Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Loved by locals

American food sandwiches in Yorkville

A substantial sandwich is the only thing that feels right for a classic American meal.

Based on 727 Opinions
+724
User
User
User
Updated April 2026
01
Vegan Grill image 1
Vegan Grill image 2
Vegan Grill image 3
View all
Vegan restaurant

Spacious vegan restaurant with clean, bright interiors and outdoor seating options offers a calm, cozy atmosphere with reggae and rai music playing. The vibe suits relaxed dining and casual co-working with wifi available. The environment feels comfortable but lacks distinctive diner or vegan cafe style.

Nachos stand out with strong flavor and texture, rivaling authentic Mexican versions. Options include corn ribs, tofu scramble, and a vegan hamburger noted for its quality.

Vegan sandwiches stand out with options like tofu scramble and vegan chicken that taste authentic and satisfying. Breakfast sandwiches come large and flavorful, featuring sausage, egg, and cheese or a version that mimics real egg and bacon closely.

People are saying

"Their vegetarian food is amazing, especially the vegan chicken parm wedge."

"The vegan American food, like the crunch wrap, is amazing."

"I had the best vegan sandwich of my life here."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for parties larger than 2 or 3 people.

2

If you're in a hurry, order ahead as food is made to order.

3

Expect to pay around $14 for 6 bite-size pieces of cauliflower.

02
Avoca image 1

Backyard patio offers a quaint and spacious setting with beautifully renovated interior and dog-friendly amenities. Loud music, including rap during brunch, creates a lively atmosphere that suits private events and group gatherings. The space balances sunlit outdoor areas with cozy indoor seating.

Mac and cheese stands out as very fresh and highly praised. Burgers come with amazing flavor. Eggs benedict feature thinly sliced ham and are consistently on point.

Fried chicken sandwich stands out with its flavorful taste and comes with crispy fries. Egg white smash sandwich pairs well with seasoned breakfast potatoes cut into wedges.

People are saying

"The food here is super good and delicious."

"You have to try the bottomless brunch drinks here."

"I thought the chicken sandwich was really good."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended as this place gets booked up quickly.

2

Happy hour prices are available until dinner time on weekdays.

3

On Taco Tuesday, three tacos are available for $10.

03
Isle of Us image 1

Bright, airy space with boutique-like design and cozy seating creates a welcoming atmosphere. Staff contribute to a friendly vibe, while USB outlets under banquette seating support device charging. The café offers a dedicated laptop-free dining room and connects to a wellness shop and spa.

Kimchi grilled cheese stands out with a unique twist. Sandwiches like the mushroom Reuben and tarragon chicken offer solid American flavors. Desserts include vegan brownies and chocolate chip cookies.

House Roasted Turkey sandwich features focaccia, orange-miso aioli, and fresh herbs. Green Eggs and Jam Sandwich offers a fluffy, custard-like egg. Tarragon chicken salad sandwich includes pickled onions for a tangy touch.

People are saying

"I loved their delicious gluten-free breakfast burrito and avocado toast."

"The eggs and jam sandwich is delicious and huge."

"The mushroom Reuben sandwich is excellent and guilt-free American food."

Good to know

1

Everything is made in-house and to order, ensuring freshness.

2

The cafe gets crowded, so you may need to wait for a seat.

3

The location is ideal near Central Park and the museums.

04
Hollybrook Lane image 1

Black-themed bar offers a modern, inviting atmosphere with well-curated hip hop and old school R&B music at a comfortable volume. The space feels homey and trendy with artwork and a friendly vibe that encourages relaxation and socializing.

Fried chicken stands out with a crispy, flavorful crust. Key lime pie offers a sharp, sweet finish. Dishes like mac and cheese and Cajun chicken wings bring rich, comforting Southern flavors.

Fried chicken sandwiches come huge, moist, and crispy. They taste very delicious and can be shared between two people.

People are saying

"The food, like the mac and cheese, was surprisingly soupy."

"The fried chicken here is some of the best I've had."

"I thought the fried chicken sandwich was moist, crispy, and delicious."

Good to know

1

Happy hour deals on drinks are available from 4-7pm on weekdays.

2

Mimosas are $5 during brunch hours.

3

Expect a 35-40 minute wait for entrees during peak hours.

05
Sojourn Social image 1
Restaurant

Outdoor patio offers multi-level spaces with string lights and private booths, creating a lively yet intimate atmosphere. Music stays at a comfortable volume, encouraging conversation without shouting. Dog-friendly policy and creative cocktails add to a welcoming, casual vibe.

Eggs Benedict stands out with rich flavor and careful preparation. Steak and eggs offer a hearty, satisfying option with solid taste.

Grilled chicken sandwiches come big and flavorful, often taking longer to prepare than other items. The chicken sandwich stands out as a fan favorite with a huge, satisfying portion size.

People are saying

"I enjoyed their really great happy hour."

