Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
SoHo's best

Pie spots

You have no patience for a pie that isn't made with intention.

Based on 456 Opinions
+453
User
User
User
Updated
01
The Dutch image 1
The Dutch image 2
The Dutch image 3
View all

Restaurant offers a lively, historic Soho vibe with well-shaded outdoor areas and a bar wrapping the center. Apple pie shines with a crispy shell and rich cherries, while unique treats like salted lime pie add flair. Sidewalk tables under a covered structure enhance the vibrant atmosphere.

Apple pie stands out with a crispy shell and rich cherries, often served with ice cream. Unique options include a salted lime pie and a Keylime Donut filled with keylime custard and topped with gram cookie crumbles.

People are saying

"The strawberry rhubarb pie was perfect with my cappuccino."

"I can't get enough of their pies."

"The comfort food and pies hit the spot."

Good to know

1

Reservations are needed for brunch to ensure a table.

2

Brunch time is a popular time to visit, expect crowds.

3

The price of a glass of white wine is $19.

02
The Corner Store image 1
The Corner Store image 2
The Corner Store image 3
View all

Huge venue with gorgeous decor and a cool 90's vibe offers a chic yet upbeat atmosphere. Guests love the hand-held apple pie and the Samoa sundae for dessert. Music keeps energy high, making it a polished spot for a refined night out.

Hand-held apple pie stands out as a signature dessert. The Samoa sundae and apple pie offer distinct, memorable flavors.

People are saying

"I love the creative cocktails and cool vibe here."

"You have to try the apple pie with vanilla bean ice cream."

"The Wagyu dishes were perfectly cooked and delicious."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended due to high demand, especially on weekends.

2

Expect to wait up to 2 hours for a table during peak times.

3

Walk-ins are accepted, but seating is limited and may require a wait.

03
Lucia Pizza Of SoHo image 1
Lucia Pizza Of SoHo image 2
Lucia Pizza Of SoHo image 3
View all

Small, cozy shop serves poblano style slices with a lively, hectic vibe. Signature vodka pie shines with fresh dough and precise toppings. Warm interior and quick bites make it perfect for pizza lovers seeking intimate atmosphere and fast service.

Slices and whole pies come fresh with careful dough stretching and precise toppings. The vodka pie stands out as a signature choice, while the Caramelle Piccanti offers a spicy, flavorful option despite some sogginess.

People are saying

"Whole pies taste better and are a better deal."

"I think this place serves some of the best pies around."

"I love their unique pies like spinach and spicy ones."

Good to know

1

This place is strictly takeout with no seating available.

2

The pizza shop gets busy quickly, especially during late night and weekends.

3

Plan to grab and go as there is limited standing space.

04
The Otter image 1
The Otter image 2
The Otter image 3
View all

Nautical 50s style with lacquered navy walls sets a cozy mood for dining. Signature Boston Cream Pie shines as a must-try dessert. Outdoor patio offers a quiet, comfortable spot to enjoy cocktails like the Otter Dirty Martini.

The Boston Cream Pie stands out as a signature dessert here. It pairs well with other sweets like ice cream and gelatos.

People are saying

"The food is amazing and the vibe is cozy."

"It's a great new spot with a cool setting."

"You have to try the Boston Cream Pie; it's a must-try."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for dinner, especially on weekends.

2

Expect a $100 tab for four cocktails, including tip.

3

The restaurant offers a variety of seafood dishes and options for non-seafood lovers.

05
Pi Bakerie image 1
Pi Bakerie image 2
Pi Bakerie image 3
View all

Bright, cozy space offers natural light and indoor-outdoor seating for a casual vibe. Savory pies like spinach pie shine with flaky crusts, while sweet treats include baklava. Friendly service and reasonable prices make it inviting and relaxed.

Savory pies like spinach and Greek varieties stand out with rich flavors and flaky crusts. Sweet options include baklava and apple pie, all served with friendly service and reasonable prices.

People are saying

"I loved their sweet and savory pies; they were so good."

"I love their sweet and savory pies."

"Their spinach pies and savory dishes are amazing."

Good to know

1

A 3-course lunch is available for $31.95, including an octopus appetizer.

2

You can get food to go if you prefer not to dine in.

3

The bakery offers a selection of sweet and savory pies.

06
Hamburger America image 1
Hamburger America image 2
Hamburger America image 3
View all

Vintage burger diner buzzes with retro-modern design and a lively crowd. Key Lime Pie shines as a dream dessert, while the visible burger assembly line adds to the old school American vibe. Outdoor seating and a bar offer a fun, varied experience.

