Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Best of South Village

Unique pizza spots

A slice of pizza should be an experience that stands out from the standard crust and cheese routine.

Based on 628 Opinions
+625
User
User
User
Updated April 2026
01
Little Charli image 1
Little Charli image 2
Little Charli image 3
View all
Pizza restaurant

Tiny, cozy space centers on wood-burning brick oven pizzas with a smoky flavor. Dim lighting and intimate atmosphere create a chill vibe suited for quiet evenings. Open bay windows add fresh air, while stylish decor complements the relaxed setting.

Incredible pizza shines here with unique options like the Diablo and s'mores pizza. Gluten free and vegetarian pizzas get special attention, making the menu diverse and accommodating.

Pizza stands out with the drunk grandma special and spicy meat pizza, both offering unique flavors. Warm, charming atmosphere features a unique candlescape that adds to the experience.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was amazing and delicious."

"You have to try the s'mores dessert pizza; it's amazing."

"It's a truly unique atmosphere with cozy, burning candles."

Good to know

1

Reservations are required for weekend classes, so book in advance.

2

The pizza-making class lasts about 45 minutes, including cooking and eating.

3

The class is suitable for all skill levels; no prior cooking experience needed.

02
Two Boots Pizza West Village image 1

Colorful decor blends DIY aesthetic with cheeky wall art and vintage kitsch, creating a funky, vibrant atmosphere. Crowds often include costumed people, adding to the lively, nostalgic New York vibe. Seating ranges from comfortable booths to stools for solo diners, with outdoor options available.

Unique pizzas stand out here, especially the vegan options and the white pizza. The Duchess pizza is a popular choice, offering authentic New York style flavors.

Unique pizzas stand out with a hint of spice and a distinctive sauce. The menu offers a wide variety of refreshing and unusual options that differ from typical pizza places.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was amazing and one of a kind."

"I thought the dairy-free pizza was the best I ever had."

"The pizza here has unique topping combinations and bold flavors."

Good to know

1

The restaurant is open till very late on weekends.

2

The establishment does not allow non-customers, including children, to use the restroom.

3

There are lots of vegetarian and vegan choices.

03
John's of Bleecker Street image 1

Nearly 100-year-old coal-burning oven creates a thin, crispy crust and historic vibe with celebrity photos and wooden booths. Atmosphere feels like a return to another era, cozy but sometimes cramped inside. Outdoor seating includes heaters, making it comfortable even in cooler weather.

Thin crust pizza offers a classic New York style with a perfect tomato flavor that rivals Napoli. Slices deliver a traditional taste that many consider the best pizza ever eaten.

Coal fired ovens create a unique flavor in the pizza. Freshly made sauce and an old-fashioned throwback style add to the distinct experience.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was amazing."

"You have to try the spaghetti with meatballs; it's amazing."

"The coal-fired oven gives the pizza unique flavors and a great crust."

Good to know

1

Get there early to avoid waiting; a line forms 20-30 minutes before opening.

2

Expect to wait over half an hour during peak lunch and dinner times.

3

They only serve whole pies, no slices available.

04
Bleecker Street Pizza image 1
Pizza restaurant

Classic New York slice shop with a bright, roomy interior and authentic character offers both indoor and outdoor seating. The atmosphere carries positive energy with friendly, quick service and lively music. It draws a steady crowd seeking some of the city's best casual pizza slices.

Slices feature a thin crust with a perfect balance of sauce and cheese. The Nona Maria pizza stands out for its unique flavor and quality.

Slices have a cracker-like hard bottom that stands out. Lots of herbs and fresh mozzarella give the pizza a unique flavor. The crust is extra crispy but not too much, creating a distinct texture.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was some of the best I had."

"This is a fantastic late night spot for tasty, fresh pizza."

"The Nonna Maria slice has a unique, vibrant tomato flavor."

Good to know

1

Customers must order in advance using the app on Sundays.

2

You don't have to buy the whole pie; they serve per slice.

