Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Midtown South's best

Cake shops

Cake that tastes like a traditional recipe instead of a sugary, artificial slab from a factory.

Based on 690 Opinions
+687
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Butterflied image 1
Butterflied image 2
Butterflied image 3
View all
Greek restaurant

Open kitchen and plentiful seating create a clean, tidy layout with a warm ambiance. Music adds a lively atmosphere reminiscent of Mykonos, while outdoor seating offers a comfortable option. Utensils come cleverly packed in high-quality napkins, reflecting attention to detail.

Flavors stay true to Greek roots with authentic taste and fresh ingredients. The menu blends classic and fusion dishes, all served in generous portions.

Orange Cake stands out with a superb flavor. The Carrot Cake also tastes delicious, making desserts a real treat here.

People are saying

"The food here is fresh, authentic, and perfectly seasoned."

"The flavors here are so fresh and authentic, like homemade."

"Their orange cake is something special."

Good to know

1

Prices for sides are around $8, with chicken burgers priced at $18.

2

The restaurant offers a variety of menu options including soups, salads, and sandwiches.

3

The restaurant is clean and well-maintained.

02
Cinco de Mayo image 1
Mexican restaurant

Small, hole-in-the-wall Mexican restaurant with austere decor and limited seating. Atmosphere feels authentic and homely with chill Mexican music at a comfortable volume. Space is cozy but not crowded, offering a cultured and heartwarming vibe.

Mexican dishes here have a flavor profile authentic to its name. The food feels tasty, healthy, and truly authentic in every bite.

Carrot cake stands out with its consistent flavor and comes with icing. Small carrot cake muffins often arrive as a complimentary treat with meals.

People are saying

"The birria tacos here are full of flavor and really good."

"The food here is so authentic and tasty."

"You have to try the carrot cake; it's delicious."

Good to know

1

For about $11, you get a burrito and a drink.

2

The price of the New Yorker wrap is $10.75 before tax.

3

They offer good healthy options.

03
Çka Ka Qëllue image 1
Mediterranean restaurant

Mediterranean restaurant offers an intimate, cozy space with Eastern European decor and a romantic vibe. Outdoor patio and terrace provide beautiful seating for small to medium groups, enhanced by traditional music. The atmosphere feels like a European escape within a bustling city.

The spot serves authentic Albanian cuisine with a touch of Eastern European flair. The atmosphere feels cozy and genuine, with thoughtful decor and friendly staff enhancing the experience.

Trileca cake stands out as a notable dessert option. The cake served is consistently yummy and pairs well with savory dishes like qebapa.

People are saying

"The food here is delicious, hearty, and flavorful."

"The food here is truly authentic, with rich, homemade flavors."

"The tres leches style cake was a meal highlight."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended as the restaurant can get full quickly.

2

Prices on the menu may be outdated by $4-6 per dish.

3

An 18% gratuity charge is automatically added for parties of 2.

04
Berimbau Brazilian Table - 36th Street image 1

Restaurant offers a fresh, modern decor with an atmosphere that blends sophistication and warmth. Live Brazilian samba and bossa nova music energize the space, encouraging dancing and singing. Guests enjoy authentic Brazilian vibes that evoke a beachside bar experience far from the city.

Authentic Brazilian cuisine shines through with dishes that capture the true flavors of a Brazilian bar. The food stays true to traditional recipes and offers a delicious taste experience.

Flourless chocolate cake brigadeiro tastes like a Molten chocolate lava cake. Cheese cake de caju com paçoca stands out with its unique flavor combination.

People are saying

"I found the food to be amazing and creative."

"The authentic Brazilian flavors here are comforting and remind me of home."

"I thought the food was very good and flavorful."

Good to know

1

Happy hour runs from 4-7 PM with great drink and food deals.

2

Samba performances occur every Sunday, adding to the lively atmosphere.

3

Reservations can be made through Resy for table bookings.

05
Fushimi Times Square image 1

Entry features Torii gates and atmospheric lighting creating a mini Kyoto vibe. The lively atmosphere includes a DJ and dance floor, blending dining with club energy. Sushi stands out as exceptionally fresh and high quality.

