Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Best of Smithtown

Sandwich spots

Made for those who view the construction of a sandwich as a serious culinary endeavor rather than a quick convenience.

Based on 592 Opinions
+589
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Weinisch's Deli image 1
Weinisch's Deli image 2
Weinisch's Deli image 3
View all

Old-school deli with an at-home atmosphere and handmade signs adding personal charm. Friendly, familiar crowd creates a warm, welcoming vibe like stepping into a grandma's kitchen. Cash-only policy and family-run operation emphasize local, traditional feel.

Food here is consistently fresh and delicious. Every meal delivers outstanding flavor and quality.

Egg sandwiches stand out with their delicious taste and are considered among the best around. Sandwich platters also serve well for groups like hospital staff.

People are saying

"The deli sandwiches here are amazing and always fresh."

"I found the food here to be delicious and flavorful."

"I thought their egg sandwich was one of the best."

Good to know

1

Weinisch's Deli only accepts cash payments.

2

Everything at Weinisch's Deli is homemade.

3

They offer complimentary muffins for first-time visitors.

02
chubs meats image 1

Butcher shop and market with generous portions and fresh, high-quality meats draws a steady crowd. Atmosphere feels like being part of a family, with affordable prices and catering options that arrive on time and satisfy large groups.

Food comes ready-made or as meat packages that are simple, delicious, and affordable. Catering arrives on time and warm, with many guests praising the taste.

Lines form for outstanding sandwiches known for their quality and flavor. Premade dishes and catering options add variety beyond just sandwiches.

People are saying

"The food here is awesome and delicious."

"The sandwiches here are outstanding and worth waiting for."

"I found their marinated strip steak to be perfect."

Good to know

1

Catering packages are competitively priced and tailored to various needs.

2

Food arrives on time and is served warm, ensuring quality.

3

Generous portions in catering packages make for satisfying meals.

03
Pho Fans image 1
Vietnamese restaurant

Modern, cozy Vietnamese restaurant with authentic pho and fresh vegetable dishes creates a nice, clean atmosphere. Seating feels somewhat close, fostering a comfortable vibe with professional staff. Known for consistent quality and unique menu items like intestine in beef pho and lemongrass pork chop.

Fresh food and comforting Pho stand out here. The Vietnamese dishes consistently deliver delicious and amazing flavors.

Steamed bun sandwich with short ribs stands out for its juicy meat, soft buns, and on-point sauce. Vietnamese grilled chicken sandwiches vary, sometimes thin on chicken and heavy on cucumber and bread.

People are saying

"I found the food here to be amazing and delicious."

"The pho broth is amazing and packed with complex flavor."

"I found the sandwiches to be very good and tasty."

Good to know

1

Seats are allocated on a first come, first serve basis.

2

Expect quick service; food is ready in less than 5 minutes.

3

The portion sizes are generous and justify the price.

04
Smithtown Bagels Inc image 1

Bagel shop offers a cozy but energetic atmosphere with welcoming, friendly staff and well-decorated interior reflecting strong community ties. It draws consistent crowds, often with lines out the door, and operates 24 hours. Known for fresh, crispy-on-the-outside, chewy-on-the-inside bagels and a wide variety of delicious cream cheeses, it also serves notable chicken salads and large omelettes.

Food here is consistently fresh and delicious. Many find the flavors amazing and highly praise the quality.

Egg sandwiches come out perfectly cooked with brittle but not burnt bacon. Bagel choices pair well with delicious breakfast sandwiches and wraps.

People are saying

"The staff here are so friendly, it's like they're family."

"I consider this my favorite place for breakfast and bagels."

"I thought the food was delicious and fresh."

Good to know

1

Smithtown Bagels Inc is open 24 hours, making it a convenient option any time.

2

Expect long lines during peak hours, especially on weekends.

3

A promotion offers a dozen free bagels with the purchase of a dozen after 3pm.

05
Sweetwaters Coffee & Tea image 1

Coffee shop offers cozy indoor and outdoor seating with local artwork decorating the walls. Atmosphere stays welcoming and chill, suitable for studying or casual chats. Drive-through service adds convenience for quick visits.

