Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Williamsburg's best

Bagel sandwiches

Made for those who view a bagel not as a breakfast item, but as the essential foundation for a substantial, well-built sandwich.

Based on 678 Opinions
+675
User
User
User
Updated June 2026
01
Hidden Grounds Chai & Coffee House image 1
Hidden Grounds Chai & Coffee House image 2
Hidden Grounds Chai & Coffee House image 3
View all

Cozy space with floor-to-ceiling windows and family photos creates a warm, homey vibe. Aromatic spices fill the air, adding a unique cultural touch. Small tables and solid WiFi support a chill atmosphere suited for working or studying.

Salmon bagel sandwiches come on warm and fluffy bagels with seasoning that complements the salmon and cream cheese well. Unique options like the Bombay bagel add variety beyond the usual.

Warm and fluffy bagels hold the Salmon Everything Bagel Sandwich with well-balanced seasoning and fresh salmon. Handmade sandwiches offer a simple, enjoyable option.

People are saying

"I thought the masala chai and chai lattes were amazing."

"I loved their Bombay Bagel and masala chai."

"I had a spectacular chai latte, lightly sweetened with spices."

Good to know

1

The latte art class lasts for two hours and requires advance booking.

2

The coffee shop is fully wheelchair accessible.

3

Seating is limited, especially during peak hours.

02
A&C Super image 1
Bakery

Small bakery nook with thoughtful interior design and a charming outdoor seating area tucked around the corner. Atmosphere carries good neighborhood vibes with friendly people and a relaxed pace. Known for house-baked pastries and breakfast sandwiches that attract visitors from afar.

Bagels here have a chewy and crispy texture with options like everything and poppy seed varieties. Cream cheese pairs well, though the vegan version has a noticeable oil aftertaste.

Breakfast sandwiches stand out with cheddar biscuit bases and simple, well-done flavors. The mortadella sandwich and bacon biscuit sandwich also deliver consistently mouthwatering taste.

People are saying

"I thought the sandwiches here were delicious."

"I found the cheddar biscuits to be amazing and light."

"I found the bagels here to be awesome and delicious."

Good to know

1

Seating outside the bakery is limited, so pickup is recommended.

2

They cater to gluten-free diets.

3

You can conveniently order ahead through their website.

03
Williamsburg Bagel image 1

Corner bagel shop offers authentic Jewish deli vibes with flavorful bagels and fresh sandwiches. Friendly atmosphere blends with wholesome neighborhood energy. Prices tend to be on the higher side, reflecting the quality and specialty items available.

Fresh bagels come in classic styles like sesame and Jewish, always well priced and delicious. The fried lox and grilled avocado bagels stand out for their flavor and quality.

Crunchy fried lox stands out as a signature sandwich here, served on delicious bagels. Tuna melt and crispy lox sandwiches also come fresh and tasty, with prices around $12.

People are saying

"This Bagel With Lox is mouth-watering and divine."

"I loved the crunchy fried lox sandwich."

"I thought these were the best bagels I ever had."

Good to know

1

Bagels cost around $15 for a small bagel with toppings and a drink.

2

There is no seating available inside the establishment.

3

Expect additional charges for adding vegetables from the salad bar.

04
Apollo Bagels image 1
Bagel shop

Spacious bagel shop with a clean, minimalist design and ample seating that accommodates large crowds comfortably. Atmosphere feels stale and functional, more suited for quick visits than lingering. Popular among tourists and newcomers, it offers a small, focused menu with highly praised bagels.

Bagels here have a delicious sourdough base with a wide variety including salmon and shrimp options. The smoked salmon bagel stands out as especially flavorful and well toasted.

Toasted bagels have a crunchy texture with a chewy bite that suits open-faced sandwiches well. Tomato sandwiches feature sweet and slightly sour tomatoes with olive oil and black pepper, while smoked salmon and lox sandwiches balance salmon, cream cheese, and red onion flavors but do not overshadow the sourdough bagel base.

People are saying

"I thought the bagels here were the best I ever had."

"This Everything Bagel has the perfect crunch-to-soft ratio."

"I found their bagels to be the best toasted bagels I had ever tasted."

Good to know

1

There is basically zero wait time at the bagel and coffee shop.

2

They have vegan cream cheese options available.

3

The line moves super quick at this spot.

05
Hot Bagels image 1
Bagel shop

Bagel shop offers fresh, crunchy bagels with toasty bread and smooth cream cheese. Atmosphere feels authentic and deli-style. Prices range from reasonable to great for sandwiches, attracting early morning crowds.

Bagels come out fresh and crunchy with a good variety of toppings including shmear and lox. Prices stay fair and service is fast, though bagels may not be hot later in the day.

Sandwiches come at great prices and taste delicious. The breakfast sandwich stands out as a solid choice.

People are saying

"The bagels weren't hot because I visited late in the day."

"I thought the sandwiches here were good."

Good to know

1

The restaurant opens early in the morning.

2

Expect long lines and a very long wait during peak hours.

