Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Loved by locals

Pie date spots in Midtown West

You believe that sharing a slice of pie is the most honest way to gauge if a date is going well.

Based on 567 Opinions
+564
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Redeye Grill image 1
Redeye Grill image 2
Redeye Grill image 3
View all
American restaurant

Semi-private rooms with high ceilings and gorgeous bar create a warm, buzzing atmosphere. Live piano music covers a wide range of genres, adding to the sophisticated vibe. Walls feature unique NYC-inspired murals that enhance the energetic setting.

Very vibey with a setting suited for date nights and special occasions like anniversaries. Offers a relaxed atmosphere for late dinners and intimate conversations.

Banana cream pie stands out as a signature dessert, often paired with sparkling rosรฉ. It features a rich, creamy texture that complements the meal and is frequently recommended.

People are saying

"The food here is amazing, full of flavor."

"The food here is terrific, especially the fresh guacamole."

"You have to try the banana cream pie; it's superb."

Good to know

1

Happy Hour is from 3 PM to 6 PM on weekdays.

2

The restaurant offers bottomless brunch on Sundays.

3

Live music is featured on weekend evenings, typically jazz.

02
Brooklyn Diner USA image 1

Classic diner space with cherry wood decor and vintage neon signage creates a nostalgic 1960s vibe. Atmosphere shifts from laid-back mornings to chaotic, noisy evenings with loud music. Outdoor seating offers a pleasant alternative to the lively interior.

Couples get seated quickly and can enjoy large portions like the spicy chicken and bacon cheeseburger. Staff handle food allergies carefully, ensuring safe meals without cross contamination.

Chicken pot pie stands out for its size and flavor, often running out quickly. It pairs well with pastrami and offers a hearty portion that can feed two people.

People are saying

"The diner food, especially the pastrami sandwich, is delicious."

"The food here is great for a date spot."

"I thought the chicken pot pie was huge and delicious."

Good to know

1

Expect to pay around $120 for three dishes at the diner.

2

The diner offers takeout options for those on the go.

3

You need to order one menu item per person.

03
Carnegie Diner & Cafe image 1

Upscale diner with cramped seating and dim lighting creates a classic yet hectic atmosphere. Live music and a small patio add to the vibe, while bottomless mimosas and standout dishes like the burger and French toast draw attention. Crowds fill the space, making it lively but noisy.

Intimate setting creates a comfortable space for conversation. Cozy ambiance pairs well with aromatic freshly brewed coffee and ends with a slice of tiramisu cake for a sweet finish.

Pies here come with a buttery flaky crust and balanced flavors, like the key lime pie that is neither too sweet nor too tart. Options include pumpkin pie and apple pie pancakes that serve as a hearty breakfast or two meals.

People are saying

"The food here is a peaceful escape from busy routines."

"The food here is incredible, especially the chicken and waffles."

"You have to try the pies; the key lime and Greek orange were amazing."

Good to know

1

Make reservations for Easter Sunday to ensure a spot.

2

Unlimited mimosas for $20 are available every day all day.

3

Bottomless mimosas and waffles are available on Sunday morning.

04
Cassidys Pub image 1

Pub offers a traditional Irish vibe with classic dรฉcor and plenty of TVs for sports fans. Atmosphere is loud and crowded, especially during lunch and events, creating a lively and energetic setting. Features include a pool table and outdoor seating, adding to the social environment.

Friendly staff accommodate requests like showing sports games. Sharing buffalo wings, French onion soup, and a pint creates a casual, relaxed vibe for couples.

Shepherd's pie stands out with consistent praise for its flavor. The chicken pot pie also earns strong marks for being delicious and well-made.

People are saying

"The bar staff here are super friendly and welcoming."

"The staff here are so welcoming and helpful for Date Spots."

"I thought the chicken pot pie was delicious."

Good to know

1

Happy hour is available every day from 5 PM to 8 PM.

2

The pub fills up to maximum capacity during happy hours.

3

Karaoke nights are hosted regularly.

05
P. McDaidโ€™s Irish Pub image 1

Traditional Irish decor creates a cozy, warm setting with live music and multiple televisions broadcasting sports. Outdoor terrace offers a rare open-air option on a busy avenue. Atmosphere suits music and sports fans, combining stylish charm with a lively yet comfortable vibe.

Cozy spot for couples with well-catered Irish pub meals like fish and chips. Drinks include authentic Guinness and a spicy mango margarita for variety.

Shepherd's Pie features a perfect balance of filling and mashed potatoes. It tastes very tasty and comes across as fantastic on Saturdays.

People are saying

"The drinks here are great and varied."

"You can watch all the games on the many TVs here."

"The staff here are so friendly, it makes for a great date spot."

Good to know

1

The kitchen is open late at the Irish Pub.

2

Expect a 20% gratuity automatically added to your bill.

3

Live music happens on Saturday nights.

06
Loi Estiatorio image 1
Greek restaurant

Greek restaurant showcases traditional blue and white decor with candlelit ambiance that feels warm and inviting. Guests enjoy private outdoor seating and artistic Greek music, creating a cozy and intimate atmosphere. The space welcomes groups and celebrations with a friendly, home-like vibe.

Offers a cozy atmosphere suited for a quick bite or a relaxed evening. Fits well for date nights or family outings with its inviting setting.

Spinach pie stands out as authentic and consistently offered, often served as spanikopitas. The octopus appetizer pairs well, making the pie experience distinctive here.

People are saying

"The desserts, like baklava and chocolate cake, were rich and sweet."

"The Mediterranean food here is amazing, especially the appetizers."

"You have to try the spinach pie; it's incomparable."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended due to the restaurant's popularity.

2

Last seating is at 9 PM, even though the restaurant closes at 10 PM.

3

The restaurant accommodates gluten-free diets and uses no butter in dishes.

07
53 image 1
Restaurant

Two-story restaurant combines intimate upstairs with lively downstairs for varied dining moods. Interior showcases stunning, sophisticated design that feels cozy despite no windows. Unique Asian fusion menu pairs with standout cocktails and carefully curated wine selections.

Beautiful setting creates a perfect date night vibe. Suitable for first dates or anniversaries with a mid- to high-end feel.

Duck pie tee stands out with its flavor explosion and juiciness. It ranks as the most notable pie dish here.

People are saying

"The food here is amazing, truly made with love."

"The food and drinks here are amazing for Date Spots."

"I thought the duck pie was amazing."

Good to know

1

Reservations are needed for lunch at this place.

2

You should book your table immediately.

3

Expect to spend over $200 for two people.

08
Magnolia Bakery - Rockefeller Center image 1

Small bakery with vintage-inspired decor creates a cozy atmosphere despite a chaotic layout and long queues. The space lacks seating, leading many to eat outside. It draws crowds with its large selection of cakes and cookies and a reputation for standout desserts.

Banana pudding stands out as a sweet highlight, loved by many regardless of their usual preferences. The spot offers a cozy vibe that fits well for a relaxed date with a shared dessert experience.

Banana cream pie and pumpkin pie stand out with rich, classic flavors. Other notable pies include coconut, pecan, lemon icebox, and key lime, all served alongside homemade cupcakes and banana pudding.

People are saying

"I thought the banana pudding was sweet and delicious."

"The banana pudding here is creamy, dreamy, and melts in your mouth."

"I found the famous banana pie to be delicious."

Good to know

1

There is a separate line to order the banana pudding versus other bakery items.

2

You must order anything that is not pudding outside the line before getting in the long line.

3

If you're short on time, you can order your treats online and pick them up at the store to avoid the wait.

Discover more

Midtown West, New York

Area guide
Loading Map...