"The American Food, especially the cheeseburger truffle fries, is crave-worthy."

"I found the chicken sandwich to be big and flavorful."

Good to know

1

Happy Hour is available Monday to Friday with great deals.

2

Enjoy 2 for 1 cocktails during happy hour.

3

The happy hour offers small bites, burgers, cocktails, and wines by the glass.

06
Chicken Insider image 1
Korean restaurant

Small, cozy Korean restaurant with a casual vibe and K-pop music playing softly. Seating is limited but comfortable, creating a relaxed atmosphere without overwhelming smells. Known for crispy fried chicken and a humble, unassuming setting that contrasts with the quality of food.

Fried chicken comes with a crispy exterior and a mouthwatering soy garlic sauce or a Korean spicy sauce. Sandwiches like the Nashville Hot Chicken stand out, and sides such as Cajun fries and sweet potato fries add a flavorful kick.

Chicken sandwiches feature crispy, juicy chicken with flavorful sauces like Soy Garlic and spicy Korean sweet chili. Buns tend to get soggy quickly, so sandwiches are best eaten fresh in person.

People are saying

"The fried chicken is so crispy and juicy."

"The American food here is so crispy and juicy."

"I thought the chicken sandwich was juicy and crispy."

Good to know

1

The bathroom in the back is not wheelchair accessible.

2

Dine-in is not allowed for 30 minutes before closing.

3

Expect a 20-minute wait for wings and drumsticks.

07
Flex Mussels image 1
Seafood restaurant

Seafood restaurant offers intimate yet buzzing atmosphere with tables packed tightly indoors and ample outdoor seating providing more space. Decor features custom murals and unique lighting fixtures that create a marine-inspired vibe. The setting suits both lively brunches and cozy date nights.

Seafood shines with a buttered toasted bun lobster roll packed with lobster and fresh oysters. The menu also features a fish sandwich, fish tacos, calamari, and a creamy bacon mac and cheese.

Fish sandwiches feature a filet cooked just right and stand out among the options. Lobster rolls also appear frequently and receive positive mentions alongside fish tacos and burgers.

People are saying

"The oysters here are fresh and full of flavor."

"You've got to try the lobster roll; it's perfect."

"I loved the fish sandwich; it was a standout dish."

Good to know

1

Make a reservation in advance, especially for weekend brunches.

2

Happy hour at the bar is from 5-7pm on weekdays.

3

Happy hour at tables is from 4-5pm on weekends.

08
The Penrose Bar image 1

Bar combines old New York atmosphere with a modern touch and features a speakeasy vibe in a remodeled back room. Atmosphere shifts from cozy to lively with frequent live jazz music and parties. Layout encourages mingling with an open bar, buffet station, and perimeter tables.

Steak frites and lobster roll stand out alongside a strong cocktail menu. The Mac and cheese ranks among the best, and the eggs Benedict with country ham offers a solid choice. Fried chicken leans sweet rather than spicy.

Chicken sandwiches stand out with creeping heat and a balance of slaw and pickles on a brioche bun. The burrata sandwich features crispy prosciutto and a perfectly crisped texture. Bacon egg supreme sandwiches offer a satisfying, hearty option.

People are saying

"This bar has a warm, rustic vibe that feels both lively and comfortable."

"The cocktails here are well-crafted and balanced."

"I thought the fried chicken sandwich paired perfectly with the martini."

Good to know

1

The Penrose Bar offers a boozy brunch on weekends.

2

Expect a crowd during weekend brunch hours.

3

After 8 PM, only guests 21 and older are allowed.

09
Giacomo's Pizza and Restaurant image 1

Pizza restaurant offers indoor and outdoor seating with big windows providing a spectacular view. Atmosphere feels cozy and well decorated, with a lively vibe supported by music and a dedicated party space. Guests enjoy a notable wine and beer selection alongside highly praised pizza.

Buffalo wings stand out with their crispy outside and juicy inside, paired well with blue cheese. Steak and eggs also deliver solid flavor, while fried chicken wings offer a juicy, crispy bite.

Meatball Parm sandwich features melty cheese and savory meatballs. Sandwiches come alongside soups and salads, often enjoyed as a combo.

People are saying

"The pizza here has a perfectly crisp crust and fresh toppings."

"The American Food here, especially the wings, is crispy and juicy."

"The meatball sandwich is huge with melty cheese."

Good to know

1

Happy hour runs from 4-6pm with discounted drinks and appetizers.

2

The breakfast pizza slice is available only until 12 PM.

3

You can get 5 large slices of a random variety of pizza for $5-6.

10
Horn's Hook Tavern image 1

Bar and grill with Revolutionary War theme and Texas Longhorns support offers a large round bar and many TVs for sports. Atmosphere is friendly and social with live entertainment and game commentary sound. Seating includes rows of tables and outdoor space, with darts available in the back.

