Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Local picks in Park Slope

Pie spots

A slice of pie should be a reliable comfort, not a gamble on quality.

Based on 493 Opinions
+490
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Casita of Brooklyn image 1
Casita of Brooklyn image 2
Casita of Brooklyn image 3
View all

Small coffee shop offers homemade spinach pies with flaky phyllo and fresh ingredients. Cozy indoor seating and a spacious patio with fast Wi-Fi create a laidback vibe. Dog-friendly space with treats and live music makes it a personal retreat for comfort seekers.

Homemade spinach pies come straight from Greek tradition with flaky phyllo and fresh ingredients. Cheese pie and bougatsa also stand out as tasty pastries alongside strong coffee options.

People are saying

"I found the coffee here to be delicious every single time."

"It's a cozy spot with comfy seats inside."

"I had their homemade spinach pie, it was out-of-this-world."

Good to know

1

Casita fills up fast, so plan accordingly if you want to work there.

2

There are only 3 tables available.

3

The small latte is $5.19, and a 32oz nitro cold brew is $7.

02
Dukan SYKO Marketplace image 1

Market offers made-from-scratch Syrian pies with rich, authentic flavors. It blends Middle Eastern and Korean groceries for unique finds. Warm, family-like atmosphere invites exploring spicy hummus and other fresh foods.

Made-from-scratch Syrian pies burst with genuine Syrian flavors. Fresh Middle Eastern hand pies and pastries offer perfect seasoning and rich taste.

People are saying

"The Korean food here is amazing, and the staff are so kind."

"I found the fresh Syrian pies bursting with genuine flavors."

"I loved the homemade lentil soup; it was fantastic."

Good to know

1

The marketplace offers a fantastic selection of prepacked traditional items from Syria and Korea.

2

Expect reasonable prices for high-quality products throughout the store.

3

This place has a perfectly curated selection of Korean and Syrian groceries and prepared foods.

03
Prospect Bar and Grill image 1

Rustic decor and a big bar create a welcoming space with garden patio for outdoor seating. Chicken pot pie shines with its savory filling and flaky crust, perfect alongside mac and cheese. Soft 90's music sets a casual vibe for a local hang-out.

Chicken pot pie stands out with its savory, hearty filling and flaky crust. It pairs well with sides like mac and cheese or prospect eggs.

People are saying

"The food at this bar is way better than it needs to be."

"I enjoyed the awesome beer list and great beers on tap."

"I thought the chicken pot pie was heavenly."

Good to know

1

Reservations are easy to make for large group parties.

2

The venue is family-friendly and suitable for casual gatherings.

3

Happy hour offers decent deals on drinks and appetizers.

04
Buttermilk Bakeshop image 1

Small bakery shines with custom cakes praised for taste and look. Apple pie flavors come alive in rich layers and Coconut Cream Pie delights with creamy sweetness. Clean, organized space offers no seating, perfect for quick takeout.

Cakes here capture the essence of apple pie filling with rich, tasty layers. The Coconut Cream Pie and Strawberry Shortcake cupcakes offer sweet, creamy options alongside classic pies.

People are saying

"I found the cake to be beautiful and delicious."

"You'd never know the gluten-free cake was gluten-free; it's delicious."

"You have to try the Nutella pecan pie; it's a best seller."

Good to know

1

The cake is ready at the designated pickup time.

2

The ordering and pickup process are super easy.

3

Buttermilk Bakeshop accommodates vegan and gluten-free guests by clearly marking everything.

05
Macario image 1
Mexican restaurant

Cozy shop serves spicy sandwiches with fantastic bread and bold flavors. Herbal salsa verde and rich guacamole add zest. Frozen lime pie is homemade and refreshing, with new versions often available.

Frozen lime pie stands out with its homemade and refreshing qualities. The restaurant often offers new versions of this key-lime dessert to try.

People are saying

"I had a sandwich here unlike any I've had before; the flavor was outstanding."

"I experienced authentic food that felt like I was in Guadalajara."

"You have to try their frozen lime pie; it's to die for."

Good to know

1

Prices at Macario are comparable to other sandwich places in the neighborhood.

06
Ladybird Bakery image 1

Small bakery offers freshly made cakes and a cozy atmosphere with limited indoor seating and outdoor benches for people watching. Cherry pie shines with a super sweet crust and strong flavor, while seasonal pies like key lime and apple provide good value and solid taste.

Cherry pie stands out with a super sweet crust and strong flavor. Seasonal pies like key lime and apple also deliver solid taste and good value.

People are saying

"The cake here is stunningly beautiful and delicious."

"I loved the strawberry cupcakes; the filling won me over."

"I found the key lime pie to be fantastically sweet and tart."

Good to know

1

The bakery has a minimum purchase requirement of $10.

2

Ladybird Bakery offers delivery for a small fee.

3

The blackout cake offers great value for the price.

07
SottoVoce image 1
Italian restaurant

Cozy Italian spot with a warm, old school Brooklyn vibe welcomes families and dogs. Apple pie shines with Italian-style preparation and pairs well with cinnamon ice cream. Drinks like espresso martinis and Chianti complete the authentic experience.

Apple pie stands out with its Italian-style preparation and pairing with cinnamon ice cream. It is generally fresh and authentic, though some find it dry.

People are saying

"The pasta here is served with incredible hospitality and care."

"The desserts here are remarkable and very delicious."

"The apple pie here is delicious with cinnamon ice cream."

Good to know

1

A 20% service charge is automatically added to all dining bills.

2

The restaurant can accommodate large groups of 15 people.

3

The restaurant puts real effort into being accommodating for vegetarians, vegans, and gluten-free customers.

08
Cheese Plate Brooklyn : Park Slope image 1

Small space offers Parmigiano-Reggiano wheels and fresh pastries with coffee. Intimate atmosphere invites sampling of mature cheeses and international treats. Slices of Four and Twenty Blackbird pies add a sweet touch to the quality selection.

They carry Four and Twenty Blackbird pies, offering slices from this well-known bakery.

People are saying

"I loved the cheese and the generous samples they provided."

"The desserts here are always enticing and yummy."

Good to know

1

The store offers an unprecedented variety of cheeses.

2

There are plenty of samples to try.

3

The prices for the cheeses are very reasonable.

09
Bar Louise image 1
Cocktail bar

Stylish cocktail bar shines with beautiful decor and a cozy interior featuring chandeliers. Chicken pot pie offers hearty comfort food perfect for cold weather, while outdoor seating with blankets adds a comfortable option despite the loud, energetic atmosphere.

Chicken pot pie serves as a cold weather comfort food with a delicious, hearty filling. The tuna pot pie is misleading, containing chicken and broth instead of tuna, and has a stringy, fishy texture.

People are saying

"You have to try the cocktails; they're unique and delicious."

"The staff here are super friendly and attentive during dinner."

"The chicken pot pie is perfect comfort food for cool weather."

Good to know

1

Happy hour offers great deals on cocktails and light snacks.

2

The venue does not serve shots during private events.

3

The cocktail menu features a variety of unique drinks.

Discover more

Park Slope, New York

Area guide
Loading Map...