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended, especially for special events like birthdays.

2

The restaurant offers a pre-fixe dinner option for events.

3

Expect to spend around $600 for a dinner for two.

05
Jabä image 1
Taiwanese restaurant

Modern, elegant space blends minimalist design with earthy tones and handmade pottery. Atmosphere balances cozy, lively energy with a warm, family-friendly vibe. Seating offers comfortable spacing, making it suitable for groups or intimate dinners.

Three cup lobster stands out with rich, savory flavors. Lobster dishes come with sides like soft boiled egg and pair well with other bold items like basil garlic razor clams.

Milk tea cheesecake and ham hock stand out as must-try items. Boba cheesecake features chewy bobas and good flavor but can have issues like being over burnt or slightly broken.

People are saying

"The food here is delicious and prepared with high quality ingredients."

"The three cup lobster here is delicious."

"You have to try the milk tea cheesecake here."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for larger groups to ensure seating.

2

Expect to find authentic Taiwanese flavors with a focus on quality ingredients.

3

Portion sizes are generous, making it ideal for sharing.

06
Empire Steak House image 1

Steak house occupies a grand space with historic elements and a gorgeous wine cellar for private events. Warm, elegant ambiance blends with live jazz music and a legit cocktail bar, creating a memorable dining atmosphere. The crowd enjoys top-tier aged beef and creative drinks in a setting that balances coziness with sophistication.

Super fresh lobster shines in dishes like lobster ravioli and lobster bisque. The lobster tail is tender and melts in your mouth.

Offers an amazing cheesecake that stands out as a top dessert option. Pairs well with the steak served here.

People are saying

"I found the food here to be amazing."

"The cheesecake here is one of the best I've ever had."

"The lobster tail just melted in my mouth."

Good to know

1

Happy hour offers half-price appetizers and runs from 4-7pm on weekdays.

2

Jazz nights occur every Friday and Saturday, starting at 9pm.

3

Reservations are recommended for large events, especially for parties over 60 guests.

07
Le Café Louis Vuitton NYC image 1

Elegant café space features Louis Vuitton-themed decor with artistic design and monogrammed tableware. Atmosphere feels upscale yet relaxed, with expertly crafted cocktails and attentive service creating a warm, welcoming vibe.

Small but delicious lobster rolls cost $36 and show solid flavor and execution. Poached lobster and lobster rolls come out perfect, with attentive service addressing any overcooking issues.

Apricot cheesecake stands out with its light and delicate texture. Raspberry sorbet pairs well, adding a fresh contrast to the creamy cheesecake.

People are saying

"The desserts here are rich, indulgent, and beautifully presented."

"The lobster rolls were my favorite and exceptional."

"You have to try the pumpkin cheesecake."

Good to know

1

Reservations are required to enter the venue.

2

You definitely need a reservation for lunch at 12pm.

3

Strollers are not allowed in the restaurant.

08
Sea Fire Grill image 1
Seafood restaurant

Modern space combines white tablecloths and white glove service with a refined yet inviting ambiance. Atmosphere ranges from peaceful and cozy near the fireplace to louder areas with higher ceilings. Guests enjoy top-notch cocktails and exceptional seafood and steak in a beautifully decorated setting.

Seafood includes a crab-stuffed lobster bursting with fresh, sweet crab meat and a rich, creamy lobster bisque with smooth texture and perfect seasoning. The menu features a squid ink spaghetti with lobster praised for its exceptional flavor.

Rich and creamy New York cheesecake stands out with a smooth texture and balanced sweetness. The cheesecake pairs well with fresh cannoli, both offering a classic, satisfying dessert experience.

People are saying

"The service at these dinner spots is amazing and attentive."

"The cheesecake is light and not overly sweet."

"The lobster bisque was very good, but it had shell pieces."

Good to know

1

Reservations are strongly recommended due to the restaurant's popularity.

2

The restaurant offers a special restaurant week menu for $45 per person.

3

Happy hour includes oysters and champagne at a discounted price.

09
Smith & Wollensky image 1

Quintessential high-end steakhouse with a loud, boisterous atmosphere and an exclusive club vibe. Spacious layout contrasts with some cramped booths and high air conditioning. An adjoining room offers an intimate bar with skilled mixologists.

Lobster comes tender and springy, often paired with Filet Mignon or served in a seafood platter with shrimp and crab. The Lobster tail is perfectly cooked and served with professionalism.

Cheesecakes stand out as spectacular and divine desserts here, consistently praised alongside other excellent sweets like carrot pie.

People are saying

"I enjoyed the excellent steaks here."

"I loved my bone-in filet with lobster tail."

"The New York cheesecake was the perfect finish to our meal."

Good to know

1

The "Weekend Wine Dinner" is offered Thursday through Saturday after 8:00 PM for $95 per person.

2

The weekend wine dinner includes 3 courses and unlimited wine for $95.

3

The Prix Fixe promotion is only available on Fridays and Saturdays after 8:30 PM.

10
Crab House NYC image 1
Seafood restaurant

Seafood restaurant offers an intimate setting with private booths and a sea-inspired aesthetic. Atmosphere features soft old school R&B music that encourages singing along, creating a lively yet cozy vibe. Known for fresh lobsters and crabs, it combines great food with a vibrant musical backdrop.

Mini lobster cakes deliver rich flavors in every bite. Lobster mac & cheese stands out as a popular dish. The buffet includes lobster for an extra cost and suits big lobster eaters well.

Complimentary cheesecake appears often, especially for birthdays and anniversaries. The cheesecake tastes yummy and comes with a happy birthday song when served for celebrations.

People are saying

"The bottomless seafood here is fresh, made-to-order, and flavorful."

"I loved the all-you-can-eat lobster and seafood."

"They brought out a free slice of cheesecake for my birthday!"

Good to know

1

Make a reservation before visiting to avoid a long wait.

2

The wait time for a party of 2 on a Saturday night at 5 pm is 3 HOURS.

3

You have 2 hours to eat as much as you wish.

11
Grand Central Oyster Bar image 1
Oyster bar restaurant

Huge space with classic architecture and old school NYC charm creates a unique atmosphere that feels like stepping back decades. Oyster shuckers perform visibly at the bar, adding to the lively, traditional vibe. Seating options include a hidden saloon and multiple bars, catering to varied preferences.

Fresh lobsters come live from the tank and cook perfectly. The menu features a lobster cocktail appetizer and lobster rolls known for their quality. The Seafood Platter includes a whole lobster alongside oysters, clams, and mussels.

NY cheesecake stands out as a solid dessert choice. It pairs well with other sweets like lime pie and holds its own alongside savory dishes.

People are saying

"The oysters here are so fresh, with many varieties to choose from."

"I found the clam chowder to be deeply flavorful and delicious."

"The cheesecake was delicious and a good surprise."

Good to know

1

Happy hour happens on Thursdays from 4-6 PM in the Saloon and Lounge.

2

The happy hour includes two options of $1 clams.

3

The kitchen closes at 9 PM, and it’s impossible to order after that.

Discover more

Midtown East, New York

Area guide
Loading Map...