Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Loved by locals

Footwear stores in Midtown East

A footwear store where you can actually try on shoes in peace, instead of fighting for a seat and a salesperson.

Based on 653 Opinions
+650
User
User
User
Updated April 2026
01
Alden Shoes New York image 1
Alden Shoes New York image 2
Alden Shoes New York image 3
View all

Small store offers classic boots with expert measurements ensuring perfect fit and comfort. Staff provide knowledgeable service and can special order styles featuring brass eyelets. Atmosphere reflects timeless quality and caters to unique foot shapes.

Classic boots and shoes fit perfectly without needing to break in. Staff provide expert measurements and have years of experience helping find the best fit and style.

People are saying

"The staff at this Footwear Store expertly measure you for the perfect fit."

"The boots fit perfectly and felt comfortable right away."

"I highly recommend these shoes for their quality and classic style."

Good to know

1

The store does not carry size 14 shoes.

2

The store has been a New York institution for 30 years.

3

The store sells $1000 shoes to tourists.

02
Carmina Shoemaker image 1
Carmina Shoemaker image 2
Carmina Shoemaker image 3
View all

Compact shop buzzes with customers and offers high-quality shoes known for craftsmanship and unique designs. Staff provide detailed advice and help with custom orders shipped from Spain. Atmosphere stays sophisticated and clean, focusing on durable, well-made footwear.

Shoes here offer top-notch quality and come in many different lasts to fit various foot shapes. Staff provide detailed advice and help with custom orders shipped directly from Spain.

People are saying

"Leila's attentiveness at this Footwear Store made the experience unforgettable."

"Carmina shoes are beautiful and worth the price."

"The shoes feel great and I’m excited to wear them."

Good to know

1

Carmina uses UK sizing for their shoes.

2

The store has a great selection of high-quality shoes.

3

Carmina offers recommendations for online ordering of custom shoes shipped directly from Spain.

03
Super Runners Shop image 1
Super Runners Shop image 2
Super Runners Shop image 3
View all

Store uses feet scan technology for perfect shoe fit. Staff offer custom orthotics and wide options for foot issues. Clean space with wide running shoe selection and helpful advice on gear and local running groups.

Ski boots and runners offer incredible comfort and support. Staff provide patient, knowledgeable help to find the right shoes, including custom orthotics and wide options for foot problems.

People are saying

"This footwear store's staff scanned my feet and gave expert shoe recommendations."

"I love how they help find the perfect running shoe fit."

"These running shoes fit my feet just right."

Good to know

1

Super Runners Shop uses a foot scanning technology that provides a full 3D image of each foot.

2

The store can run a scan on your feet to determine the exact size, pronation, and gait.

3

This shop is suitable for all levels of running.

04
Allen Edmonds image 1
Allen Edmonds image 2
Allen Edmonds image 3
View all

Small store offers classic American-made shoes with quality craftsmanship. Cozy space suits those needing extra narrow or broad sizes. Staff focus on durable, stylish dress shoes with expert service and recrafting options.

Shoes feature quality craftsmanship and classic style with options for wide feet. All shoes are American made and built to last with recrafting.

People are saying

"Their dress shoes last forever and feel great."

"The salesperson here really knows their footwear and helped me find the right fit."

"Their shoes fit wide feet and look amazing."

Good to know

1

The store offers an impressive range of sizes, from narrow to wide.

2

Allen Edmonds makes shoes for extra narrow or broad feet.

3

The shoes at this store are great quality and with recrafting, they last forever.

05
Johnston & Murphy image 1
Johnston & Murphy image 2
Johnston & Murphy image 3
View all

Store features a beautiful interior and a wide variety of comfortable shoes. Unique business model builds strong brand loyalty. Management shows clear vision and leadership.

Offers a solid selection of quality shoes that customers return to. Shoes purchased here meet expectations for style and comfort.

People are saying

"The footwear store's customer service is top-notch and friendly."

"I love the shoes I bought here."

"I appreciate how they helped me get rare shoes shipped."

Good to know

1

The store offers smart casual shoes in size 14.

2

The salesman brings up all options in size 14 and theme.

3

It would be helpful if the store adhered to the posted hours.

06
HOKA Flagship Store, NY image 1
HOKA Flagship Store, NY image 2
HOKA Flagship Store, NY image 3
View all

Small shoe store offers wide color options and foot scanning technology for precise fits. Staff provide personalized fitting assistance and a 30-day trial for running shoes. Atmosphere feels hot and crowded with loud radios, limiting seating and stock.

Offers a wide range of comfortable running and walking shoes with a 30-day trial period to test them outside. Staff provide personalized fitting assistance, helping try on many pairs to find the right fit for long-distance runs and training.

People are saying

"Jasmine at this Footwear Store was so sweet, quick, and efficient."

"They helped me find the perfect shoes."

"I got super comfy shoes even with few sizes."

Good to know

1

The store opens at 10 am sharp.

2

Returning shoes is very easy at this store.

3

The return policy allows refunds within 30 days via store credit.

07
SKECHERS Retail image 1
SKECHERS Retail image 2
SKECHERS Retail image 3
View all

Offers a wide selection of lightweight, comfortable sneakers for all ages with excellent color and design. Staff provide great service and a 50% discount on the second pair. Stores vary in atmosphere and stock, making each visit unique and affordable.

Shoes here feel light and very comfortable with excellent color and design. Staff bring multiple options and offer a 50% discount on the second pair.

People are saying

"The helpful staff at this footwear store made the shopping experience a pleasure."

"Their sneakers are comfy and stylish for everyone."

"Skechers shoes are good and won't cost much."

Good to know

1

The store on 5th Ave opens an hour later than the posted opening time.