Dishes showcase authentic Japanese flavors with a menu that stays true to tradition. Sushi comes at a reasonable price while maintaining great taste.

Molten lava cake stands out as a very tasty and highly recommended dessert. It pairs well with other menu items like crispy rice toro and pork gyoza.

People are saying

"I found the food here to be delicious and artfully presented."

"I tried authentic Japanese cuisine with many flavors."

"The molten lava cake was so good."

Good to know

1

The early dinner special is offered Mondays to Thursdays from 3 to 6 PM for $38.99.

2

Happy hour at Fushimi is from 4pm to 7pm at the bar.

3

The restaurant does not require a reservation for two people and can accommodate walk-ins.

06
Hangawi image 1
Vegan restaurant

Floor seating with shoe removal and under-table leg cutouts creates an authentic Korean dining setup. Soft lighting and traditional decor foster a calm, immersive atmosphere. The space balances minimalist design with cultural touches, offering a peaceful and comfortable experience.

Dim lighting and authentic art create an immersive Korean atmosphere. Guests remove their shoes and sit on cushions around low tables, adding a minimalist yet calming vibe.

Top notch cake pairs well with vegan ice cream, creating a solid dessert combo.

People are saying

"The food here is plant-based Korean and incredibly flavorful."

"The vegan red velvet cake was unbelievable."

"I loved the authentic Korean atmosphere, especially taking my shoes off."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended at least a week in advance due to high demand.

2

Diners must remove their shoes before entering the seating area.

3

The emporer's tasting menu costs $75 per person.

07
787 Coffee Co. image 1
Coffee shop

Spacious coffee shop with an upstairs lounge offers comfortable seating and plenty of outlets for work or study. The atmosphere is cozy and quiet, encouraging relaxation and creativity with walls adorned by bold, funny sayings. Unique whiskey-infused drinks and fresh pastries add to the inviting vibe.

Authentic Puerto Rican coffee stands out with fresh, high-quality flavors. Pastries match the drinks in being delicious and carefully made, creating a genuine taste experience.

Banana cake features prominently with walnuts adding texture and flavor. Coffee pairs well, including options like macchiato and drip coffee.

People are saying

"I enjoyed the great coffee and service here."

"The Puerto Rican coffee here tastes homemade and authentic."

"I loved the homemade banana cake."

Good to know

1

The establishment does not serve coffee, only espresso and americanos.

2

The WiFi is really good for Zoom meetings.

3

Choosing either the rum or whiskey infused coffee costs an extra $4.

08
Ramerino - Italian Prime Restaurant image 1

Italian restaurant offers a quiet, pleasant atmosphere with a well-decorated interior and an open patio. A rooftop bar provides stunning city views, including the Empire State Building, enhancing the dining experience. Staff serve with attention to detail, and some dishes are prepared tableside for added engagement.

Dishes feature fresh, homemade flavors with a cozy, authentic ambience that suits relaxed meals. The menu offers authentic Italian cuisine with a homemade touch and outstanding service.

Chocolate lava cake stands out as a rich dessert option. Staff allow bringing in cakes and celebrate with a birthday song and cake cutting for groups.

People are saying

"The Italian food here is served by attentive and friendly staff."

"The chocolate lava cake was excellent and made for a happy ending."

"I tasted authentic Italian flavor in every bite."

Good to know

1

A reservation is not necessary as the restaurant was pretty empty on a Sunday night.

2

The restaurant adds a 20+% gratuity to the bill and then asks if customers will be tipping more.

3

Tap water is chargeable and costs $10.

09
NIKU X | Limitless Wagyu BBQ & Seafood image 1

Private rooms with table-side cooking and high-quality grills create an intimate and luxurious dining experience. The space combines a modern, cozy vibe with sleek design elements, offering privacy and warmth. Ventilation issues upstairs can cause heavy smoke, contrasting with the otherwise comfortable atmosphere.

Wagyu beef here matches the authentic taste and texture found in Japan. The menu includes unlimited A5 Wagyu, king crab, lobster, caviar, and lamb, all served with genuine New York-style friendliness.

