Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Local picks

Italian food in Murray Hill

A craving for handmade pasta or wood-fired crusts settles in when nothing else will do.

Based on 567 Opinions
+564
User
User
User
Updated April 2026
01
Villa Berulia image 1
Villa Berulia image 2
Villa Berulia image 3
View all

Inside arches create a stylish space with an Old New York vibe and warm energy. Lamb shank with gnocchi shines in the Italian cuisine, paired with an extensive grappa selection. Classic pasta dishes are made to order, enhancing the distinctive menu.

Lamb shank with gnocchi stands out as a special main dish. Marinara sauce is second to none. Classic Italian pasta dishes can be made to order, even if not on the menu.

People are saying

"The Italian food here is amazing, with friendly and attentive service."

"The Italian food here is truly authentic and delicious."

"They nail classic Italian dishes with amazing detail."

Good to know

1

Villa Berulia can accommodate large groups, seating teams of 12 within 30 minutes.

2

The restaurant can accommodate guests with celiac disease and a nut allergy.

3

Party packages are available and offer great value for events.

02
Previti Pasta & Pizza image 1
Previti Pasta & Pizza image 2
Previti Pasta & Pizza image 3
View all

Cozy spot with a terrace facing the street offers a chill vibe and quiet seating. Italian dishes shine with penne vodka and pepperoni cups on fresh mozzarella delivering great flavor. Prices stay affordable, making it a balanced choice for pizza lovers.

Pizza and pasta stand out with great flavor and generous portions. The penne vodka and pepperoni cups on fresh mozzarella are especially notable for taste and quality.

People are saying

"The Italian food here, especially the pizza and pasta, is amazing and fresh."

"I really enjoyed their pizza and pasta."

"The pasta is tasty and comes in big portions."

Good to know

1

The establishment now closes at 7:16 PM.

2

You need to get to the restaurant before 7:30 PM if you want anything other than pizza because they close the kitchen early.

3

The total price for a supreme slice and soda was $7.xx.

03
Sam's Place image 1
Sam's Place image 2
Sam's Place image 3
View all

Small Italian spot offers huge chicken under mozzarella and delicate tortellini in Alfredo sauce. Cozy, old-school vibe creates a friendly, family-like atmosphere with easy conversation. Known for generous wine pours and authentic flavors.

Chicken under mozzarella comes huge and piping hot with a lemon sauce. Tortellini features delicate pasta in a heavenly Alfredo sauce. Chicken piccata is made without butter for dairy restrictions.

People are saying

"I love the authentic Italian food and vibe here."

"The homemade Italian food here is so creamy and satisfying."

"It's a cozy, old-school Italian spot perfect for dates."

Good to know

1

The entrees are around $20 a plate, excluding the veal chop.

2

The portions are large, so expect to take leftovers home.

3

The restaurant does not have a cocktail menu, but you can order any drink you like.

04
Previti Pizza 41st St. image 1
Previti Pizza 41st St. image 2
Previti Pizza 41st St. image 3
View all

Typical NYC pizza joint buzzes with crispy thin-crust slices and a lively vibe. Pasta dishes shine with consistent deliciousness while flavorful mozzarella sticks add a tasty twist. High-tech ordering and classic rock music keep the energy up.

Pizza and focaccia come with a crispy bottom and a large selection of toppings. Pasta dishes are consistently delicious. Mozzarella sticks stand out as very flavorful.

People are saying

"The pizza here tastes fresh and delicious."

"The Italian food here is authentic New York pizza, crispy and juicy."

"I love the pasta and the mozzarella sticks here."

Good to know

1

Pro tip: go with cash for quicker transactions.

2

Expect long wait times during peak hours, especially on weekends.

3

Seating is limited, so plan for takeout if it's busy.

05
Cinico Coffee Company image 1
Cinico Coffee Company image 2
Cinico Coffee Company image 3
View all

Cafe blends modern Italian vibe with a quiet atmosphere perfect for work, featuring Wi-Fi and outlets. Menu highlights classic lasagna and focaccia, plus a unique tiramisu croissant with espresso. Staff speak with Italian accents, enhancing the authentic feel.

Purely Italian dishes focus on lasagna and focaccia, with options for vegans and vegetarians. The tiramisu croissant offers a unique twist by injecting espresso into the pastry before eating.

People are saying

"I love the authentic Italian coffee and vibe here."

"The focaccia sandwiches here are generously portioned and crispy."

"I enjoyed the strong Italian espresso and sweets."

Good to know

1

The coffee shop is open until 9 PM.

2

Prices are steep, with lattes around $8 and croissants at $5.

3

The menu offers a delightful selection of amazing dishes.

06
Allโ€™Antico Vinaio image 1
Allโ€™Antico Vinaio image 2
Allโ€™Antico Vinaio image 3
View all

Italian sandwich shop shines with fresh mortadella and stracciatella cheese. Clean interior offers bar stools and quick service during lunch rush. Sandwiches feature beautiful bread and bold flavors like spicy eggplant and salty prosciutto.

Fresh ingredients like mortadella, stracciatella cheese, and pistachio cream stand out. Sandwiches combine textures and flavors, such as spicy eggplant with bread or salty prosciutto with sun-dried tomatoes and burrata.