3

Prices are very good for the quality of food.

06
Leonโ€™s Bagels image 1

Street stand setup with custom tree seating and outdoor benches creates a casual, cozy vibe. The atmosphere feels immaculate and chilled, drawing a steady flow of people who enjoy watching the scene while waiting. The simple, stylish design with white and green checks adds to the neighborhood charm.

Bagels here are fresh and flavorful, with options like the gluten-free everything bagel and egg bacon and cheese sandwiches on egg everything bagels. The to-go window makes picking up bagels quick and easy.

Breakfast sandwiches feature heaps of bacon and egg on a great bagel. The everything bagel sandwich stands out for its taste and quality.

People are saying

"I thought Leon's Bagels served the best bagels I had in NYC."

"I had the best bagel sandwich of my life here."

"The salmon on the bagel is so generous and delicious."

Good to know

1

Expect to wait more than 30 minutes for your order during busy times.

2

Ordering ahead online is recommended on weekends to avoid long lines.

3

They donโ€™t serve egg or cheese before 9am, so plan accordingly.

07
Bread & Butter Market (505 Grand Street) image 1

Spacious market combines bakery, deli, and espresso bar with a well-stocked grocery section and pressed juices. Warm, friendly atmosphere draws a diverse crowd, creating a community hub feel. Clean, classy space offers 24-hour access to a wide variety of fresh and trendy food options.

Offers New York-style bagels known for their authentic taste. Serves as a go-to spot for bagels and sandwiches in the neighborhood.

Deli sandwiches stand out with fresh ingredients and solid preparation. The Reuben sandwich ranks among the neighborhood's notable options, paired well with shakes and coffee.

People are saying

"The deli staff here are always super friendly and welcoming."

"I enjoyed the sandwiches here; they were always fresh and made the way I liked."

"I thought their bagels were the best New York bagels ever."

Good to know

1

The deli is open 24 hours for convenience.

2

Double-check prices at the register to avoid overcharges.

3

They offer vegan and gluten-free options for dietary needs.

08
The West Brooklyn image 1

Rustic industrial space with cozy wood interior and outdoor backyard seating creates a warm, inviting atmosphere. Music shifts from chill indie to lively Latin pop, supporting a hipster, creative vibe that suits freelancers and social gatherings. Frequent live music and film nights add to the dynamic cultural energy.

Bagels come with fresh, tasty options like tuna salad and cost around $8. They pair well with coffee, including iced oat cappuccinos.

Crunchy and warm textures stand out in the chicken sandwich. Grilled cheese sandwiches also feature a satisfying melt. Some ham and swiss sandwiches have caused food poisoning.

People are saying

"The outdoor seating area is lovely and bright."

"It's a cozy coffee spot with amazing vibes."

"I loved the airy atmosphere for a morning bagel bite."

Good to know

1

The west cafe opens at 7AM, making it the earliest option in the area.

2

The establishment is open late, perfect for night owls.

3

The coffee shop is near the Lorimer stop of the L train for easy access.

09
Angels Cafe image 1
Bagel shop

Bagel shop with electronic ordering kiosks and outdoor seating on a quiet street offers a cozy, homey vibe with artistic interior design. Atmosphere feels kind and inviting, suitable for quick breakfast or lunch. Wide variety of vegan and gluten-free options complement the exceptional bagels.

Bagels here are fresh and delicious, with options like gluten-free varieties and caviar bagels standing out. They offer a satisfying taste that leaves a good feeling after eating.

Bagel sandwiches stand out with fresh salmon and a variety of fillings like pastrami with Swiss cheese and bacon, egg, and cheese. Prices stay reasonable, and options include chicken parm and classic lox on everything.

People are saying

"I found the bagels here to be really tasty."

"I thought the coffee was the smoothest and most balanced I'd ever tasted."

"I loved the delicious bagel sandwich, especially the bacon, egg, and cheese."

Good to know

1

There is a two for one promotion this summer for certain bagels.

2

40% of all profits go to the North Brooklyn Angels to help feed neighbors.

3

Purchasing bagels helps provide breakfast to the homeless.

10
Simply Nova image 1
Bagel shop

Bagel shop with a cozy, old school vibe and a small outdoor seating area. Busy atmosphere moves quickly, inviting for coffee and reading outside. Known for top-tier smoked fish and specialty cream cheeses.

Bagels come with fresh ingredients and classic New York style. The everything bagel with lox and scallion cream cheese stands out for its balance of flavors and quality.

Sandwiches feature fresh ingredients and come made to order. The pastrami sandwich stands out for its size and flavor, while breakfast sandwiches offer good value compared to local options.

People are saying

"I had the best lox cream cheese bagel I ever had."

"The salmon here is rich and flavorful."

"The pastrami sandwich here is large and delicious."

Good to know

1

The price for two bagels with smoked fish is around $40, including tip and tax.

2

The restaurant offers a full menu of Jewish takeout, all made in house.

3

The classic lox sandwich requires you to ask for tomato, onion, or capers.