Yuzu cake stands out with its bright citrus flavor and moist texture. The cake pairs well with savory dishes like wagyu, offering a nice balance.

People are saying

"The food here is cooked perfectly by attentive servers."

"The Wagyu was stunning and perfectly cooked."

"The staff's authentic knowledge made the experience so meaningful."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for dinner service to ensure a private dining experience.

2

Expect a wait time of 30 minutes during peak dinner hours.

3

Private dining rooms are available for special occasions with prior reservation.

10
Luxsa Thai Spa NYC image 1

Upscale spa offers authentic Thai massages in a luxurious, serene setting with soothing scents and calming music. Guests enjoy complimentary champagne and chocolates in a beautifully decorated, clean space. Atmosphere feels like a peaceful escape from the city bustle.

Offers authentic Thai massages that feel like a trip to Thailand. The experience captures the traditional techniques and atmosphere well.

They offer a slice of cake as a surprise during birthdays and sing happy birthday to celebrate.

People are saying

"The spa massages here are amazing and rejuvenating."

"They surprised me with a birthday cake and sang to me!"

"I had an authentic Thai massage that felt like a trip to Thailand."

Good to know

1

Luxsa Spa offers a lovely couple massage for Valentine's month.

2

There is a minimum required tip of $84 (35%) for the couples massage service.

3

Expect a serene environment that enhances relaxation.

11
GRIND THE NYC COFFEE SHOP & BAGEL HOUSE image 1

Coffee shop offers an authentic Greek design with green chairs and wood accents and real plants creating a warm, welcoming vibe. Loud music fills the space, which is open and airy with plenty of seating including outdoor tables. Atmosphere suits working, socializing, or relaxing away from city stress.

Greek coffee here nails the authentic Freddo Espresso and Freddo Cappuccino experience. The Greek cheese and spinach pie matches the genuine vibe, and the interior feels fully authentic.

Cakes here include orange cake that tastes like the ones in Greece, walnut pound cake, and carrot cake. The Lemington cake also stands out alongside good coffee.

People are saying

"I experienced the best coffee in the city."

"I found an authentic NYC bagel with the perfect chewiness."

"I thought the orange pie was good."

Good to know

1

A bagel with cream cheese and a cup of coffee costs $14.

2

The café opens before 7am for early customers.

3

The price of macaroons is $17.

12
La Pecora Bianca Bryant Park image 1

Italian restaurant offers beautifully decorated spaces with in-house pasta and an extensive cocktail program. Atmosphere ranges from charming and lively to tight seating that can affect conversation, especially in the basement area. Drinks like espresso martinis and unique cocktails stand out alongside highly praised pasta and desserts.

Dishes offer authentic Italian flavor with fresh ingredients. The Margherita pizza stands out as light and flavorful, capturing traditional tastes well.

Moist and fluffy olive oil cake stands out here. Nutella cake also appears as a notable dessert option.

People are saying

"The homemade Italian pasta here is cooked to perfection."

"I loved the moist olive oil cake."

"The authentic Italian flavors here are outstanding and fresh."

Good to know

1

Reservations are required for the Valentine's Day menu.

2

The restaurant is busy around happy hour.

3

Brunch is served on weekends with a special Sunday menu.

13
Westway Diner image 1

Classic American diner with nostalgic decor and big red banquettes creates a genuine, hardworking vibe. Atmosphere feels warm and welcoming but can be uncomfortable due to noise from dishes. Seating is cozy with comfortable booths and some outdoor options.

Offers a truly authentic American diner experience with a strong focus on classic breakfast dishes. The flavors stay true to traditional New York diner style, making each bite distinctly authentic.

Decadent mousse cake stands out among a tempting case full of cakes and pies. Options include carrot cake alongside other sweet treats, all looking amazing and abundant.

People are saying

"This diner has amazing, classic American comfort food."

"The food here is delicious and traditional."

"Their cakes, especially the German chocolate, are delicious and look amazing."

