Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Loved by locals

New York style pizza in the Theater District

A slice of thin, foldable crust is the only thing that feels like home.

Based on 788 Opinions
+785
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
MR Pizza image 1
MR Pizza image 2
MR Pizza image 3
View all
Pizza Takeout

Enjoy authentic New York style pizza with thin, foldable slices and a crispy, chewy crust. The spot offers a casual vibe perfect for quick bites, with standing tables outside. Open late, it provides great value and halal options for diverse tastes.

Slices feature a classic thin crust and a foldable style true to New York tradition. The setting suits casual nights with friends, enhancing the authentic pizza experience.

People are saying

"This pizza is fantastic, with a great crispy bite."

"I was so happy to find this place was halal pizza!"

"This New York Style Pizza is delicious, with fresh and flavorful ingredients."

Good to know

1

Pizza slices cost $1.50 for cheese and $3 for pepperoni.

2

Two slices and a drink cost around $4.

3

They are open very late for late-night pizza cravings.

02
Roma Pizza image 1
Pizza restaurant

Offers quick service with classic New York style pizza featuring a thin crust and simple toppings. Indoor seating provides a straightforward dining space ideal for fast meals. Prices stay affordable with gluten-free options near a busy area.

Quick service delivers classic New York style pizza with a thin crust and simple toppings. The slices stay tasty even cold, making it a solid choice for a fast, casual bite.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was one of the best in town."

"The Italian food here, especially the pasta, is delicious and satisfying."

"I found the New York style pizza to be great."

Good to know

1

Fire serves food late at night.

2

Pizzeria Roma has affordable prices, offering excellent value for money.

3

There are lots of vegetarian options available.

03
Famous Pops Pizzas image 1
Pizza restaurant

Cozy spot serves classic thin crust New York style pizza with tangy sauce and melty mozzarella. Friendly staff create a lively atmosphere with upbeat music. Plenty of seating includes tables with electrical outlets for convenience.

Slices feature a classic thin crust with a foldable texture. Toppings balance well with a tangy tomato sauce and melty mozzarella that captures authentic New York style pizza.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was amazing and delicious."

"This place is so kid friendly; my children loved watching the pizzas being made."

"This New York Style Pizza is amazing and exactly what I was looking for."

Good to know

1

The restaurant is open late for late-night pizza cravings.

2

Expect to pay around $9.26 for two cheese slices and a soda.

3

One or two slices of pizza will fill you right up for less than $10.

04
Carve: Unique Sandwiches & Pizza image 1

Small indoor space with wood-fired oven creates a lively, tight setting. New York style pizza shines with thin, crunchy dough and classic taste. Quick service and outdoor seating add to the energetic, welcoming vibe.

Generous portions of thin, crunchy, yet bready dough define the New York style pizza here. The slices avoid sogginess and deliver a classic, delicious taste true to the style.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was the best I had in a long time."

"The breakfast staff here are so friendly and make you feel at home."

"I thought this New York Style Pizza was the best I've ever had."

Good to know

1

The bagel and coffee combo costs 3 dollars.

2

Pizza costs $7 for a slice.

3

The seating is very limited.

05
Joe's Pizza Broadway image 1
Pizza restaurant

Small, bustling spot serves thin crust New York style pizza with a perfect crisp-chew balance. Limited seating and a lively, electric atmosphere make it feel very authentic. Celebrity photos add character, while visible pizza prep keeps the vibe fast and real.

Thin crust and classic sauce define the New York style pizza here. The slices hold a perfect balance of crispiness and chew, making it a solid example of authentic New York pizza.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was the best I'd ever tasted."

"The line for pizza slices moves quickly, and it's worth the wait."

"I tried authentic New York style pizza and it exceeded my expectations."

Good to know

1

Expect to wait in a long line, especially on weekends.

2

The wait time for this pizza store is over 1 hour.

3

Theyโ€™re open till 4am, making it a perfect place for late night cravings.

06
Patzeria Perfect Pizza image 1
Pizza restaurant

Counter service spot offers authentic New York style pizza with a perfect thin crust and classic toppings. Outdoor seating with heaters creates a lively atmosphere reminiscent of a small Italian kitchen. Minimal English adds to the authentic vibe.

Authentic New York style pizza shines here with a perfect thin crust and classic toppings that capture the true NYC flavor. The pizza tastes genuine and delicious, reflecting the city's iconic slice.

People are saying

"I experienced a perfect New York pizza here."

"The lasagna pizza here is crispy, crunchy, and not greasy at all."

"I found the most authentic New York Style Pizza here."

Good to know

1

Pizzas are sold by slices at 3 to 5 dollars by flavor.

