Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Guide to West Islip

Food

A meal that reflects the character of the neighborhood instead of just offering generic options.

Based on 579 Opinions
+576
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
1683 Sports Bar & Restaurant image 1
1683 Sports Bar & Restaurant image 2
1683 Sports Bar & Restaurant image 3
View all

Bar and grill shines with fresh chicken tenders and Philly Cheesesteak. Live music and party lights create a lively club vibe. Multiple TVs and dart boards keep guests entertained and social.

Food here stands out for its fresh and delicious quality. Dishes like chicken tenders, bar pizza with fresh toppings, and the Philly Cheesesteak offer more than typical bar fare.

People are saying

"I thought the food was surprisingly good, a level above typical pub grub."

"The bar's karaoke nights are lively with great music and vibes."

"The food here is amazing, truly the best I've had in a while."

Good to know

1

Karaoke nights happen every Thursday with a two-drink minimum.

2

Latin nights are hosted every Saturday, featuring live music and dancing.

3

Ladies Night occurs every Thursday, encouraging groups to join for karaoke.

02
Benedetto's Pizza & Pasta image 1

Pizza restaurant shines with great flavor and consistent quality in its pizza and pasta. Friendly neighborhood vibe and patriotic decor create a lively atmosphere. Multiple TVs add to the dynamic setting, making it popular and affordable.

Food offers great flavor and consistent quality. Pizza and pasta stand out with excellent taste and reasonable prices.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was amazing and tasted so fresh."

"The pasta here is superb, with generous portions and great flavor."

"The food here is delicious and the portions are generous."

Good to know

1

Expect about 30 minutes wait for an 18-inch pizza during peak hours.

2

Benedetto's offers a first responder discount.

3

The restaurant maintains a clean environment throughout.

03
Farrells of Brooklyn image 1

Firefighters-themed decor creates a nostalgic vibe in this old school Brooklyn Irish bar. Bar favorites are cooked perfectly, making great food a highlight. Live bands bring lively energy several nights a week, while the spacious outside area adds a friendly neighborhood feel.

Great food features bar favorites cooked perfectly. Delicious dishes pair well with watching the game or enjoying live bands.

People are saying

"The bar's burger is a definite top 10 winner."

"I was stuffed after finishing this huge, delicious burger."

"The food here, especially the burgers, is huge and delicious."

Good to know

1

Bingo nights are held every Wednesday at 8pm.

2

Burgers are half off on Mondays and Thursdays.

3

Happy Hour food specials include half-price wings and $4 Taco Tuesdays.

04
Summerwind Gourmet Delicatessen & Catering image 1

Deli shines with fresh bread and homemade chipotle mayo that lift its chicken cutlet sandwiches. Friendly vibe makes it a pleasant lunch spot. Prices are higher but fair for the quality and quick delivery.

Food here is consistently fresh and delicious. The owners focus on quality and care about the dishes they serve.

People are saying

"I found the food here to be fresh and delicious."

"This is a great lunch spot; the food is always fresh."

"The wraps here are amazing, everyone is super friendly."

Good to know

1

The hero sandwich costs $13.

2

Delivery service is available with quick turnaround.

3

Salads are delivered safely packaged.

05
West Islip Bagel image 1

Family-run shop serves fresh bagels and egg sandwiches with great taste. Small space means no seating and busy parking near a busy intersection. Locals love the quality food and quick service.

Food here stands out for its excellent quality and consistently satisfying taste. Service complements the delicious offerings, making it worth going out of the way for a meal.

People are saying

"I found the bagels here to be amazing and fresh."

"The food here is excellent and the bagels are always fresh."

"I thought their egg sandwiches were the best."

Good to know

1

The parking lot is small and often congested.

2

There is no seating available for customers.

3

Hunter Avenue is busy; parking can be challenging.

06
Repxotica, Inc image 1
Reptile store

Clean and well-organized store offers healthy reptiles and in-house bred feeders. Fresh food for reptiles is available at reasonable prices, including options for crested geckos. Expert guidance makes shopping straightforward and informative.

Offers fresh food for reptiles at reasonable prices. Supplies food suitable for crested geckos and similar pets.

People are saying

"The staff here are amazing and knowledgeable, making it kid friendly."

"The staff here are so knowledgeable and kind."

"The pet stores here have happy, healthy-looking animals."

Good to know

1

Repxotica breeds their own live feed, ensuring better quality than big box stores.

2

The store is known for its cleanliness, making it a pleasant shopping environment.

3

They have a wide selection of healthy reptiles and exotic pets.

07
Crispino's Pizza image 1
Pizza restaurant

Enjoy authentic Italian dishes with fresh, delicious toppings and unique desserts. Cozy, welcoming atmosphere shines with seasonal decor. Expect quick service and steady crowds, especially on Fridays, making it a reliable spot for quality pizza and sides.

Food comes out very fresh and delicious with consistently great quality. The menu offers a variety of tasty options that stand out from other pizza places nearby.

People are saying

"I found their pizza to be great tasting and delicious."

