Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Local picks in Smithtown

Italian food spots

Made for those who hold Italian culinary traditions to a standard that requires constant verification.

Based on 579 Opinions
+576
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Pietro Cucina Italiana image 1
Pietro Cucina Italiana image 2
Pietro Cucina Italiana image 3
View all
Italian restaurant

Outdoor seating includes a garden area and fire pit with live music, creating a relaxing atmosphere. Indoor spaces feel cozy and intimate with tables packed closely together. The vibe blends soft jazz and a romantic mood, offering a charming dining experience.

Food features extreme freshness and authentic Italian flavors. The menu pairs well with a carefully selected Italian wine list.

Homemade pappardelle pasta with short rib ragu stands out for its rich flavor. Dishes like linguine vongole, mussels, eggplant, and branzino are fresh and tasty. The tiramisu and burrata also offer notable highlights.

People are saying

"The homemade pasta here is truly amazing."

"The outdoor seating area is beautifully decorated and really nice."

"I thought the food here was delicious."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended as tables fill up quickly.

2

The restaurant accommodates food allergies upon request.

3

Dinner service is available only, with no lunch options.

02
La Famiglia image 1
Italian restaurant

Italian restaurant with a modern design and cozy, family-friendly atmosphere. Space feels crowded with small tables and a large bar area. Loud environment with interactive management creates a lively, homey vibe.

Italian food stands out with its rich flavors and authentic preparation. Every dish offers a consistently amazing taste that makes dining here a great experience.

Penne a la vodka and rigatoni dishes stand out with strong flavors. Specials like snapper and burrata add variety, and the Carbonara can come with chicken cutlet for extra protein.

People are saying

"The Italian food here is amazing, and the staff treats you like family."

"The food at these dinner spots is always fresh and delicious."

"The food here is amazing and delicious."

Good to know

1

Happy hour runs from 4-6pm on weekdays with discounted drinks and appetizers.

2

The restaurant can get very crowded, especially on Saturday nights.

3

Parking is limited, so arrive early or consider alternative transportation.

03
Carmelina's image 1
Pizza restaurant

Bright, modern space features hand-painted murals and a clean, cozy vibe. Atmosphere balances lively energy with a welcoming feel, suited for casual dinners or quick slices. Pizza ovens positioned at the back add to the open, inviting layout.

Food here stands out for its great taste and excellent quality. Service includes prompt delivery of dishes once ready, enhancing the overall dining experience.

Homemade mozzarella shines in dishes like golden, gooey sticks and a thin Sicilian crust grandma pizza with fresh mozzarella and plum tomatoes. Pasta options include penne alla vodka and linguine in white clam sauce, all served hot with authentic sauces and generous portions.

People are saying

"I found the pizza here to be really good."

"The food here is excellent, especially the homemade mozzarella."

"The pizza here has a phenomenal crust and fresh mozzarella."

Good to know

1

Carmelina's offers a family dinner deal every day of the week.

2

They make their own mozzarella in-house, enhancing the quality of their dishes.

3

A service charge applies when using credit cards.

04
Monteโ€™s Pizzeria image 1
Pizza restaurant

Italian pizzeria offers an authentic neighborhood vibe with consistent, delicious pizza and reasonable prices. The atmosphere is friendly and clean, making it a reliable spot for casual dining.

Food arrives hot and on time with consistently excellent quality. Pizza and catering options stand out as amazing and well-liked.

Pizza slices include Grandma, vegetable, pasta, and BBQ chicken options. A 3 foot chicken cutlet hero comes with mozzarella and roasted peppers. Pasta dishes and pizza stand out. Eggplant rollatini appears instead of eggplant Parmesan.

People are saying

"I found the pizza here to be delicious and great."

"The food here is amazing and delicious."

"Mario promised to carry over the Italian food traditions that make this place stand out."

Good to know

1

The lunch special includes 2 slices and a drink for $8.

2

The price is $11 for 3 slices.

3

Monteโ€™s Pizzeria delivers without using an app and without additional fees.