Food stays consistently fresh with a menu that features French Vietnamese iced coffee and cheesecake that stands out. Drinks and food often reach an amazing level, though pastries vary in quality.

Breakfast sandwiches come with customizable options and include egg sandwiches on bagels. They stay consistently tasty and pair well with coffee.

People are saying

"I loved the sweet, dreamy coffee here."

"The coffee and food here are on another level."

"I loved how customizable the breakfast sandwiches were."

Good to know

1

The coffee shop has a drive-through for quick service.

2

Signing up for their points system offers great rewards.

3

Prices for drinks and snacks are reasonable, with lattes starting at $7.

06
Bagel Gallery image 1
Bagel shop

Bagel shop operates 24/7 with a welcoming atmosphere and spotless interior. Bagels are often fresh and flavorful, with a variety of cream cheese options. The ordering area feels tight but the overall vibe is warm and inviting.

Food comes 24/7 with a focus on authentic New York bagels and breakfast foods. The offerings justify a small wait and a drive.

Breakfast sandwiches come with coffee included and feature fresh ingredients like honey maple turkey and perfectly cooked bacon. The sandwiches consistently offer high-quality flavors and good value.

People are saying

"I considered these the best bagels on Long Island."

"These bagels are fresh, soft, and full of flavor."

"Tara always made the best sandwiches here."

Good to know

1

Bagel Gallery is open 24/7, making it convenient for late-night cravings.

2

Prices for bagels start at around $4, but can be higher for specialty items.

3

Credit cards are accepted, but the reader does not have a tip option.

07
Heritage Delicatessen image 1

Bright, clean deli with house-made bagels and quality roast beef. Busy atmosphere, especially on weekends, with quick cooking and reasonably priced offerings. Known for flavorful sandwiches including Turkey club and egg sandwiches.

Delicious Latin food stands out with consistent quality and good taste. Meals arrive on time, matching the terrific flavor and solid service.

Egg sandwiches stand out here, especially on a roll with ham and cheese. The Turkey club sandwich and Hero sandwiches also get positive mentions, though a turkey sandwich once caused illness.

People are saying

"I was so impressed with the quality of the food here."

"I thought their egg sandwich was the best."

"I thought this was the best deli on Long Island."

Good to know

1

Expect a busy atmosphere on Saturday mornings.

2

They use quality roast beef in their sandwiches.

3

Prices are competitive and reasonable for a deli.

08
Rockwells Bar & Grill image 1
American restaurant

Bar and grill with numerous big screen TVs and a large outdoor picnic area creates a lively setting. Atmosphere is casual and loud, often filled with positive energy and a friendly, supportive crowd. Separation between bar and restaurant areas offers distinct spaces for watching sports or dining.

Food features fresh and delicious flavors with a good-sized menu that goes beyond typical pub burgers. Service is friendly and the overall experience combines quality food and drinks.

Steak and pulled pork sandwiches stand out with rich flavor and satisfying taste. The Ruben sandwich also appears on the menu, showing some variety in options.

People are saying

"The food here is delicious, especially the shrimp wrap."

"It's a friendly local spot with welcoming staff."

"I thought their pulled pork sandwich was awesome and very tasty."

Good to know

1

Happy hour runs daily from 10 AM to 5 PM with two-for-one drinks.

2

The establishment is known for its large portion sizes.

3

Parking is available nearby, but can fill up quickly during peak hours.

09
BAGEL CITY CO. image 1
Bagel shop

Bagel shop offers fresh, soft bagels and customizable egg sandwiches with a variety of toppings. The atmosphere is clean and convenient, featuring a drive-through that changes the pace of service. Prices vary widely, with some items considered expensive compared to local standards.

Food here stays fresh and delicious with a consistently cravable taste. Breakfast options arrive with just enough napkins, focusing more on the generous portions than extras like towels.

Breakfast sandwiches stand out with custom egg options and quick remakes without extra charge. Lunch sandwiches come out hot and delicious, showing consistent quality.

