Pie shops in Williamsburg

Unique Turkish café offers a warm, cozy atmosphere with reliable Wi-Fi and puppy-friendly space. Albanian cheese pie delivers an indulgent, rich flavor while chicken pot pie burek is flaky and perfectly seasoned. Ideal for solo work or socializing.

Albanian cheese pie stands out with its indulgent, rich flavor that really hits the spot. The chicken pot pie burek offers a flaky, perfectly seasoned experience unlike anything else.

Open kitchen fills the air with frying oil aroma, creating a raw, urban feel. Back patio offers a garden-like oasis with cozy lighting, perfect for romantic nights. Key lime pie with a five-spice twist adds a playful, nostalgic touch to desserts.

Key lime pie stands out with its five-spice twist. Desserts like bacon donuts and this pie offer a sweet, nostalgic, playful vibe.

Spacious coffee shop offers cozy seating and a library-like atmosphere perfect for families and pets. Blueberry and cherry pies shine with fresh fruit fillings and flaky crusts. Plenty of power outlets make it great for work or play.

Blueberry and cherry pies stand out with their fresh fruit fillings and flaky crusts. The blueberry pie bar offers a delicious twist on the classic dessert.

Dark, romantic space with a serene Japanese aesthetic and modern decor sets a chill vibe. Rooftop patio with Studio Ghibli projections offers unique outdoor seating. Yuzu lime pie shines with its bright flavor, while drinks boast an extensive cocktail and sake list.

Yuzu lime pie stands out with its light texture and bright flavor. The pumpkin pie also delivers a rich, satisfying taste.

Cozy indoor space with vintage touches and lively vibe sets a fun mood. Heated garden patio and rooftop terrace offer quiet dining. Key lime pie is a fantastic dessert best enjoyed with a wine pairing.

Key lime pie stands out as a fantastic dessert with a strong recommendation to try it. A wine pairing is suggested to complement the pie's flavors.

Greenery-filled space with natural sunlight sets a warm, vintage mood. Limited seating includes bar seats and tiny tables, which can feel tight. Watch pastry chefs craft desserts live, especially the flaky pumpkin pie and Basque cheesecake.

Pumpkin pie features a flaky croissant-like crust and a mousse texture. Basque cheesecake also stands out alongside the very good pumpkin pie.

Cow-themed decor and staff in milk-stained overalls create a lively, unique vibe. Signature soft serve ice cream with crunchy corn flakes delights visitors. The Milk Bar Pie offers a sweet, buttery crust with creamy filling, balancing flavor and texture perfectly.

Sweet and buttery with a little salt, the Milk Bar Pie features an amazing crust and creamy filling. Variations like the peanut butter and waffle cone pies offer distinct, flavorful experiences, though some find them quite sweet.

Rooftop bar shines with stunning Manhattan views and a live jazz vibe perfect for social nights. Key lime pie delivers an unreal flavor with smooth mousse, while chicken pot pie offers a rich filling. Indoor and outdoor seating with blankets adds cozy comfort.

Key lime pie stands out with its unreal flavor and smooth mousse. The chicken pot pie offers a rich, flavorful filling.

Rustic space with wooden panel walls and string lights sets a homey mood. Peanut butter pie is a rich standout, while key lime pie offers a tart balance but misses fresh whipped cream. Large screen sports add a casual energy to the laid-back vibe.

Peanut butter pie stands out with its rich flavor. Key lime pie offers a tart balance but lacks fresh homemade whipped cream.

Old-fashioned charm and a cozy vibe create a smoky atmosphere that feels lively yet low-key. Spinach pie shines with authentic Middle Eastern flavors, while meat pies offer variety. Casual and personal, the place delivers a no-frills experience.

Spinach pie stands out as amazing here. Meat pies come in multiple orders and show up alongside other dishes, while the cheese pie feels underwhelming.

Spacious bakery offers a lively vibe with a live DJ and outdoor seating. Banana cream pie is fresh and fluffy, perfect for pie lovers. The welcoming design makes it great for relaxing or socializing.

Banana cream pie stands out as fresh, light, and fluffy. Other notable options include berry napoleon and sour cream apple pie, all homemade and delicious.

Modern dining space features a large wood stove and outdoor seating by a park. Spinach pie offers rich flavor and tender texture, while meat pie provides a hearty bite. Guests enjoy authentic Greek cuisine with Mediterranean wines and cocktails.

Spinach pie stands out with rich flavor and tender texture. The meat pie offers a hearty, satisfying bite that complements other dishes like lamb riblets and octopus.

Southern restaurant blends vintage diner charm with lively music for a cozy vibe. Pies shine with freshness and balanced sweetness, like the flavorful apple and light banana cream. Space feels intimate but can be cramped, perfect for casual dates or quiet gatherings.

Pies here stand out for their freshness and balanced sweetness. The apple pie offers a flavorful, just-right portion, while the banana cream pie is light, creamy, and not too sweet.

Cozy bakery offers sweet potato pie and individual key lime pies that are perfectly baked. Woman-owned charm shines through custom cake designs and handcrafted sweets like banana pudding. Warm, inviting energy makes it a quality spot for treats.

Sweet potato pie stands out as a signature item. Small pies like the key lime are perfectly baked and come in individual sizes.

Small Mediterranean spot offers fresh shawarma and affordable falafel in a casual, bright setting. Spinach pie shines with great flavor, while cheese pie is a bit salty. Perfect for tasty, budget-friendly meals in a chill atmosphere.

Spinach pie stands out with a great flavor. Cheese pie comes with a tad salty taste.

Rooftop space offers incredible decor and a pool with cabanas overlooking the skyline. Lamb shank pot pie shines with flaky pastry and tender, flavorful meat. Loud music from a live DJ fuels a lively atmosphere perfect for summer nights.

Lamb shank pot pie features a perfectly flaky pastry and tender, fall-off-the-bone lamb full of flavor. The broth includes carrots and celery that balance the richness of the lamb.

Dark interior and pink decor set a nostalgic yet modern vibe. Bold passion fruit pie and hearty chicken pot pie shine on the menu. Experimental cocktails and cold beer taps keep the lively crowd energized.

Passion fruit pie stands out with its bold flavor. Chicken pot pie also appears on the menu, offering a hearty option to enjoy at the bar.