Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Midtown South's best

Pizza and sandwich spots

You want a menu that treats a sandwich with the same respect as a pizza. You should not have to compromise on quality just because you want a different shape of dough.

Based on 739 Opinions
+736
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Slate Cafe NoMad image 1
Slate Cafe NoMad image 2
Slate Cafe NoMad image 3
View all

Cozy cafe with quiet, professional atmosphere and ample seating including cute outdoor igloo-houses. Music volume varies, sometimes loud enough to distract. Offers free water station and a refreshing, inviting interior with a view of bustling streets.

Breakfast pizza features fresh ingredients and a perfect balance of cheese. The egg can be cooked to order, making it a flavorful and satisfying option for one person.

Sandwiches come with fresh greens and insanely good bread. Options include a Dijon chickpea salad for vegans and classics like Bacon Egg and Cheese or Salmon and egg.

People are saying

"Their breakfast pizza with eggs over medium is delicious."

"The flank steak sandwich was tender and juicy."

"I found the breakfast pizza to be delicious and flavorful."

Good to know

1

You order at the counter and food comes out within a few minutes.

2

The restaurant can be crowded, so be quick to get a spot.

3

Do not go for lunch unless you have 45 minutes to spare.

02
The Ragtrader & Bo Peep Cocktail and Highball Store image 1

Small speakeasy with live jazz piano and retro decor reflecting its garment factory roots creates a cozy, intimate atmosphere. Upstairs dining offers a lively vibe with eclectic design and dim lighting. Staff and performers engage actively, enhancing the dynamic entertainment experience.

Varied pizzas include artichoke and olive and mushroom options with a perfectly crisp crust. Plain cheese pizza suits kids well and flavors range from earthy to rich.

Hot prosciutto and chicken panini with smoked mozzarella stands out. Steak and chicken sandwiches deliver solid flavor. Creative grilled cheese and coconut shrimp sandwiches add variety.

People are saying

"I thought the food here was phenomenal."

"The pizza here is amazing with a perfectly crisp crust."

"I loved the creative grilled cheese sandwich."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for the piano bar, especially on busy nights.

2

Happy hour offers half-price appetizers on weekdays from 4-7pm.

3

Wine is half price on Mondays.

03
Roma Pizza & restaurant image 1
Pizza restaurant

Small, narrow space fills quickly, creating a crowded, humid atmosphere with limited seating indoors and a small patio outdoors. Pizza stands out as the best in Manhattan, drawing a lively crowd despite the tight quarters. Attention to gluten-free protocols adds a thoughtful touch to the busy vibe.

Pizza here features a perfect sauce and crispy crust that stands out. Gluten-free options follow strict protocols with separate pans and individually wrapped cutters.

Philadelphia-style sandwiches stand out here, served alongside slices and Sicilian style options. The sandwiches come with a variety of fillings and pair well with soups and pastas.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was delicious and perfectly baked."

"I thought the pasta was amazing, especially the rich sauce."

"The staff here is super friendly and attentive."

Good to know

1

The restaurant is open all night.

2

They deliver after midnight.

3

The location is a good spot near lots of subway stops and Bryant Park.

04
Heritage Grand Bakery image 1

Small bakery with Parisian-quality pastries and an in-store bakery visible from seating. Quiet, cozy atmosphere invites lingering away from city noise. Limited seating with high stools and narrow counters creates an intimate setting.

Fresh warm bread accompanies the pizzas, which include a clam pizza and a Margarita that appeals to kids. The slices are flavorful and well-prepared, making them a solid choice for a quick meal.

Sandwiches offer amazing freshness and quality taste with options like turkey and brie baguette, prosciutto, and roast beef. Prices hover around $10, making them a great deal for a quick, satisfying meal.

People are saying

"I found the pastries to be incredibly varied and beautifully crafted."

"I really enjoyed the pizza; it was soft and crispy."

"I loved the chicken salad sandwich on soft, golden bread."

Good to know

1

During the soft opening week, customers can enjoy pre-opening 50% off.

2

Happy hour runs daily from 4-6pm with discounted drinks.

3

Expect to wait for a seat during busy hours, especially on weekends.

05
Pan dโ€™oro Italian Cafe image 1

Narrow, cozy space with bright lighting and a pastry display featuring Italian sweets like zeppole and cannoli. Warm, welcoming atmosphere with authentic Italian flavors and expertly prepared fresh pasta. Often quiet early, sometimes loud later, offering a charming spot for coffee or a meal.

Fresh pizzas come with authentic Italian flavors, including focaccia and Italian sweet pasta. Slices cost about $7 and pair well with rich coffee or a cold Coke.

Soft, buttery sandwiches come fresh and big, often served alongside Italian pastries and croissants. Panini and other sandwiches taste delicious and pair well with cappuccino.

People are saying

"I found the pastries here to be excellent and delicious."

"I thought the pizza here was amazing and really good."

"I found the sandwiches here to be amazing and delicious."

Good to know

1

Expect to pay around $8 for a pastry at this cafรฉ.

2

The cafรฉ does not display prices on the menu, which can be confusing.

3

The total for two hot chocolates and a pastry can reach $35.

06
Angelina Bakery HSQ image 1

Space combines intimate seating with a modern, classy vibe and a full bar offering craft cocktails. Music plays loudly, especially with a DJ on weekends, creating a lively atmosphere that suits dates and gatherings. Tables sit close together, enhancing a cozy but energetic feel.

Pizza comes with a thin, crispy crust and fresh toppings like basil and cheese. Wood oven cooking adds a smoky, authentic flavor to both classic and creative gourmet options.

