Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Prospect Heights' best

Italian food

Italian food that sticks to the fundamentals without feeling the need to reinvent the wheel.

Based on 628 Opinions
+625
User
User
User
Updated June 2026
01
Radio Bakery image 1
Radio Bakery image 2
Radio Bakery image 3
View all

Busy bakery buzzes with a long line and early sellouts. Outdoor seating invites you to savor fresh pastries in a lively spot. Italian flavors shine in smoked salmon focaccia and burrata prosciutto sandwiches packed with fresh kale.

Focaccias stand out with options like smoked salmon with dill and bacon egg and cheese. Sandwiches feature burrata with prosciutto and fresh ingredients like green kale in the turkey pesto.

People are saying

"I found their sandwiches to be large and flavorful."

"The focaccia here is worth waiting in line for."

"The Italian Food here, especially the focaccia, is out of this world."

Good to know

1

The line at Radio Bakery can be long, especially during lunch hours.

2

By 11:30, they often sell out of the Sweet Corn & Pecorino Foccaccia Slice.

3

Radio Bakery has no toilet available for customers.

02
Ogliastro Pizza Bar image 1
Pizza restaurant

Big outdoor patio offers a lively vibe and garden seating perfect for dates. Italian dishes shine with bold pizzas like Poplette and creamy carbonara. Friendly service and a popular spot for casual diners add to the charm.

Tiramisu stands out as a memorable dessert. Pizzas like the Poplette with meatball and caramelized onions, and the carbonara pizza offer rich, bold flavors. Prosciutto pairs well with parmesan and arugula, and the pesto adds a tasty touch.

People are saying

"You'll love their beautiful backyard patio for dining."

"I thought the gluten-free pizza here was amazing."

"The Italian food, especially the pizza, is incredible."

Good to know

1

The restaurant offers gluten-free crust as a choice for the pizza.

2

Expect to pay around $68 for two pizzas and a salad.

3

Happy hour includes food and runs at the bar.

03
Wayward Fare image 1
Italian restaurant

Space blends sexy, elegant design with a cozy vibe around an open wood-burning oven. Pasta shines with unique flavor profiles like malloreddus and pairs well with mezze and fresh bread. Guests enjoy thoughtful touches like complimentary teas and a menu inspired by forgotten spice routes.

Pasta stands out with a unique flavor profile and pairs well with mezze appetizers and fresh bread. Roasted squash and malloreddus pasta offer distinctive tastes alongside dishes like prawns, oysters, and steak.

People are saying

"You have to try the Mediterranean mezze here; they're a must-have."

"The wood-fired bread has the best char and is a must-have."

"The pasta here is unique and very tasty."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended, especially for weekend dining.

2

Gluten-free options are available for those with dietary restrictions.

3

The restaurant offers a private booth for a more intimate dining experience.

04
Pasta Night image 1
Restaurant

Bright, clinical space blends fast casual and fine dining with heated outdoor seating. Pasta shines with authentic, al dente noodles and rich sauces. Pair dishes like carpaccio and arancini with curated cocktails for a satisfying meal.

Pasta dishes feature creamy sauces and rich meats with perfectly textured noodles. Specials like carpaccio, arancini, and cacio e pepe stand out alongside in-house made pastas and simple, satisfying desserts.

People are saying

"The Italian food here has a lively, big family dinner energy."

"This casual spot is a fantastic addition to the neighborhood."

"The desserts here are high caliber and simple yet satisfying."

Good to know

1

You need to order at the counter before being seated.

2

Pasta Night is a highlight at this restaurant.

3

Expect to spend around $130 for two mains, one app, and two drinks.

05
Caffè De Martini image 1

Cozy indoor space with authentic European vibe and heated outdoor cabin invites relaxation or work. Italian pastries like cannoli and tiramisu balance sweet and savory perfectly. Savory options include focaccia sandwiches and panino di prosciutto, making it a tasty spot for real Italian coffee and food.

Pastries like cannoli and tiramisu stand out for their balance of sweetness and savory notes. Focaccia sandwiches and panino di prosciutto offer solid savory options alongside tasty croissants and brownies.

People are saying

"I thought the coffee here was delicious."

"The outdoor seating is beautiful and gives the place a unique charm."

"The Italian food, especially the pastries, is fresh and impeccable."

Good to know

1

Expect a 30-minute wait for takeout sandwiches during peak hours.

2

The cafe does not have a restroom for customers.

3

The cafe is usually busy on Sundays, but the line moves fast.

06
Ozakaya image 1
Japanese restaurant

Cozy Japanese spot shines with a beautiful back patio and soft music for a peaceful vibe. Mentaiko pasta offers a rich flavor while the tempura set adds a crispy contrast. Outdoor seating on the sidewalk is perfect for people watching.

