Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Loved by locals

Pie and Beer in Midtown South

There is no better pairing than a cold beer and a slice of pie.

Based on 604 Opinions
+601
User
User
User
Updated
01
Keens Steakhouse image 1
Keens Steakhouse image 2
Keens Steakhouse image 3
View all

Exposed pipes and vintage memorabilia create a historic chophouse vibe. Keen's IPA and Pilsen beer offer great pairings with hearty steaks. Key lime pie shines with its light texture and strong citrus flavor.

Key lime pie stands out for its light texture and strong citrus flavor. It ranks among the best pies experienced here.

Keen's IPA beer stands out as a solid choice, priced around $10. Pairing a T-bone steak with a glass of Pilsen beer complements the meal well.

People are saying

"You have to try the key lime pie for dessert."

"I loved the perfectly cooked, beautiful cut of prime rib."

"Their fresh ginger ale and beers hit the spot."

Good to know

1

Reservations are required as this is a popular restaurant.

2

The portions at the steakhouse are quite big, so definitely come hungry.

3

If you mention an anniversary when reserving, they celebrate with ice cream and candles.

02
Slattery's Midtown Pub image 1
Slattery's Midtown Pub image 2
Slattery's Midtown Pub image 3
View all

Bar offers spacious upstairs area with a balcony and tons of TVs for watching sports. Atmosphere turns buzzing and festive during games, supported by a DJ playing upbeat music. Crowd includes many sports fans, especially those rooting for the Dolphins.

Shepherd's Pie stands out with its good flavor and is often paired with sauces like HP or A1. Chicken pot pie serves well for sharing, offering a generous portion for two.

Cold beer comes with a free shot on the first purchase every day. The house beer is very good and pairs well with food. Prices stay cheap while offering a solid selection.

People are saying

"It's a great sports pub with good beer and lively atmosphere."

"The beer was cold, good, and reasonably priced."

"I thought the shepherd's pie was amazing and flavorful."

Good to know

1

Happy hour offers all drinks for $6, making it a great deal.

2

The venue is ideal for hosting events or private dinners.

3

The upstairs event space can get very hot in summer.

03
Skirt Steak image 1
Skirt Steak image 2
Skirt Steak image 3
View all

Woodwork and Scandinavian design create a calm, stylish setting with a rolling dessert cart adding a unique touch. The atmosphere ranges from relaxing to warm and lively near the bar. Long waits are common due to no reservations and high demand.

Black cherries make the cherry pie stand out with a rich flavor. The Key Lime Pie on the dessert cart offers a satisfying, sweet and tart finish.

People are saying

"The beer and cocktails here are really good."

"The beer selection here is small but good."

"The key lime pie with whipped cream was the star."

Good to know

1

If you like french fries, it's all you can eat.

2

Dessert is offered via a cart at $10 after the entree is finished.

3

The restaurant does not take reservations unless for a party of 7+.

04
Vezzo NYC Thin Crust Pizza image 1
Vezzo NYC Thin Crust Pizza image 2
Vezzo NYC Thin Crust Pizza image 3
View all

Cozy dining room and outdoor patio create a friendly vibe. Thin crust pizza shines with unique toppings and a solid white pie. Happy Hour offers pitchers of beer with discounted pizza, featuring a narrow but good draft selection like Brooklyn.

Pitchers of beer come with a Happy Hour deal that includes a discounted pizza. The draft beer selection is narrow but offers good beers like Brooklyn.

People are saying

"I loved the thin crust of the pizza."

"Their specialty pies always hit the spot."

"Sharing big pies with salads is the best."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended to avoid long wait times, especially during peak hours.

2

Happy hour runs from 3:30 to 6:30 PM with discounts on pizza and drinks.

3

A pitcher of beer or a bottle of wine comes with a $24 discount on pizza during happy hour.

05
Maggie Reilly's image 1
Maggie Reilly's image 2
Maggie Reilly's image 3
View all

Cozy Irish pub offers a friendly vibe and outdoor seating for sports fans. Shepherd's pie is hearty and satisfying when done right. Beers come very cold and fresh, with creamy Guinness served in branded glasses at fair prices.

Shepherd's pie features a rich filling with a comforting texture. Some versions come off as watery and lack flavor, while others are quite hearty and satisfying.

Beers come very cold and fresh, including creamy Irish Guinness served in matching branded glasses. Prices stay affordable without tricks, and friendly staff let you relax without rushing.

People are saying

"The beers are good and priced fairly here."

"I found the beer here to be good and fairly priced."

"I enjoyed cold, cheap beer that hit the spot."

Good to know

1

Happy hour runs with discounts on drinks, making it a great after-work spot.

2

The kitchen closes early if no one is eating, so plan accordingly.

3

Reservations for four are easy to make before a show at MSG.

06
The Playwright Irish Pub image 1
The Playwright Irish Pub image 2
The Playwright Irish Pub image 3
View all

Irish pub with multiple TVs showing various sports and a full bar featuring friendly bartenders. Cozy, warm-hearted atmosphere with a lively mix of locals and expats. Low ceilings and a rooftop view add to the space's character.

Shepherd's pie stands out with its rich, hearty filling served in its own pot. It matches home-cooked quality and earns praise for being consistently delicious and a favorite choice.

Craft beer knowledge runs deep with over two decades of experience behind the bar. The selection features local craft options, international brews, and includes Forged Irish Stout. Happy Hour offers great prices on draft beers.

People are saying

"Some beers were watered down, but others tasted great and cold."

"You'll find a great selection of cold beer here."

"The shepherd's pie was divine and phenomenal."

Good to know

1

Happy hour runs Monday to Friday starting at 3 PM.

