Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Top picks in the Theater District

Unique spots

A unique milkshake that offers something genuinely different instead of the same standard flavors found everywhere else.

Based on 665 Opinions
+662
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Van Leeuwen Ice Cream image 1
Van Leeuwen Ice Cream image 2
Van Leeuwen Ice Cream image 3
View all
Ice cream shop

Small, tight space with no seating creates a quick, casual vibe. Calm and classy atmosphere with an uplifting aroma fills the air. Offers a wide variety of vegan flavors and is known for exceptional ice cream quality.

Milkshakes come in traditional or vegan options with flavors like honeycomb and pistachio standing out. Staff help create custom combos and the shakes are consistently rich and creamy.

Ice cream features many unique flavors alongside traditional ones. The honeycomb flavor stands out for its distinct taste and consistency.

People are saying

"I found the ice cream to be so creamy and delicious."

"I loved the unique flavors of the ice cream."

"I thought the milkshakes were wonderful."

Good to know

1

The store doesn't accept cash, only credit or other forms of e-money.

2

Expect long wait times, especially after Broadway shows end.

3

There isn't anywhere to sit down at this location.

02
Hershey's Chocolate World image 1

Chocolate shop offers an immersive sensory experience with an overwhelming smell of sugar and chocolate. Colorful, fun decor and interactive displays create a lively, crowded atmosphere. Unique features include custom candy bar wrappers and a stuff your own cup-Reese's bar.

Chocolate and s'mores milkshakes stand out for their rich, delicious flavors. Milkshakes come with a small Hershey's chocolate as a courtesy, adding a nice touch.

Unique candies and limited edition bars stand out here. The s'mores and milkshake station adds a different twist to the usual chocolate experience.

People are saying

"I found a really varied selection of Hershey's Chocolate here."

"It's a fun, kid-friendly experience with interactive chocolate making."

"I thought the milkshake I had was so good."

Good to know

1

Hershey's central location in Times Square makes it easily accessible.

2

The establishment only accepts plastic payments.

3

There are no restrooms available for anyone, including paying customers.

03
Gayle's Broadway Rose image 1

Restaurant features talented singing servers performing Broadway tunes throughout dinner, creating a fun and lively atmosphere. Seating is spacious but obstructed by pillars, which can limit views of performers. Music volume is often very loud, affecting conversation and comfort near the bar area.

Milkshakes here taste divine and come out delicious every time. They pair well with sandwiches for a solid combo.

Dinner combines with live entertainment featuring wonderfully talented performers. The show offers a fun and memorable experience unlike typical outings.

People are saying

"The food here is delicious."

"I loved my milkshake; it was divine."

"It's a unique dining experience with talented servers singing Broadway songs."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended to avoid long wait times.

2

The live music show starts at 5 PM and runs until 8 PM.

3

There is an 80-minute time limit on tables during dinner.

04
Junior's Restaurant and Bakery image 1

Space combines retro diner vibe with vibrant decor featuring red and yellow hues. Atmosphere stays fun and lively, often busy and chaotic, with music that is pleasant and not overpowering. Crowd enjoys classic American comfort with standout cheesecake and a bar offering notable cocktails and beers.

Milkshakes come with generous portions and rich flavors like strawberry and banana that taste fresh. Some include cheesecake on top, making them very filling and over the top.

Unique cheesecake stands out on the menu. The place features a distinctive design and a one-of-a-kind atmosphere.

People are saying

"I found their famous cheesecake to be truly delicious."

"I thought the cheesecake and milkshake were really good."

"The service here is uniquely attentive and genuinely kind."

Good to know

1

You can put your name on a waitlist to plan your visit better.

2

The place is busy and open till midnight, close to Times Square.

3

On Saturday night at 6:00 PM, there was a 10-minute wait for a table for two.

05
Junior's Restaurant & Bakery image 1
American restaurant

1950s decor with neon lights and period furniture creates a movie-like atmosphere. The space feels spacious yet busy, with a high noise level typical of a bustling city setting. A wide variety of cheesecakes and a full bar complement the lively environment.

Milkshakes come in giant sizes and rich flavors like brownie cheesecake and coffee. They pair well with cheesecakes and offer a sweet, creamy treat with about 2,500 calories each.

Cheesecake stands out with a unique cake combo that sets it apart. French toast features a great cereal crust that adds a distinct texture and flavor.

People are saying

"I thought the cheesecake here was the best ever."

"Their giant milkshakes are amazing and surprisingly good."

"The cheesecake here is unique and one of a kind."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended at the diner.

2

Breakfast service ends at 11:00 AM on Christmas day.

3

Expect long queues; wait times may exceed 1 hour.