Mentaiko pasta stands out with its rich flavor. The tempura set offers a crispy contrast, making both dishes solid choices.

People are saying

"The Japanese food here, especially the ramen, is top-notch."

"The seafood here is so fresh, especially the uni."

"The Italian food here is so creamy and delicious."

Good to know

1

Make sure to make a reservation for dinner.

2

Ozakaya is launching a Valentine’s Day special menu.

3

Customers can participate in a fun drawing gamble when they spend more than a hundred dollars.

07
Ciao, Gloria image 1

Rustic decor and ample outdoor seating create a lively spot with Italian-inspired dishes like fresh pastas and stacked sandwiches. Bright space hums with italo disco music as people work, read, and chat. Bustling vibe makes it great for food and socializing.

Menu offers a tempting array of Italian-inspired dishes with fresh pastas and creative appetizers. Sandwiches come stacked with meats, shaved cheese, roasted peppers, arugula, and basil pesto, served on soft focaccia.

People are saying

"The coffee here is delicious and smooth."

"I found the pastries here to be amazing and freshly baked."

"The Italian food here, especially the sandwiches, is so tasty."

Good to know

1

Expect a big cyclist crowd on Friday mornings from 8-9am.

2

Laptops are limited to bar seating and common tables from 11:30 AM to 2 PM.

3

Get there early to avoid long waits for tables.

08
SIMÒ PIZZA - BROOKLYN image 1
Pizza restaurant

Bright, modern space with gluten-free pizza offers a quiet, relaxed atmosphere perfect for casual meals. Rich, creamy burrata and authentic Italian desserts like tiramisu highlight the menu. Large round tables foster a welcoming, community feel.

Burrata stands out with its rich, creamy texture. Desserts like Tiramisu and fresh-made cannolis offer sweet finishes. Cheese plates come with salami and grapes for variety.

People are saying

"This pizza is the best I've had, closest to Italy."

"The staff here are so nice and accommodating to kids."

"The Neapolitan style pizza here is as good as in Napoli."

Good to know

1

All pizzas cost $16 or less, making them affordable for New York.

2

Ordering is done via QR code at the table for convenience.

3

The restaurant offers excellent gluten-free pizza options.

09
Amorina Cucina Rustica image 1
Pizza restaurant

Old school pizza spot offers homemade Italian dishes like vegetable lasagna and Spaghetti Alle Vongole. Cozy, timeless vibe suits families and community events with live music. Indoor and outdoor seating make it great for gatherings.

Lasagna stands out as a favorite, especially the vegetable version. Pastas like Spaghetti Alle Vongole with clam sauce and mushroom rigatoni offer solid Italian flavors, with some dishes featuring house-made ingredients like green garlic and basil pesto.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was great and the best I ever had."

"The homemade pasta here is outstanding."

"It's a really cozy place with warm vibes."

Good to know

1

Live music is available on Wednesdays.

2

The prices on the menu do not match what customers are charged.

3

The restaurant offers indoor and outdoor seating.

10
Dilly Dally image 1
Restaurant

Bright space with quirky decor and diverse art creates a fun vibe. Italian dishes like bolognese lasagna and meatballs shine with rich sauces. Covered patio and greenhouse room offer cozy seating, while kid-friendly touches make it welcoming for families.

Meatballs and lasagna stand out with balanced acidic red sauce and creamy bechamel. Squash ravioli offers a sweet filling paired with a savory sauce. Bolognese lasagna cooks to a mouth-watering perfection.

People are saying

"I thought the lasagna was cooked to perfection and mouth-watering."

"The brunch here has creative takes on breakfast staples."

"I'd go back for the Italian food, especially the lasagna."

Good to know

1

The restaurant can accommodate large parties, making it suitable for group dining.

2

Expect high prices, with meatballs costing $22 for two without bread.

3

Brunch is served on weekends, featuring a variety of comforting dishes.

11
Bird Pepper image 1
Caribbean restaurant

Caribbean restaurant shines with bold seasoning in dishes like Rasta pasta and Bird pepper pasta. Loud live DJ spins soca and reggae, creating an energetic vibe that encourages dancing but limits conversation. Enjoy the awesome bar and a private room for unique dining.

Fresh ingredients make the Rasta pasta and Bird pepper pasta stand out with bold seasoning. Crispy wings, oxtail, and shrimp pasta add variety and strong flavors to the menu.

People are saying

"The food here is really good, especially the Creole pasta with oxtail."

"The DJ really had the vibes just where they needed to be."

"The Italian food, especially the pasta with shrimp, was insanely delicious."

Good to know

1

Happy Hour creates a lively atmosphere, especially on weekdays.

2

The restaurant had a one-hour wait for a spot during peak hours.

3

The price for the oxtail meal is $38.00.

Discover more

Prospect Heights, New York

Area guide
Loading Map...