Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Local picks in Park Slope

Pie spots

A slice of pie should be a reliable comfort, not a gamble on quality.

Based on 628 Opinions
+625
User
User
User
Updated
01
Sicily Pizzeria image 1
Sicily Pizzeria image 2
Sicily Pizzeria image 3
View all

Cozy spot with a lively vibe and friendly feel. Fresh mozzarella pies shine with homemade sauce. Specialty slices like eggplant pesto offer unique flavors. Great prices make it a top pick for pizza lovers.

People are saying

"I love how their pizza always tastes fresh."

"I love the fresh sauce on their specialty pies."

"The classic and square pies hit the spot."

Good to know

1

You can get cheese slices for $2.50.

2

The lunch special offers great value for money.

3

The pizzeria has a variety of amazing slice options and custom rolls.

02
Casita of Brooklyn image 1
Casita of Brooklyn image 2
Casita of Brooklyn image 3
View all

Small coffee shop offers homemade spinach pies with flaky phyllo and fresh ingredients. Cozy indoor seating and a spacious patio with fast Wi-Fi create a laidback vibe. Dog-friendly space with treats and live music makes it a personal retreat for comfort seekers.

Homemade spinach pies come straight from Greek tradition with flaky phyllo and fresh ingredients. Cheese pie and bougatsa also stand out as tasty pastries alongside strong coffee options.

People are saying

"The coffee and homemade pastries always hit the spot."

"I love how cozy and welcoming the place feels."

"I had their homemade spinach pie, it was out-of-this-world."

Good to know

1

Casita fills up fast, so plan accordingly if you want to work there.

2

There are only 3 tables available.

3

The small latte is $5.19, and a 32oz nitro cold brew is $7.

03
Peppino's image 1
Peppino's image 2
Peppino's image 3
View all

Brick oven pizza shines here with Diavola Pie and Cheese Pie cooked to perfection. Cozy, lively spot buzzes with energy, perfect for groups. Family-run charm adds warmth to every visit.

People are saying

"I love the authentic and delicious pizza here."

"I always order my favorite cheesesteaks and pizza here."

Good to know

1

They close the kitchen more than an hour before closing time.

2

Delivery on weekends takes at least an hour and a half.

3

The restaurant is very kid friendly.

04
Prospect Bar and Grill image 1
Prospect Bar and Grill image 2
Prospect Bar and Grill image 3
View all

Rustic decor and a big bar create a welcoming space with garden patio for outdoor seating. Chicken pot pie shines with its savory filling and flaky crust, perfect alongside mac and cheese. Soft 90's music sets a casual vibe for a local hang-out.

Chicken pot pie stands out with its savory, hearty filling and flaky crust. It pairs well with sides like mac and cheese or prospect eggs.

People are saying

"The bar has a welcoming vibe with great drinks."

"The food here tastes great and hits the spot."

"I thought the chicken pot pie was heavenly."

Good to know

1

Reservations are easy to make for large group parties.

2

The venue is family-friendly and suitable for casual gatherings.

3

Happy hour offers decent deals on drinks and appetizers.

05
Lenny's Pizzeria image 1
Lenny's Pizzeria image 2
Lenny's Pizzeria image 3
View all

Old-school Italian pizzeria offers classic Brooklyn-style pizza with fresh, scratch-made sauce. Square pies deliver a distinct shape perfect for a quick stop. Enjoy standout zeppoles in a welcoming, cash-only spot with original decor.

People are saying

"I love their classic Brooklyn-style pizza."

"The sauce and mozzarella really make the pizza."

"The zeppoles are the best thing here."

Good to know

1

On Wednesdays, they have a deal of 2 pies for 25 dollars.

2

Customers need to bring cash because there is no card machine.

3

The pizza starts at 4 dollars.

06
Two Boots Park Slope image 1
Two Boots Park Slope image 2
Two Boots Park Slope image 3
View all

Pizza spot shines with gluten-free vegan pies and quick remakes. Cozy brick layout and outdoor seating create a friendly vibe. Diverse crowd enjoys cornmeal crust and lively music for a relaxed, tasty experience.

People are saying

"I love the tasty pizza and good vegan options."

"The prices are really reasonable here."

Good to know

1

The restaurant is a popular choice for Pizza Night on Fridays.

2

Each child receives a free slice of pizza and juice after the class.

3

The prices at the pizza joint are great.

07
Antonio's Pizza image 1
Antonio's Pizza image 2
Antonio's Pizza image 3
View all

Small dining area with classic New York look and lively, family-owned vibe sets the scene. Grandma pie shines with fresh pies coming out regularly, matching wait times. Booth seating and neon sign add to the simple, no-frills atmosphere loved by locals.

People are saying

"The pizza tastes authentic with a crispy, flavorful crust."

"I love their classic neighborhood-style pies."

"I often grab fresh whole pies here."

Good to know

1

Customers can bring their own booze.

