Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Top picks in Nolita

Ice cream desserts

You want a dessert menu that prioritizes a variety of ice cream options.

Based on 604 Opinions
+601
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Figo il Gelato Italiano image 1
Figo il Gelato Italiano image 2
Figo il Gelato Italiano image 3
View all

Small gelato shop offers authentic Italian flavors with vibrant, creamy gelato displayed in a clean, modern space. Outdoor seating includes comfortable tables and heaters, complemented by a live DJ that creates a lively atmosphere. The spot blends Little Italy ambiance with a relaxed yet energetic vibe.

Offers authentic Italian desserts with standout items like buttery, chocolatey dessert salami and refreshing gelato flavors. The affogato serves as a classic, satisfying finish after dinner.

Gelato quality stands out as exceptional, with flavors like Cioccomenta and Amarena Amore Mio noted for their richness. The Figo flavor is often highlighted as a unique and memorable experience.

People are saying

"This is the best gelato I've ever had."

"The pistachio gelato is creamy and full of flavor."

"I found the desserts here to be amazing and delicious."

Good to know

1

There is no public bathroom at this gelato shop.

2

Prices for gelato start around $6 for a single scoop.

3

Vegan and dairy-free options are available.

02
Mimi's Frozen Yogurt image 1
Frozen yogurt shop

Bright, chic space with large windows offers a warm, inviting atmosphere and trendy design. Lines grow long in the evenings, attracting a crowd seeking fresh, high-quality frozen yogurt with unique toppings. Location on a busy block encourages casual people-watching alongside enjoying the treat.

Offers feel-good frozen yogurt that makes desserts worth the calories. Stands out as a go-to dessert spot with treats that satisfy cravings without regret.

Frozen yogurt features a creamy texture with fresh toppings and unique gourmet options. Mango soft serve stands out as creamier than tart flavors, while raspberry sorbet offers a tasty alternative.

People are saying

"The frozen yogurt here is honestly that good."

"I found the ice cream here to be really delicious."

"These desserts are worth every single calorie."

Good to know

1

Expect long lines in the evenings; arrive early to avoid waiting.

2

Frozen yogurt costs $1.20 per ounce, leading to average bills of $16-$18.

3

The store has limited topping options, and nut toppings are not clearly separated.

03
Sant Ambroeus Lafayette image 1
Italian restaurant

Small Italian restaurant offers an elegant Milanese escape with brass lighting, marble surfaces, and soft tan leather seating. Outdoor patio features private dining cabins with heaters and blankets for comfort. Atmosphere stays welcoming and cozy with a noise level that allows easy conversation.

Tiramisu and panna cotta impress with their taste and presentation. A hazelnut layered dessert stands out, and an unexpected birthday dessert adds a nice touch.

Italian gelato stands out with flavors like pistachio, raspberry, and strawberry. The gelato pairs well with coffee and offers a refreshing treat on hot days.

People are saying

"The Italian food here, especially the pasta, is heavenly and delicious."

"I fell in love with this spot for coffee."

"I found the gelato here to be amazing and delicious."

Good to know

1

Reservations are required to secure a table, especially during peak hours.

2

Expect a wait time of over 2 hours during busy weekends.

3

The pasta bolognese costs $31, and the linguine alle vongole is $34.

04
Milk Bar image 1
Dessert shop

Small shop fronts with takeout-only service create a quick, casual vibe. Colorful, fun branding contrasts with limited seating and a walk-up window setup at some locations. Unique flavors like cereal milk soft serve and cake crumble toppings define the menu's distinctive character.

Birthday Cake stands out as a moist, flavorful, and perfectly sweet dessert. The combination of cereal milk ice cream and cornflake crunch creates a unique late night treat.

Soft serve stands out with its creamy texture and comes topped with cereals or paired with cookies. The pancake soft serve offers a unique twist that adds to the delicious experience.

People are saying

"The cereal milk ice cream here is the best I've ever tasted."

"I wished I had more of the delicious Milk Bar pie."

"I found their desserts to be amazing and a must-do."

Good to know

1

Milk Bar is a takeout only spot with no indoor seating available.

2

Street parking is the only option available near the location.

3

The price for a small cup of soft serve ice cream is $9.50 with tax.

05
Momoya SoHo image 1
Japanese restaurant

Two levels of modern Tiffany blue decor surround windows with city views. Seating feels cramped and close, creating an intimate but sometimes intrusive atmosphere. Sake and cocktails receive strong attention, complementing the sophisticated vibe.