Grilled cheese and tomato soup stand out as very tasty and a highlight. The menu features hamburgers, buffalo wings, and potato skins as key items. The Soldier's Sandwich offers pulled pork with cheese, coleslaw, pickles, and a large side of fries.

Pulled pork with cheese, coleslaw, and pickles defines the Soldier’s Sandwich, served with a large side of fries. The spicy chicken Burr sandwich comes with fries, while the hanger steak sandwich stands out for its flavor but is a bit small.

People are saying

"The bar food here is great, especially the wings and fish and chips."

"I loved the good vibes and nice neighborhood feel."

"The American Food, especially the grilled cheese and tomato soup, was so tasty."

Good to know

1

Horn's Hook offers unlimited clams on Tuesdays.

2

Yorkville sports bar hosts trivia night every Tuesday at 8pm.

3

Horn’s Hook Tavern usually has live music on Friday nights.

11
Luke's Lobster Upper East Side image 1

Small seafood restaurant decorated like a fisherman’s tavern offers a cozy, quiet atmosphere with no loud music. The place serves fresh, succulent lobster rolls that pair well with an IPA. Prices are high, but the quality of seafood stands out.

Lobster rolls stand out with freshness and warm butter richness. Options include truffle lobster roll and cold lobster roll, both highly flavorful and simple.

Lobster sandwiches stand out for their freshness and unique flavor. Gluten-free options exist, all tasting delicious but the lobster sandwich comes at a higher price than classic sandwiches.

People are saying

"The lobster roll here is fresh, delicious, and perfectly seasoned."

"The seafood rolls here are so fresh, you can taste the ocean."

"I found the lobster sandwich to be fresh and tasty."

Good to know

1

The bathroom at Luke’s is non-accessible.

2

The cost for two rolls, two packets of crisps, and two cokes is $70 (£54).

3

The price of the lobster roll is extremely high at $27.00.

12
Gracie Mews Diner image 1

Classic diner with fresh updated interior and large heated outdoor dining area offers a spacious, quiet atmosphere with plenty of natural light. Comfortable seating and multiple TVs create a relaxed vibe, while great music adds to the ambiance. Busy and lively during Sunday brunch, it balances a fancy yet affordable feel.

Cajun shrimp tacos stand out alongside a penne a la vodka sauce with chicken. Classic diner dishes like meatloaf and New York strip steak breakfast with scrambled eggs also feature, plus fresh fruits and tasty pastries.

Huge portions define the sandwiches here. The pastrami sandwich and Cuban Sandwich stand out for their flavor and size, while the chicken Louisiana sandwich ranks among the best.

People are saying

"I had the best food and it was delicious."

"I considered the sandwiches here to be excellent and huge."

"Their American Food soups, like minestrone, were the best I tried."

Good to know

1

The diner is only open from 12 PM to 6 PM on weekdays.

2

Expect a $2 upcharge for multigrain toast or substituting sliced tomato.

3

The restaurant is a popular brunch spot on Saturdays and Sundays.

13
The Mansion image 1

Old-style NYC diner with cozy interior and festive outdoor seating under a corrugated metal roof. Loud kitchen and crowd create a high-energy atmosphere where conversation is difficult. Decor includes celebrity photos and large American flags, adding to its unique charm.

Double smash hamburger and patty melt stand out with rich flavors. Sandwiches like the meatloaf and shaved corned beef come piled high with fresh toppings. Chicken noodle soup, omelettes, and hash browns add classic comfort to the menu.

Chicken parm cutlet sandwich stands out with its rich flavor. Meatloaf sandwich leaves a lasting impression. Shaved corned beef sandwich comes piled high with tomato, lettuce, coleslaw, and pickle. Specialty breakfast sandwich called The York offers a delicious start to the day.

People are saying

"This diner's food is so delicious, I'm already craving more."

"The American food here, especially the burgers, is fantastic."

"This sandwich was so delicious, it haunted me."

Good to know

1

The diner is especially good for breakfast with a large menu of options.

2

You will never have to wait a crazy long time, no matter how crowded it is.

3

There can be a little wait on the weekend for brunch times.

14
Madame Bonté Café image 1

Small space offers cozy seating indoors and outdoors with a warm, up-to-date design. Atmosphere feels homely and comforting, welcoming for casual meetings or working on a PC during weekdays. Dog-friendly policy includes treats for pets, adding to the inviting vibe.

Grilled cheese comes as a to-go option with a gooey texture. Opinions on its quality vary, with some finding it mediocre.

Vegan chickpea sandwich stands out as super filling. Tiny sandwiches with provolone add variety. Coffee and pastries complement the good sandwiches well.

People are saying

"I found the coffee here to be the best I ever had."

"The sandwiches here are tiny and provolone."

"The American Food service was fast and friendly."

Good to know

1

The cafe prohibits laptops and iPads on weekends.

2

Expect limited seating, especially during busy hours.

3

The cafe closes at 5 PM daily.

Discover more

Yorkville, New York

Area guide
Loading Map...