Key Lime Pie stands out as a dream dessert here. The chocolate pudding pie also gets a solid recommendation.

People are saying

"The key lime pie here is surprisingly good."

"The key lime pie was tasty but not tart enough."

"The pie was small and sometimes sold out."

Good to know

1

You order food and pay upfront, which makes the process easy and efficient.

2

Be warned that lines can be long on certain days at George Motzโ€™s restaurant.

3

Opening time is the best time to visit to avoid crowds.

07
Lucia Alimentari image 1
Lucia Alimentari image 2
Lucia Alimentari image 3
View all

Small, intimate space with cozy atmosphere sets a perfect mood for date nights. Vodka pie offers a unique flavor that divides opinions, while Bianca pizza adds tasty variety. Sexy music and special ambiance make dining feel truly special.

People are saying

"The pizza and drinks here are amazing."

"The atmosphere is cozy and perfect for date night."

Good to know

1

The establishment does not accept cash.

2

They have $2 espresso shots available.

3

Unique market/pantry items are for sale.

08
Harbs SoHo image 1
Harbs SoHo image 2
Harbs SoHo image 3
View all

Massive space with a refined Japanese aesthetic offers a calm spot for reading. Banana cream pie features chunky bananas and a heavenly crust. Fresh blueberries add a perfect balance to the dessert experience.

Banana cream pie stands out with its chunky bananas and a heavenly crust. Blueberries in the pie are always fresh and not too sweet.

People are saying

"I dream about the banana cream pie here."

"The banana cream pie was delicious and creamy."

"The pie has a strong banana flavor."

Good to know

1

The daily lunch special is available from 11am to 3pm.

2

You need to come exactly between 11am and 12pm to get cake.

3

Each customer must order one item to be served.

09
Famous Ben's Pizza image 1
Famous Ben's Pizza image 2
Famous Ben's Pizza image 3
View all

Local spot serves crispy pizza slices with a classic white pie option. Space is small but lively, featuring pizza dough flipping and music. Offers gluten-free whole pies and has both indoor and outdoor seating.

People are saying

"I loved the fresh, crispy, and delicious pizza here."

"The pizza was tasty with lots of options to try."

"The pizza felt overpriced for what I got."

Good to know

1

The restaurant is cash only; no credit cards accepted.

2

Slices of pizza are only $3 each.

3

They always have pizza slices ready to pick up.

10
$1.50 Fresh Pizza image 1
$1.50 Fresh Pizza image 2
$1.50 Fresh Pizza image 3
View all

Offers authentic New York-style pizza with large 18-inch pies at just $12. Cash-only spot has a no-frills interior with standing counters for a quick, casual vibe. Free pepper shakers stay clean and full, adding to the straightforward experience.

People are saying

"The pizza is cheap but tastes really good."

"This place gives the best value and feels like real NYC."

"The pizza pies cost way more than I thought."

Good to know

1

The establishment only accepts cash.

2

The pizza place is open 24/7.

3

A slice costs 99 cents or 8 dollars for a very big pizza.

11
Emmett's image 1
Emmett's image 2
Emmett's image 3
View all

Small space with intimate seating and vintage charm creates a cozy vibe. Loud music energizes the room while the heated outdoor patio offers fresh air. Chicago-style deep dish pizza shines with rich crusts and hearty fillings, paired well with a solid beer selection on tap.

People are saying

"I love the chill vibe and great beer selection."

"It feels like real Chicago pizza, but prices are high."

"The deep dish pizza is super filling and tasty."

Good to know

1

Reservations are a must if you want to eat inside due to limited seating.

2

They have amazing happy hour deals from 5-6:30.

3

On busy nights, be prepared for a long wait at Emmettโ€™s.

12
Dominique Ansel Bakery image 1
Dominique Ansel Bakery image 2
Dominique Ansel Bakery image 3
View all

Small bakery buzzes with innovative pastries and a warm vibe. Pies get safe holding and come with lemon treats. Quiet back garden offers Wi-Fi and flowers, perfect for a calm break.

Pies here come with helpful recommendations and are held safely until pickup. The bakery offers small lemon pie treats while waiting and hosts private pie night dinners.

People are saying

"The staff here is so accommodating with pie."

"The pies and pastries tasted amazing."

"I loved the apple pie cronut but found the Boston cream pie dry."

Good to know

1

Get to the bakery before 10am to avoid a long line.

2

Each month, a new flavor of the Cronutยฎ is unveiled, drawing eager crowds.

3

You can't find any cronuts after 1 PM.

Discover more

SoHo, New York

Area guide