Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Best of Midtown South

Pie

You know exactly what kind of crust and filling you want, and you have no interest in settling for anything less.

Based on 481 Opinions
+478
User
User
User
Updated July 2026
01
GRIND THE NYC COFFEE SHOP & BAGEL HOUSE image 1
GRIND THE NYC COFFEE SHOP & BAGEL HOUSE image 2
GRIND THE NYC COFFEE SHOP & BAGEL HOUSE image 3
View all

Coffee shop shines with authentic Greek design and a warm vibe from green chairs and plants. Spinach pie is a standout favorite, offering true Greek flavor. Loud music and open space make it great for working or socializing.

Spinach pie stands out as excellent and authentic, especially when warmed up. Orange pie offers a distinct, sweet flavor, and Greek cheese and spinach pies bring traditional tastes to the table.

People are saying

"I experienced the best coffee in the city."

"The staff here is so friendly and welcoming during breakfast."

"I thought the orange pie was the best."

Good to know

1

A bagel with cream cheese and a cup of coffee costs $14.

2

The cafรฉ opens before 7am for early customers.

3

The price of macaroons is $17.

02
Keens Steakhouse image 1
Steak house

Exposed pipes and vintage memorabilia create a historic chophouse vibe. Key lime pie offers a light texture with strong citrus flavor. The atmosphere blends classic tradition with hearty steakhouse energy.

Key lime pie stands out for its light texture and strong citrus flavor. It ranks among the best pies experienced here.

People are saying

"The atmosphere and service at this Steakhouse are professional and pleasant."

"I had one of the best T-bone steaks I've ever eaten."

"You have to try the key lime pie for dessert."

Good to know

1

Reservations are required as this is a popular restaurant.

2

The portions at the steakhouse are quite big, so definitely come hungry.

3

If you mention an anniversary when reserving, they celebrate with ice cream and candles.

03
Slattery's Midtown Pub image 1

Bar features a spacious balcony and many TVs for sports fans, creating a buzzing atmosphere during games with a DJ playing upbeat music. Shepherd's Pie offers good flavor and pairs well with sauces, while Chicken pot pie is a generous portion ideal for sharing.

Shepherd's Pie stands out with its good flavor and is often paired with sauces like HP or A1. Chicken pot pie serves well for sharing, offering a generous portion for two.

People are saying

"The staff made our party unforgettable and incredibly easy to plan."

"The energy here is great for Miami Dolphins fans watching live sports."

"I thought the shepherd's pie was amazing and flavorful."

Good to know

1

Happy hour offers all drinks for $6, making it a great deal.

2

The venue is ideal for hosting events or private dinners.

3

The upstairs event space can get very hot in summer.

04
Skirt Steak image 1
Steak house

Woodwork and Scandinavian design create a calm, stylish setting with a rolling dessert cart adding charm. Cherry pie shines with black cherries for rich flavor, while Key Lime Pie offers a sweet and tart finish. Atmosphere shifts from relaxing to lively near the bar.

Black cherries make the cherry pie stand out with a rich flavor. The Key Lime Pie on the dessert cart offers a satisfying, sweet and tart finish.

People are saying

"The bottomless fries here are unlimited and totally worth the price."

"The steak here is perfectly cooked and nicely flavored."

"The key lime pie with whipped cream was the star."

Good to know

1

If you like french fries, it's all you can eat.

2

Dessert is offered via a cart at $10 after the entree is finished.

3

The restaurant does not take reservations unless for a party of 7+.

05
The Playwright Irish Pub image 1

Irish pub buzzes with friendly bartenders and a rooftop view. Shepherd's pie shines with rich, hearty filling that feels like home. TVs show various sports, creating a lively mix of locals and expats.

Shepherd's pie stands out with its rich, hearty filling served in its own pot. It matches home-cooked quality and earns praise for being consistently delicious and a favorite choice.

People are saying

"The staff at this pub made me feel right at home."

"The atmosphere during games here is electric."

"The shepherd's pie was divine and phenomenal."

Good to know

1

Happy hour runs Monday to Friday starting at 3 PM.

2

Expect lively watch parties for Mets games at this location.

3

Free shots are given during nights with major sports events.

06
STK Steakhouse image 1
Steak house

Modern design and live DJ music create a lively, chic atmosphere with upbeat energy. Warm apple pie offers a flaky crust and spiced filling, perfect with ice cream. Seating ranges from spacious tables to booths with blossom trees, blending steakhouse and nightclub vibes.

