Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Loved by locals

Cheap pie in Midtown South

You want a slice of pie that respects your budget as much as your appetite.

Based on 505 Opinions
+502
User
User
User
Updated April 2026
01
Pizza Town image 1
Pizza Town image 2
Pizza Town image 3
View all
Pizza restaurant

Small space with well-lit interiors and fans for cooling creates a straightforward setting. Atmosphere feels hot and oven-like, lacking a distinct vibe. Offers fresh, tasty pizza with a unique crust, often considered better than nearby options.

Slices offer good value with prices that stay pretty cheap. Pizza costs remain affordable throughout.

Fresh pies come with great service here. The Pepperoni Pie stands out as a solid choice.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza was amazing, especially the crispy dough and well-topped crust."

"I found the food to be delicious and fresh."

"I found the pizza to be pretty cheap and a good value."

Good to know

1

A slice of pizza costs $5.

2

The establishment is open until 4 AM.

3

You need to pay beforehand.

02
Roma Pizza & restaurant image 1
Pizza restaurant

Small, narrow space fills quickly, creating a crowded, humid atmosphere with limited seating indoors and a small patio outdoors. Pizza stands out as the best in Manhattan, drawing a lively crowd despite the tight quarters. Attention to gluten-free protocols adds a thoughtful touch to the busy vibe.

Prices stay consistently cheap here. It offers a quick and convenient option for eating without spending much.

Variety stands out with a great selection of pies available by the slice or whole. The dough and crust of the margherita pie slice are amazing, and whole pies arrive quickly, often within 10 minutes.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was delicious and perfectly baked."

"I thought the pasta was amazing, especially the rich sauce."

"I found the pizza to be cheap and yummy."

Good to know

1

The restaurant is open all night.

2

They deliver after midnight.

3

The location is a good spot near lots of subway stops and Bryant Park.

03
Quality Pizza Co. Midtown image 1

Pizza restaurant offers a clean, modern interior with comfortable seating and open kitchen design. Atmosphere is cozy and lively, featuring 80's and 90's music that creates an upbeat vibe. Lighting is better than typical pizza spots, making it inviting without feeling upscale.

Pizza costs stay super cheap, with a New York slice priced at $7. Lighting is better than many cheap spots, and the pizza comes out quick and simple while tasting great.

People are saying

"I thought the NYC style pizza slices were amazing."

"I found the pizza to be delicious and affordable."

"The pizza here is super cheap and tastes great."

Good to know

1

They offer a $7 deal that includes 2 slices and a drink of your choice.

2

The location is right near Penn Station.

3

Quality Pizza has an all day deal: 2 cheese slices with water or soda for $7.

04
Little Italy Pizza image 1
Pizza restaurant

Pizza restaurant offers loud music and energetic vibe with staff conversing loudly in a non-English language. Seating is clean and spacious, featuring both high tops and lower tables. Customers can enjoy beer on tap alongside pizza praised for its excellent crust and flavor.

Pizza costs are super cheap and offer a cheerful option for budget meals. Prices stay low but the flavors tend to be lacking.

People are saying

"The pizza here is delicious and perfectly baked."

"They had the coldest beer in NYC."

"The pizza here is super cheap and good."

Good to know

1

The location is conveniently just a 2-3 minute walk from the Port Authority Bus Terminal (PABT).

2

The price for one slice of pizza is $5.34.

3

You can choose to take away or dine in.

05
Keens Steakhouse image 1
Steak house

Exposed pipes line the ceiling, creating a historic chophouse vibe with old-school New York decor. The atmosphere feels classic and timeless, filled with vintage memorabilia and a sense of tradition. Guests enjoy a unique dining experience that blends rich history with hearty steakhouse energy.

A bottle of Malbec for $42 stands out as surprisingly cheap for Manhattan. Overall, prices feel reasonable for the quality but not cheap.

Key lime pie stands out for its light texture and strong citrus flavor. It ranks among the best pies experienced here.

People are saying

"The atmosphere and service at this Steakhouse are professional and pleasant."

"You have to try the key lime pie for dessert."

"The prime rib here is a standout dish."

Good to know

1

Reservations are required as this is a popular restaurant.

2

The portions at the steakhouse are quite big, so definitely come hungry.

3

If you mention an anniversary when reserving, they celebrate with ice cream and candles.

06
NY Pizza Suprema image 1
Pizza restaurant

Small building hides a surprisingly spacious interior with authentic New York vibe and clean dining area. Noise level runs high, creating a lively atmosphere where people get loud. Quick grab-and-carry service pairs with plenty of tables for sitting down and enjoying pizza.

Pizza slices come in big sizes and stay not soggy. Prices stay very cheap for the area with many types available.

People are saying

"I loved the delicious vegan pizza slices here."

"I experienced the perfect New York Style Pizza I ever had."

"I found the pizza to be cheap and big."

Good to know

1

Do not go when there is an event happening at Madison Square Garden.

2

You should always come before a Rangers game.

3

Card payments only start at $10, even if you just want another slice.

07
Westway Diner image 1

Classic American diner with nostalgic decor and big red banquettes creates a genuine, hardworking vibe. Atmosphere feels warm and welcoming but can be uncomfortable due to noise from dishes. Seating is cozy with comfortable booths and some outdoor options.

Prices stay cheap for New York with filling breakfast options. The place offers good value without cutting corners on service.

Apple pie stands out as a solid, classic choice. The pie and cake case offers a tempting variety, though the spinach feta pie suffers from being microwaved too much.

People are saying

"This diner has amazing, classic American comfort food."

"I found the food here to be cheap and filling."

"I stopped in for a slice of pie and it hit the right spot."

Good to know

1

Arrive early for breakfast to avoid long queues.

2

Happy hour offers $4 beers and $6 cocktails on weekdays.

3

Expect busy breakfast hours on rainy Saturdays.

Discover more

Midtown South, New York

Area guide
Loading Map...