Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Local picks

Cozy pizza spots in Midtown East

Made for those who want the communal, unpretentious joy of a pizza night without the chaos of a crowded room.

Based on 653 Opinions
+650
User
User
User
Updated
01
Norma Turtle Bay image 1
Norma Turtle Bay image 2
Norma Turtle Bay image 3
View all

Narrow space with rustic charm and cozy atmosphere evokes a homey Italian feel. Jazz music plays softly, creating a warm and inviting vibe. Known for authentic Sicilian cuisine, it attracts those seeking flavorful pasta and personal pizzas.

Warm and cozy atmosphere with a Sicilian touch creates a homey vibe. The interior feels intimate and the service is warm and welcoming.

Neapolitan pizza here stands out with authentic Sicilian flavors that differ from usual styles. The mortadella and funghi pizzas offer unique tastes, confirmed by Italian friends as true to Sicilian tradition.

People are saying

"The Sicilian pizzas and dishes taste truly authentic."

"I ate one of the best pizzas I've ever had."

"I really enjoyed the great Sicilian pizza and dishes here."

Good to know

1

Reservations are required for groups of 15 or more with a fixed menu.

2

The fixed menu costs $60 per person, but can be negotiated down.

3

Payment is accepted by card only in groups of three.

02
Sofia Wine Bar image 1
Sofia Wine Bar image 2
Sofia Wine Bar image 3
View all

Wine bar offers an intimate upstairs and expansive downstairs with cozy, casual dรฉcor and a beautiful back outdoor patio. Atmosphere ranges from loud and cramped inside to quieter outside seating with less foot traffic. Italian wines and cocktails feature prominently, creating a lively and inviting vibe.

Cozy vibes fill the space with an eclectic atmosphere and warm, festive decor. Attentive service adds to the comfortable, inviting feel.

Gluten-free pizza stands out here, with options like the truffle burrata pizza and Nona pepperoni offering rich flavors. The pizzas pair well with their cheese and meat boards, making for a well-rounded meal.

People are saying

"The gluten-free pizza here is amazing."

"The pizzas were mostly delicious with great variety."

"It's so cozy and comfortable here, a real local hideaway."

Good to know

1

The restaurant offers late night dining until 10 PM.

2

Expect a wait during peak times, especially on weekends.

3

A 20% tip is automatically added to your bill.

03
The Naked Pig image 1
The Naked Pig image 2
The Naked Pig image 3
View all

Bar space combines multiple TVs with loud, energetic music and a stellar DJ to create a lively atmosphere. Crowd enjoys casual vibe with plenty of room to sit, stand, or dance. Decor shows unique charm and recent renovation, balancing fun energy with clean, inviting surroundings.

Warm and welcoming staff create a cozy atmosphere with neat decor and soft music. The space feels inviting from the moment you walk in.

Prosciutto truffle pizza stands out as a favorite with a rich, savory flavor. The truffle pizza is a go-to choice, offering a unique and enjoyable taste experience.

People are saying

"The atmosphere here is so cozy and inviting."

"I loved the truffle prosciutto pizza; it's a perfect 10."

"The place has cozy and friendly vibes."

Good to know

1

Happy hour deals are available every day from 4-7pm and 10pm-close.

2

Weekend reservations are a must for boozy brunch.

3

Expect a 90-minute limit on unlimited brunch drinks.

04
La Piazza New York image 1
La Piazza New York image 2
La Piazza New York image 3
View all

Space features Murano chandeliers and a mask wall, creating an elegant, cozy setting with live jazz music enhancing the atmosphere. Energy feels friendly and inviting, suitable for casual meals and special occasions alike. Guests enjoy a warm, Venetian vibe that blends beauty and comfort seamlessly.

Warm, elegant atmosphere filled with Italian charm creates an intimate setting. Perfect for a cozy dinner or a special night out.

Wood-fired pizzas feature a crispy crust and high-quality ingredients. Options like Pizza Margherita, Pizza Venezia, and Pizza Diavola offer great flavor with a touch of Italian tradition.

People are saying

"I found the pizza here to be delicious and satisfying."

"The pizza and pasta here taste amazing."

"The atmosphere here is so cozy and elegant."

Good to know

1

Live jazz performances happen every Thursday evening, creating a lively atmosphere.

2

Happy hour runs from 4-7pm on weekdays with great drink specials.

3

The $10 Aperol Spritz is available during happy hour on Sundays.

