Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Local picks in Ohio

Ice cream sandwiches

You have a specific craving for a sandwich and a sweet finish, and you expect both to be handled with care.

Based on 579 Opinions
+576
User
User
User
Updated April 2026
01
Village Grocery image 1
Grocery store

Old timey vibe defines the space with picnic benches outside along the bike trail. The atmosphere suits casual stops, featuring short order lunches and a big walk-in cooler stocked with beverages including a craft beer selection. Sandwiches and soft serve stand out as popular, freshly made options.

Soft serve stands out with a great selection and smooth texture. Sandwiches pair well with the ice cream for a satisfying combo.

Great sandwiches come with daily specials and quick service. Options include a huge roast beef sandwich, a flavorful bologna, a fresh BLT made on the spot, and egg salad.

People are saying

"I found the food here to be fresh and well-made."

"I enjoyed the great sandwiches, especially the roast beef."

"The soft serve ice cream here is great."

Good to know

1

Village Grocery charges only 99 cents for Arizona tea.

2

Short order lunches at Village Grocery are popular in the area.

3

Village Grocery is conveniently located along the bike trail.

02
Newtown Farm Market image 1
Produce market

Rustic charm and simple handwritten signage create a serene, nostalgic atmosphere. Quiet setting features an enticing deli counter, fresh produce, and an island of bulk candies. A talkative parrot and a patio add unique touches to this locally run market.

Soft serve stands out with its creamy texture and rich flavor. Ice cream options come alongside local snacks and lunches.

Sandwiches come fresh from the deli with pulled pork on a pretzel roll and warm BBQ on a Kaiser bun. They offer tasty, affordable options with unique sauces like BOOM SAUCE and sides like cole slaw.

People are saying

"This market has a huge variety of fresh produce and delicious baked goods."

"I loved the delicious sandwiches made fresh here."

"I thought the soft serve ice cream here was really tasty."

Good to know

1

The market offers fresh produce and a variety of local products.

2

Expect long lines at the deli counter during peak hours.

3

They have seasonal plants, flowers, and unique Amish goods.

03
Milkman image 1
Hamburger restaurant

Old 50s style diner with retro decor and granite tabletops creates a warm, inviting vibe. Music adds to the fun, clean atmosphere where classic and boozy shakes stand out. The place blends vintage charm with an upscale twist.

Creative flavors and generous portions define the ice cream offerings. Soft serve stands out for its fluffy texture and yummy taste. Alcohol slushies add a unique twist to the selection.

Crispy, flavorful fried chicken sandwiches stand out with a phenomenal crunch and rich taste. The tofu sandwiches offer a spicy kick without sogginess, delivering solid texture and flavor.

People are saying

"These juicy burgers are the best I've ever had."

"The chicken sandwich here is the best I've ever tasted."

"The soft serve here is so creamy and fluffy."

Good to know

1

Parking is available on the street, but meters are in effect.

2

Downloading the parking app is necessary for street parking.

3

Expect a wait time of 5-7 minutes for food after ordering.

04
Kerry's Café image 1
Coffee shop

Small, quaint coffee shop on a busy corner offers a cozy atmosphere with plenty of outdoor seating and a friendly vibe. Kids run freely in the yard while patrons enjoy specialty coffee and simple, flavorful breakfast sandwiches. The place feels like a quiet country spot despite its location.

Offers ice cream alongside summer drinks and breakfast sandwiches. The shop has a cute and charming vibe.

Sandwiches come with basic ingredients and simple preparation. Some sandwiches like the bacon one stand out, but others use frozen components and lack strong flavor.

People are saying

"I enjoyed the great coffee and delicious drinks here."

"Kerry and Karl make you feel like you've known them for years."

"I enjoyed the good sandwiches and coffees here."

Good to know

1

Kerry's Café offers non-dairy milk options for those with allergies.

2

There is plenty of outdoor seating available, perfect for warm days.

3

The café has limited indoor seating, so plan accordingly.

05
Halal Burgers (Washington Township, Dayton) image 1

Halal restaurant offers a homey vibe with a friendly atmosphere and clean, well-lit interior. TVs show sports like NBA and UFC, creating a lively, sometimes loud environment. Known for exceptional halal burgers, it draws those seeking authentic halal dining.

Employees serve ice cream sundaes alongside meals. A brookie with ice cream stands out as a dessert option. Kids receive ice cream treats on the way out.

Chicken sandwiches stand out with a sweet sauce and a chicken mango habanero option. Fries come as a common side in combos.

People are saying

"I thought their burgers were the best I had ever eaten."

"I thought the Nashville chicken sandwich was awesome."

"The burgers here are amazing and full of flavor."

Good to know

1

Reservations are not accepted; expect a wait during peak hours.

2

Seating is very limited, so be prepared for a wait.

3

All meat served is halal, adhering to Islamic dietary guidelines.

06
Nanny Belle's image 1
Ice cream shop

Ice cream shop offers creamy soft serve and overstuffed sandwiches in a clean, family-friendly setting. The atmosphere feels distinctive and lively, especially when nearby ice rink events draw crowds. Pricing aligns with similar spots, making it a popular local choice.

Soft serve ice cream stands out with its creamy texture and delicious flavor. The vanilla and blueberry options offer a smooth, tasty experience.

