Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Loved by locals

Sandwich shops in West Brighton

A quick, reliable sandwich is the only thing that will bridge the gap until dinner.

Based on 604 Opinions
+601
User
User
User
Updated June 2026
01
Italo A&S Fine Foods image 1
Italo A&S Fine Foods image 2
Italo A&S Fine Foods image 3
View all

Small deli shines with authentic sandwiches featuring thin sliced meats and fresh veggies. Immaculate butcher case offers top-quality Italian specialties like fresh mozzarella. Family-run vibe ensures large portions and fair prices for meals or catering.

Italian sandwiches stand out with thin sliced meat, cheese, vinegar, oil, lettuce, and tomatoes. Options like the Rimini and Napoli roasted veggie offer variety and fresh flavors.

People are saying

"The food here is really good and fresh."

"I found the Italian sandwiches here to be very good."

"I considered this the best deli in Staten Island."

Good to know

1

The restaurant offers delivery service for convenience.

2

A&S has fair prices and large portion sizes.

3

The products are top-notch and always fresh.

02
The Point Tavern image 1

Cozy bar and dining spaces create a warm vibe with a fireplace room that invites gatherings. Roast beef sandwiches shine with juicy beef and fresh bread like pretzel bun and onion ciabatta. Friendly crowd enjoys affordable prices and great flavors.

Roast beef sandwiches stand out with juicy beef and fresh bread options like a pretzel bun and fresh onion ciabatta roll. The South Shore sandwich offers a fantastic combination of flavors and textures.

People are saying

"I thought the roast beef sandwich was tender and juicy."

"The sandwiches and appetizers here are delicious."

"This roast beef sandwich is juicy, tender, and savory."

Good to know

1

Ample parking is available in the surrounding streets.

2

The menu features a variety of roast beef sandwich options.

3

Happy hour is a great time for teachers to unwind after work.

03
Forest Superette Bagels image 1

Bagel shop runs 24 hours with early opening and serves fresh sandwiches like spicy Italian and Reuben. Atmosphere fits late-night cravings with moderate prices. Parking is tight with no pick-up service, but sandwich sizes are satisfying.

Offers both hot and cold sandwiches with fresh, tasty ingredients. Sandwiches come in decent sizes and include options like spicy Italian, Reuben, and egg sandwiches.

People are saying

"I found the sandwiches here to be very good and tasty."

"The breakfast cook was excellent and friendly."

"I enjoyed the great coffee here."

Good to know

1

The restaurant is open 24 hours for flexible dining options.

2

They deliver breakfast sandwiches for added convenience.

3

Prices are moderately priced for a variety of meals.

04
Supreme Burger Company image 1

Cozy spot with a modern vibe and free arcade games offers fun and comfort. Chicken sandwiches shine with fresh ingredients and crispy Buffalo style. Pet-friendly policy welcomes dogs with treats, making it a lively, tasty hangout.

Chicken sandwiches stand out with fresh, high quality ingredients and crispy Buffalo style options. Burgers and BBQ chicken sandwiches come in large, hearty portions that are very tasty.

People are saying

"These burgers have incredible caramelized edges and juicy patties."

"The waffle fries here are perfectly seasoned and crispy."

"I enjoyed the tasty grilled chicken sandwich."

Good to know

1

The wait time for food can be 1 hour and 30 minutes even with an online order.

2

The vegan options listed were unavailable aside from the vegan burger.

3

The restaurant does not have a bathroom for customers.

05
Filoncino Cafe - Forest Ave image 1

Charming decor creates a cozy vibe with huge portions and soft bread that make sandwiches stand out. Fresh ingredients deliver solid flavors in every bite, while kid-friendly touches keep the atmosphere welcoming. Pastries shine as excellent treats alongside satisfying dishes like spicy Italian tuna.

Sandwiches come out amazing with fresh ingredients and solid flavors. They stand out alongside top notch salads, making the menu feel split between a sandwich shop and a full restaurant.

People are saying

"The Cafe's sandwiches and platters are great."

"I found the Philly Cheesesteak to be pretty impressive."

"I thought the sandwiches were top notch."

Good to know

1

The restaurant offers large portion sizes, suitable for sharing.