05
Bucatini image 1
Bucatini image 2
Bucatini image 3
View all

Elegant interior blends spaciousness with intimacy, creating a cozy atmosphere reminiscent of Tuscany. Energy suits unhurried evenings and date nights, with superb cocktails complementing the setting.

Warm and inviting ambiance sets a cozy tone. Staff show genuine kindness and generosity, enhancing the comfortable atmosphere.

Truffle Pizza offers an American twist in flavors. The Pizza Bianca stands out among other great options like Tuna Tartare and Carbonara Arancini.

People are saying

"It's a cozy atmosphere, elegant and pretty."

"The pizza and Italian food are amazing."

"I had maybe the best pizza Iโ€™ve ever had."

Good to know

1

The menu accommodates dairy allergies with several options available.

2

Reservations are recommended for special occasions like anniversaries and birthdays.

3

Bucatini is suitable for private events and gatherings.

06
Club A Steakhouse image 1
Club A Steakhouse image 2
Club A Steakhouse image 3
View all

Two-level classic steakhouse offers spacious seating with live jazz music and private wine cellar dining. Ambiance is quiet and elegant, featuring classical tunes and picturesque city views. Staff provide thoughtful touches like complimentary photos and personalized service.

Warm red lighting and a red room create a welcoming yet cozy ambience. The dinner setting feels inviting and intimate.

Chicken parm pizza stands out with its extraordinary flavor and is available even though it is not on the menu. Veal parm pizza also features as a notable option among the pizza choices.

People are saying

"It's a cozy and authentic dining experience."

"I love how cozy and welcoming it feels."

"The chicken parm pizza is extraordinary."

Good to know

1

Live jazz performances occur from 6-10 PM on Fridays and Saturdays.

2

During Restaurant Week, a special three-course meal is available.

3

Reservations are recommended for special occasions like birthdays and anniversaries.

07
Uncle Paul's Pizza image 1
Uncle Paul's Pizza image 2
Uncle Paul's Pizza image 3
View all

Pizza restaurant offers indoor and outdoor seating with illuminated marble walls and a cozy, old hole-in-the-wall feeling. Atmosphere stays lively with a diverse crowd moving through. Known for some of the best pizza and a straightforward, no-frills setup.

Cozy and warm atmosphere suits cold days. Staff are friendly and cheerful, adding to the inviting vibe.

Prosciutto di Parma stands out as a signature topping. The lasagna pizza offers a unique twist. Pizza here consistently ranks among the best tasting in the city.

People are saying

"The pizza is tasty and priced just right."

"The pizza tastes fresh and is made fast."

"I thought the pizza here was delicious."

Good to know

1

Happy hour offers $5 beer from 3-7 PM.

2

Tables may be hard to come by during lunch or dinner.

3

The restaurant charges $4.00 for a slice of plain cheese pizza.

08
Abaita - Kosher Dairy image 1
Abaita - Kosher Dairy image 2
Abaita - Kosher Dairy image 3
View all

Small space with close tables and an open kitchen creates a lively, engaging atmosphere. Outdoor areas offer a cozy, modern design that feels like an indoor cafe. Noise levels can be high, and seating may feel cramped or stuffy during busy times.

Inviting space blends cozy and modern design for casual meals or special nights. Food offers fresh, flavorful, comfort dishes.

Homemade pizzas stand out with classic margherita and mushroom pizza offering rich, balanced flavors. Unique options like artichoke and spinach pizza add variety and depth to the menu.

People are saying

"The pizza dough here is amazing and the crust is rated A++."

"The pizza was delicious with a perfect crust."

"I loved the authentic kosher pizza that felt like Italy."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended due to the restaurant's small size.

2

Expect to pay around 600 shekels for a starter, two mains, and dessert.

3

The small salad portion does not reflect the high price of the meal.

09
Pasta Corner 53rd image 1
Pasta Corner 53rd image 2
Pasta Corner 53rd image 3
View all

Bright, white space with an open kitchen and fresh house-made pasta visible from inside and outside. Atmosphere feels warm and cozy with pretty decor and unique photo spots like a swing and a decorative wall. Seating is limited, creating an intimate dining experience.

Warm and inviting ambiance creates a cozy atmosphere. The open kitchen concept adds to the welcoming vibe.

Pizza features a chewy dough that holds up well in sandwiches and traditional slices. Toppings like prosciutto add a tasty touch, making the pizza both flavorful and satisfying.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was top class and delicious."

