Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Prospect Lefferts Gardens' best

Chill Italian food spots

A slow, unhurried meal of Italian food is the only way to settle into a quiet evening.

Based on 838 Opinions
+835
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Trove Wine Bar & Kitchen image 1
Trove Wine Bar & Kitchen image 2
Trove Wine Bar & Kitchen image 3
View all

Intimate space with cozy, laid-back vibe and beautiful decor creates a welcoming atmosphere. Windows bring in natural light, enhancing the warm, classy feel. Regulars come for unique wines and a chill spot suited for dates or casual gatherings.

The spot has a very laid back atmosphere with consistently chill vibes. It feels super relaxed and easygoing throughout.

Burrata stands out with its creamy texture and pairs well with the house-made focaccia and pickles. Classic dishes like pizza and lasagna come alongside unique touches like white bean dip and pickled veggies.

People are saying

"I loved the great wine selection and recommendations."

"The vibe here is super chill and laid back."

"Their Italian Food has a beautiful, large wine list."

Good to know

1

The restaurant is women-owned, adding a unique touch to the dining experience.

2

The menu is perfect for sharing, making it great for groups.

3

They have a by-the-glass wine list that complements the menu well.

02
The Green Room PLG image 1

Space features lush green velvet, warm gold accents, and intimate lighting with portraits of legendary African American musicians. Live jazz music plays in the back room, creating a vibrant yet conversational atmosphere. The crowd enjoys a comfortable, elegant vibe suited for relaxed evenings and social gatherings.

Green and gold colors set a calming atmosphere with laid back vibes. The space feels like a spot to just relax and enjoy a chill mood.

Mozzarella salad and truffle fries stand out with fresh and rich flavors. Pasta dishes like linguine with mushrooms and tomatoes and chickpeas offer excellent texture and delicious taste.

People are saying

"The staff's warm hospitality made our evening truly special."

"The atmosphere here is so chill, giving grown laid-back vibes."

"The Italian food here has layers and levels of flavor."

Good to know

1

Live music is available on Thursday, Friday, and Saturday.

2

They host shows with local musicians in the backroom usually on weekend nights.

3

Live music starts at 8pm on Fridays.

03
Novelli Cafe and Restaurant image 1
Italian restaurant

Cozy and elegant space with warm, stylish decor featuring glass, mirrors, and floral accents. Atmosphere balances lively yet intimate energy with a relaxed pace. Guests often enjoy fine Italian dishes like steak and salmon alongside delicious cocktails in a visually appealing setting.

Atmosphere feels relaxing and nicely decorated. Everything moves at a perfect pace, relaxed but never slow.

Fresh breadsticks start the meal, followed by margarita pizza, artichokes, calamari, and burrata. The panna cotta serves as a perfect dessert to finish.

People are saying

"The bacon egg and cheese waffle during brunch was amazing."

"The Italian food here is mouth-watering and delicious."

"Justin's warm, friendly vibe makes it the perfect place to chill."

Good to know

1

Expect to pay an additional 18% service charge on your bill.

2

Prices are higher than average for the portion sizes offered.

3

Total bills can be unexpectedly high due to service charges.

04
Market Bar image 1

Small space with cozy seating and live music creates a chill, welcoming vibe. Frequented by a mix of couples and families, it offers board games and a curated playlist for a relaxed social atmosphere. Music volume can be loud, shaping a lively energy throughout.

The spot has a super chill vibe with a cozy and relaxed atmosphere. It works well for unwinding after work with its welcoming ambiance.

Pizza features overdone toppings like soggy onions and burnt prosciutto. Dishes include jerk chicken pasta, sweet chili wings, and griot tacos alongside various pizzas.

People are saying

"You have to try the happy hour frozen drinks, they were great."

"The atmosphere here is super chill and welcoming."

"The pizza and pasta here are amazing."

Good to know

1

Happy hour is only available Monday to Friday, contrary to what their Instagram states.

2

The happy hour deal of a 14 inch pizza and two pints for $25 is amazing.

3

The happy hour prices are unbeatable at $7 for a cocktail.

05
DJONDJON image 1
Haitian restaurant

Authentic Caribbean restaurant with Haitian paintings and artistic decor creates a cozy atmosphere. Loud live Haitian music fills the space, making conversation difficult but energizing the environment. Outdoor seating offers a comfortable and pleasant experience.

Relaxing ambience and cozy vibes make it easy to stay for hours. Drinks are wonderful, and konpa music plays softly in the background, creating a chill atmosphere for casual meals or solo visits.

Voodoo pasta stands out with rich flavors and a unique twist. The menu also features Rasta pasta with a spicy kick, tender fried goat, and a variety of pasta dishes like black mushroom ravioli with chicken.

People are saying

"I found the food here to be amazing and flavorful."

"The Italian food, especially the ravioli, was amazing."

"The food here is delicious; I'll definitely order the macaroni au gratin again."

Good to know

1

Happy hour runs from 4-7pm on weekdays with half-price appetizers.

2

Karaoke starts at 10pm on Wednesdays with a two-drink minimum.

3

The bar has a game night on Wednesday.

06
Sweet Catch BK image 1
Seafood restaurant

Small, cramped space with heated backyard patio and island-inspired decor featuring black and white sea life photos. Energetic vibe with a DJ playing hits and lively music that encourages dancing. Offers specialty cocktails and a cozy bar area, creating a warm and engaging atmosphere.

Atmosphere stays very chill with nice music playing. It offers a low key vibe perfect for relaxing with friends.

Seafood pasta stands out with its rich flavor and versatile noodles. Dishes like branzino, chargrilled oysters, and fried lobster with corncake waffle offer well-cooked, flavorful options.

People are saying

"The seafood here is fresh, flavorful, and seasoned perfectly."

"The seafood pasta here is flavored to perfection."

"The vibe here is so chill and laid-back."

Good to know

1

Happy hour features $1.50 oysters and $10 drinks from 5 to 7pm.

2

Bottomless brunch costs $60 per person for 90 minutes, including one entree.

3

Reservations are highly recommended due to limited seating.

07
Edie Joโ€™s image 1
American restaurant

Open kitchen and vertical grass decor create a unique setting with twinkly lights enhancing the vibe. Music plays loudly with an eclectic playlist, contributing to a lively atmosphere. Comfortable booths and large tables accommodate groups, while bartenders serve balanced cocktails that keep energy high.

A laid-back, low-stress atmosphere sets the tone with good music and a nice drink menu. Seating options inside and outside make it easy to relax and chat over cold drinks or brunch.

Kale pesto bursts with flavor in the vegan and nut-free pasta topped with summer squash and red cabbage. Burrata pairs with strawberries in a salad, while paccheri pasta and risotto come cooked to perfection.

People are saying

"I thought the burgers here were really good."

"The food here is delicious, especially the bacon, egg, and cheese."

"This Italian food's kale pesto is bursting with flavor."

Good to know

1

Karaoke happens every Wednesday night, starting at 8pm.

2

You must order at the front counter; table service is not available.

3

Expect a wait time of up to 2 hours for brunch on weekends.

Discover more

Prospect Lefferts Gardens, New York

Area guide
Loading Map...