05
Uncle Giuseppe's Marketplace image 1
Gourmet grocery store

Store resembles a high-end food festival with old world charm and Italian music setting a lively mood. Shoppers encounter fresh mozzarella made in-house and a variety of authentic Italian specialty foods. Friendly atmosphere includes unique touches like a chocolate and gelato stand and live singing.

Prepared foods include fresh sushi, antipasti, olives, cheeses, and meats. A hot foods bar offers many fresh options. Seafood is consistently fresh and quality is higher than typical grocery stores.

Fresh mozzarella stands out, made right in front of you with a bakery aroma that sets the scene. The prepared foods section offers restaurant-quality chicken parmesan and a wide variety of antipasti, cheeses, and fresh pasta.

People are saying

"This grocery store offers an amazing, gorgeous supermarket experience."

"The prepared Italian food here, like chicken parmesan, is restaurant-quality."

"The prepared food selections here are amazing and restaurant-quality."

Good to know

1

The store offers a wide selection of authentic Italian products.

2

Expect high prices on most items, reflecting the quality of products.

3

Expiration dates are clearly marked on all products for safety.

06
Casa Rustica image 1
Sicilian restaurant

Small Italian restaurant offers a cozy atmosphere with quiet dining rooms that encourage conversation. Warm, friendly vibe suits family celebrations, romantic dinners, and nights out. Decor changes over time, creating a homey feel with carefully prepared dishes.

Food here stays authentic Italian with creative, beautifully prepared dishes. Quality and service remain exceptional year after year.

Fresh pasta and bountiful portions define the menu. Dishes like Elk Osso Buco over creamy risotto and classic chicken parmesan showcase authentic Italian flavors with outstanding quality.

People are saying

"The food here tastes like someone's grandma is in the kitchen."

"The Italian food here is old-school and always good."

"You have to try the tableside Lobster Flambรฉ; it's unforgettable."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for special events like New Year's Eve.

2

The restaurant offers a special wild game menu for New Year's Eve.

3

Gluten-free options are available upon request when making a reservation.

07
Garden Grill image 1
American restaurant

Victorian and vintage farmhouse styles combine in a cozy space with beautiful interior design and a historic home setting. Live music plays almost daily, creating a lively vibe alongside an inviting bar and outdoor patio. The atmosphere suits casual dining and social gatherings with ample space and private rooms.

Food here is consistently delicious and well thought out. The sample platter of appetizers stands out as a highlight.

Penne Alla Vodka stands out with its savory taste and a hint of rosemary. The menu features fresh dishes like baked clams, burrata, and Seafood Capellini with carefully selected seafood over capellini pasta.

People are saying

"I found the food here to be delicious and great."

"The outdoor space here is beautiful and well-organized."

"The Italian food here is phenomenal and over the top."

Good to know

1

Live music is available Thursday through Sunday evenings.

2

Happy hour offers discounted drinks and appetizers.

3

The buffet brunch serves food directly to your table.

08
Bonappetito Pizzeria and Ristorante image 1

Small, comfortable dining space offers a warm, family-style atmosphere with live cover band music that encourages some dancing. The place fills up quickly, especially on special nights, and suits smaller groups better than large parties. Pizza with crispy crust and tasty sauce stands out as a highlight amid varied menu experiences.

Food here is consistently good with a focus on chicken parmesan as a reliable dish. The kitchen delivers delicious meals with solid service.

Generous portions of pasta come with dishes like bowtie pasta with shrimp in a pink sauce and pasta primavera. The pizza features crispy crust, good cheese, and tasty sauce, while the pasta selection includes unique items like pasta purses.

People are saying

"The pizza here has a perfect crust and delicious sauce."

"This Italian food has a tasty sauce and crispy crust."

"The food here is delicious and always good."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended as tables fill up quickly, especially on weekends.

2

Expect a busy atmosphere during dinner hours, particularly on pasta special nights.

3

Prices are generally reasonable, with meals averaging around $22.

Discover more

Smithtown, New York

Area guide
Loading Map...