2

Customers should arrive at least 20 minutes before the posted opening time.

3

There is a 50% discount for the second pair of shoes.

08
Mad Under image 1
Mad Under image 2
Mad Under image 3
View all

Luxury menswear shines with massive discounts on brands like Brunello Cucinelli. Warm, welcoming vibe makes shopping suits and coats a pleasure. Extensive men's shoes selection offers authentic designer shoes at smart prices.

Offers an extensive men's selection with high-end suits and shoes. Carries authentic designer shoes at common sense prices.

People are saying

"I love the amazing selection and great prices."

"This place offers top luxury fashion with a great vibe."

"I found amazing shoes and designer clothing at common sense prices."

Good to know

1

The store didn't start letting people in until 11:20 AM, despite the advertised opening time of 11:00 AM.

2

Numerous security staff were present, but they lacked clear information on prices.

3

Some items had price labels, but others did not, leading to confusion about pricing.

09
Louis Vuitton New York Saks Fifth Ave image 1
Louis Vuitton New York Saks Fifth Ave image 2
Louis Vuitton New York Saks Fifth Ave image 3
View all

Building looks like a gigantic luggage bag with a unique stacked trunks facade. Inside, find luxurious ambiance and a branded chocolate cafΓ© on top. Shoes for men and women come in varied sizes and styles, plus belts, bags, and sunglasses.

Shelves hold shoes for men and women in various styles and sizes, including distinctions between US and UK sizing. The store also offers belts, bags, and sunglasses alongside footwear.

People are saying

"The building’s design is striking and a must-see for brand fans."

"The store feels like a luxurious, multi-level adventure with great food."

"Chris at the Footwear Store got me the sneakers I wanted."

Good to know

1

Reservations are required to dine at the cafΓ© on the top floor.

2

The flagship store is temporarily closed for renovations; visit the store across the street.

3

The cafΓ© is often fully booked, so plan ahead.

10
ALDO image 1
ALDO image 2
ALDO image 3
View all

Store buzzes with pumped-up energy and draws a fashion-forward crowd. Staff offer quick and patient help for events like graduations and interviews. Shelves hold affordable, comfortable shoes perfect for business casual and boots.

Staff provide quick and patient help finding shoes for events like graduations and interviews. Shoes range from business casual to boots, with many options noted for comfort and quality.

People are saying

"Saryna at this Footwear Store was so patient and helpful picking out shoes."

"Some shoes last great, others don't."

"The staff helped me find shoes quickly."

Good to know

1

The shoes range from $100 to $200 a pair.

2

The store cleans shoes on display instead of providing new ones.

3

Sample shoes are provided instead of new ones.

11
McQueen image 1
McQueen image 2
McQueen image 3
View all

Elegant atmosphere suits an executive office setting with champagne service adding luxury. Classic shoes offer comfort and fair pricing, though some sizes may be missing. Occasional scratched shoes are a minor issue.

Shoes here feel comfortable from the first second and include classic styles at fair prices. Some sizes may be missing and occasional issues with scratched shoes have occurred.

People are saying

"The classic shoes felt comfortable from the start."

"I love the shoes from this Footwear Store; they're so comfortable."

"They shipped boots overnight to make my day."

Good to know

1

You cannot return items bought in-store.

2

If you buy online, you can return the items.

3

The store did not have my shoe size available.

12
Saint Laurent image 1
Saint Laurent image 2
Saint Laurent image 3
View all

Offers complementary tailoring and uses high-quality materials rivaling luxury brands. Footwear includes hold and exchange options but expect delivery delays beyond 3 days. Shopping experience is innovative and premium with a wide variety of signature pieces.

Sandals and shoes can be put on hold or exchanged if they don't fit. Customers must wait and sign to receive shoes since the store does not call when items arrive. Delivery times can exceed the promised 2 to 3 business days, sometimes causing delays.

People are saying

"I enjoyed shopping but some products felt low quality."

"The material feels great and fits my style perfectly."

"Nzingha at the Footwear Store was so helpful finding my size."

Good to know

1

The return policy requires the original wrapping paper and plastic wrap for returns.

2

Look for Roxanne when you visit this store for assistance.

3

Cooper is a recommended sales representative at YSL for a great shopping experience.

13
Belgian Shoes image 1
Belgian Shoes image 2
Belgian Shoes image 3
View all

Showroom offers unique stylish shoes with a classic design and good quality. Staff are patient during fittings, ensuring a confident and strict focus on perfect fit. Prices are high, reflecting the brand's exclusive reputation.

A lovely showroom offers a variety of unique and stylish shoes with a focus on classic style. Staff show patience during fittings, making it easy to try many pairs.

People are saying

"The shoes look great and feel high quality."

"Amber made my footwear shopping experience easy and enjoyable."

"These slippers don’t feel like real shoes to me."

Good to know

1

The shoes are of good quality and stylish.

2

The retail experience is exceptional and unique.

3

The collection of shoes is new but will expand.

14
Lacoste image 1
Lacoste image 2
Lacoste image 3
View all

Clean, modern layout with artistic installations invites exploration. Wide selection of tennis apparel suits all styles. Offers classic sneakers for men and women, perfect for couples shopping during sales.

Offers a variety of classic sneakers for men and women. Includes options for couples shopping together during sales.

People are saying

"The store feels modern and true to the brand."

"I was pleased with the quality and prices at this Footwear Store."

"The team really knows their stuff and helps a lot."

Good to know

1

The store offers a solid variety of products including signature polos and casual wear.

2

Prices are standard for Lacoste, not outlet-style deals.

3

The store features a clean, modern layout for easy browsing.

Discover more

Midtown East, New York

Area guide
Loading Map...