People are saying

"The egg sandwiches here are great and always fresh."

"The food here is always delicious and fresh."

"The coffee here is hot and delicious."

Good to know

1

The drive-thru offers quick service for those on the go.

2

Breakfast specials include a small coffee with orders before 11am, Monday to Friday.

3

Sandwich prices range from $10 to $24.95, depending on the type.

10
Best on a Bagel image 1
Bagel shop

Small bagel shop offers great bagels and quick service with a decent selection of sandwiches and pastries. Atmosphere is basic and grab-and-go, with some outside seating available. Pricing stays reasonable despite some price increases, and snacks for kids add a family-friendly touch.

Food here is consistently good and often described as perfect. The menu offers solid options that satisfy without fail.

Egg sandwiches with ham and cheese stand out for their freshness and flavor. Roast beef sandwiches are advertised at a special price but cost more without extras, and sandwiches tend to be smaller than at other spots.

People are saying

"I thought the bagels here were the best I've ever had."

"I thought the egg sandwich was the best in the area."

"The food here was good and the workers were super kind."

Good to know

1

The grill closes before 2pm, even though the store closes at 3pm.

2

The store has a $7.99 roast beef sandwich special.

3

The shop offers outside seating and a selection of bagels and sandwiches.

11
Nino's Delicatessen image 1

Classic neighborhood deli with a fast and friendly atmosphere and a small eat-in area. Staff and customers share laughter and smiles, creating a welcoming vibe. Offers an excellent selection of quality prepared foods and sandwiches.

Freshness stands out with a variety of quality prepared foods and Boars Head products. Friendly service moves orders quickly, and hot food options look decent.

Selection includes Italian hero sandwiches with fresh bread and thin meat slices. Sandwiches come with classic toppings, are affordable, and prepared exactly as requested.

People are saying

"The deli sandwiches here are delicious and packed with flavor."

"The roast beef hero sandwich was outstanding and packed with flavor."

"I found the prepared food and salads to have an excellent selection."

Good to know

1

Nino's Delicatessen opens at 7 AM on Sundays.

2

An undisclosed 'admin fee' is added to credit card bills.

3

The mac salad costs $4.79 for a quarter pound.

12
Cafe Lahooti image 1

Small cafe with a cozy ethnic atmosphere and charming decor filled with the smell of freshly brewed coffee. The vibe is friendly and relaxing, with many board games available to keep people engaged. Seating arrangements encourage socializing, creating a warm and hospitable environment.

Awesome variety of food selections pairs with amazing coffee. The overall dining experience offers truly delightful and flavorful dishes.

Tikka Club Sandwich features a strong mayonnaise base on bread. Paratha Rolls and crepes also stand out as top tier options alongside the club sandwich.

People are saying

"The food and drinks here are amazing and high quality."

"The Cafe staff were so kind and friendly."

"The staff here are so kind and hospitable."

Good to know

1

The cafe is clean and has a friendly environment.

2

Prices at Cafe Lahooti are considered affordable by some visitors.

3

Some visitors found the food to be overpriced for the quality.

13
Javier's Cafe image 1

Small cafe with cozy indoor seating and a pleasant outdoor patio creates a charming atmosphere. Noise levels rise due to low ceilings and metal acoustics, making it lively and sometimes loud. Staff work smoothly together, fostering a friendly environment despite the tight space.

Food here is consistently very good with fast service. The dishes stand out as delicious and offer a solid alternative to other local options.

Grilled chicken on pita stands out as a popular choice. Chicken salad sandwich also features as a favorite lunch item. Sandwiches overall receive positive remarks.

People are saying

"The breakfast here is gorgeous, like a home-cooked meal."

"The food here is delicious, fresh, and generously portioned."

"I loved their chicken salad sandwich with cranberries."

Good to know

1

Javier's Cafe only accepts cash or debit cards.

2

The space at Javier's Cafe isnโ€™t the largest, so getting a seat can be tough.

3

There was always a wait to get in.

Discover more

Smithtown, New York

Area guide
Loading Map...