2

The restaurant is busy, so be prepared for a 5-10 minute wait.

3

There is no indoor dining and limited sidewalk dining.

07
Little Italy Pizza image 1
Pizza restaurant

Small, narrow space with smoky atmosphere feels hectic but lively. Upstairs seating offers spacious relief from the crowd. Phenomenal New York style pizza with authentic taste and high-quality ingredients makes the busy vibe part of the charm.

Authentic New York style pizza shines here with high-quality ingredients and a classic taste. The slices capture the true essence of original New York pizza.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was the best I ever ate."

"I found the pizza here to be really good and affordable."

"I thought this New York Style Pizza was the best I ever had."

Good to know

1

The price for a slice of pizza is $5.13.

2

You need to order your slices, pay at the cashier, and then move out of the way.

3

There is no parking available nearby.

08
Famous Original Ray's Pizza image 1

Small pizzeria serves classic New York style pizza with thin, foldable crust. Atmosphere is bustling and active, especially after shows. Outdoor terrace offers people watching in a tight, no-frills space.

Slices feature a quintessential New York style with a thin, foldable crust. The pizza offers a classic, authentic taste that stays true to traditional New York flavors.

People are saying

"This pizza is the best I've ever tasted."

"It's a great late night spot for a quick bite."

"I enjoyed an authentic, classic New York Style Pizza slice."

Good to know

1

Slices of pizza cost $8 each, which is considered expensive.

2

Expect to pay almost $10 for a slice with any toppings.

3

At night, only 3 topping slices are served.

09
Famous Famiglia Pizza image 1
Pizza restaurant

Small, crowded spot offers fresh New York style pizza with thin crust and classic toppings. Walls covered in celebrity photos create a unique vibe. Friendly, warm atmosphere feels like a family gathering despite busy tourist crowds.

Slices come fresh and classic with a thin crust and traditional toppings. Small spots serve pizza by the slice, capturing the authentic New York style taste.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was the best I'd ever had."

"This late night spot has great pizza, especially the thin crust."

"I found the New York style pizza to be great and fresh."

Good to know

1

Famiglia's opens at 9am, allowing early morning pizza cravings to be satisfied.

2

The price of a pizza is $36.00.

3

Expect to pay $1 for a cup of water instead of getting refills.

10
John's Pizzeria of Times Square image 1

Converted church with a stained glass ceiling offers a unique dining vibe. Watch pizzas made in four coal-fired brick ovens for an engaging experience. Enjoy classic thin crust New York style pizza with authentic, quality ingredients.

Traditional New York pizza stands out with its quality ingredients and classic thin crust. The pizza offers a delicious, authentic taste that captures the essence of New York style perfectly.

People are saying

"The pizza here has a super crispy crust and amazing flavor."

"The salads here are great and very generous in size."

"I traveled to NY looking for the best New York style pizza."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for groups larger than four to avoid long waits.

2

Expect a 30-minute wait on Friday nights if you arrive after opening.

3

Only whole pies are sold; no slices available.

11
Radio City Pizza image 1
Pizza restaurant

Small spot offers classic New York style pizza with a crispy, airy crust and fresh toppings. Cozy mezzanine seating fits eight tables, perfect for quick bites or casual lunches. Prices stay reasonable, making it a great choice for flavorful, affordable pizza.

A hole-in-the-wall spot serving quick slices of classic New York style pizza. The pizza has a genuine NYC flavor that stands out.

People are saying

"I found the pizza here to be delicious and perfectly topped."

"The food here is hot, fresh, and delicious."

"I thought their New York Style Pizza was the best I had tried."

Good to know

1

The establishment closes 15 minutes before the official closing time.

2

You can buy just slices of pizza; you don't need to take a whole pizza.

3

The pizza is ready within 5 minutes, making it a quick option.

12
$1.50 Fresh Pizza image 1
Pizza restaurant

Tiny spot serves New York style pizza at just $1.50 a slice, offering great value and fresh taste. Inside feels chaotic and crowded with standing-room-only bars, but outdoor benches provide a relaxed place to eat. Free seasonings add extra flavor to affordable slices.

Offers New York style pizza at an unbeatable price of $1.50 per slice. Quality stands out compared to many other places charging more, making it a clear example of affordable, fresh pizza.

People are saying

"I found the pizza to be cheap and quite good."

"This late night spot's pizza is shockingly good for the price."

"This New York Style Pizza tastes like the classic I remembered."

Good to know

1

The pizza costs 99 cents a slice.

2

You can get two pieces of pizza and a drink for just $3.

3

They accept only cash for all orders.

Discover more

Theater District, New York

Area guide
Loading Map...