Parfaits stand out with their tart, crunchy, and flavorful layers, especially the seasonal Hana Kanmuri. Desserts like the sake pear mousse and red bean chocolate cake offer unique tastes reminiscent of authentic Japanese sweets.

Sorbet options include a pink pineapple flavor that pairs well with passion fruit. Unique choices like soy sauce ice cream appear alongside traditional ones such as hojicha ice cream, often served with desserts like mille-feuille aux banana featuring rich cream and caramelized banana.

People are saying

"The Japanese food here, especially the sushi, is amazing and fresh."

"The desserts here are gorgeous, intricate, and delicious."

"Our server Nick made my birthday special with the ice cream."

Good to know

1

Reservations are advisable due to busy times, especially during Restaurant Week.

2

Happy hour runs from 5-6 PM with discounted drinks.

3

The restaurant offers a special menu during Restaurant Week.

06
Torrisi image 1
Italian restaurant

Space combines warm tones and vintage greens with high vaulted ceilings for a luxurious dining atmosphere. Music blends soul, jazz, and 70’s R&B, creating a lively yet refined vibe. Cocktails and Italian dishes feature bold, unique flavors that match the elegant setting.

Desserts feature a green apple dish that stands out for its flavor. All options tried are very good, making it easy to want to return just for dessert and drinks.

Frozen affogato features vanilla-packed ice cream with chocolate syrup and shaved espresso. Frozen yogurt offers a fluffy texture with pink-grapefruit pulp and fruity green olive oil.

People are saying

"The tortellini here is probably the best I’ve ever had."

"You have to try the desserts; they're enormous."

"You have to try the affogato; it's a coffee-flavored ice cream dream."

Good to know

1

Reservations open 30 days in advance but fill instantly.

2

Getting a reservation is super hard unless you want to wait in line right before they open at 5 PM.

3

If you can’t get a reservation, arrive before 5 PM to wait in line for walk-in seating at the bar.

07
Ma•dé image 1
Indonesian restaurant

Small, intimate space with Tulum-inspired decor and a tiki bar vibe creates a cozy, tropical atmosphere. Balanced upbeat energy with unique cocktails and sophisticated beach-themed design transports diners away from the city. Tight seating encourages a close, lively dining experience.

Black sesame ice cream stands out with its unique flavor. The chocolate mousse impresses with rich texture, and the cheese dessert paired with red wine offers a refined finish.

Black sesame ice cream stands out with a rich, nutty flavor paired often with raspberry sorbet or chocolate mousse. Unique combinations like basil ice cream with mango pudding add a fresh, creamy twist to the desserts.

People are saying

"The seafood, like the butterfish and oyster, was executed with care."

"You have to try the desserts; the chocolate mousse is amazing."

"The black sesame ice cream with chocolate mousse was amazing."

Good to know

1

Reservations are a must, especially on Friday and Saturday nights.

2

Expect a 20% service charge for large parties, even for two people.

3

The restaurant has limited gluten-free options and cannot modify dishes for dietary needs.

08
Peasant image 1
Italian restaurant

Italian restaurant offers a romantic, dimly lit atmosphere with candles and dried flowers creating a cozy, intimate vibe. A downstairs wine bar provides a quiet space for conversation, while the wood-burning smoker adds unique flavor to dishes. Tables sit close together, giving a slightly cramped feel but enhancing the lively energy.

Desserts here are mouthwatering and bursting with flavors. They stand out enough to make up for the steak.

Coffee flavored gelato and olive oil ice cream stand out with rich, unique tastes. Roasted strawberries and berries pair well with the ice cream, balancing warmth and coolness in desserts.

People are saying

"The rigatoni and carbonara are amazing Italian food."

"The desserts here are mouthwatering and bursting with flavor."

"The roasted strawberries with olive oil gelato was an unbelievable finish."

Good to know

1

Reservations are highly suggested for a romantic evening or special occasion.

2

Parking is available right out front on busy nights.

3

Expect to pay around $200 per person, including tip and wine.

09
La Churreria image 1
Spanish restaurant

Small indoor space seats about 10 with an outdoor table, creating an intimate and cozy setting. Warm, welcoming vibe with great music and seasonal decorations adds charm. Known for authentic churros and fun atmosphere, though seating can feel cramped and busy.

Desserts here are simply exceptional and often described as mind-blowing. They offer to go options like stuffed churros, making sweets easy to enjoy anywhere.