3

Paying in cash is cheaper than paying by card.

05
La Lanterna di Vittorio image 1
Italian restaurant

Historic brownstone hosts a cozy Italian restaurant with low lighting and an intimate atmosphere. A garden oasis and covered outdoor patio add unique charm. The space feels both spacious and intimate with high ceilings and quiet corners.

Thin crust supports the goat cheese and arugula pizza with fresh, balanced toppings. The margarita pizza offers classic, fresh flavors alongside other Italian dishes like lasagna and pasta.

Lasagna flights offer nearly ten kinds of distinct, well-seasoned lasagnas served together. Seating includes three options with unique atmospheres, especially the garden area.

People are saying

"The lasagna flight was playful and comforting, offering a range of flavors."

"The pizza here is crispy, flavorful, and delicious."

"Vittorio's passion for regional foods is truly unique."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended, especially for the garden room seating.

2

The restaurant features live jazz on select nights.

3

Valentineโ€™s Day fixed menu includes a glass of champagne and dessert.

06
Artichoke Basille's Pizza image 1

Small space with limited seating indoors and a few outdoor tables creates a cozy but crowded setting. Lively and energetic atmosphere fills the area, especially late at night. Views of iconic buildings add a unique backdrop to enjoying large, flavorful pizza slices.

Slices cost $7 each and feature a crispy crust with amazing sauce. The artichoke pizza stands out as a unique and delicious specialty not found elsewhere.

Unique pizza combinations stand out here, especially the artichoke pizza with white sauce. The pizzas offer a rich and distinctive flavor that sets them apart.

People are saying

"I loved their creamy artichoke pizza."

"I found the artichoke pizza unique with its creamy, white sauce."

"There's some outdoor space with seating, but it's pretty small."

Good to know

1

Expect to eat and walk or stand outside if busy.

2

Do not expect to find parking on that street.

3

The price for a slice is $7.57.

07
Emily image 1
Restaurant

Cozy restaurant with a heated terrace and semi-private downstairs dining featuring a wooden ship vibe. Atmosphere is lively inside yet tucked away on a quiet street, with close tables that create an intimate setting. Outdoor seating offers people watching and a relaxed spot for cocktails.

Detroit-style pizza stands out with its honey and truffle combination creating a unique flavor. Gluten-free options also deliver a notable taste experience.

Burgers feature dry aged beef patties with a unique umami flavor and juicy texture. The Emily Sauce and other unique spicy tangy sauces stand out, especially on the pretzel bun and wings.

People are saying

"I thought the burger was phenomenal and juicy."

"I tried the pizza, and it was incredibly flavorful."

"This burger is unique, the best I've ever had."

Good to know

1

Reservations need to be made a day before visiting the restaurant.

2

The kitchen closes at 9:15 PM, be careful.

3

The establishment is always busy, so it's best to get a reservation online.

08
Tokyo Record Bar image 1
Japanese restaurant

Small space with seating for about 16 people creates an intimate setting. Loud, energetic atmosphere feels more like an American party than a traditional Japanese izakaya. Guests participate by selecting records, contributing to a curated playlist that shapes the lively vibe.

A pillowy soft slice with a slightly spicy tomato sauce arrives as a bonus course to end the meal. A candle sometimes tops the slice for birthdays, adding a personal touch.

A vinyl song selection adds a personal touch to the dining experience. The menu features unique dishes like umami-spicy-sweet popcorn with chopsticks and kanpachi crudo on a nori-covered rice cracker.

People are saying

"The sake here is served with a fun, interactive vinyl playlist."

"It's unique how you pick songs from the vinyl playlist for the DJ."

"They even give you a pizza slice to go, so you don't go home hungry."

Good to know

1

The restaurant has 3 seatings on a Saturday night.

2

Reservations are required due to limited seating; each seating has about 20 people.

3

The pre-fixe menu is an INCREDIBLE value at $65 per person for 7 courses.

Discover more

South Village, New York

Area guide
Loading Map...