Thin crust New York-style pizza defines the menu in a cozy space with old school vibes and a family atmosphere. The setting feels like a grandma's kitchen, simple and inviting, with small tables and fun decorations. The place draws a steady crowd who appreciate authentic flavors without fuss.
Hand tossed with fresh dough daily, the pizza has a crust that holds its form when lifted. Toppings include fresh mushrooms, lots of pepperoni, and sweet crunchy onions for a fresh tasting, authentic New York style experience.
Pizza and pasta dishes come with rich, authentic flavors that recall the east coast style. The meat lasagna and cannoli stand out with their velvety filling and perfect texture.
"I had the best New York style pizza I've ever had."
"I found the calzone to be always delicious."
"The pizza and pasta here are amazing Italian food."
Good to know
Parking is easy and available near the restaurant.
The restaurant primarily offers takeout service.
A large pizza costs $23, making it an affordable option.
Tiny space with limited seating and a walk-up window creates an old school neighborhood joint feel. The vibe mixes 90’s hip hop deep cuts with festive tunes, offering a cool, cozy atmosphere. Quality pizza and craft cocktails attract a crowd despite tight quarters.
Slices feature a great flavor boosted by extra virgin olive oil and shredded Parmesan cheese. Pepperoni is a common topping choice alongside classic options.
Burrata pizza stands out with fresh, milky burrata on top. The hot honey pepperoni pizza offers a sweet and spicy kick. Caesar salad also pairs well with these dishes.
Good to know
Parking at Guardia is one of the worst places in the country.
There is limited seating, so calling ahead is recommended.
Prices for the 18-inch pie are competitive compared to local options.
Small dining area with cozy atmosphere and quaint seating creates a peaceful, clean environment. Authentic New York style pizza draws a loyal crowd seeking genuine Italian flavors. Community-focused spirit shows through unique gestures like a food-for-those-in-need board.
Authentic New York style pizza comes out bubbly hot with fresh cheese and toppings. The texture nails the classic thin, foldable crust that reminds many of home.
Baked spaghetti comes in large portions and pairs well with excellent meatballs. The house-made cannoli and limoncello stand out as delicious desserts, while the marinara sauce is rich and flavorful.
Good to know
Parking can be challenging during rush hour; plan accordingly.
Pizzas take about 20-25 minutes to prepare after ordering.
The restaurant is small, so dining in may be limited.
Small pizzeria with cozy seating including a bar and two-person tables creates an intimate setting. Atmosphere stays quiet and relaxed, offering a pleasant, authentic New York vibe. Limited seating and mostly carryout shape a casual, neighborhood feel.
Thin crust and chewy dough define the pizza here. The style stays true to classic New York with a solid, authentic taste.
Pizza comes with a solid crust and fresh toppings. Cannolis stand out with small snack sizes and a peanut butter option that adds a unique twist.
Good to know
The space is small with limited seating; parties larger than two must carry out.
Expect to wait or carry out at peak times, especially during dinner rush hours.
There is lots of parking available for anyone not in walking distance.
New York style pizza defines the menu with crispy, crunchy crust and generous portions that often leave leftovers. The atmosphere stays friendly and clean, creating a welcoming spot for quick takeout. Popularity leads to sold-out items early, showing strong demand despite some parking challenges.
Thin crust pizza folds easily and matches the classic New York style. The 16-inch size offers an authentic taste that reminds many of New York itself.
Chicken Alfredo Pizza stands out with rich flavor. Pizzas like bruschetta and pastas including spaghetti and Four Pasta Bake offer solid Italian options. Calzones and Strombolis add variety alongside classic sides like garlic knots and cannolis.
Good to know
Expect a 15-minute wait for pick-up orders during peak hours.
Parking can be challenging; arrive early to secure a spot.
Prices are reasonable, with a large pizza costing around $20.
Small space offers authentic Italian energy with friendly atmosphere and plentiful portions. Seating includes intimate indoor tables and outdoor picnic spots. Known for high-quality, flavorful pizza that stands out in the region.
Thin crust and classic toppings define the New York style pizza here. Pizzas stay consistently satisfying with a taste true to the style, though some expect a different take.
Authentic Italian food shines through with huge, flavorful pasta dishes and delicious pizza. Desserts like tiramisu, cannoli, and limoncello cake add a sweet finish.
Good to know
Roma's offers pizza slices from 11 AM to 3 PM.
The restaurant has a community giveaway event today.
Carryout orders can be timed for pickup when the pizza is in the oven.
Tiny, cozy space with Italian atmosphere and limited indoor seating plus outdoor tables. Energy feels family-oriented and authentic, attracting those who appreciate New York/New Jersey style pizza and hearty subs. Offers pizza by the slice, making it convenient for varied tastes in a small, quaint setting.
Authentic New York style pizza stands out here with a classic taste. The menu also features awesome salads that complement the slices well.