2

The pizza place requires a minimum purchase of $10 to use a credit card.

3

You get a free can of soda if you buy two slices.

08
Da Nonna Rosa Restaurant & Pizzeria image 1
Da Nonna Rosa Restaurant & Pizzeria image 2
Da Nonna Rosa Restaurant & Pizzeria image 3
View all

Southern Italian spot shines with family-oriented atmosphere and classic Brooklyn vibe. Pies impress with gluten free options and the nonna pie is a must-try. Spacious dining and event space add to its warm, welcoming charm.

People are saying

"The pizza and pasta here taste amazing and fresh."

"I highly recommend this place to everyone."

Good to know

1

The restaurant offers gluten-free options on pasta, pizza & dessert.

2

An entire pizza with six slices costs $30.

3

Two slices of pizza cost $12.

09
Brooklyn DOP image 1
Brooklyn DOP image 2
Brooklyn DOP image 3
View all

Narrow pizzeria offers Brooklyn style pies like large pepperoni and grandma with meatball. Cozy interior with counter seating contrasts a chill backyard patio. Lively vibe pairs well with crafted beers and unique wines for a relaxed pizza experience.

People are saying

"The pizza tastes fresh with great cheese and toppings."

"The pies and slices impress with crisp crust and flavor."

"I love grabbing a great slice or pie in a chill spot."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended at DOP, especially on weekends.

2

The restaurant only offers takeout and does not provide delivery options.

3

Seating is very limited.

10
Smiling Pizzeria image 1
Smiling Pizzeria image 2
Smiling Pizzeria image 3
View all

Old pizzeria buzzes with a bustling neighborhood vibe and offers classic New York-style pizza that draws a diverse crowd. Fresh pies feature extra sauce and a unique grandma style. Location near transit hubs makes it very convenient.

People are saying

"I love how the pizza tastes just right and feels authentic."

"I love ordering whole pies to share."

"The Grandma pie with extra sauce is delicious."

Good to know

1

The restaurant is open late until 1:30 AM on many nights.

2

They accept only cash for purchases below $10.

3

A minimum tip of $3 is required.

11
La Villa Pizzeria image 1
La Villa Pizzeria image 2
La Villa Pizzeria image 3
View all

Cozy spot with classic 1940s-50s music and Italian opera creates a warm vibe. Indoor and outdoor seating, especially the circular booth, add comfort. Pizza shines with fresh toppings and the veggie pie is rich and flavorful.

Pies here feature phenomenal quality with fresh toppings. The veggie pie stands out for its rich flavor and care in preparation.

People are saying

"The food here always hits the spot with classic Italian flavors."

"The pies here taste amazing with great toppings."

"The pies always come out perfectly cooked and the apple pie is delicious."

Good to know

1

The restaurant offers lunch specials and family specials.

2

Go early to beat crowds on weekends for a better experience.

3

The restaurant closed early at 9:20 PM despite online hours stating 10:30 PM.

12
L'arte Della Pizza Brooklyn image 1
L'arte Della Pizza Brooklyn image 2
L'arte Della Pizza Brooklyn image 3
View all

Cozy pizza shop offers large pies with thin, crisp crusts and exceptional tomato sauce. Family-friendly vibe and clean space make it great for groups. Outdoor tables add charm on sunny days.

People are saying

"The pizza tastes authentic with great cheese and sauce."

"I love the Tuesday cash-only large pizza deal."

Good to know

1

On Tuesdays, there is a takeout special of a large pizza for $14, but it is cash only.

2

You can walk in and get served in just five minutes.

3

The restaurant is within perfect walking distance from Barclays Center.

13
Pino's La Forchetta image 1
Pino's La Forchetta image 2
Pino's La Forchetta image 3
View all

Old school booths with TVs create a family-friendly atmosphere and plenty of seating. Deep dish eggplant and cheese pies show clear skill and taste great. The vibe stays relaxed and welcoming with reliable food and late hours.

Pies here show clear skill with a deep dish eggplant pie and a cheese pie that stays consistently good. Options include pepperoni and anchovies on personal pies, all priced around $20.

People are saying

"The pizza tastes like classic Brooklyn and is usually perfect."

"I stopped going because the card fees felt unfair."

Good to know

1

They do free wine and garlic knots for the holidays.

2

The lunch special costs $9.50 when paying with a card.

3

The lunch special costs $6.50 when paying with cash.

14
Ladybird Bakery image 1
Ladybird Bakery image 2
Ladybird Bakery image 3
View all

Small bakery offers freshly made cakes and a cozy atmosphere with limited indoor seating and outdoor benches for people watching. Cherry pie shines with a super sweet crust and strong flavor, while seasonal pies like key lime and apple provide good value and solid taste.

Cherry pie stands out with a super sweet crust and strong flavor. Seasonal pies like key lime and apple also deliver solid taste and good value.

People are saying

"I found the key lime pie to be fantastically sweet and tart."