11
Black Seed Bagels - Williamsburg image 1

Cramped indoor space fills with delivery workers and loud early 2000s prom music, creating a loud, energetic vibe. Outdoor seating offers a dog-friendly area with umbrellas and street views. The atmosphere feels hip and inviting, supported by enthusiastic staff and a well-curated playlist.

Bagels come out super fresh and baked on site. Options like the garlic confit with marinated tomatoes and pastrami on everything bagel stand out. Breakfast sandwiches with bacon, egg, and cheese are solid choices.

Bagel sandwiches come with classic fillings like salmon, bacon, egg, and cheese or pastrami. The lox and bagel options are ready quickly for pickup and the cheese blends well with tuna in some sandwiches.

People are saying

"The staff here is so friendly and kind, making the bagels experience great."

"I thought the tuna salad tasted good, especially with celery."

"I now know why the bagel breakfast sandwiches are considered the best."

Good to know

1

Expect to wait over an hour for your bagel order.

2

Bagels cost around $15, which is considered expensive.

3

There is no public restroom available for customers.

12
Dough Bros image 1
Bagel shop

Bright, clean bagel shop with ample seating inside and out offers a laid-back, relaxing vibe. Freshly baked sourdough bagels stand out for their quality and unique flavors. Free coffee accompanies orders, enhancing the casual morning experience.

Sourdough bagels baked fresh every morning stand out for their soft texture and freshness. Bagel sandwiches with toppings like salmon cream cheese, avocado, and Asiago add high-quality flavors.

Bagel sandwiches come with a strong saltiness that can overpower other flavors. Breakfast sandwiches pair with espresso, and a full sandwich plus coffee costs under $10.

People are saying

"The bagels here are fantastic and friendly."

"I loved my smoothie, made with the freshest ingredients."

"I enjoyed the delicious bagel sandwiches."

Good to know

1

You can get a full bagel sandwich and customized coffee for $10 or less.

2

They crack and cook the eggs to order right there.

3

They use only organic ingredients, which makes a huge difference in the flavor.

13
Edithโ€™s Sandwich Counter image 1

Interior feels homey and chic with knick-knacks and old photos creating a cozy vibe. Small space fills quickly, especially on weekends, with some outdoor seating available. Music adds to the good atmosphere while the crowd enjoys some of the best sandwiches and bagels in the area.

Chicago style Everything Bagel and lox bagel stand out for their flavor and quality. Bagels come with creative toppings and the sandwiches make for a solid breakfast choice.

Sandwiches come with high quality schmears and careful assembly. Options include pastrami, flavorful turkey, vegetarian versions, and a notable Sephardi breakfast sandwich.

People are saying

"I loved the breakfast sandwiches, especially with latkes."

"The tahini iced coffee slushy has a strong, creamy flavor."

"You have to try the slushy; it's the bomb."

Good to know

1

Expect a 20-30 minute wait during peak hours.

2

Prices for sandwiches can exceed $25 for takeout.

3

The restaurant has no indoor seating available.

14
Leo image 1
Pizza restaurant

Spacious and bright restaurant with minimal and stylish interior and small seating and tables. Atmosphere is lively and cozy with good street seating that is somewhat heated. Wine selection is notably strong, featuring natural wines and draft options.

Bagels come out crispy on the outside and soft on the inside with an open crumb texture. Weekend offerings include plain, cinnamon date, and lox bagels that pair well with cream cheese and salmon.

Sandwiches feature sourdough bread and include options like mozzarella and prosciutto with a sweet and mildly spicy taste. Some breakfast sandwiches, including a salmon bagel, are popular, but quality can vary, with occasional dryness or unimpressive flavors.

People are saying

"The Italian food, especially the pizza and pasta, is delicious."

"You have to try their weekend bagels; they're a total game changer."

"I loved the sourdough bread for the sandwiches."

Good to know

1

Reservations are necessary on weekends due to potential waits of over an hour.

2

The price is 4 and 5 USD per slice, which is excellent value for money.

3

Dining in is the preferred option because you can also get soft serve and wine.

15
Black Star Bakery & Cafe image 1

Small bakery with bright natural light and white tile floors creates a chic, cozy atmosphere. Multiple seating areas suit working, chatting, or casual dining. Music volume varies, sometimes loud, but overall vibe stays relaxed and inviting.

Bagels come with egg salad, lox, or cream cheese options. They serve tasty sandwiches and pastries alongside quick coffee.

Breakfast sandwiches stand out with options like the Avocado Tripp and Sriracha Egg & Cheese featuring sriracha mayo. Croissant sandwiches, especially the prosciutto croissant, pair well with cold brew coffee.

People are saying

"I loved the fresh, delicious coffee and beautiful pastries."

"The breakfast sandwich with egg and cheese is delicious."

"I enjoyed their delicious bagels with cream cheese."

Good to know

1

There is no bathroom available for customers.

2

The place is very busy in the morning.

3

Laptops are not allowed on the center tables.

Discover more

Williamsburg, New York

Area guide
Loading Map...