"It's a cozy place perfect for enjoying a slow afternoon."

"I love their pizza sandwiches and tasty pasta."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended as the restaurant often reaches full capacity by 7:30 p.m.

2

Prices for pasta dishes have increased significantly, with some items now costing over $36.

3

The restaurant runs out of popular dishes quickly, so order early.

10
Rosemary's Midtown image 1
Rosemary's Midtown image 2
Rosemary's Midtown image 3
View all

Indoor and outdoor seating blend with big windows that open, creating an almost indoor/outdoor dining experience. The atmosphere is lively and buzzing, with high noise levels that make conversation difficult. Tables are cramped, adding to the energetic but crowded vibe.

Warm atmosphere and attentive service create a comfortable setting without feeling rushed. The balance of cozy vibes with top-notch cuisine makes it inviting for a relaxed evening.

Pizza features a thin dough base with a soft airy crust and balanced flavors. The Stinger pizza pairs honey with spicy pepperoni and vegetables to cut greasiness.

People are saying

"The pizza crust here is divine, so soft and chewy."

"The pizzas have great dough and balanced flavors."

"The atmosphere here is so warm and cozy."

Good to know

1

Happy hour runs from 4-6pm on weekdays with discounted drinks.

2

Reservations are not required, but it's best to arrive early.

3

The restaurant charges $21 to store birthday cakes, $7 per person.

11
Aragvi image 1
Aragvi image 2
Aragvi image 3
View all

Georgian restaurant offers a beautiful interior with warm atmosphere and authentic decor. Music and a giant plasma screen showing Georgian scenery add to the cozy vibe. The space suits both intimate dates and large gatherings.

Warm, attentive staff create a truly welcoming atmosphere. Comfort food adds to the homey feel.

Bread resembles Neapolitan pizza but includes minced meat, Georgian-style cheese, and sauce for a unique twist. Kamcha root serves as a pizza bread with spinach, often dipped in bean lobio for added flavor.

People are saying

"It's a really cozy spot with a warm atmosphere."

"The atmosphere feels cozy and welcoming."

"It's a cozy spot perfect for nights out with friends."

Good to know

1

Happy hour is available with discounted drinks and appetizers.

2

Reservations are recommended for special events like graduation dinners.

3

Free parking is available for restaurant guests.

12
Patsy's Pizzeria image 1
Patsy's Pizzeria image 2
Patsy's Pizzeria image 3
View all

Spacious dining room with quaint seating and nostalgic decor creates a cozy, family-friendly atmosphere. Music varies from Caribbean vibes to festive tunes, contributing to a generally quiet and relaxed mood. Known for exceptional pizza, the place draws those seeking classic Italian flavors in a charming setting.

Warm and inviting staff create a cozy atmosphere. Comfortable seating and a family-friendly environment make it easy to relax and enjoy the evening.

Pizza here features purest dough and a fantastic brick oven style. The gourmet margarita pizza stands out as a highlight.

People are saying

"The pizza has a great crust and delicious taste."

"Patsy's pizza is classic and reliably delicious."

"I thought the pizza here was amazing and so good."

Good to know

1

Reservations are not accepted; walk-ins are welcome.

2

The restaurant opens at 11:30 AM, not 11 AM as stated online.

3

Patsy's Pizzeria does not serve pizza by the slice, only whole pies.

13
Vanderbilt Market - Bars & Eateries image 1
Vanderbilt Market - Bars & Eateries image 2
Vanderbilt Market - Bars & Eateries image 3
View all

Food court offers spacious seating with both indoor and outdoor areas and features two bars with local craft beers. The atmosphere is loud and busy, especially during lunch, with poor acoustics that amplify noise. Open kitchen layout and varied food options create a lively, bustling environment.

A cozy atmosphere fills the space with comfortable seating and a varied menu. Warm chicken broth adds a refreshing touch even on hot days.

Variety stands out with pizza, sushi, and tacos all available. Pizza pairs well with craft beer and appeals to all ages.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was pretty good."

"It's a cozy spot with a great atmosphere for gatherings."

"The pizza was tasty and hit the spot."

Good to know

1

Vanderbilt Market can host private events outside of normal business hours.

2

Most vendors at URBANSPACE VANDERBILT can only be paid for by credit card.

3

Seating is available inside the building or outside.

Discover more

Midtown East, New York

Area guide