Overstuffed sandwiches stand out, with the ham and salted rye being a favorite. The menu offers many options, and sandwiches come with sides that provide a good deal.

People are saying

"I found the ice cream sandwich to be the best I had."

"I thought the soft serve ice cream was fantastic."

"The soft serve ice cream here is so creamy and delicious."

Good to know

1

The place can get very busy, especially when the ice rink opens.

2

The menu does not specify that the caramel topping is hot.

3

Prices are great for an ice cream spot.

07
Fent's Dairy Corner image 1
Ice cream shop

Ice cream shop with a cool, updated interior and a busy atmosphere that draws a steady crowd. The vibe is family-friendly and lively, especially with a drive-thru option that adds convenience. People come for affordable prices and a wide menu featuring tasty ice cream and sandwiches.

Soft serve stands out with its affordable price and quality matching Dairy Queen. Cyclone ice creams offer a distinctive treat alongside consistently tasty flavors.

Shredded chicken sandwiches stand out with great flavor and fair pricing. Pizza Steak sandwiches taste like cheeseburgers with subtle cheese, lacking strong pizza flavors. Cheese-only sandwiches require specifying extra toppings.

People are saying

"I thought the ice cream here was great and creamy."

"I thought the food here was always delicious."

"I thought the shredded chicken sandwich was good and fairly priced."

Good to know

1

The drive-thru is often busy; expect a 20-minute wait during peak times.

2

Prices are reasonable compared to similar places in the area.

3

Food is made to order, ensuring freshness and quality.

08
Freddy's Frozen Custard & Steakburgers image 1

Old diner style creates a nostalgic atmosphere with good music enhancing the vibe. Burgers and frozen custard stand out as quality offerings that attract people for casual meals. Some chaotic energy comes from staff interactions, but the place maintains a lively feel.

Offers good ice cream with flavors like Oreo cookie dessert. Service can be slow, with long waits and sometimes melted ice cream on arrival.

Steak sandwiches come with fresh shoestring fries and shakes. Staff like Alex and Jacob are knowledgeable and check orders carefully, though sometimes additions to sandwiches are missed.

People are saying

"I thought the food here was amazing and a great price."

"The ice cream here is just really good."

"Alex and Savanna were a great team making my sandwich."

Good to know

1

Drive-through orders are prioritized over dine-in orders.

2

Expect high prices for the quality of food received.

3

The kids' meal costs five dollars, which is a good value.

09
Culver’s image 1
American restaurant

Bright, clean dining areas include outdoor seating with varied table sizes. Atmosphere stays family-friendly and inviting, with Christian music playing softly. Sections reduce noise, keeping the space comfortable even when busy.

Offers a variety of super ice cream and shakes that stand out. Kids' meals include ice cream, adding to the appeal. Chocolate ice cream and other flavors are consistently good.

Flaky fish sandwiches come with lemon wedges on request and stand out for their delicious flavor. The spicy chicken sandwich and roast beef pot roast sandwich also impress with strong, satisfying tastes.

People are saying

"I found the food here hot, fresh, and delicious."

"These Wisconsin cheese curds are crispy and cheesy."

"I'd go back just for their delicious fish sandwich."

Good to know

1

Expect long drive-thru lines during peak hours.

2

Parking can be tricky due to the drive-thru location.

3

A meal costs around $9, which may feel small for the price.

10
Dixie Dairy Dreem image 1
Ice cream shop

Small mom-and-pop ice cream shop with an old school family vibe and nostalgic small town feel. Outdoor window and drive-thru convenience serve families with kids, creating a lively, quick-moving atmosphere. Known for soft serve ice cream and classic treats with a good selection of flavors.

Soft serve ice cream stands out with its silky, creamy texture and great flavor choices. Classic treats like cones, blizzard shakes, and cherry cordial offer a nostalgic, old school vibe.

Fish sandwich stands out with strong flavor and is a common repeat choice. The Pork tenderloin sandwich also gets a solid recommendation. Sandwich quality varies, with some considered just alright.

People are saying

"The ice cream here is so creamy and smooth."

"The ice cream here is excellent with great flavor choices."

"I'd go back for the awesome fish sandwich."

Good to know

1

The drive-thru offers a convenient way to order without leaving your car.

2

Expect a nostalgic experience with classic hot dogs and ice cream options.

3

Prices are generally affordable, making it a good spot for families.

11
Element Eatery image 1
Food court

Open food court with a spacious bar and plenty of seating suits large groups and casual hangouts. Live music and big TVs create a lively yet conversational atmosphere. Wide variety of food options and craft beers offer diverse choices for quick meals or social gatherings.

Aglamesis ice cream features prominently, served alongside a small gelato stand offering delicious flavors. The ice cream sundae stands out as a tasty dessert option among diverse food choices.

Italian Beef and BBQ Beef sandwiches stand out with rich flavors. The grilled chicken and Cuban sandwiches offer solid, tasty options.

People are saying

"I found so many great food options to choose from."

"The BBQ chicken sandwich was excellent."

"I was surprised to find Aglamesis ice cream here."

Good to know

1

Trivia night occurs every Monday night at 8pm.

2

Live music is featured every Friday and Saturday night.

3

Element Eatery hosts a Cars and Coffee meet every Saturday year-round.

Discover more

Ohio

Area guide
Loading Map...