"The food here is really fresh and delicious."

"This place is so Kid Friendly, my son ranked their Sicilian slices higher than his favorite spot."

Good to know

1

Call early on Fridays to ensure availability of pies.

2

Expect a wait time of about 5-10 minutes for your order.

3

The restaurant offers a wide selection of pizzas and desserts late in the evening.

08
Lion's Den image 1
Bar & grill

Small bar with a cozy vibe and a family-oriented crowd offers top-tier burgers and Guinness on tap. Food is generous and flavorful at fair prices. Atmosphere feels welcoming and communal with good music.

Food features great quality, fair prices, and generous portions. Pub-style dishes deliver solid flavor and satisfy expectations.

People are saying

"The pub food here is great, especially the hot wings."

"I found the food here to be great."

"This local spot has Guinness on tap."

Good to know

1

Karaoke starts at 10pm on Thursdays with a two-drink minimum.

2

Parking is limited, so arrive early to secure a spot.

3

Food prices are reasonable with fair portion sizes.

09
Bang Bang Burritos image 1
Burrito restaurant

Small, cozy spot offers top-tier burritos and amazing shrimp tacos with fresh, delicious flavors. Calm energy and friendly vibe make dining pleasant. Portions are substantial and prices stay reasonable.

Food stands out for being consistently fresh, delicious, and well made. Shrimp tacos are a popular choice among the menu items.

People are saying

"I found the food here to be fresh and full of flavor."

"I found the burritos here fresh and delicious."

"These nachos are loaded with toppings, you can barely find a chip without something on it."

Good to know

1

Prices are reasonable, but some items may be slightly higher than competitors.

2

The portion sizes are generous, especially for fish tacos.

3

Bang Bang Burritos is not a sit-down restaurant; it's more of a takeout spot.

10
Bagel Buzz image 1
Bagel shop

Strip mall spot offers fresh bagels with some inconsistency but shines in allergy-conscious meals free from peanuts and red dye 40. Simple setting with five small tables creates a no-frills atmosphere loved by locals for classic flavors like everything bagels and egg sandwiches.

Food comes fresh and meets strict allergy needs like peanuts and red dye 40. Service supports following directions closely, ensuring safe and allergy-conscious meals with consistently amazing quality.

People are saying

"I found the bagels here to be fresh and delicious."

"I thought the food here was amazing and fresh."

"I thought they had the best egg sandwich on the island."

Good to know

1

Quality control may vary; check your order before leaving.

2

They charge 50 cents to cut bagels in half.

3

Be cautious if you have food allergies; they may not guarantee allergen-free options.

11
Primi Italian Steakhouse image 1

Elegant space with live piano music sets a warm, intimate mood. Food boasts excellent quality and pairs well with crafted cocktails. Noise rises in bar and upstairs, making conversation tough during busy times.

Food features excellent quality and top notch flavors. The menu pairs well with carefully crafted cocktails.

People are saying

"The Date Spots here have amazing steak, like the filet mignon."

"The calamari here is fresh, lightly battered, and crispy."

"I thought the food was out of this world delicious."

Good to know

1

Reservations are strongly recommended for Saturday nights due to high demand.

2

Valet parking is available, which is convenient during cold weather.

3

A coat check service is offered to keep bulky coats out of the way.

12
Best Farms image 1
Supermarket

Small supermarket offers fresh produce and a varied product selection. Premade food shines with quality and variety, complemented by a solid deli. Clean space and convenient hours make shopping easy, though prices can be a bit high.

Premade food stands out with its quality and variety. The deli also offers a good selection alongside the ready-to-eat options.

People are saying

"I found the premade food incredible, especially the rice balls."

"I found the deli here to be great and fresh."

"I miss the grocery store's original layout with fresh produce and bakery."

Good to know

1

Best Farms offers fresh produce, but it ripens quickly, so buy wisely.

2

The store has a clean and organized layout for easy shopping.

3

Last chance produce is often on sale to reduce waste.

13
Atlantis Diner image 1

Bright, airy diner offers fresh tasty food at fair prices. Cozy, nostalgic vibe with moderate noise makes chatting easy. Quirky animated decor adds unique character to the clean space.

Food comes fresh and tasty with reasonable prices. Staff serve delicious dishes that satisfy every meal.

People are saying

"The food at this diner is tasty and delicious."

"I enjoyed their salads; they were large and made me happy."

"The food here is tasty and delicious."

Good to know

1

Expect slow service on weekends due to high traffic.

2

There is plenty of free parking available.

3

The prices at Atlantis Diner are considered expensive.

14
SPK image 1
Deli

Deli space shines with best egg sandwiches and a welcoming atmosphere. Fresh ingredients create excellent quality food that pairs well with friendly service. Wall of customer photos adds a personal touch.

Food here is consistently fresh and of excellent quality. The menu offers great flavors that stand out alongside friendly service.

People are saying

"I thought the food here was great and fresh."

"The owner makes the sandwich herself and it's delicious."