Good to know

1

Arrive early for breakfast to avoid long queues.

2

Happy hour offers $4 beers and $6 cocktails on weekdays.

3

Expect busy breakfast hours on rainy Saturdays.

14
Keens Steakhouse image 1
Steak house

Exposed pipes line the ceiling, creating a historic chophouse vibe with old-school New York decor. The atmosphere feels classic and timeless, filled with vintage memorabilia and a sense of tradition. Guests enjoy a unique dining experience that blends rich history with hearty steakhouse energy.

Steakhouse offers a truly authentic atmosphere with fantastic steaks and attentive service. The experience feels genuine and captures the classic steakhouse vibe well.

Carrot cake stands out with its rich flavor and moist texture. Staff sometimes offer a complimentary slice for special occasions.

People are saying

"The atmosphere and service at this Steakhouse are professional and pleasant."

"You have to try the homemade carrot cake; it's one of the best."

"It's an authentic steakhouse with a rich history."

Good to know

1

Reservations are required as this is a popular restaurant.

2

The portions at the steakhouse are quite big, so definitely come hungry.

3

If you mention an anniversary when reserving, they celebrate with ice cream and candles.

15
Nizza image 1
Italian restaurant

Small, cozy Italian restaurant with gluten-free menu and outdoor seating featuring heat lamps. Atmosphere is cozy and elegant with lounge music that enhances the vibe. Tables are close together inside, creating an intimate but cramped setting.

Italian dishes taste 100% authentic and maintain rich flavor even in gluten-free options. The menu includes a variety of authentic liquors from Italy alongside classic cuisine.

Chocolate cakes stand out here, especially the flourless chocolate cake which is rich and dense. The cake often comes with whipped cream drizzled with olive oil, adding a unique touch.

People are saying

"The Italian Food here is amazing, and the service is incredible."

"The Italian food here is so authentic and delicious."

"The chocolate cake here is unbelievable."

Good to know

1

The restaurant offers a bottomless brunch special on weekends.

2

Wine Wednesday features select bottles for only $24.

3

Reservations are recommended to secure a table, especially on weekends.

16
Marseille image 1
French restaurant

French bistro style combines with classic, spacious layout and stunning panoramic views from a high floor. Atmosphere feels bougie and lively, with a warm ambiance and occasional loudness during dinner rush. Outdoor seating offers heated comfort for enjoying weather during lunch.

Dishes feature authentic flavors and traditional preparations with a modern touch. Staff provide gracious hospitality that matches the genuine French atmosphere.

Chocolate lava cake stands out as a rich dessert option. Complimentary birthday cakes mark special occasions with a personal touch.

People are saying

"The food here is amazing, thanks to Johnny's knowledgeable suggestions."

"The staff's warm, authentic hospitality made me feel right at home."

"The staff's attentive service made our cake experience feel special."

Good to know

1

Happy hour includes oysters for $1.50 until 5:30 PM daily.

2

Brunch includes bottomless Mimosas for $25.

3

Make reservations, especially if you are visiting prior to a theatre show.

17
Tatsuda Omakase image 1
Sushi restaurant

Small sushi restaurant seats about a dozen people around an L-shaped bar with intimate setting and tasteful decor. Atmosphere feels romantic and cozy, with soft lighting and a relaxed vibe that contrasts city bustle outside. Complimentary sake and optional pairings enhance the affordable omakase experience.

Fresh fish from Japan delivers a genuine taste of Japanese sushi. Prices stay reasonable while offering an authentic, top-tier sushi experience.

A 12-layered matcha crepe cake stands out as a special dessert. Birthday celebrations include a cake, candle, and a complimentary sake shot.

People are saying

"The Omakase experience here is intimate and wonderfully cared for."

"It's the most authentic taste of Japan I've ever found."

"They brought out cake and sang for my birthday."

Good to know

1

Reservations are needed for a visit, preferably made via Resy.

2

The omakase offers 14 courses for just $90 before tax and tip.

3

The restaurant is BYOB, so bring your favorite sake or wine.