2

Expect lively watch parties for Mets games at this location.

3

Free shots are given during nights with major sports events.

07
Mustang Harry's image 1
Mustang Harry's image 2
Mustang Harry's image 3
View all

Large bar with many TVs shows multiple sports games simultaneously, creating a loud, energetic atmosphere. Space feels confined in some areas despite high ceilings and wide layout. Frequented by young, noisy crowds especially during games and concerts.

Shepherd's pie stands out with its home cooked and delicious qualities. Chicken pot pie also ranks as very tasty and satisfying.

Delicious lager beer pairs well with the menu's offerings. The beer selection complements dishes like the short rib grilled cheese sandwich.

People are saying

"The beer here is served cold and was phenomenal."

"The beer selection is good but can be pricey and sometimes limited."

"I enjoyed the local draft beers and the menu, though it can get pricey."

Good to know

1

Happy hour runs daily from 2 PM to 5 PM with drink specials.

2

Reservations are recommended if visiting before a game.

3

Expect large crowds before events, so arrive early for a table.

08
The Long Hall Pub & Grocery image 1
The Long Hall Pub & Grocery image 2
The Long Hall Pub & Grocery image 3
View all

Traditional Irish pub with tall ceilings and two-room layout creates a spacious feel. Atmosphere ranges from relaxed socializing to rowdy energy during live Irish music and sports broadcasts. Known for authentic Guinness pours and a retro vibe that reflects decades of family ownership.

Guinness Irish stout stands out as a key highlight. The beer selection is wide and reasonably priced, including a few wines. Bartenders manage large groups smoothly while serving food and drinks.

People are saying

"They have a good selection of draft beer here."

"They have a good variety of beers and a nice pub vibe."

"It's a great place to grab beer and hang out."

Good to know

1

Joining the quiz is free with a 1 drink minimum.

2

The restaurant offers Trivia Tuesday events at 8 PM.

3

The pub opens as early as 10 AM and stays open until 4 AM.

09
The Westbury image 1
The Westbury image 2
The Westbury image 3
View all

Spacious bar with authentic Irish decor offers lively vibes from traditional music and sports. Enjoy shepherd's pie and flavorful curry pie with chips. Choose from a variety of beers including Krombacher, with $7 drafts during happy hour and excellent service.

Shepherd's pie stands out as a very delicious and solid choice here. The curry pie and chips also earn praise for their excellent flavor and quality.

Offers a variety of beers including local and recognizable brands like Krombacher. Happy hour features $7 drafts for premium beer with excellent service.

People are saying

"They have a good variety of tasty beers."

"The beer here is great and cold."

"I enjoyed the beer and cider here."

Good to know

1

Happy hour offers $7 drafts for premium beer from 4-6pm on weekdays.

2

Trivia night occurs every Tuesday at 8pm with a $5 entry fee.

3

The kitchen closes at 9 PM, so arrive early for food.

10
The Keg Room image 1
The Keg Room image 2
The Keg Room image 3
View all

Large open space filled with over 30 televisions showing a wide variety of sports creates a sports-focused atmosphere. Loud music and crowd noise make conversations difficult, contributing to a high-energy vibe. Plenty of seating and a large bar area support a social and lively environment.

Shepherd's pie stands out with a rich, hearty flavor and creamy texture. Some find it greasy and bland, but many describe it as divine and satisfying.

A huge selection of 90 beers on tap and in bottles offers plenty of variety. Lots of beers on tap include options like a Keg Lager and light-flavored dark beers, paired well with fresh fried potato chips.

People are saying

"They have a great variety of cold beers to enjoy."

"They had a great choice of beer, including a Pilsner Urquell."

"It's a nice spot to enjoy good beer and food."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for major events like the Super Bowl.

2

Expect large crowds during major sports events, especially on weekends.

3

The kitchen closes before the bar, so check food hours if needed.

11
Tรญr na Nรณg image 1
Tรญr na Nรณg image 2
Tรญr na Nรณg image 3
View all

Irish restaurant combines roomy bar, lots of TVs, and live music for a lively atmosphere. Crowds gather especially during sports events, creating a noisy, energetic vibe. Comfortable booths and an upstairs dining area offer spots for conversation amid the bustle.

Shepherd's pie stands out with its tasty and satisfying flavor. The pot pie differs, resembling a soup in a shallow dish rather than a traditional pie.

Cold beer and good draft selections stand out here. The spot offers self-made brewed beer alongside Irish options like Smithwick's, making it a solid place to grab a beer before a game or show.

People are saying

"I love their cold draft and Irish beers."

"I enjoyed the cold beer and good draft selections."

"I found the shepherd's pie to be great."

Good to know

1

Make a reservation anytime there's something going on at MSG.

2

The bar is great for before or after events at Madison Square Garden.

3

The crowd gets sports heavy on game days.

12
Little Italy Pizza image 1
Little Italy Pizza image 2
Little Italy Pizza image 3
View all

Pizza restaurant offers loud music and energetic vibe with staff conversing loudly in a non-English language. Seating is clean and spacious, featuring both high tops and lower tables. Customers can enjoy beer on tap alongside pizza praised for its excellent crust and flavor.

Cold draft beers complement the New York-style pizza slices well. Options include beer on tap or in draft bottles, all served cold for a refreshing pairing.

People are saying

"They had the coldest beer in NYC."

"They have lots of big beers and sodas."

"The draft beers here go great with pizza."

Good to know

1

The location is conveniently just a 2-3 minute walk from the Port Authority Bus Terminal (PABT).

2

The price for one slice of pizza is $5.34.

3

You can choose to take away or dine in.

Discover more

Midtown South, New York

Area guide