"I always look forward to their cherry pie every fall."

"I didnโ€™t expect the apple pie to be this good."

Good to know

1

The bakery has a minimum purchase requirement of $10.

2

Ladybird Bakery offers delivery for a small fee.

3

The blackout cake offers great value for the price.

15
La Casa Del Panuozzo and brick oven pizza image 1
La Casa Del Panuozzo and brick oven pizza image 2
La Casa Del Panuozzo and brick oven pizza image 3
View all

Small space with outdoor patio offers a relaxed vibe and fresh, homemade pizza. Vegan pies come in substantial slices that satisfy like larger ones. Affordable prices and owner's presence make it a unique spot despite limited seating.

People are saying

"The pizza and pasta taste fresh and special."

"They have tasty vegan pies and options."

Good to know

1

The restaurant has no dine-in option; only takeout and delivery are available.

2

You can get 2 slices of pizza for $5, a great deal.

3

The $8 special includes 2 slices and a fruit smoothie.

16
SottoVoce image 1
SottoVoce image 2
SottoVoce image 3
View all

Cozy Italian spot with a warm, old school Brooklyn vibe welcomes families and dogs. Apple pie shines with Italian-style preparation and pairs well with cinnamon ice cream. Drinks like espresso martinis and Chianti complete the authentic experience.

Apple pie stands out with its Italian-style preparation and pairing with cinnamon ice cream. It is generally fresh and authentic, though some find it dry.

People are saying

"The food is fresh and the place feels cozy."

"I felt the bill was unfairly high with added charges."

"The apple pie here is delicious with cinnamon ice cream."

Good to know

1

A 20% service charge is automatically added to all dining bills.

2

The restaurant can accommodate large groups of 15 people.

3

The restaurant puts real effort into being accommodating for vegetarians, vegans, and gluten-free customers.

17
Emmy Squared Pizza: Park Slope image 1
Emmy Squared Pizza: Park Slope image 2
Emmy Squared Pizza: Park Slope image 3
View all

Detroit-style pizza shines with its crispy, fluffy crust and the MVP pie steals the show. Bartenders mix notable cocktails and suggest wines, fueling a lively bar scene. Giant ESPN screens add to the chaotic, loud atmosphere.

Square pies feature a light and fluffy crust that stays crispy. The MVP pizza stands out as a distinctive specialty pie with a memorable flavor. The apple pie offers a heavenly dessert option.

People are saying

"Some loved the pizza, but others found it salty or undercooked."

"The square pies have a light, crispy crust."

"I can't wait to try their specialty pies."

Good to know

1

Happy hour runs from 4-7pm on weekdays with half-price appetizers.

2

Reservations are required at least two weeks in advance for dinner service.

3

The restaurant is open until 11pm, later than most in the area.

18
Patsyโ€™s Pizzeria image 1
Patsyโ€™s Pizzeria image 2
Patsyโ€™s Pizzeria image 3
View all

Cozy spot with an old school New York vibe offers a quiet, warm atmosphere perfect for relaxed dining. Outdoor seating includes a covered patio and private garden. Their cheese pie is a standout, making it a must-try for pie lovers.

People are saying

"I love the classic New York-style pizza and big portions here."

"The service was amazing and made my visit great."

"They automatically add a 20% tip without clear warning."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended, especially on event nights.

2

Cash only is accepted for all orders.

3

A 20% service charge is automatically added for parties of 2 or more.

19
Bar Louise image 1
Bar Louise image 2
Bar Louise image 3
View all

Stylish cocktail bar shines with beautiful decor and a cozy interior featuring chandeliers. Chicken pot pie offers hearty comfort food perfect for cold weather, while outdoor seating with blankets adds a comfortable option despite the loud, energetic atmosphere.

Chicken pot pie serves as a cold weather comfort food with a delicious, hearty filling. The tuna pot pie is misleading, containing chicken and broth instead of tuna, and has a stringy, fishy texture.

People are saying

"The cocktails and food here are tasty and inventive."

"The place has a beautiful vibe but can be loud sometimes."

"The chicken pot pie is perfect comfort food for cool weather."

Good to know

1

Happy hour offers great deals on cocktails and light snacks.

2

The venue does not serve shots during private events.

3

The cocktail menu features a variety of unique drinks.

20
Normโ€™s Pizza image 1
Normโ€™s Pizza image 2
Normโ€™s Pizza image 3
View all

Retro vibe and sourdough crust create a cozy, lively spot. Supreme and Pepperoni pies shine, with a unique vodka sauce twist. Friendly, diverse crowd enjoys upbeat energy and flavorful, hot pies every visit.

People are saying

"I think their pizza is some of the best around."

"The prices here are fair and reasonable."

"The garlic knots are hit or miss for me."

Good to know

1

The total cost for the meal is under $20.

2

All pizza types are reasonably priced.

3

Norm's is very generous with all the toppings.

Discover more

Park Slope, New York

Area guide