Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Local picks in Ohio

Brownies

Made for those who judge a bakery entirely by the density and richness of its brownies.

Based on 419 Opinions
+416
User
User
User
Updated April 2026
01
Whit's Frozen Custard of Centerville image 1
Whit's Frozen Custard of Centerville image 2
Whit's Frozen Custard of Centerville image 3
View all

Garage-turned ice cream shop offers creamy frozen custard with a rich taste. Brownies come in small portions priced around $7, including the Brownie Sundae and Brownie Whitser. Atmosphere blends retro 50s decor with modern LED displays, creating a lively, family-friendly vibe.

Brownies come in small portions priced around $7. Options include the Brownie Sundae and Brownie Whitser, both with a rich, good taste.

People are saying

"It's so kid friendly, my grandbabies loved seeing Spiderman."

"You have to try their banana split; it's phenomenal."

"I ordered a brownie dessert and it tasted really good."

Good to know

1

They offer a sugarless custard option, and everything is made fresh.

2

The daily and weekly flavors keep things interesting and encourage repeat visits.

3

There is plenty of seating and parking available.

02
Sugar image 1
Bakery

Small bakery with fast service through a walk-up window offers rich brownies and unique desserts. Soft, flavorful treats like the chocolate chip bomb attract those seeking exceptional cookies. Hidden spot with limited hours adds to its charm.

Brownies here stand out for their rich flavor and classic simplicity. Even the plain Jane brownie delivers a satisfying, well-made treat.

People are saying

"These cookies are fantastic; I thought they were the best ever."

"I drove from Mason just for this brownie."

"The Banana Pudding's taste was amazing, a girlfriend's favorite."

Good to know

1

Sugar is only open a few days each week, limiting access.

2

The bakery operates through a walk-up window for convenient ordering.

3

Expect popular desserts to sell out quickly, so arrive early.

03
Cake, Hope, & Love image 1

Quaint bakery shines with sparkly atmosphere and creative decorating. Frosted brownies offer rich flavor and fun Shark Week designs. Fun classes and party rentals add to the happy vibe.

Frosted brownies stand out for their freshness and rich flavor. Unique designs like Shark Week decorations add a fun touch to the delicious treats.

People are saying

"The cakes here are beautiful and taste incredible."

"This bakery has delicious treats and kind, helpful staff."

"The brownie was super fresh and so delicious."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for special events like cupcake decorating parties.

2

The bakery hosts themed days throughout the year, including Star Wars and Ohio State.

3

Cupcake decorating classes are available for birthday parties and group events.

04
Dorothy Lane Market image 1
Grocery store

Upscale grocery store offers a cozy vibe with retro stylized theming and a beautiful interior design. Enjoy browsing while sipping a glass of wine or beer. Fresh brownie bites stand out among bakery treats, though prices can vary.

Fresh baked goods include brownies alongside bagels and croissants. Several types of brownie bites stand out for their quality. Pricing labels show killer brownies at $12.99 but sometimes charge more.

People are saying

"The grocery store staff are so friendly and helpful."

"The bakery here has an amazing, unique, and delicious selection."

"You can't go wrong with their killer brownie bites."

Good to know

1

Expect higher prices compared to typical grocery stores; budget accordingly.

2

The market features a unique selection of local and organic products.

3

Parking can be limited, so arrive early during peak hours.

05
Angilo's Pizza image 1
Pizza restaurant

Family-owned for nearly 50 years, this pizza spot serves homemade sauce and classic hoagies in a cozy, old school setting. Fudge brownies are a delicious treat, often offered free by friendly staff. Prices stay fair, matching the steady quality and hometown vibe.

Fudge brownies stand out as a delicious treat here. Staff sometimes offer free brownies, adding a nice touch to the meal.

People are saying

"The food here is always fresh and hot."

"I thought the pizza here was the best I ever had."

"I really enjoyed their delicious fudge brownie."

Good to know

1

They have daily specials that provide added savings.

2

The menu at Angilo's Pizza is large, offering something for everyone.