"I thought the egg sandwich here was delicious."

Good to know

1

Katya prioritizes cleanliness, keeping the store and kitchen spotless.

2

The total for a bagel and drink is $11, with the bagel at $7.75.

3

The price for two egg sandwiches and drinks is $40.

15
Secatogue Brewing Company image 1

Brewery has a relaxed atmosphere with food trucks like BBQ and Senor Burger. It welcomes families and dogs, offering wide beer pours from tasters to growlers. Sports play on TV while groups enjoy activities inside.

Food comes mainly from food trucks, with options like the BBQ truck and Senor Burger offering solid choices.

People are saying

"I enjoyed the really good beer here."

"I found the food trucks here to be amazing."

"The brewery staff were friendly, funny, and accommodating."

Good to know

1

Music bingo is a fun event to join on certain nights.

2

The venue accommodates parties of 50-70 people comfortably.

3

The brewery offers a wide range of pour options, from 4oz to 64oz.

16
Chiddy's Cheesesteaks of West Islip image 1

Cheesesteak spot serves generous portions with rich meat and cheese. Food is fresh, hot, and made to order with quick preparation. Clean space with music-themed posters and fast, efficient service suits quick meals and catering.

Food arrives fresh and hot, cooked to perfection with quick preparation. Orders come exactly as requested, including special modifications, offering great value for the portion size.

People are saying

"You have to try the steak sandwich; it's the best I've ever eaten."

"These empanadas are the best I've ever had, always hot and fresh."

"The food here is awesome and delicious."

Good to know

1

The restaurant offers catering services for business lunches.

2

They have a delivery option through Uber Eats called BeebeeZ burgers.

3

The restaurant maintains a clean environment throughout.

17
Anthony's Pizza & Pasta image 1
Pizza restaurant

Small space offers old-school charm with a clean setup and grandma style pizza featuring mouthwatering sauce. Fresh ingredients create unique flavors at affordable prices. Spanish-speaking staff adds a welcoming vibe that feels straightforward and friendly.

Food features fresh ingredients and unique flavors that stand out. Prices stay affordable despite the high quality and taste.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was the best around."

"I thought the pizza here was the best in town."

Good to know

1

The place has lots of options, including slices and full menu items.

2

They said it would take 10-12 minutes for food preparation.

3

Spanish speaking staff is available for better communication.

18
Southdown Marketplace - West Islip, NY image 1

Supermarket shines with fresh produce and quality meats. Prices are high but match the wide variety and convenient location. Staff help non-English speakers easily find what they need.

Variety of fresh food includes fruits, vegetables, and international options. The meat section and deli counter offer quality meats and prepared foods that stay fresh and tasty.

People are saying

"The prepared foods here are fresh, delicious, and a great value."

"I'm allergic to nuts, so I'm cautious about this grocery store's pesto."

Good to know

1

Prices are generally high compared to other grocery stores in the area.

2

Caution is advised for customers with food allergies due to safety concerns.

3

Expect to find a good selection of fresh produce and baked goods.

19
Best Kitchen image 1
Chinese restaurant

Chinese restaurant offers affordable prices and a clean environment. Dishes like pork fried rice and boneless ribs are flavorful and safe for those with allergies. Staff carefully check orders for takeout and delivery.

Food here is consistently great and free from any off tastes like mold or spoilage. The kitchen is accommodating to food allergies and keeps prices reasonable.

People are saying

"I thought the food here was great and top notch."

Good to know

1

The place maintains a high standard of cleanliness.

2

Prices are reasonable and reflect good value for the quality of food.

3

Always check your order thoroughly when picking it up or upon delivery.

20
Hometown Heroes image 1
Sandwich shop

Sandwich shop serves generous portions with fresh, hot food in a clean, casual space. Quick service supports local youth employment. Catering offers custom wrap platters and large hero sandwiches for easy transport.

Food comes out fresh and hot with generous portions. Quality stays consistent and the meals are ready on time for takeout or dine-in.

People are saying

"The catering salad was fresh, plentiful, and a hit at the party."

"Their hero sandwiches are second to none."

"The Mac and Cheese bites are off the charts!"

Good to know

1

Parking can be difficult, so plan accordingly.

2

Catering services are available and competitively priced.

3

Expect to pay over $20 for a sandwich.

21
Four Season Kitchen image 1
Chinese restaurant

Chinese takeout shines with quick delivery and stays open during snow. Enjoy spicy noodle soups and crispy rolls that arrive hot and tasty. Food tastes clean, showing high quality ingredients and great flavor.

Food arrives hot and tasty with quick delivery. Dishes taste clean and not oversalted, showing high quality ingredients and great flavor.

People are saying

"I thought this was the best Chinese food I had in a long time."

"The Chinese Food arrived hot and tasty."

"I found the spicy beef noodle soup to be excellent."

Good to know

1

The establishment remains open during major snow events.

2

Expect quick delivery service for takeout orders.

3

They call when they arrive for delivery.

Discover more

West Islip, New York

Area guide
Loading Map...