Fresh made pizza stands out with amazing dough and crust and unique toppings like chicken, spinach, and Alfredo sauce. Pastas come with a mildly sweet, nicely spiced marinara sauce, and subs feature hearty meats like meatball, pepperoni, and capicola.
Good to know
Tony's Corner Deli sells pizza by the slice, which is convenient for families.
The meatball sub costs under $11, offering good value.
Portions are generous, making it easy to share meals.
1920s speakeasy theme shapes a small pizza restaurant with a top-end bourbon bar upstairs and rustic lounge seating. Atmosphere blends great music and a lovely outdoor space allowing eating, drinking, and smoking. Pizza ranks among the best in town, served quickly in a chill environment with lively energy.
Slices have a crispy bottom without burning and come in classic styles like cheese, pepperoni, and sausage. The pizza closely resembles real New York style with a thin, foldable crust and balanced toppings.
Pizza stands out with a rich marinara sauce and excellent breadsticks. The cannoli matches quality found in New York City, and pasta salad complements the Italian offerings well.
Good to know
They offer 50% off on their 12-inch pies every Monday.
The lunch special is a fantastic value.
Parking is available just down the block or through street parking.
Cozy pizza shop with a mom and pop atmosphere and authentic New York style pizza. Casual and warm vibe with personal attention to decorations and affordable prices. Customers and staff often engage in political conversations, adding to the lively environment.
Thin crust and classic New York flavor define the pizza here. It offers a solid take on New York style with a balanced cheese and sauce blend.
Massive portions of lasagna and a variety of Italian dishes like Triple Meat Triple Cheese pizza and ziti pasta stand out. Cannoli desserts also rank among the best in the city.
Good to know
They add a fee for credit card payments.
You can get pizza by the slice.
They offered both dine-in and takeout options.
Pizza restaurant combines upstairs speakeasy bar with outdoor balcony patio for a relaxed vibe. Atmosphere shifts from warm and inviting inside to incredible back patio vibes outside. Frequented by those who enjoy top-notch pizza paired with craft cocktails and bourbon tastings upstairs.
Slices come with a bit of grease, which is essential for authentic New York style pizza. The pizza features a thin crust and classic New York style toppings, capturing the essence of the original.
Pizza and breadsticks come with a homemade, hearty marinara sauce that tastes like it has simmered for hours. The cannolis stand out as extremely delicious, and the pesto bread is exceptionally good.
Good to know
Goodfellas offers different food and drink specials every night.
Parking can be tricky, so plan ahead.
There is typically a 30 to 50-minute wait at most.
Small, homey Italian spot with limited indoor seating and a few outdoor tables, mainly designed for takeout. Family-friendly atmosphere with cartoons playing for kids and a cozy vibe. Known for authentic New York-style pizza, generous portions, and standout dishes like manicotti and tres leches cake.
Thin crust and foldable slices define the New York style pizza here. It offers a classic taste that stands out in the Dayton area.
Pizza and spaghetti come with garlic rolls. Calzone features ricotta and mozzarella cheese with meats and veggies. Pasta trio, Stromboli, tiramisu, and Fettuccine Alfredo also stand out.
Good to know
Verona’s Pizza Fairborn is primarily a takeout restaurant with limited seating.
There is very little indoor seating, with only one table available.
Parking is plentiful and easily accessible near the restaurant.
Old school pizza parlor with open kitchen where dough tossing happens in full view. Atmosphere feels small-town cozy and low key, suited mainly for pickup with limited seating. Known for authentic East Coast style pizza with scratch-made crust and quick service.
Offers authentic New York style pizza with a thin, foldable crust and generous toppings. Recognized as the closest to classic NY pizza available locally.
New York-style pizza features big, thin crust slices with rich sauce and locally-sourced mozzarella melted into gooey deliciousness. Meals include complimentary breadsticks with homemade garlic butter and sides like salad with dressing.
Good to know
A single slice of cheese pizza costs $4, and a 16-inch pizza is $24.95.
The wait time for pizza is about 10 minutes, which is reasonable for quality.
Flying Pizza offers pizza by the slice during lunchtime.
New York-style pizza defines the menu with thin crust and plentiful real toppings. Casual, family-friendly atmosphere keeps noise low and pace relaxed. Seating accommodates large groups easily, making it a solid choice for gatherings.
Classic New York style pizza slices come with a thin crust and a good balance of sauce and cheese. Garlic knots often accompany the pizza, adding to the authentic experience.
New York style pizza comes in large 18-inch sizes with toppings like chicken, pineapple, meatball, and green peppers. Pasta dishes include spaghetti, though the sauce can be watery, and garlic bread is also available.
Good to know
Reservations are not required, and the restaurant can accommodate large parties.
Fratelli's Pizzeria serves New York style pizza by the slice.
An 18-inch pizza costs $17, and a large slice of cheese is $3.