2

The cafe is kid-friendly, making it a good choice for families.

3

Bakery items are available and recommended for trying.

06
Jody's Club Forest image 1
Irish restaurant

Irish restaurant offers a spacious bar area with multiple sports TVs and a relaxed atmosphere where patrons feel like family. Steak sandwich delivers strong flavor, while the Gobble sandwich is also a favorite. DJ music adds energy without overpowering the vibe.

Steak sandwich stands out with strong flavor. The Gobble sandwich also ranks highly. Turkey club stays consistently good, but pastrami falls short.

People are saying

"The American food here is delicious and flavorful."

"I hosted multiple private parties here and would have another."

"I found the steak sandwich to be amazing."

Good to know

1

The venue is great for small events and private parties.

2

Expect a lively atmosphere during events like the St. Patrick's Day Parade.

3

The restaurant offers affordable meals, with burgers and fries priced at $8.

07
Bagels Bread & Butter image 1

Bagel shop serves in-house baked bagels with soft bread and unique cream cheese. Breakfast sandwiches with bacon or sausage, egg, and cheese are popular, alongside standout pastrami heroes. Fast-paced, clean, and inviting atmosphere keeps customers coming back.

Breakfast sandwiches feature bacon or sausage, egg, and cheese on a roll or bagel with a good variety of options. Pastrami sandwiches and heroes also stand out, though staff sometimes open sandwiches to check contents due to communication gaps.

People are saying

"I thought these bagels were the best I could find."

"I loved their amazing sandwiches and heroes."

"The Deli employees were so friendly and welcoming."

Good to know

1

Fresh bagels are available every day.

2

A plain bagel costs $1.25, while a bagel with cheese costs $4.85.

3

The place gets crowded, especially on weekends.

08
Baba shawarma image 1
Shawarma restaurant

Corner store shines with well-seasoned shawarma and juicy lamb chops. Chopped cheese sandwich is a popular choice among solid burgers and gyros. Unique smoke shop design adds to its peaceful energy and 24/7 convenience.

Chopped cheese sandwich stands out as a popular choice. Other sandwiches like burgers and gyros are consistently solid and satisfying.

People are saying

"The food here is always super fresh and delicious."

"This Mediterranean food's shawarma is so juicy and perfectly seasoned."

"I loved the chicken shawarma sandwich; it was crispy and juicy."

Good to know

1

Baba Shawarma is open 24/7 for food at any time.

2

The restaurant serves halal food for dietary preferences.

3

The prices at Baba Shawarma are super reasonable.

09
Redemption Coffee image 1

Cozy cafe offers a peaceful atmosphere with tall windows and a spacious outdoor patio. Sandwiches feature sourdough bread but can be dry and messy with avocado. Outdoor seating welcomes dogs and provides plenty of outlets for casual chats.

Bacon Egg & Cheese sandwiches come with orange slices instead of chips. Turkey and bacon are heavily salted, and the bread tends to be very dry, making the sourdough stand out. Sandwiches can fall apart easily with avocado spilling out.

People are saying

"I loved my cortado; it was sincerely the best."

"I loved the buttery, warm croissant."

"I found the sandwich here delicious and fresh."

Good to know

1

Street parking is the only parking option available.

2

The coffee shop has limited indoor seating.

3

They have gluten-free options available.

10
Panini Grill image 1
Italian restaurant

Live entertainment brings loud, fun energy while seating blends indoor and outdoor with a charming garden room. Huge sandwiches shine, especially the il padrino, though eggplant parm can be soggy. Decor adds a welcoming, cozy vibe throughout.

Huge sandwiches come with a lunch special that pairs a half-sandwich with soup or salad for $14. The eggplant parm sandwich tends to be soggy and falls apart, while the il padrino stands out as a notable option.

People are saying

"The food here is fresh and delicious."

"The Italian food here is amazing, and the staff is so friendly."

"The service here made me feel like family."

Good to know

1

Make a reservation if dining on weekends to avoid long wait times.

2

The pre-fix menu runs on Monday, Tuesday, and Wednesday.

3

Panini Grill hosts various events throughout the year, including theme nights.

Discover more

West Brighton, New York

Area guide
Loading Map...