18
Pan d’oro Italian Cafe image 1

Narrow, cozy space with bright lighting and a pastry display featuring Italian sweets like zeppole and cannoli. Warm, welcoming atmosphere with authentic Italian flavors and expertly prepared fresh pasta. Often quiet early, sometimes loud later, offering a charming spot for coffee or a meal.

Fresh ingredients and expert preparation create authentic Italian flavors. The café offers Italian coffee and specialties like pizza, focaccia, and sweet pasta in a cozy setting.

Almond Chocolate Cake stands out as gluten free and rich in flavor. Apple tart or cake features a sour flavor in the apple pieces that some might find unusual.

People are saying

"I found the pastries here to be excellent and delicious."

"It's an authentic taste of Italy, like pizza and focaccia made there."

"This gluten-free cake is delicious; I wish I'd bought the whole thing."

Good to know

1

Expect to pay around $8 for a pastry at this café.

2

The café does not display prices on the menu, which can be confusing.

3

The total for two hot chocolates and a pastry can reach $35.

19
Ravagh Persian Grill image 1
Persian restaurant

Modern interior design combines with elegant decor and a beautiful street view to create a welcoming dining space. The atmosphere is lively and often noisy with echo, filled with traditional Persian music that adds cultural flavor. Crowds tend to gather, leading to wait times and a bustling energy.

Food features authentic Persian flavors with perfectly cooked kebabs and fragrant saffron rice. Dishes stay consistently well-prepared and delicious.

Chocolate lava cake stands out with its delightful richness and balanced sweetness. Baklava and chocolate cake also offer rich flavors that satisfy without overwhelming.

People are saying

"The food here is delicious and flavorful."

"The food here is authentic, rich in flavor, and prepared with care."

"Anthony gave us a complimentary pistachio cake."

Good to know

1

Reservation is highly recommended as the wait can be as long as an hour on a busy night.

2

The restaurant has a mandatory gratuity policy regardless of party size.

3

The restaurant automatically applies a 20% gratuity for a table of 3.

20
NONONO image 1
Japanese restaurant

Multi-level layout with modern industrial design and dim lighting creates a chic, lively atmosphere. Two counter bars and an open kitchen add to the vibey interior, attracting groups and solo diners alike. Seating includes bar seats for walk-ins and private nooks, offering varied dining experiences.

Food captures the feel of Japan with authentic yakitori, chicken ramen, and dishes like skewers, soups, and marinated vegetables.** The flavors soothe both body and mind, recalling dining in Kyoto.

Chocolate cake comes with ice cream and stands out for its rich flavor. The thousand layer cake offers a delicious, layered texture.

People are saying

"The skewers, ceviche, and corn at these dinner spots are all delicious."

"I loved the authentic Japanese dishes; the yakitori was flavorful and juicy."

"The chocolate cake is so rich, you'll want ice cream with it."

Good to know

1

Happy hour runs until 7 PM with $9 beer and $5 whiskey highball.

2

Brunch menu is available on Saturday afternoons.

3

Reservations are highly recommended as walk-in wait times can exceed 90 minutes.

21
Angelina Paris New-York image 1
French restaurant

Elegant Parisian decor with ornate chandeliers and pastel hues creates a refined atmosphere. The space feels vibrant and classy, with a bustling yet sophisticated tearoom vibe. Seating extends indoors, upstairs, and outside, offering a spacious and private dining experience.

Authentic Parisian patisserie vibe shines through with fluent French-speaking staff and an authentic French hot chocolate that stands out. Classic French dishes taste genuine and true to tradition.

Signature Mont-blanc cake offers a not too sweet and moist texture with flavorful notes. Cakes come in small bites priced around 13 dollars each, crafted by original patissiers in the tea room.

People are saying

"The hot chocolate here is rich, creamy, and delicious."

"I thought the cake was classy and delicious."

"I found the authentic hot chocolate to be rich, thick, and utterly divine."

Good to know

1

Reservations are required for brunch on Sundays.

2

Each person must order at least two items to sit down.

3

Expect long wait times during weekend brunch hours.

Discover more

Midtown South, New York

Area guide
Loading Map...