Churro ice cream sandwiches stand out with flavors like Honey Lavender and Salted Caramel. The churros pair well with creamy ice cream, including a refreshing cantaloupe option and classic vanilla.

People are saying

"These churros are delicious, hot, and crispy right from the order."

"The churros with ice cream are delicious."

"Their exclusive desserts, like the Dubai Chocolate Toast, were mind-blowing."

Good to know

1

Be prepared to wait for a table, especially during busy hours.

2

Get there early if you plan on dining in, as seating is limited.

3

They offer 5 churros for $4.50, a great deal for a sweet treat.

10
Gelateria Gentile - Nolita image 1

Small gelato shop offers cozy indoor and outdoor seating with Italian pop music creating a comfortable vibe. Gelato features authentic, artisanal flavors without artificial additives, including standout options like pistachio and Bergamotta. Space is limited but atmosphere remains pleasant and inviting.

Desserts and pastries taste delightful and offer a tasty finish. Service mood can affect the experience of enjoying or taking desserts home.

Artisanal Italian gelato stands out with high-quality pistachio and hazelnut flavors. The ice cream is refreshing and rich in tradition, offering some of the best gelato experiences around.

People are saying

"The gelato here is authentic Italian and incredibly smooth."

"The staff here are so kind and funny, they made it enjoyable."

"I experienced authentic Italian gelato carrying the weight of tradition."

Good to know

1

There is free street parking available at night.

2

The shop is open until midnight, which is convenient for late night cravings.

3

The price charged was $19.60 for about 2 scoops total.

11
Kimika image 1
Japanese restaurant

Japanese restaurant blends Japanese/Italian fusion with gorgeous interiors and a heated outdoor patio. Atmosphere shifts from intimate and quiet for family dinners to lively and fun for large parties. Bar seating and small event spaces create a versatile, welcoming environment.

Yakult soft serve stands out as an exceptional dessert here. Staff accommodate seating changes smoothly so you can enjoy desserts while catching up.

Yakult soft serve stands out with its refreshing flavor and unique crispy chicken skin streusel topping. It pairs well with desserts like lava cake and Apple Crostini served with ice cream.

People are saying

"The Italian food here is amazing, especially the truffle carbonara."

"You have to try their desserts, especially the matcha French toast."

"The apple pie comes with a very small amount of espresso ice cream."

Good to know

1

Reservations are required to secure a table, especially on weekends.

2

You must provide your phone number for reservations, which may lead to spam.

3

Expect to pay around $200 for two without drinks.

12
Wayan image 1
Indonesian restaurant

Indoor and outdoor spaces blend earthy decor with plant-filled design creating a cozy, spacious setting. Atmosphere shifts from laid-back Bali beach club vibes to intimate and trendy, suitable for groups or quiet dining. Cocktails stand out as fab and inventive, complementing a menu that fuses Indonesian and French flavors.

Desserts feature a unique Indonesian spin on classic recipes. Highlights include passion fruit custard and a banana sundae with taro ice cream.

Ube ice cream appears in several desserts, pairing well with banana bread and banana cake. The cheddar ice cream served with a chocolate chip cookie skillet offers a rich, unusual flavor combination.

People are saying

"The food here is beautifully presented and flavorful."

"The pandan custard dessert is the star of the show."

"The ube and cheddar ice cream flavors were a delicious surprise."

Good to know

1

Reservations are required to secure a table, especially during peak hours.

2

Expect long wait times during weekends, particularly for dinner.

3

Prices are considered expensive for the portion sizes offered.

13
Thai Diner image 1
Thai restaurant

American diner setting blends with Thai-style decor featuring plants and art, creating a vibrant atmosphere. Outdoor seating offers a cozy, multi-season space that welcomes dogs and service animals. Crowd tends to be cool and lively, with dim lighting and a mix of indoor and outdoor areas.

Mango sticky rice features plenty of mango and pairs well with coconut ice cream. Thai coffee cake offers a rich, sweet finish to the meal.

Coconut ice cream stands out as a key dessert, often paired with banana rum pudding or served in a sundae. These options highlight the dessert menu with rich, tropical flavors.

People are saying

"The diner food here is flavorful, comforting, and perfectly executed."

"You have to try the sundae dessert; it's huge and beautiful."

"The coconut ice cream sundae was the best I had."

Good to know

1

Expect a wait of 1.5 hours during peak hours, especially on weekends.

2

Reservations are recommended for breakfast to avoid long wait times.

3

The restaurant serves brunch items daily before 5pm.

Discover more

Nolita, New York

Area guide
Loading Map...