06
Planet Hollywood New York image 1
American restaurant

American restaurant with giant LED screens showing music videos creates a loud, energetic atmosphere where conversation requires shouting. Design is streamlined and sophisticated, lacking traditional Hollywood memorabilia. Guests enjoy vibrant music and video entertainment that dominates the space.

Milkshakes come with bold toppings like a whole piece of cake on the strawberry one. Flavors range from intense chocolate to artistic presentations that look as wild as the pictures.

Concepts offer a unique touch that stands out from other restaurants. The environment suits celebrations and events with a distinct vibe.

People are saying

"The American food here, like the burgers and nachos, is delicious and satisfying."

"The decor and atmosphere here are unique and exciting."

"The strawberry milkshake had a whole piece of cake on top!"

Good to know

1

The restaurant takes reservations for dining.

2

Planet Hollywood is back in NYC with a new location.

3

The menu is upscale but limited.

07
Sugar Factory New York - Time Square image 1

Restaurant offers upstairs and downstairs bars with loud music and a fun atmosphere suited for celebrations. Maximalist desserts and cocktail variety stand out amid a space with worn decor and mixed cleanliness impressions.

Maximalist desserts stand out here, especially the Nutella and banana milkshake and the brownie volcano milkshake. Milkshakes are very sweet and popular, often paired with candy or burgers for a rich treat.

Drinks stand out with little candies and playful flavors. Colorful, eclectic decor adds to the fun and unique vibe for breakfast or any meal.

People are saying

"It's a fun spot with a high-energy, exciting atmosphere."

"You should get one of the insane milkshakes because they are so good."

"The atmosphere here is uniquely fun and colorful."

Good to know

1

Lunch is served after 3:30 PM.

2

A mandatory 20% service fee is added to every bill.

3

The restaurant has no parking available.

08
Carnegie Diner & Cafe image 1

Diner offers a clean, spacious interior with music-themed decor and a vibrant atmosphere near a busy city area. The space includes outdoor seating with pet-friendly amenities and features lively background music and sports broadcasts. Strong, well-priced cocktails and bottomless mimosas add to the energetic vibe.

Homemade milkshakes stand out with rich flavors like the Brownie Extravaganza. Options include towering skyscraper milkshakes and creative combos like the milkshake waffle sandwich.

Menu offers diverse and unique dishes, including a burger with a distinct taste and avocado toast with flavorful toppings. Staff provide incredible service in a relaxed, unique atmosphere.

People are saying

"The food here is fresh, well-seasoned, and beautifully plated."

"The milkshakes here are rich and a meal unto themselves."

"The staff's service was so unique and impeccable."

Good to know

1

Happy hour runs from 3-7 PM with great prices on drinks.

2

Reservations are recommended for breakfast to avoid long waits.

3

Breakfast is available all day, so you can enjoy it anytime.

09
Ellen's Stardust Diner image 1

Classic Broadway-themed diner with singing waitstaff performing throughout, creating a lively, energetic environment. Small, crowded space with a balcony overlooking the whole place adds to the unique atmosphere. Entertainment feels like being inside a Broadway musical.

Milkshakes come with a unique twist, served during a waiter's song that feels like a musical rehearsal. This adds a lively, unexpected vibe to the experience.

Singing waitstaff perform live, creating an entertaining atmosphere that blends dining with Broadway-style shows. The experience feels over the top and campy, making it unlike typical restaurants.

People are saying

"The singing servers put on a Broadway-caliber show; it's such fun activities!"

"The singing waiters create a unique, festive atmosphere with their Broadway talent."

"The singing servers make the milkshake experience feel like a Broadway show."

Good to know

1

Expect a 50-minute wait during evening hours.

2

A 20% tip is automatically added to the bill.

3

Come during the week to avoid long lines.

10
Friedman's image 1
Gluten-free restaurant

Dining room features Broadway-style singing staff creating a lively and fun atmosphere. Ornate, historic interior with authentic design lacks sound dampening, leading to high noise levels. Offers gluten-free options and a gluten-free dedicated fryer, attracting those with dietary restrictions.

Gluten free milkshakes come in vanilla, chocolate, and Oreo cookie mint choc chip flavors. Kids and adults both enjoy the delicious taste.

A unique environment sets this bar apart with a sensation of flavors in its hot chocolate and a unique twist on drinks and food. Service and refreshments combine to create a distinct experience.

People are saying

"I found the gluten free pancakes to be amazing."

"You'll love the fudgie brownie milkshake here."

"The waitstaff singing here is a unique touch that adds magic."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended, especially for large groups.

2

The restaurant offers Broadway night events where servers perform.

3

Food service starts at 3:30 PM, but drinks are available at the bar before that.

Discover more

Theater District, New York

Area guide
Loading Map...