People are saying

"The sandwiches are fresh, huge, and filling."

"These Italian sandwiches are fantastic and huge, easily feeding two."

"I love the fresh mortadella and creamy stracciatella."

Good to know

1

It gets busy on weekends due to nearby offices.

2

Sandwiches cost around $20 and can serve two people.

3

Portion sizes have decreased over time, affecting value.

07
Rossini's image 1
Rossini's image 2
Rossini's image 3
View all

Northern Italian restaurant shines with authentic risotto and gluten-free pasta options. Tuxedo-clad servers and live opera create a romantic atmosphere perfect for special occasions. Rustic decor and multi-level seating add to the cozy, intimate vibe.

Risotto stands out with its rich, creamy texture. Lasagna features sausage and bolognese sauce. Spaghetti Carbonara matches authentic Italian style. Tiramisu offers a classic, creamy finish. Gluten-free pasta options accommodate dietary needs.

People are saying

"The Italian food here is authentic and delicious."

"I love the classic Italian dishes that taste like home."

"The place has a charming old-school Italian vibe."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended well in advance to secure a table.

2

Live entertainment with a pianist and singer occurs on Friday and Saturday nights.

3

Expect to spend around $100 per person for a full meal.

08
Serafina Madison 38th (Midtown) image 1
Serafina Madison 38th (Midtown) image 2
Serafina Madison 38th (Midtown) image 3
View all

Spacious Italian spot offers fresh pasta with gluten-free options and rich risotto. Romantic decor with candlelit tables sets a cozy yet classy mood. Enjoy live music by the lively bar or relax on the heated patio with strong air conditioning.

Fresh pasta comes with gluten-free options and pairs well with meatballs and marinara. Risotto with porcini mushrooms and tiramisu dessert highlight the Italian menu.

People are saying

"The Italian food, especially the ravioli, is so creamy and flavorful."

"I think the Italian food here is good."

"I think this is the best modern Italian place around."

Good to know

1

The restaurant automatically includes a 20% tip for parties of 5 or more.

2

You can only pay using Apple Pay; cash and cards are not accepted.

3

The restaurant does not have a liquor license, so no cocktails are available.

09
Tiberias image 1
Tiberias image 2
Tiberias image 3
View all

Kosher dining shines with creamy pasta and perfectly cooked sea bass in an upscale setting. Comfortable chairs and a glass bar create a calm, inviting vibe. Soft music enhances the chill atmosphere, perfect for a city escape.

Creamy pasta dishes like tortellini and penne stand out with rich, flavorful sauces. Seafood options such as branzino and baked sea bass come cooked to perfection alongside classic pastas and pizza pesto.

People are saying

"Some pasta dishes were great, but others felt overpriced."

"The pasta dishes here are delicious and perfectly prepared."

"The pizza fries, mozzarella sticks, and gnocchi are the best I've had."

Good to know

1

A mandatory 20% gratuity is added to your bill without prior notice.

2

Expect high prices, with dishes like fettuccine costing $32.

3

The establishment claims to close at 12am, but doors may lock earlier.

10
Libretto's Pizza image 1
Libretto's Pizza image 2
Libretto's Pizza image 3
View all

Small, cozy pizzeria offers authentic New York vibe and classic Italian dishes like Spaghetti Bolognaise and tiramisu. Friendly, casual atmosphere with dim lighting makes it perfect for relaxed dining. Unique pizza options include vodka sauce slices and customizable pesto toppings.

Tiramisu and cannoli stand out as classic Italian desserts here. Pasta dishes like Spaghetti Bolognaise come in generous portions and taste like traditional Italian cooking. Pizza options include unique slices like vodka with creamy sauce and fresh mozzarella, plus customizable pesto toppings.

People are saying

"The Italian food here, especially the pizza and pasta, is the best I've ever had."

"Some pasta dishes had sauce that was too sweet or watery."

"The tiramisu and cannoli were absolutely delicious."

Good to know

1

The prices for pizza slices are low: $3 for plain, $4 for regular, and $5 for special slices.

2

The restaurant is open late for those craving pizza at night.

3

It is super quick to get a slice if you need something to eat fast.

11
Madison & Vine image 1
Madison & Vine image 2
Madison & Vine image 3
View all

Cozy spot with intimate atmosphere and enclosed outdoor seating perfect for casual dates or business lunches. Italian dishes shine with mushroom risotto offering a rich, truffle aroma. Unique visible basement kitchen adds charm to the clean, well-planned space.

Mushroom risotto stands out with a lingering undergrowth aroma likely from truffle oil and leaves a lasting scent on the palate. Other dishes include grilled shrimp with mushroom risotto, Sicilian sausage pasta, linguine, and a burrata appetizer that varies from its online photo.

People are saying

"I loved the mushroom risotto but had mixed feelings about other dishes."

"The Italian food here is delicious and worth the cost."

"The mushroom risotto was the best I've had, but the burrata lacked flavor."

Good to know

1

Brunch is only available on Saturday and Sunday.

2

Even at happy hour with 25% off, cocktails are still $14-15.

3

The bill for 3 persons was $300.

Discover more

Murray Hill, New York

Area guide
Loading Map...