Affordable and savory sandwiches stand out here. The spot offers good breakfast sandwiches in a cute setting.

People are saying

"I found the food here delicious and hand-crafted."

"The pizza here is delicious and made with quality ingredients."

"I found the sandwiches here to be affordable and delicious."

Good to know

1

Happy hour specials are available on weekdays from 4-7pm.

2

The restaurant gets busy on Friday nights, so arrive early.

3

Nighttime parties happen on weekends with a DJ after 9pm.

07
Don Pepi Deli image 1
Pizza restaurant

Pizza restaurant inside a busy train station offers a lively atmosphere suited for quick meals. It serves consistently excellent pizza with a magical sauce and flavors that stand out among nearby options. The place mainly attracts tourists passing through and provides a fast-paced dining experience.

Slices come with a thin, crispy crust that avoids doughiness. Pepperoni, sausage, and onion toppings taste like a restaurant meal, not typical takeaway. This spot stays busy and delivers consistently amazing pizza even inside a train station.

Deli sandwiches use Boar's Head meats and come together quickly, often in about 2 minutes. Options like ham and cheese with fresh veggies are served warm and pair well with a cold beer.

People are saying

"I always grab a slice of their amazing pizza when I pass through Penn Station."

"I loved the fresh, crusty New York Style Pizza."

"It's the best place to grab a freshly made sandwich."

Good to know

1

The price for 2 slices, soda, and tax is around $15.00.

2

The buffalo chicken pizza costs $6 a slice.

3

Expect a busy atmosphere due to the location in the station.

08
Refinery Rooftop image 1
American restaurant

Rooftop space offers breathtaking Empire State Building views with a retractable glass roof for open-air or sheltered enjoyment. Atmosphere mixes lively, well-curated music suited for dancing with occasional loudness. Crowds gather early, making reservations essential for access to this popular urban rooftop bar.

Flatbreads stand out with options like pepperoni flatbread that is spicy and slightly sweet, and a margherita flatbread that is simple and fresh. Pizzas include a white mushroom scallion variety and a pizza trio, all noted for strong flavors.

Offers a fairly extensive food menu with sandwiches, sliders, and a grilled chicken club. The steak sandwich and burger stand out as excellent choices.

People are saying

"The Rooftop service is so attentive and makes the experience extra special."

"The sandwiches here are great with a view of the Empire State Building."

"The truffle pizza was the highlight of my visit."

Good to know

1

Reservations are highly recommended, especially during busy hours.

2

Happy hour starts at 3:30 PM and is popular among guests.

3

Brunch is served until 2:30 PM on Saturdays.

09
Jerusalem Cafe image 1
Kosher restaurant

Spacious kosher restaurant with two floors of seating and a self-serve setup featuring a pizza bar, salad bar, and sushi. Atmosphere feels airy and friendly, resembling a casual business lunch spot rather than a formal dining experience. Plenty of seating and amenities like WiFi and outlets support a relaxed, easygoing vibe.

Garlic knot crust pizza stands out with a delicious flavor. The menu includes a wide variety of pizzas, all noted for being tasty and well-prepared.

Offers a wide choice of sandwiches including an XL tuna melt bagel and falafel options. Sandwiches come alongside soups and salads, with options to order to go.

People are saying

"It's a great kosher place with delicious food."

"I thought the pizza here was amazing and delicious."

"The sandwich here is clean and spacious."

Good to know

1

The restaurant is kosher and offers a variety of options for kosher consumers.

2

A regular lunch in the cafeteria costs $35, with pizza slices at $6.

3

Parking in the area can be difficult to find.

10
Parker & Quinn image 1
American restaurant

Historic decor and cozy booths create an intimate, lively atmosphere with live music enhancing the experience. Small, oblong space feels warm but can be noisy, making conversation challenging. Access to a rooftop bar offers city views and a quieter alternative to the main dining area.

Flatbreads like the Margherita and Bianca stand out with fresh, simple toppings. The chef personally explains any pizza delays, showing care in service.

Breakfast sandwiches come with a little salad and pair well with a Cappuccino and freshly squeezed orange juice. The French dip sandwich offers a great size for hunger without feeling stuffed.

People are saying

"The Brunch food here is delicious and very fresh."

"The grilled cheese sandwich was delicious and paired well with soup."

"The pizza here is amazing, with attentive service all around."

Good to know

1

Reservations are highly recommended, especially on busy nights.

2

Expect a one-hour wait for tables during peak hours.

3

The last order is taken at 10:30 PM.

11
Fresh Pizza and Deli image 1
Pizza restaurant

New York-style pizza shop offers friendly atmosphere with calm vibes and a wide variety of dishes. Pizza features a soft crust with balanced sauce and cheese, providing a fresh and tasty experience. Prices are affordable, making it a practical spot for quick, casual meals.

Slices come huge and tasty with a soft crust and rich cheese flavor. Prices stay reasonable while the pizza stays fresh and flavorful.

Sandwiches come in huge, stacked layers that deliver a lot of flavor in each bite. Options include deli breakfast sandwiches that are decent, alongside other items like pizza and burgers.

People are saying

"I found the food here to be great for the price."

"These pizza slices are authentically New York, like a Spike Lee film."

"I thought the pizza was great for the price."

Good to know

1

A cheese slice costs $1.50, while a large slice of cheese pizza costs $2.

2

You can get two cheese slices and a can of soda for $5.

3

They offer two slices of cheese and a drink for $4.99.

Discover more

Midtown South, New York

Area guide
Loading Map...