Warm apple pie features a flaky crust and spiced filling. It pairs well with ice cream and tastes delicious.

People are saying

"I found the food here to be very good."

"The service for dinner spots is attentive and makes the night smooth."

"The apple pie was warm, spiced, and had a flaky crust."

Good to know

1

Happy hour includes half off appetizers and is highly recommended.

2

Avoid 6pm bookings during the week due to happy hour lasting until 6:30pm.

3

STK has a deal for $69 per person for two, including wine and appetizers.

07
Maggie Reilly's image 1

Cozy Irish pub offers a friendly vibe and outdoor seating for comfort. Shepherd's pie stands out with a rich filling and comforting texture that satisfies. Plenty of screens keep sports fans engaged in a warm, authentic setting.

Shepherd's pie features a rich filling with a comforting texture. Some versions come off as watery and lack flavor, while others are quite hearty and satisfying.

People are saying

"I found the food here to be remarkably tasty and freshly prepared."

"The staff at this pub are so friendly and engaging."

"I found the shepherd's pie to be excellent."

Good to know

1

Happy hour runs with discounts on drinks, making it a great after-work spot.

2

The kitchen closes early if no one is eating, so plan accordingly.

3

Reservations for four are easy to make before a show at MSG.

08
Mustang Harry's image 1
Restaurant

Large bar buzzes with many TVs showing sports and concerts. Shepherd's pie is home cooked and delicious, matching the lively vibe. Space feels confined despite high ceilings, drawing a young, noisy crowd.

Shepherd's pie stands out with its home cooked and delicious qualities. Chicken pot pie also ranks as very tasty and satisfying.

People are saying

"The food and drinks here are great for live sports."

"The pasta dishes here are the best I've ever had."

"I had the most amazing shepherd's pie I've ever tasted."

Good to know

1

Happy hour runs daily from 2 PM to 5 PM with drink specials.

2

Reservations are recommended if visiting before a game.

3

Expect large crowds before events, so arrive early for a table.

09
The Westbury image 1

Spacious bar buzzes with authentic Irish decor and lively music. Shepherd's pie is a delicious solid choice, while curry pie and chips impress with excellent flavor. Friendly vibe shines during major sports events.

Shepherd's pie stands out as a very delicious and solid choice here. The curry pie and chips also earn praise for their excellent flavor and quality.

People are saying

"The food here is excellent and flavorful."

"The pub staff here are super friendly and attentive."

"The curry pie and chips here are excellent."

Good to know

1

Happy hour offers $7 drafts for premium beer from 4-6pm on weekdays.

2

Trivia night occurs every Tuesday at 8pm with a $5 entry fee.

3

The kitchen closes at 9 PM, so arrive early for food.

10
The Keg Room image 1
Sports bar

Large space with over 30 TVs creates a sports-focused atmosphere. Loud music and crowd noise add to the high-energy vibe. Shepherd's pie offers a rich, hearty flavor that many find divine and satisfying.

Shepherd's pie stands out with a rich, hearty flavor and creamy texture. Some find it greasy and bland, but many describe it as divine and satisfying.

People are saying

"The food here is great, especially the steak and wings."

"They had a great choice of beer, including a Pilsner Urquell."

"I had the best Shepherd's Pie I have ever tasted."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for major events like the Super Bowl.

2

Expect large crowds during major sports events, especially on weekends.

3

The kitchen closes before the bar, so check food hours if needed.

11
Bryant Park Grill image 1

Enjoy Bourbon Apple Pie in a lively setting with garden and rooftop views of Bryant Park. Outdoor seating offers warmth from lamp heaters and live jazz, blending nature and elegance. Perfect for casual meals or special events in a climate-controlled conservatory.

Bourbon Apple Pie stands out as a top dessert choice. The apple pie is consistently delicious, while chocolate options are less impressive.

People are saying

"It's a quintessential Manhattan lunch spot with outstanding food."

"You'll love the great Scenic Views overlooking Bryant Park."

"The apple pie here is perfection."

Good to know

1

Free entertainment is available Monday to Friday from 12:30 PM to 2:30 PM through the beginning of October.

2

The venue is suitable for weddings and corporate events.

3

You need to make reservations for lunch.

Discover more

Midtown South, New York

Area guide
Loading Map...