Best Cookie in South Village, New York City
Thin Cookies - Bleecker
Tiny bakery offers a cozy vibe with limited outdoor seating perfect for quick visits. Cookies are thin and chewy, boasting fresh, balanced flavors like melting chocolate chip and caramel-like snickerdoodle. Packaging ensures cookies stay intact for takeout.
"I thought the cookies here were the best I ever had."
"I found the chocolate chip cookies to be perfectly chewy and warm."
Prices for cookies start at $7 for six cookies.
Limited outdoor seating is available; consider takeout for more options.
The shop occasionally runs out of standard chocolate chip cookies.
Insomnia Cookies
Warm, welcoming space fills with the aroma of freshly baked cookies late into the night. Soft, rich double chocolate chunk and macadamia nut cookies draw a crowd despite higher prices and limited availability near closing. Open until 2am for sweet late-night treats.
"These cookies are warm, fresh, and absolutely amazing."
"The staff made my daughter and I feel welcome and enhanced our visit."
The establishment is open until 2am.
The prices at Insomnia Cookies are a little on the higher side.
There were barely any cookies left.
Molly's Cupcakes
Space feels like a nostalgic schoolyard with wooden desks and swings. Chocolate chip cookies are delicious and high quality. Build-your-own cupcake options add a fun twist to the cozy, friendly atmosphere.
"These cupcakes are amazing, especially the creme brulee."
"This cake is so moist and delicious, it's perfect."
They offer BYO (build your own) options.
The establishment requires customers to buy something in order to use the bathroom.
Free wifi is available with a code.
More lists like this in every city
Atly has top 10s for every category โ gluten-free, dog-friendly, date spots and more.