3

The prices at Angilo's Pizza were reasonable.

06
Shooters Sports Grill Hamilton image 1

Large open space with biggest Jumbotron creates a lively sports vibe. Bright lighting and family-friendly staff make it welcoming. Brownie dessert is mediocre, best paired with a Reuben sandwich but not a must-have alone.

Brownie comes as a mediocre dessert that does not stand out. It pairs with the Reuben sandwich but lacks a reason to return for it alone.

People are saying

"The food here is very good with a wide variety of choices."

"It's a family friendly place with a great atmosphere."

"The brownie here did not disappoint."

Good to know

1

Happy hour runs from 4-6pm with discounted appetizers and drinks.

2

Wings are $1 each on Tuesdays with additional weekly specials.

3

The kitchen closes at 10 PM, but the bar remains open until 11 PM.

07
Aglamesis Brothers image 1
Ice cream shop

Old-fashioned parlor offers a nostalgic atmosphere with vintage decor and marble tables. Brownie Ala Mode is exceptional and rich, perfect for dessert lovers. Cozy space fills with lively families, making it a fun spot for kids and adults alike.

Brownies in the sundaes are rich and satisfying with a delicious texture. The Brownie Ala Mode stands out as exceptional and truly memorable.

People are saying

"The ice cream and brownie sundaes were rich and satisfying."

"I found the house-made candy to be outstanding."

"The brownie sundae is rich, satisfying, and truly exceptional."

Good to know

1

Ice cream prices start at $6 for a single scoop.

2

The shop accepts cash and credit cards, but may have issues during power outages.

3

Limited seating is available, so be prepared for a wait during peak hours.

08
Buca di Beppo Italian Restaurant image 1

Space feels like a maze with unique artwork and half-naked pictures. Atmosphere is fun and chaotic with low lighting and cramped seating. Brownie sundaes are colossal and heavenly, perfect for sharing in themed rooms with lazy Susans.

Colossal brownie sundaes come with ice cream and are huge enough to share. The brownie sundaes stand out as a heavenly and insane dessert option.

People are saying

"The food here is amazing, and the staff remembered us."

"It's a great spot for a big party, especially for birthdays."

"The colossal brownie sundae is huge and heavenly."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended, especially for large parties or special occasions.

2

Expect to pay dinner prices during lunchtime on Saturdays.

3

Portion sizes are family-style, so come hungry or plan to share.

09
Peach Cobbler Factory image 1

Large, clean space with a unique layout offers a classy atmosphere for fun family outings. Brownies are hand-sized and packed with chocolate chips, some topped with whipped cream and chocolate syrup. Friendly staff and loud Muzak create a lively, welcoming vibe.

Brownies come in large, hand-sized portions packed with chocolate chips. Some have a thick layer of whipped cream and chocolate syrup on top, with flavors like salted caramel and double chocolate chip.

People are saying

"I found the Caramel Apple Cobbler to be my go-to dessert."

"The churros here are served by the kindest, most welcoming staff."

"Colton was fantastic and friendly, making sure we got our food."

Good to know

1

They offer a flight where you can pick any 4 puddings or cobblers.

2

The portions of the cobbler are large enough for two people to share.

3

Prices range from $4 for drinks to $8 for brownies.

10
elรฉ Cake Co. image 1

Spacious bakery offers fudge chocolate brownies and peanut butter buckeyes alongside customizable cakes and cupcakes. Cozy seating and amazing decorations create a welcoming spot to enjoy fresh, quality treats.

Brownies come with fudge chocolate icing and stay fresh. They share the spotlight with peanut butter buckeyes and other specialty treats.

People are saying

"The cake here is always moist and delicious."

"These frosted sugar cookies are super cute, soft, and delicious."

"This brownie is super moist and delicious."

Good to know

1

Reservations for cake tastings are recommended to ensure availability.

2

The bakery offers a variety of dessert options, including cupcakes and cookies.

3

Prices for cakes and cupcakes are generally affordable compared to other bakeries.

Discover more

Ohio

Area guide
Loading Map...